Jörn Rhode / ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH
Jörn you and I met at FNA in Florida a couple of years back and since then have run across each other at a number of shows, including Wiesbaden, Germany last year where we enjoyed a few beers and too much Schnapps but at the end of the day I don’t know a great deal about your background. How did you ever get involved in the heat treating industry?
“Yes, Wiesbaden at night is always good fun and I also enjoy that every year. Well, I got involved in the heat treating industry since I was a child. My father founded the company over 30 years ago and anytime I wanted to get something like for example a new bike, I had to work during the holidays and earn my own money. So I started by cleaning the workshop and step by step I was allowed to do other work. Then I did an apprenticeship as an industrial mechanic before I started my studies as a mechanical engineer. And today I run the business together with my wife Natasha. So I could say that heat treatment or better said industrial furnaces have always been and will be in the future an important part of my life.”
Your company ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH would appear to be quite well known in Europe but less so in North America and I think of ROHDE mainly for pit furnaces but this impression could be incorrect. Perhaps you could give us some details about ROHDE?
“This is correct. As we are a family business our main focus in the past has been on the European market. But the last couple of years we started to get more international and the North American market is also interesting for us. We try to get known better and that’s also the reason why we attend the FNA and Heat Treat Shows in the US. I believe we are mainly known for pit furnaces as we are very innovative in that field and maybe even the technology leader. We constantly develop in that area and make improvements. For example our “big furnace” which is 5,2m x 5m is a completely new construction in pit design and this project was a great challenge for us. And we managed that challenge as the furnace is now running. Besides pit furnaces we also manufacture chamber furnaces, furnaces for special processes and salt recovery units. Basically I can say that our product range includes every furnace with a retort.“
Every furnace builder in the world is eyeing China, India and other developing countries as the areas where most growth in heat treating will be coming from. Do you share this view and if so how are you expanding your presence in these areas?
“I do agree that these are definitely growing markets. We are not expanding our presence in China, but in India we have a representative as it is not possible to handle that from Germany. We believe that in the future India will be an important market for us. But we do not want to establish production sites in one of these countries. We deliver our products worldwide but we want to guarantee “quality made in Germany”.
Perhaps I could pick your brain a little about the European market in general and the German market in particular seeing as you are a German company. I have spent quite a bit of time in Germany over the past few years and what I see is that heat treating in Germany primarily revolves around the auto industry both captive and commercial. In most other areas around the world I do not see as large a percentage of heat treating being dedicated to the auto industry. Am I way off the mark on this?
“I think you are right. I have heard that around 40 % of heat treating is done for the auto industry and in some heat treat shops even more.”
It is estimated that in North America 10% of heat treating is done commercially however as far as I can tell this is at best an educated guess. This might be an unfair question but do you have a good feel for what percentage of heat treating in Germany is done in commercial shops as opposed to captives?
“I am sorry, but I have no idea.”
There are quite a few different heat treating technologies on the market today everything from tried and true such as batch IQ furnaces, pushers, pit and vacuum furnaces all the way to what is perceived as newer technologies (which isn’t always the case I realize) such as gas and plasma nitriding and vacuum carburizing. I certainly realize that the process is largely determined by the actual part but out of all the technologies out there which one do you find most interesting with the brightest future?
“You are absolutely right. Either the part or the process determines which furnace is the most suitable. In my opinion the process with the brightest future is nitriding. There are more and more parts that need to be gas- or plasma (ion) nitrided. We have developed a prototype furnace together with IWT (Institut für Werkstofftechnik) – a university research institute – in Bremen and Process Electronic (United Controls) which allows plasma (ion) nitriding and gas nitriding in one furnace. We are now able to develop new processes together with our project partners and we are very excited. And in the field of gas carburizing there will also be new processes in the future which will allow companies to treat parts at atmospheric pressure without surface oxidation. We have done research on that issue together with IWT Bremen and the results are really promising. Once the process development is completed there will be the possibility to combine the advantages of atmosphere carburizing technology with low-pressure carburizing technology.”
Wind energy is big business in Germany and involves a great deal of heat treating. From what I have seen in Europe the typical approach to heat treating large gears for the wind industry is pit furnaces. In North America on the other hand the trend seems to be larger and ever larger batch IQ furnaces. Obviously there are advantages and disadvantages to both technologies but if you personally had to make the decision about which style of furnace to use for large gears which would be your choice? Pit or Batch IQ?
“Do you mean multipurpose chamber furnaces? As we do not manufacture this kind of furnace, for me the choice is easy. The wind energy plants get bigger and bigger and the components, that need to be heat treated get bigger, too. I believe that for big parts, big amounts of parts and parts with a high weight, pit furnaces are the best and most beneficial alternative.”
Europe is home to a large number of new furnace builders, do you have a feel for where ROHDE fits in in terms of annual sales? Continuing with this thought are there too many new furnace builders if the economy slows down substantially?
“Europe is a big market, but you are right, there are also many furnace builders. Sometimes I am surprised when I get to know new companies in the industry. If the economy slows down substantially, it will be hard for the furnace builders and competition will get tougher. It is hard to say if there are too many furnace builders. I believe it depends on which industries they serve. If they only serve one industry like for example automotive, then it is problem for them, if the economy slows down. But if they serve many different industries like we do, they can handle a potential crisis much easier.”
Which of your competitors are you the most impressed by?
“It is hard to say. There are of course some competitors which we can partially compare our company with. But in many ways we are different from other companies. The fact that we are not part of a group, that we are an owner-managed family business, is in my opinion our biggest advantage.”
Recently I asked the CEO of a very large European furnace builder if he was worried about competition from low cost areas such as China. His response I completely agreed with when he said in his opinion distance would be a factor and that he did not see in the near or medium future that it would be an issue. Do you agree with this statement or do you see an influx of competition from other low cost areas such as Eastern Europe.
“I think I read your interview. Regarding Asia I do agree and I believe that the costs in the so called low-cost countries will increase in the future and with that also the costs of the products. But I think the main problem is quality and quality is expensive everywhere. I think Eastern Europe is a bigger issue for us. You need to be better than your competitors and if you are better, then you don’t have to be afraid. But that means permanent development and research. And that is what I try to do at my company.”
So Jörn what do you see in the future? A consolidation of furnace builders? Substantial growth or a decline in new furnace orders? New technologies changing the face of the whole industry?
“In the past years I have seen -especially in Germany – many companies becoming part of groups and I think that this will continue in the following years. I think it is a shame because in my opinion, when a company becomes part of a group, it loses its own personality and I do never want to become part of a group. I am sure that there will be a decline in new furnace orders. For Rohde this current year has been absolutely great and we do not expect the next year to continue the same way. The worldwide economy is decreasing and the problems in Europe are present and will have an important influence. But I believe that there will be new technologies which improve our products and those will assure even in bad times orders for the innovative companies on the market.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
John Hubbard
John you have the dubious distinction of being the only individual we have ever interviewed twice for “The Monty”, the first being 10 years ago when you were CEO of Bodycote. Seeing as that was quite some time ago could you give us some brief background about your heat treating career?
“Gord, it is an honor to be interviewed by “The Monty”. You have developed into a very effective and probing enquirer. Briefly I worked my way through University as a night shift heat treater in Cleveland. Upon graduation I became a Metallurgical Engineer (qualified as PE) working days while earning an MBA at night. After completing my MBA I had an opportunity to start a new company designing and building custom furnaces for the forging industry. Over the next few years my partner and I added two more companies. Interestingly all three companies are still in operation but remain “micro-companies”. I was not married and working all the time, Cleveland was “burning and rioting” and I wanted to be in the Southwest. I sold my interests to partners and joined Hinderltier Industries in Tulsa becoming the GM of their heat treating department (captive / commercial). Over the next years I sprayed out the department into an independent business and bought into ownership of that division. When the oil field business was in one of it’s regular crashes I got the opportunity to buy the division. I awarded key managers shares in my company, we grew and prospered then Bodycote, plc approached us to sell. After evaluating the opportunity with my independent board of directors and completing successful due diligence of Bodycote’s original culture (investing in operations they acquired, promoting from the floor up) we sold (cash and tax-free stock swap). Over the next 5 years I ran the North American heat treating operations growing it dramatically (from 7 plants to 56 plants). The board of directors selected me to become CEO to follow the very successful retiring John Chesworth. Over my years as CEO of the group we grew dramatically becoming the largest thermal processing company in the world and one of the largest testing companies in the world. The year before I retired we did a strategic review of our business and decided to divest of our testing division as the synergy which initially attracted us to testing had become less than 5% of testing sales. Luck (preparation meeting opportunity) was on our side as we sold the testing divisions in the fall of 2008 as worldwide markets were crashing. This strategic achievement allowed me to retire with peace of mind leaving Bodycote, plc essentially debt free.“
Since your departure from Bodycote how much involvement have you had with the industry?
“Not enough. I have consulted, pro-Bono, for friends in the industry. I missed the people.“
From Facebook photos I have been following your exotic travels around the world with a great deal of envy I have to say. What possessed you to get back into the industry?
“To some degree you and my surgeon are responsible. I finally had my chronically painful hip by my surgeon (advice, if in pain get it replaced) giving me freedom of movement again. You, as an April Fools joke posted that I had come out of retirement, which I hadn’t but it put the thought into my mind. The temptation has been there since retiring as I have been approached multiple times with investment groups wanting to do anything from taking Bodycote private to creating a synergistic group of thermal processing companies (they look at Bodycote and think – we can do that better or too). I have listened to all approaches but never found any that made any sense based on their history, strategy or patience. Until Calvert Street that is. When Calvert “pitched” me I looked past their sales pitch and did my own due diligence (like I did before selling to Bodycote). I spoke with numerous x-owners who had sold to Calvert Street. I spoke with current long term employees. I spoke with key several long term customers. I learned that Calvert Street has the right knowledge, strategy and patience to own a group of industrial service companies (business to business). I have drunk the cool-aid and believe we have the ability to create a synergistic group of Thermal Processing companies focused on technological excellence, customer service beyond expectations, putting our team of people at the forefront and earning an attractive return on investment. We are positioned to bring new opportunities for any company that joins us.“
Please tell us about Calvert Street and what it was about them that appealed to you.
“Calvert Street, for more than 20 years, has acquired family owned businesses. They understand and value the importance of family legacies and serving as appropriate stewards of the companies. Typically they acquire family businesses that do not have a successor or need capital or expertise to help them grow. Like myself, they value people — everything they do is based upon personal relationships. They also know they are not operators; they seek to put in place experienced, professional managers and provide them the resources and support to run the business. Speaking of investing in people Calvert Street put their money where their mouth is, they hired me, The Monty has already announced that Mike Sobieski has joined as CEO and Don Longenette has joined as our facilities, equipment and safety expert. With more team members soon to be announced. Calvert Street also seek to have highly experienced and respected outside board directors to serve as mentors to our management teams and to ensure the company is focused on the right issues strategically. Our ultimate objective: to have a better company (for all constituents) at the end of our ownership.”
How much at this point can you share with us about what their plans are? I know a question in the backs of many people will be “are you an investor, partner or consultant for the company?”
“See #3. I am an investor and will be “working” as a board member (by the way, we will be adding key board members with skills to help us achieve our goals). My work will mostly consist of selecting the right companies to join us, recruiting the best people to support the group and utilizing the experiences I have had in leading a Thermal Processing company with over11,000 team members, sales of over $1billion with 310 facilities. I have made darn near every mistake that can be made (I know, there are yet more to make) and hope to help the group not repeat the same mistakes. A key area which most companies need help with is safety and environmental compliance.“
As we all know Bodycote is the largest commercial heat treater in the world and you of course were the CEO for a long period to time. This is going to lead to assumptions that you are looking to emulate their model. How would you respond to this?
“Tough question for me to answer without sounding critical. Let me just say that we will strive to differentiate by honoring the history of the companies joining our group, development of our people, on time delivery, consistent quality and providing value for our customers.“
While your active involvement in the industry dropped with your retirement from Bodycote in 2009 you have kept up to date as we discussed. Have you seen any substantial changes in the industry since then? As an example changing technologies or geographic shifts?
“The key changes I have noted in retirement are:
– Fewer skilled people available, mostly due to retirement
– Quality standards are continuously getting tighter
- Equipment is getting more energy efficient, tighter controlled and more dependable
- Emerging markets continue to – emerge. Other than a very few companies such as Bodycote, Aalberts, IHI, HEF and a small handful of others, country borders define their imagination.
The newer technologies (LPC, case hardening of S/S, Controlled Nitriding, etc) are finding niches but not disrupting traditional processes. One technology that is capable of disrupting is Additive Manufacturing.“
From what you have told us you are looking at very substantial investments in the commercial heat treating industry in North America which obviously means you feel very optimistic about the future. What makes you so optimistic that commercial heat treating in North America has a bright future?
“Thermal Processing is an integral part of making metals fit for purpose. As long as there is local manufacturing there will be need for our services. The decision by a manufacturer to in-source or out-source is driven by economics, desire for control of quality, need for on-time-delivery, viable supplier base or even (gasp) corporate politics. We believe by demonstrating superior results we can win our share of the market opportunities.“
This question aligns very closely with the one above and is a perennial favorite of all captive and commercial heat treaters around the world. Are commercials getting a growing share of the heat treating pie? It has long been estimated that in North America 10% is commercial and 90% captive but I have yet to see any definitive data on this. What are your thoughts?
“I have to laugh and I know you are too as you regularly see market studies yourself. Calvert Street commissioned a market study last year (prior to speaking with me) to confirm the viability of their strategy. Believe it or not the study reports that the NA heat treating market is ~$20.2B. The reason I laugh is, many – many years ago I was on a MTI task force which tried to quantify the value of the total North American (NA) heat treating market. By unconfirmed consensus we arrived at $20B. Since then every NA market I have read has parroted that guess. It is true, if you say it often enough – it becomes truth. As for the % outsourced, I believe that the NA is about 10-15% outsourced. Consider it just as accurate as the market size.“
All of my questions to date have been about heat treating in North America but I would like to ask you about heat treating outside of North America. Only a handful of people in the world (and a very small handful at that) have as much experience as you at seeing the global market. In your opinion can trends in the North American market be applied to every area of the world? As an example batch furnaces and mesh belt furnace in North America keep getting larger-would it be fair to say that this is the case everywhere? Do you see commercial heat treaters in all areas of the world seeing the same consolidation as in NA?
“The commercial heat treating market in virtually every country I had the opportunity to work in exhibits, to some extent, the same drivers and trends as in NA. What varies most is the requirements for safety, environmental and quality compliance. These deviations are slowly catching up to those we find in NA. Equipment selection is driven by opportunities available in the local market. Consolidation exists in every country I know of. Founders (or their children) need to sell their company to realize their wealth so they find buyers. The sooner we realize the people in other countries have needs and desires just like us, the sooner we have a chance at world peace.“
Last question John-what in your opinion would be the absolute perfect commercial heat treat? In other words if money was not an issue and you had a greenfield site what would it look like? A location offering numerous processes? A shop specializing in one process only? Completely automated or manual labor? Would a company with annual sales of $5 million be large enough or would you prefer to see a much larger operation with the resources to go in a number of different directions.
“Oh boy, I get to dream: My ideal facility would be in a non-urban market with lots of manufacturers around requiring sophisticated thermal services. I would focus on 2-4 key processes. I would Invest in state of the art, lights out equipment (how many people enjoy working the “graveyard” shift?). In order to support a truly high quality service company $5m in sales is on the low side. Since I am dreaming, I would not want just one location. That is not based on greed, it is spreading the risk and key resources. See, I am naturally a proponent of multi-plant groups. Strength in numbers.
Gord, thanks for the honor of being interviewed by you, again.“
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
John (Chip) Keough, Applied Process
We are very pleased to have this interview with Chip Keough of Applied Process in the USA. Chip tells us about the history of Atmosphere Furnace Company, Applied Process, the advantages of the ADI process and about how it can be applied to gearing.
“About Applied Process Inc. My father, Bob Keough, started Atmosphere Furnace Company in 1962 with a couple of his brothers. Business was slack, so with a couple other partners he started a commercial heat treat called Controlled Atmosphere Processing on Idaho Street in Detroit. In 1962 there was a heat treat on every corner in Detroit, so he needed a niche….the niche he picked was Austempering of 1050 steel clips and clamps. Between CAPCO and AFC they developed the first continuous atmosphere-to-salt furnace which greatly reduced the cost of Austempering steel clips and clamps. Both companies leaned on each other and grew slowly and steadily. Along the way, Bob bought out his partners at both AFC and CAPCO and AFC relocated to Troy, Michigan
Bill joined the business in the late 1960’s and set about working on the systems. He was an early integrator of computerized process and financial tracking systems. He focused on job-based pricing and greatly improved the economic performance of the heat treat. An oil fire destroyed CAPCO in 1968 and that was the last time the Keough family employed oil in any of our plants. Out of the ashes, in 1968 AFC developed the first mesh-belt atmosphere-to-salt furnace that allowed CAPCO to hand load complex, stamped and four-slide parts. In 1972 AFC developed an atmosphere-to-salt pusher furnace that was a whole ‘nother learning experience, later to be deployed, for a time in the Wixom location (where AFC had relocated to in 1973).
In 1978 a small R&D effort was established in the back room at AFC to investigate increasing the quench severity of salt baths and experimenting with a small atmosphere-to-air-to-salt batch furnace. Initial work was done on Austempered Ductile Iron. The recession of the early 1980’s slowed the developmental work to a crawl. Meanwhile, orders were cancelled at AFC leading Bob and the crew to modify an unwanted batch furnace into the first UBQA Batch Atmosphere to Salt furnace.
After graduating with engineering degrees at Michigan, I had gone off and made gray iron blocks and heads for GM at the Pontiac Foundry and then was Principal Process Engineer in the Directionally Solidified and Single Crystal Casting Group at TRW’s Turbine Components Division plant in Minerva, OH. I had the metalcasting bug.
In 1983 Bob and Bill realized that there might be something to this Austempered Ductile Iron but they didn’t know anything about castings…..so my phone rang in Ohio. They pitched me coming to work with them and I said no. I was enjoying my role making superalloy turbine blades for jet engines. But the courtship continued until I said yes and I joined the family business in 1984.
Meanwhile, Austemper Inc. was started in 1984 (across town in Fraser, Michigan), growing the same austempered clip and clamp market with mesh belt austemper furnaces.
We incorporated Applied Process Inc. with Bill as Chairman and me as President. The journey of both the UBQA furnace and Austempered Ductile Iron began in earnest. We moved AP out of the back room at AFC in Wixom and into the Livonia, Michigan location. We capitalized heavily to grow the UBQA type work and, although we were making money month to month, Applied Process still had a negative net worth. I was VP of CAPCO and would work mornings there in Detroit and afternoons at AP in Livonia. Clips and clamps in the morning; ADI castings in the afternoon……for 8 years.
They say that running a family business is 50% business and 50% running, and that was the case at Atmosphere Group. My brother and I were, essentially, 50-50 partners. When you are 50-50 partners you either agree on everything or do nothing. It’s tough. So, in 1993 I proposed to spin Applied Process out of Atmosphere Group. So, I sold Bill my shares in Atmosphere Group and cast off with the dingy, Applied Process.
Within less than a year I had scouted out the Oshkosh location for our growing ADI business and AP Westshore Inc. was born. We established Australian and English technical licensees. By 1999 we were bursting at the seams in Livonia and Oshkosh and set up AP Southridge in Kentucky. We grew by about 15% per year for a decade and adding AP Suzhou in China. Then came the Great Recession and we had to stick a fork in Kentucky, selling the property and storing the equipment. The unexpectedly rapid business snap back in 2010 compelled us to repurpose the Kentucky equipment to the Livonia and Oshkosh plants, but not fast enough. By 2012 I sold AP Suzhou to my partners, Andy Chen and David Chang. Austemper Suzhou became a technical licensee of AP.
In the interim AP had added HighTemp in Pune, India as a technical licensee to Grow the Pie for ADI in a whole other part of the world.
Meanwhile Bob and I had designed 10-ton UBQA line on McDonalds napkins and I built a second shop in Oshkosh to house the new Monster Parts Division of Applied Process. The AFC-Holcroft built, Monster furnace came on line in 2012 and we got back on track with our customers while creating a whole new market for larger, bulkier, austempered steel and iron components.
AP’s Austempered Ductile Iron (ADI), Austempered Steel, Carbo-Austempered™ Steel, and Carbidic ADI continued to grow. The team of professionals that we developed at AP won on every front. Nearly 30 years to the day from the incorporation of Applied Process we sold the company to High Street Capital, a Chicago equity company. One of the most enjoyable things was paying “thank you” bonuses to every employee. We maintained a minority position in AP and were able to fund the Keough Family Foundation, our family charitable foundation. I continue in my role as a Director of Applied Process and have a consulting role in its continuing growth.
AP’s new CEO, Harold Karp, and his crack team, many of whom have been with AP for decades, and an equal number of newer talent, continue to grow and improve the company. AP is a family of world-class Austemper shops, but what they really do is help their customers replace one material/process combination with a better, faster, cheaper one. AP does not sell on price, but on value. I am very proud of AP and delight in its continued growth. Stay tuned for more!
Looking back, I sure didn’t know if spinning AP off of Atmosphere Group was going to work, but I knew that being brothers and partners is tougher than being just partners. Bill and I have enjoyed a great relationship, as brothers. Now, with Bill having sold AFC Holcroft to Aichelin, we look back and agree that the spinoff of AP in 1993 was a great success, for AP, for Atmosphere Group and for our family. We’re sure Bob is smiling about how everything turned out.
About Austempered Ductile Iron
ADI is three times stronger than the best forged aluminum and has only 2.5 times the density. Therefore, a properly engineered and manufactured ADI part can replace an aluminum part at equal or lesser mass. Go figure, cast iron as a WEIGHT SAVINGS over aluminum.
The microstructure in ADI (acicular ferrite and carbon stabilized austenite) is thermally stable to absolute zero, but when a high normal force is applied it can locally transform to martensite in a nest of ferrite. This “strain transformation” makes ADI respond very nicely to grinding or shot peening. In conventional steel, shot peening my increase the allowable bending fatigue by, perhaps, 20%. Shot peening ADI can result in a 70% increase in bending fatigue strength.
Further, the austenite and the graphite nodules (10% of the structure) can damp noise (hence Quiet Gear Company). The graphite also makes ductile iron less dense than steel….8%-10% less dense. Therefore, if you make an ADI part to the exact shape and size of a steel part, it will weigh 8-10% less.
Ductile iron is relatively inexpensive and can be cast to near net shape, minimizing machining.
If one is having contact fatigue (pitting) failures in carburized and hardened gears, ADI is NOT going to improve their situation. ADI can have better bending fatigue strength than carburized and hardened steel gears. ADI is consistently more impact resistant than carburized and hardened steel.
ADI’s growth during austempering is very consistent and predictable and you will never EVER crack a part when austempering it. You can machine a ductile iron gear to a given dimension, allowing for unwind during austempering, and it will grow into spec every time.
ADI makes low cost, lightweight, quiet gears. Do I think there’s a future for ADI gears? You betcha.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Jim Senne, MetalPro Resources LLC
This will be a rather unique interview in that we are speaking with all three members of rep firm MetalPro Resources in the Ohio area. The three members include; Jim Senne, Bill Andreski, and Steve Maus.
Jim if it is OK with you I will direct my questions to you and you can decide how you would like to answer them, jointly or individually. First off I and our readers would be very interested to know the 3 members of your team and their backgrounds.
“Jim, who holds an undergraduate degree in Chemistry and studied graduate level Material Science, held many roles at Xtek, Inc. in Cincinnati during his 25 years there, including Process Metallurgist, managing the Metallurgical Engineering Department and the Heat Treating Operations. His hands-on experience ranges from deep case carburizing of steel mill gears to salt bath FNC of automotive components.
Bill has an undergraduate degree in Metallurgical Engineering and an MS in Material Science and Engineering. He has over 30 years of experience in heat treatment of steel and aluminum alloys. His primary focus has been with all aspects of manufacturing of gears and gear drives, including forging, welding, heat treatment, material selection, etc.
Steve has a BS degree in Metallurgical Engineering. He was with what was Allison Gas Turbines, now Rolls-Royce Corporation for 17 years, eventually as Chief Manufacturing Engineer for Special Processes. He was with furnace builder Lindberg in the 1990’s and in the instrumentation industry with Danaher Controls, and has been an independent rep for nine years.”
I believe that you originally started the company Jim-when was that and when did Steve and Bill join you?
“February 16, 2007 is the founding date, so we recently had an awesome 10th anniversary celebration in Cincinnati with our wives to commemorate. I have to acknowledge Stahl Engineering in Indianapolis for giving me the start. They were a very well known rep agency and they called on me at Xtek, where I ran the captive heat treat shop. Bob Rodewald was the key to getting me involved in selling heat treating capital equipment. I could talk for hours about that story, but I’ll leave it at that for now. Steve Maus joined me on April 1, 2013. I have known him since 1999, when he called on me at Xtek, and I had been stalking him to join me at MetalPro Resources since day one. Bill Andreski joined us officially on January 1, 2016. I have known him since the mid 90’s, when we were counterparts at head to head competitor companies. I had been stalking him to join us since day one. “
In North America I would suggest that most heat treating products are sold through independent reps but I know that is not the case in some areas of the world. Could you very briefly tell us the role of a manufacturers rep?
“Jim: One role of the rep is to be the eyes and ears in the customer plant for the principal. It’s amazing how many opportunities we see because we spend our time in the heat treat shops, not in our offices. Another role is to offer technical assistance to the customer.
Steve: In our case, we can put ourselves in the customer’s shoes because we’ve been there. That helps us to work well with our principals because we can quickly define the situation and determine a solution to the customer’s problem. We can shorten the cycle considerably because we generally know where to start.
Bill: We like to look at ourselves as a complete metallurgical solutions provider. The solution may be equipment, controls, parts, analytics or process. We like to provide a solution for any type of heat treating requirement or problem.”
What companies do you rep for and what areas to you cover?
“The front page of our line card is all about capital equipment. Everyone who reps in the heat treating business has their own approach. Most lead with alloy. Our front page is AFC-Holcroft, Super Systems, Wisconsin Oven, South-Tek Systems and ALD Vacuum Systems. The back page basically says we can source you anything and everything you need in your heat treating shop. Generally, our territory is Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, West Virginia and Western Pennsylvania. We go outside that region for some principals (into Michigan, Tennessee and into the rest of Pennsylvania).”
Besides the rep business does MetalPro offer any other services such as consulting or metallurgical advice?
“Bill: We are technical solutions providers … my experience is that more of the younger engineers are less hands-on, and there is not a robust training program for them … they are put into positions with less tech support and mentoring around them. The requirements of the technical manufacturers rep role will only continue to increase in the future.
Steve: We are called on regularly to solve long-running process and equipment problems, and very often one is caused by the other. Since we all have done that in our previous ‘day jobs’ we can be a helpful resource in many situations, and that has led to quite a few consulting successes. In addition to the areas you mentioned, we can also manage equipment installation and upgrade projects which might involve a blend of layout, equipment modification, and process development work.”
I look back over my years as a rep and I see that things have changed substantially, with electronic communication reducing the amount of face time required with customers. This leads to a very interesting debate about whether the golden age of reps is behind us (WG Montgomery Ltd. also operates as a rep firm). What do you think? In 25 years are reps going to be redundant?
“Jim: My partner Steve Maus reminds us all the time, “There’s nothing like being there.” We can walk in to a heat treat shop, each having run our own captive shop and we say, “What is your biggest headache that we can help you with today?” You can’t get that through an on-line fill in the blank inquiry.
Steve: Customers are usually too busy for socializing, they need someone to help them solve problems, or in some cases to solve problems for them. And people are spread so thin that they need all of the technical help they can get, especially from someone with specific experience in their problem area. They don’t have time to get a rep up to speed, they need instant-on help and we can generally provide that. We only see that need increasing, so no, in 25 years there will be a greater need for knowledgeable reps, not less.”
With three people how do you handle the different lines and areas? By geographic region, product line or a combination of both?
“All of us are “full line card”. Generally, Steve covers Indiana and Kentucky. Jim covers Ohio (except NE OH), West Virginia and Western PA south of I-80. Bill covers NE OH and Western PA north of I-80. That’s for now. The geographical assignments change as needed.”
Please tell me about the area you jointly cover-is it more captive than commercial heat treating? More automotive? A large aerospace presence? A growing area or a stagnant area?
“All: We have a strong commercial heat treating presence in our territory but also some massive captive operations. Automotive and aerospace are sort of dominant here, although many of our good customers are in mining and heavy industry. There’s a lot going on in the territory, despite a lot of automotive having moved out to Mexico and the Southeast US. And manufacturing is growing again, thanks to pro-business environment and favorable state tax policy in our entire area, but especially in Indiana.”
Jointly you fellows have seen a lot over the years in the way of technology, do you see many changes in the marketplace?
“Steve: There is so much coming at today’s heat treaters; the big challenge is to help them understand what applies and how they can justify making changes. Plummeting prices for electronics and memory make controls retrofits and data acquisition systems easier to justify; much tighter industry specs are driving the need for more information and better tools.
Jim: We have to know NADCAP and CQI-9 like the back of our hand. We are fortunate to have a line card full of people who also have a great handle on industry driven requirements.”
If you gentlemen were to start a commercial heat treat plant what process would you look at first? Gas nitriding? Vacuum Heat Treating? Batch IQ furnaces? Induction?
“All: Aluminum heat treating is the fastest growing segment of what we get involved in. Vacuum, nitriding and induction are gaining also. Interestingly enough though we have sold a lot of endo based atmosphere furnaces in recent past and continue to get inquiries for batch IQ’s and continuous carburizers.”
You are in the heart of the USA but I know that there are a number of Japanese companies in your area. Do they follow the usual Japanese model which is to buy only from Japanese companies?
“All: There is a significant presence of Japanese owned companies especially in Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana. This is mainly driven by the strong presence of Honda and Toyota here. These companies are some of our best customers. We work hard to understand what they really want and try to serve their needs. Much of our capital equipment business has been to the Japanese owned customers, although you have to work extremely hard to succeed. Other opportunities in those plants are for tools like gas and carbon analyzers, oxygen probes and furnace parts where better lead times for US-sourced items makes us a good resource.”
What complaint do you hear from your customers the most about their businesses? Examples might be government regulations, experienced employees, tough competition?
“All: That’s an interesting question. We deal with people at all levels of the org chart at our customers’ plants. We probably enjoy working most with the front line supervisors, QA guys and operators, given our heat treat shop backgrounds. I think mostly we would hear: The ability to find and retain qualified shop floor-level employees as well as the tech support metallurgist or materials engineer.”
And what does the future hold for MetalPro Resources?
“Let me get out my 8 Ball and ask! We hope to be calling on our customers plants while riding along in the passenger seat of our self-driving automobiles, phoning, texting and emailing along the way.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Jeff McLaughlin / McLaughlin Services
We are pleased today to be speaking with Mr. Jeff McLaughlin, founder and owner of McLaughlin Services in Avilla, Indiana which is soon to be part of McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC.
Jeff, I think if we talk about your background to begin with it will give us a good insight into how McLaughlin Services came into being. Where and how did you get started in the heat-treating industry?
“I Graduated Hobart Welding School in Troy Ohio in 1992. My first job was a welder/ ironworker, building gas station canopies. That was not for me. So I got into a maintenances position in a mobile home factory. I married a lady whose grandfather was Dean Ramer. Dean and I talked for sometime about me coming to work at Advanced Thermal Technologies Inc (ATTI). I started there in 1993 as a maintenance man/welder. Working my way up the ladder, I became a maintenance manager/ purchasing manager. Dean and Dave VanderKaay, the owners, were two great mentors to me over the course of my career at (ATTI). They taught me the hands on operation and maintenance of a heat treat company. ATTI was sold to a company known as MP Steel, where I stayed on as maintenance manager. MP Steel had several plants throughout the Midwest, and had a fire at plant #1, where everything was lost. MP Steel was sold to Advantage Thermal Services. I stayed working at Plant #2, where I built and installed many furnaces through the years.
Over the course of my career I met a lot of good people that told me I was way more than a heat treat maintenance guy. Well I guess them guys were right, huh! To name a few of them, Randy Simmons of RMA, and John Hansen of Met-Pro, who you know. I thought to myself, if all these guys, with years of experience, are telling me this, then what do I have to lose? In April of 2007, I formed McLaughlin Services LLC with $10,000 dollars. I primarily grew my company on nights, weekends, vacation days, holidays, etc, -whatever it took. Moving forward to April 2010, I left ATS to focus on McLaughlin Services LLC full time. My experience as an in-house maintenance manager is reflected today in the core principles of McLaughlin Service, LLC. Timely service when production is down and reliability and ease of maintenance on new equipment are a few examples. All the hard work I’ve put in the heat treat industry sure has paid off!”
When you first started your working career was the idea of starting and running your own business a focus for you or something which just happened.
“For years, as I worked at the heat treat, I wanted to be the guy that changed the furnace industry. My goal in life is to make a difference with my unique designs of furnace building. I saw many things on the equipment that weren’t quite right and never understood why they were always the same. Nothing seemed to change. Now, I’m changing up the industry.”
On a very personal note you and I had a very good mutual friend, Randy Simmons who also started his own furnace business. It turned out to be a real success but unfortunately Randy passed away a number of years ago at a young age. Did you regard him as a mentor?
“Yes, Randy was one of the people that pushed me to where I am today. He told me that I was going to change the furnace industry with all the ideas I had. I helped Randy with his furnace company in Thailand off and on over the years until his passing. I truly miss working with him. I really wish he was here to see the growth and development of McLaughlin Services LLC and my expansions.”
McLaughlin Services. When I first met you, I considered McLaughlin to be more of a service business but that is probably not a fair statement anymore. How would you describe the company and what you do?
“Gord, that’s right. McLaughlin Services LLC started out as just furnace services. I’m the type of guy that if there’s a will, there a way! That’s what helped get McLaughlin Services LLC where it is today in designing and manufacturing heat treat equipment. McLaughlin Services LLC has just obtained the rights to McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC where McLaughlin Services LLC and Vacuum Engineering Services Company (VESCO) will be operating within. McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC will be building new furnaces such as IQ furnaces, Tru-Mix endothermic gas generators, tempering furnaces , large car bottoms, furnace rebuilds as well as other custom furnaces. We plan to have more service locations by the end of 2018 to mid 2019. McLaughlin Services LLC and VESCO will support the furnace services side of the business.”
Can you share with us an idea about the size of the company in terms of sales, employees or number of customers?
“Our sales are approximately 7 to 10 million per year. Now, as we formed McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC, we have slightly over 30 employees.”
Where are you going with this? You do service work, you do rebuilds and repairs, you do installs, and you build new equipment also-which area do you see becoming predominant in let’s say 10 years?
“I plan to go to the top with this! My plan is to have service centers all over the US By 2021. I feel offering a turnkey solution with cutting edge technology to the industry make’s McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC the solution for the Heat-Treating Industry like no other.”
You seem to be going in a lot of different directions these days. What I mean by that is you started a branch on the West Coast of the US and shortly thereafter bought VESCO on the East Coast which specializes in vacuum furnaces. What is the connection between these and how does it help your customers?
” I felt McLaughlin Services LLC. needed the presence on the West Coast which is working quite well. The West Coast office is primarily a service center and helps support our new equipment. We have installed a number of furnaces, generators and large car bottoms over the last several years. VESCO has been in business for 35 plus years with a great reputation in the Vacuum Furnace Services side of the business. Acquiring VESCO, with all the vacuum furnace experience, helps us offer are customers a single source solution for both vacuum and atmosphere heat treating equipment service.”
There are some big international players out there and generally they all are very good companies. With all due respect to you McLaughlin is a relatively small player-is this a plus or a minus? Does it worry you competing with companies which have very deep pockets?
“The bigger question is what do customers get from the deep pockets? I started McLaughlin Services LLC by doing whatever it took to get the job done. My vision has been to change the heat treating industry with new designs and incorporating new technologies. Large companies are more inclined to squeeze customers into their established products and services instead of adapting to the customers’ needs. They may indeed have deep pockets but also travel down the road made by their deep pockets. I feel bigger is not always better. Hard work pays off!”
I must ask you this, do you think you have caught the attention of the “big guys”?
“I believe I have their attention and if I don’t, I should soon enough! I have a passion for satisfying my customers, not my competitors. McLaughlin Furnace Group LLC is offing the best solution for companies in the Heat Treat Industry.”
I have made an assumption that your customers are only in the US, but I don’t know whether this is true or not-do you do any business outside of the US?
“We are mostly US driven. However we will work outside of the US. We are currently installing equipment in Vietnam. We plan to support the heat treat industry world wide.”
Whenever I see your booth at the Heat Treat trade shows you are generally featuring your own design of Endothermic generator-what differentiates you from your competitors?
“The McLaughlin Tru-Mix took us bout 2 years to design, as well as lots of R&D hours. The performance is top notch. Its 30% more efficient on the heating side and the turn down is as smooth as it gets. It will run at 4200 cfh down to 500cfh with very little swing on the dewpoint. I’ve worked on all of them over the years and I told myself McLaughlin Services LLC is going to build the best generator in the industry and that’s what we have done.”
What are your goals for the company? I don’t see you selling out and retiring to Florida in the near future so if that is not happening what do you see in the future?
“My plan has always been the same with McLaughlin Services LLC. is to keep growing it. Now that we have key employees in place, things are moving full steam ahead.”
I appreciate your time Jeff.
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Jeff Hemmer / Bluewater
Hi Jeff, let’s start off with a couple of background questions the first being your background-how did you get started in the industry and what positions have you held over the years?
“Funny Story , I had just finished a certified welding program. I met a girl who lived with her grandfather. my certificate in welding and charm wasn’t enough to win his approval. He suggested strongly that get a real job with him at the local heat treat ( Industrial Heat Treating in Indy owned by the Junkins family). Like many in our industry, I have worked my way through many if not all positions in the heat treat business, from load builder, to furnace operator, to maintenance, to management. I even filled in as a truck driver at one point in time.”
What can you tell us about Bluewater? The number of plants, ownership structure, employees and processes offered?
“Bluewater is a privately held company; we have 13 facilities in the Midwest, Canada and in Texas. We currently employ over 500 people. Bluewater offers nearly every commercial heat treat process and these are listed on our Website— bluewaterthermal.com”
I certainly understand that you are privately held and you might be reluctant to share sales figures but would you be willing to give us at least some idea about what yearly sales are?
“What I can tell you is that YTD our 2015 sales are outpacing 2014 sales and we have several very exciting programs starting this year.“
You’ve mentioned a number of different processes offered by Bluewater-is there any one that you would describe as a basic building block for the company? For instance do you regard brazing as key to the company or would you describe Bluewater as a heat treater first and a brazing expert second?
“I would describe Bluewater as problem solving thermal processor. Some of our core competencies include high volume, stainless/carbon belt brazing and annealing, high-volume Boriding and high volume aluminum T7 processing. We also have a significant footprint in the Casting/Forging thermal processes.”
On a personal level do you like some forms of heat treating over others? My personal feeling is that carburizing is the bedrock of all forms of heat treating but I realize not everybody might agree with me.
“I appreciate the thought that Carburizing and IBQ hardening is a staple in this industry and we do a significant amount of these type of conventional processes but we also like the more complex processes that we are having great successes with, for example CCC in our Stainless belt brazing furnaces at the Coldwater Michigan facility.“
Do you see much changing when it comes to equipment or will be still be seeing batch IQ furnaces when you and I are old and grey?
“Well Gord, if you haven’t noticed, we are old & grey. I think the technology will continue to improve, but batch IQ will always be a key piece of equipment due to its versatility, repeatability and dependability. We will continue to see things we never dreamt of, like improved automation and more reliable control and testing equipment. For example SSI has developed an instrument to test Carbon potential on the fly without the expense of a conventional Carbon analyser.”
At the beginning of this interview I mentioned that Bluewater is the largest US based commercial heat treater which is absolutely true. However in terms of the number of plants in North America UK based Bodycote is larger. This brings me to the point that many compare Bodycote and Bluewater Thermal-what differences or different philosophies do you see between the two companies?
“I have to say that Bodycote is a strong company that I hold in high regard. Before joining the private sector, I worked for Bodycote for many years, during which time I built some of the best and strongest relationships I have today. I would guide you to read the financial reporting package that BC sends out to understand their direction and strategy/philosophy . Bluewater is focused on having the strongest team possible while fostering a great company culture. We will continue to appreciate organic growth combined with making long term partnerships. We also are open to strategic acquisitive investments.”
What is your biggest concern as President of the company? Perhaps another way to phrase it is what keeps you awake at night?
“The safety and wellbeing of our employee’s is our number one goal we understand this is a people and equipment business so we take care of both. My goal is and always has been to send our employees home in as good condition or better as they were when they came to work. Our key safety metrics are always improving and we are better than the industry standard due to our attention to safety.”
How much autonomy does each individual plant have?
“As I mentioned we have 13 facilities, all of which have their own unique focus & core processes. Each has adapted to serve their customer’s markets and needs over the years. We have facilities with one type of furnace serving one or two specific markets as well as facilities with a half a dozen types of furnaces serving multiple markets. One thing all of our plants have in common is consistent & reliable corporate support in business development, finance, engineering, continuous improvement, safety and quality. We have focused on building a rock solid corporate team that is readily available and easily accessible to plant level management.”
The heat treating industry has been good to me however when my 23 year old son expressed a very strong desire to enter the business I had to think long and hard about the future of heat treating before I made a decision. If any of your children expressed an interest in becoming a heat treater would you encourage or discourage them?
“After the initial shock that my daughter was interested in pursuing a career in our field, I would be proud. I would definitely expose her to the day to day operations as we all know the life of a heat treat professional isn’t that of a super model.”
Let’s get personal Jeff, what is your favorite thing about your job and what is your least favorite?
“My favorite thing is easy, that is relationships. Relationships last a lifetime and those I have made and continue to make are what I like most about my job. I will remind you that I met the love of my life my wife Brooke at a heat treat plant . Bill Junkins and the Junkins family provided me all of my early carrier opportunities and Ben Crawford introduced me to the world of private equity after working together in the public sector. Ben has been one of the most influential people in my career and in the industry as well as one of my closest friends. Jim Hedman & Craig Zimmerman are two of the most professional respected, technical guys in the industry that I have been very fortunate to work with for many years. Clint Ooten ( Director Commercial )& Eric Mannix CFO are newer to this industry but very accomplished in their respective areas and it is great to work alongside Senior team members like them. In my position as President & COO, I have a great group of General Managers that I rely on daily and an fortunate to mentor and grow with. Brandon Bethea has been a great personal mentor to me while also providing leadership and communication from the board . Though his background isn’t heat treating, he has jumped in feet first to learn our business & provide us with all necessary support. When it comes to my least favorite thing… well my wife tells me, it’s the travel and understanding that my profession is not a 9a-5pm position. I am a hands-on manager that is available when and where needed and have daily contact with the plants. The good thing is she comes from a long line of successful heat treaters, so she was knew what she was signing up for.”
Going forward what changes do you see at Bluewater or the industry in general?
“We plan to continue to grow organically with an acquisitive outlook. As we have, I suspect the industry in general will continue to shift towards developing collaborative, solutions-oriented partnerships and move away from just being another commodity in the supply chain.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Gunter Rubig, Rübig GmbH & Co KG Interview
We are please to have an iterview with Mr. Gunter Rubig of Rübig GmbH & Co KG of Austria. When we think of Rubig we think mainly of nitriding but we are getting ahead of ourselves we will let Gunter tell us in his own words.
Gunter in light of all the recent developments in the field of nitriding I am delighted that I can ask you a few questions about RUBIG which is certainly amongst the leaders in the field. To start off how did you become involved in this industry?
“In 1986 I returned to Wels after seven years of work at BMW in Munich. Back in Austria I, my father Helmut Rübig and my brother Dr. Paul Rübig founded the first vacuum hardening service in Upper Austria. The site at Schafwiesenstrasse in Wels heat-treats tools and products not just for forges, but also for the Austrian hardware industry.”
Please give us a good idea about your company, size, history, capabilities and sales.
“Since the foundation of RUBIG in 1946, more than 70 years ago the company has grown from a small drop forging company to a center of excellence for metal processing. The unique synergy resulting from the close cooperation between RUBIG Systems Engineering, Heat Treatmentand Die Forge adds particular value for our customers. It is the knowledge and experience from all the divisions within the group that enable us to improve the performance of metal. The group employs more than 400 people who serve our customers nationally and internationally.”
When I think of RUBIG I think of nitriding but I also know that is not your entire business. What % of your business revolves around nitriding?
“Nitriding makes the major part of our business. RUBIG is a competence center dealing with all kinds of treatments around steel and aluminum. We know how to forge, mechanically process, heat treat, coat and analyze these materials, which is unique in the branch. Nitriding makes the major part of our business.”
I know I am repeating myself when I say that nitriding is in my opinion the fastest growing heat treating process out there and yet the technology is not new. Why are so many companies investing in the technology these days?
“Nitriding and specifically plasma/ion nitriding, had quite a difficult start in the eighties. Nitriding results were not consistent and some suppliers were not reliable. It took a long time to restore the image of ion nitriding. Up to now we have been doing a lot of missionary work to highlight its advantages and its reputation is getting better and better.”
What heat treating process is nitriding replacing? Carburizing?
“It depends on the application. Nitriding – I’m talking about gas as well as ion nitriding – can of course perfectly substitute carburizing. Because of lower temperatures and therefore less distortion, hard machining after carburizing can either be minimized or even be eliminated. On the other hand, combined with a subsequent oxidation or coating process, it is also often used to replace salt bath nitriding or hard chromium coatings.”
RUBIG of course offers both gas and plasma (ion) nitriding systems. My knowledge of gas nitriding is reasonable but my knowledge of Ion Nitriding is limited. To take it one step further I have never completely understood the technology and I know I am not alone. Could you please give myself and my readers a simple explanation about Ion Nitriding?
“The principle is the same – treating steel surfaces with nitrogen. However, only nitrogen and hydrogen are used instead of ammonia. Usually, up to 700 volts are applied between the work pieces and the chamber wall. The ionization of the process gas in the processing chamber creates a glow discharge and the electric field accelerates positive gas ions towards the parts being treated.”
Ok so why one over the other? For a manufacturer what decides which technology best suited for them?
“If you know exactly what the customer’s goal is, this question is answered easily. If you have a lot of small parts to be treated around their whole surface, go for gas nitriding. Ion nitriding comes into play if areas need to be protected from nitriding, as it is much easier to achieve it technically. From a manufacturer’s point of view it’s an advantage to offer both processes in order to be independent. That’s also one of the major reasons why we have now started to actively market our gas nitriding furnaces. We have been manufacturing them for over 20 years, but were never marketing them. So customers were afraid we would push them into the direction of ion nitriding, as we were officially only manufacturing ion nitriders.
The customer’s requirements need to the priority and not the company’s preference.”
A developing trend that I see these days is vacuum nitriding. At first glance it would appear to me that this is a more expensive approach than a typical pit furnace so why use vacuum?
“Yes you are right, the vacuum furnace technology has more technological components than a gas nitriding furnace and therefore has a higher investment requirement. But with our RUBIG Competence Center we are working day by day onto increasing of the filling capacity of the machines. We are working on ideas to reduce process time without a reduction in quality. With these innovations and furnace technologies we have many proof of concept examples where parts are treated more cost effectively in a vacuum furnace than is possible with gas nitriding.”
Switching gears slightly I understand that RUBIG also does commercial heat treating. Is this a significant portion of your business? Which do you personally prefer the equipment side of things or the commercial heat treating side?
“Commercial heat treating and furnace building are of the same importance. Even if both divisions deal with heat treatment, daily business is completely different. Whereas our commercial heat treatment branches (one in Austria and one in Slovakia) are working more regionally, our furnace building division is almost exclusively doing business abroad.”
What further advancements in heat treating do you see in the near and medium future?
“The quality requirements will increase and increase, while the costs have to be decreased. For the near future it is necessary to develop more efficient heat treatment technology to overcome the cost issues. Nevertheless quality has to be the priority.”
And RUBIG – what does the future hold for your company? More commercial heat treating? Adding other technologies? Or perhaps adding more facilities around the world?
“A bit of everything. To plan the future activities is mainly dependent on the needs of our customers. We have cooperative projects regarding future technologies with our customers and universities. Regarding more heat treatment or more facilities it is like looking into a crystal ball, no one knows what will happen in five years but we are prepared for future challenges.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Gord Montgomery / William G Montgomery Limited
What was your first job within the industry?
“My father William started a small rep business in Canada in 1969 concentrating on power transmission products and castings. Shortly after he started the business he was approached by Alloy Engineering and Casting of Berea, Ohio about selling their products to the heat treating industry. Gradually over the years the power transmission business shrunk and the heat treating business grew until roughly 10 years later he was selling only heat treat related products. Back in 1979 when I was 21 he talked me into working for him as a salesman, which I reluctantly agreed to on a temporary basis-I am now 57 and my father Bill is a very healthy 80 and long since retired. So my first job in the industry was as a manufacturers rep which of course is what I still am.”
So where did “The Monty” come from?
“I well remember doing an interview with Michael Korwin, founder of Nitrex a few years back and one of the questions I asked him was why he started Nitrex. His answer would was the same as mine-to feed my family. While the rep business has always provided the Montgomery’s with a respectable income it was obvious to me that with Canada and Upstate NY being small territories for Heat Treating and getting smaller that I would be able to feed my family, keep a roof over the heads and have some luxuries but not much more. “The Monty” was my idea to supplement my income by selling used equipment, the idea of advertising as an example never crossed my mind.”
What do you find to be the most enjoyable part of your career?
“Bill St. Thomas, a well known individual in the industry hit the nail on the head just the other day when he said he loves seeing how things are made. Since heat treating is part of the manufacturing process I have been lucky enough to see how cars are made, guns, jet engines and on and on-I never get tired of that. But the best part is travelling to interesting places and meeting fellow heat treaters around the world-I never cease to be amazed how I can be in a country on the other side of the world and within minutes of meeting a heat treater we realize we have ten or twenty mutual friends.”
Is the heat treating industry growing enough so that there’s room for someone young like me?
“As long as people use steel there will be lots of room for more young people.“
In your opinion are there too few or too many people entering into the heat treating industry?
“Far, far too few people are getting into the heat treating industry which is a real shame as it can be fairly well paying and is a good honest profession. In just about all cases young people getting into the industry do so because a family member is in the business. Universities need to talk about professions such as metallurgy and heat treating as opposed to turning out another 1,000 individuals with Bachelor of Arts degrees-to this day I am still not quite sure what a Bachelor of Arts actually prepares you for except possibly driving a cab.”
Do you see anything on the future horizon that could affect future opportunities?
“There are a million things that can happen that would effect the industry. If a plastic is invented that has all the charecteristics of steel and does not require heat treating we are all out of business. At the end of the day there is only so much that can be forecast with any certainty so I don’t worry about it. It is only a few years since we were told “peak oil” was arriving for the fifth time since the 1800’s. Now they can’t give it away-who would have forecast that?”
In the near future do you see more acquisitions in the commercial heat treat world?
“With the exception of the very large players such as Bodycote, Aalberts Industries, Bluewater, Hightemp in India, Paulo Products and a few others most commercial heat treaters do not have the resources or interest in growing through acquisitions. As always Bodycote is the model to look at here. The company makes acquisitions to either gain market share in an area where they are not strongly represented such as Carolina Commercial in the Southeastern US (a growing market where they had to be represented) or occasionaly they will acquire a company with a very unique technology such as Nitrion in Munich, Germany a number of year back (Plasma Nitriding). If the average commercial shop in North America has sales of $2 ½ to $3 million USD they are generally not of interest to the large players as an acquisition which pretty much guarantees that the smaller “mom and pop” shops will be with us for quite some time.”
How does heat treating differ in different countries?
“It doesn’t. To some extent by product, for instance Taiwan produces a lot of fasteners so you see a great number of mesh belt lines, whereas in the UK you see very few mesh belt lines but at the end of the day furnaces in the US, Germany, Japan or India are pretty much the same.“
What is the size of the heat treating market and do you see it growing or shrinking?
“Bodycote has put a lot of effort over the years into determining the size of the market (their estimates are available somewhere on their website) but at the end of the day I am very skeptical that anybody has a good handle on this. For instance what does heat treating include? Foundries? Steel Making? It is gospel that heat treating in the US is $20 billion/year with commercial heat treating representing 10% of this. However I have yet to find out where this number came from and what it includes so my personal feeling is pick a number, any number through in a margin of error of at least 25% and your guess is as good as anybodies. As a mature industry I see heat treating continuing to grow but at a pace exactly equal to the growth in manufacturing.“
When you look at the commercial heat treating industry do you see it growing or shrinking in the future?
“I believe that in the more developed areas commercial heat treating will slowly grow as a percentage of the overall market for the simple reason that transportation is relatively easy and certainly these days cheap and it removes a process that is generally not a core competency of the manufacturer. However in less developed areas such as India or China I believe that captive heat treating will remain the norm because logistics is an issue. Anybody that has ever seen traffic in New Delhi or Shanghai will know exactly what I mean.“
What technologies are growing in the industry?
“Nitriding and vacuum carburizing. However at the end of the day change happens very slowly in the heat treating world and the most common type of furnace in the world a batch IQ furnace is still pretty much the same as it was 60 years ago.”
Who would you say are the most influential people in the industry today?
“Jord you must have been reading back issues of “The Monty” since we did this a few years back. A few names come to mind but I would as in the past pick the CEO of Bodycote in this case Mr. Steven Harris as the most influential.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Geoffrey Somary / Ipsen
Recently we interviewed Mr. Pat McKenna, President & CEO of furnace builder Ipsen. As a follow up to that interview we have been looking forward to speaking with Mr. Geoffrey Somary, COO at Ipsen Group who is going to give us more of a global perspective about the company.
Perhaps it is a sign of age Geoffrey but it seems that I preface many of my interviews with “we have known each other for some time now” and this interview is no different-how long have we known each other now?
“We first met at the Reno FNA show in 2006 when I was leading VFS prior to merging that strong brand together with Ipsen. I believe I gave you a deck of ‘VFS Reno 2006’ playing cards – which are now treasured by collectors worldwide.”
I got a little ahead of myself with my first question, what is your background and how did you into this industry?
“Born and raised in New York City – I left the Big Apple to attend Northwestern University where I received my mechanical engineering degree. I spent the first 17 years of my career at a German-owned technology company where they asked me to train for my first two years near Stuttgart. During this time, I learned the German language – I was also there to help take down the Berlin wall and I still have a piece of it. In 2005, Ipsen recruited me to join the team as Vice President Technology and that started my journey with Ipsen which is now nearly thirteen years.”
It was not that long ago that you were primarily involved with Ipsen USA, now that you are COO of Ipsen Group how has your day-to-day responsibilities changed?
“I became Ipsen USA CEO in 2009 and in 2013 received the additional parallel responsibility of Group COO. As the group has grown (bookings up 30%+ from 2015 to 2017) the effort required globally increased to the point that I felt the USA team needed a dedicated full time leader and Patrick McKenna seamlessly took over in 2017. Today, I am responsible for all global Ipsen operating entities and work to implement the strategic plan of the company; I can highlight three of those focus areas here:
1) Excellence in aftermarket services:
Our aftermarket business (we call it ICS = Ipsen Customer Services) is nearly half of our annual business and we look to strongly increase the services team to have greater proximity to our customers. Everything starts with excellence in service and delivering the same high performance anywhere in the world.
2) Advancement of products:
Expand our capabilities in highly customized heat treatment performance systems. If you visit our facilities anywhere in the world right now you would see many first time innovations from the largest vacuum furnace ever built to high speed part manipulators to a new generation gas-tight atmosphere roller hearth furnace and more. We also tirelessly roll out continuous improvement on our global platform products like ATLAS, TITAN, Turbo2Treater and MetaPro. Due to the high quantity of these products, we are always working on the next generation of advancement.
3) Digital IoT Solutions:
PdMetrics launched two years ago is only the beginning. Although customers appreciate the cool features we roll out here, we only deliver a digital product if our customers get real measurable value from the product. Watch for more great things to come.”
Can you explain to me about the top people at Ipsen? For instance I have met Thorsten Kruger at several of the heat treat shows in Germany-where does he fit into the hierarchy? Also Marc Angenendt who is always a very friendly fellow.
“Ipsen Group is led by three people – Thorsten Krueger who is CEO and speaker, I am COO and Houman Khorram is Group CFO. We have five global operating entities and each of these has a leader, which in Europe is Marc Angenendt, in Americas it is Patrick McKenna, for China Guoxin Weng, India Shubhendra Panse and Japan Art Tsubaki.”
Pat shared with us approximate sales figures for Ipsen USA, are you in a position to tell us about worldwide sales?
“2018 revenue will be in range of $275 to $300 million.”
Ipsen is of course based in Germany but has a number of different locations around the world. Is each plant dedicated to a certain geographic area? A certain product mix or a combination of both?
“The different global manufacturing sites have varying specializations but we prefer to think from the customer’s perspective and therefore have in each county/state/country a clear customer experience owner. This person or team will sell and support the best Ipsen products and services to that customer – regardless of where they are manufactured. Whether you are located in Sweden, Singapore or Sacramento, you can expect one global standard of performance from Ipsen.”
I always think of Kleve, Germany as being the head office of Ipsen and the largest manufacturing facility-is this still the case?
“Ipsen’s Kleve, Germany and Cherry Valley (Rockford) Illinois facilities are comparable in size and output these days and depending on the year (and exchange rate) one or the other might do more. But, watch out for the fast growing Asia entities – in one example, after a very strong increase in 2017, our Q1 2018 bookings in India are up 75% over the prior year.”
Most people are aware that Ipsen makes most styles of furnaces but I would venture to say that the first thing to pop into peoples heads when they hear Ipsen is vacuum furnace. A few years back you and others were instrumental in bringing the “Titan” to market. Has this been a success? How did that whole project come about?
“The TITAN, born at Ipsen’s Cherry Valley location, came to life in the darkest hours of the 2008 financial crisis when things looked really bleak. Companies were moving factories to low cost countries faster than you could count and each day the Newspapers predicted the demise of western manufacturing. An area within Ipsen was walled-off from the rest of the business and a team of young raw talent mixed with experienced veterans got to work. Their dream was bigger than TITAN. Their dream was to prove to the world – that Ipsen could compete with anyone. Not just compete – but offer something so compelling people would just have to have one. Yes – it is a success. More than 300 TITANs have been sold into 26 different countries and that lead to other Ipsen platform products where the total global count now exceeds 600 units.”
Is there any style of furnace that Ipsen has not built?
“When looking at Ipsen’s diverse 70 years in business, we have built nearly all types of furnaces.”
You know I have to ask this question-is Ipsen for sale? The rumors have been swirling for some time now but never seem to lead anywhere. Who does own the group?
“The shareholder of Ipsen are a Germany-based private equity firm that supports us very strongly. Ipsen is not for sale and we are firmly working on our customer-focused strategy.”
There have been some mergers and acquisitions in the industry but it also seems that each time there is an acquisition amongst furnace builder a new supplier pops up, as often as not in Asia. Do you feel there are too many manufacturers these days? How about acquisitions-do you expect to see many in the near future?
“Competition is good for the industry and keeps us on our toes – always innovating – always improving. Regarding acquisitions, I foresee some action in the coming 12 months in our industry.”
I would venture to say that these are the good times for most furnace manufacturers including Ipsen-how long would you guess this is going to last for?
“Ipsen has developed some good metrics for predicting the market and I believe that the market will stay strong for the foreseeable future. There are market trends that can override down cycles in the market. One example is more wide-body aircraft – results in higher volume large diameter engines – results in older furnaces being too small. With such trends, a segment can be nearly flat while furnace sales in that segment can grow by double-digit percentage. Ipsen also has a unique stability advantage, as our recurring aftermarket business is nearly 50% of the total business.”
What can you share with us about future plans for the company? Anything you can share with us about the future?
“I have often heard that in our industry things don’t change. At Ipsen, we don’t agree. We are investing million of dollars annually into game-changing ideas. Look for great things to come from our excellent global team. Using the words first repeated by the 2008 development team and still spoken at Ipsen today: Hard Work Wins!”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Dr. Peter Schobesberger / Aichelin
Hi Peter. To start off while I am quite familiar with Aichelin some of our readers might not be as familiar with the company. Could you please give us a brief background about the company?
“Aichelin started in business in Germany in 1868 with cooking stoves for private and large-sized kitchens as well as living-room heating stoves built of iron and porcelain. At the turn of the century, in addition to these stoves, the company expanded their production range to include coal- and coke-fired ovens which were used for heat treatment of steel parts for industry. Aichelin today is an international group of manufacturers of heat treat equipment for the thermal and thermo-chemical treatment of metal components. We serve a broad range of customers – starting with manufacturers of large gears, wheels, bearings, fasteners, automotive suppliers to suppliers of small, precision parts for the watch industry. The group employs more than 1200 people and its turnover amounted to 148 m€ in 2011. (Editors note; this is roughly $188 million USD).”
The company is of course based in Austria but has a number of locations around the world. Where are your sales based geographically? Would you say that Europe remains your focus or is this gradually changing to other areas?
“Today, the Aichelin Group is internationally very well positioned. Our headquarters is in Austria, south of Vienna. This is the main manufacturing site for Aichelin furnaces in Europe. NOXMAT – specializing in the production of burner systems, EMA – a manufacturer of induction heating systems and our after market sales operation are all located in Germany. Our specialist for mesh-belt furnaces is SAFED with operations in Switzerland, France and Germany. Aichelin USA is located in Michigan and we feel our technical innovations give this location a real advantage. With a strong know-how basis from the European core companies Aichelin concentrates especially on the development of the business in the growing markets of China, India and Brazil. In all of these countries Aichelin is represented by our own production sites, service locations and/or sales offices. The business volume is constantly growing in Asia therefore we need to become more “Asian”. This does not mean that we will forget our roots and certainly we will keep on cultivating our strong base in Europe.”
January 1st, 2011 you became CEO and President of Aichelin Holding, how did you ever get involved in this industry and how long have been in the heat treating industry?
“Since starting my professional career I have been involved with high temperatures-there must be something in my genes. After studying process engineering I worked for a thermal power plant builder until 1999. This was the year when I decided to change from power generation to heat treatment as I was very familiar with high temperature applications and the associated chemistry. Looking at the heat treat industry and all the different applications in the fabrication of gears, bearings and other products I grow more and more fascinated. That`s why I am still here and I have not regretted one single day.”
My understanding is that Aichelin makes most types of furnaces available on the market with the exception of vacuum furnaces and vacuum carburizing systems. Are you seeing any particular type of furnace growing at the expense of others? For instance a trend towards batch IQ furnaces as opposed to pusher style?
“The decision about what type of furnace to use is always a matter of part geometry, size and number of pieces you need to produce. Several years ago there was a clear trend to vacuum carburizing and a lot of users were curious about this knew technology. Now the dust has settled and one can see clearly its benefits and disadvantages. Nowadays decision makers prefer a more rational approach and usually the type of furnace has a lot to do with the experience of the end user. In the US and Europe the approach is pretty conservative while in Asia the actual furnace builder has a lot of influence in the decision about what type of furnace to use.”
Tying in with my previous question about trends in furnace styles I have to ask you my favorite question-where do you see the industry going in the future? At the end of the day this is a very conservative, staid mature industry where things do not change quickly. Do you foresee any substantial changes in the next 10, 20 or even 50 years? For instance a consolidation in the furnace building industry with only a few of the major players left or a dramatic drop in the amount of heat treating done around the world?
“This is the kind of question one can fail at tremendously and part of the answer you gave already. Since heat treatment is a mature conservative industry things do not change quickly. This gives all decision makers in this industry with enough foresight sufficient time to adapt. Electro mobility will have different needs with respect to its applied parts and materials. How fast and to what extent we are moving in this direction however is at present pretty uncertain. In the near future I see no decrease in heat treatment around the world. For sure the increase in Asia will continue while in North America and Europe my expectations are not that high but I also do not see a major drop. Some consolidation probably will occur but since small to medium size furnaces are not very capital intensive to build, there will pop up new competitors with smart ideas. There is no danger that competition will die.”
My impression is that Aichelin is the largest builder of new furnaces in the world. Would you agree with this statement?
“Whether or not we are the largest manufacturer of furnaces depends upon the criteria you use. Don’t forget that Aichelin is not active in what we call “primary heat treatment”-the production of semi fabricated goods. It is true that we are pretty strong in heat treatment of already machined parts, which get their final hardness by carburizing, nitriding or similar process steps.”
One thing I have personally witnessed is the growth of new furnace builders in areas such as China and India. Some of these companies are growing at a tremendous pace and every day that goes by they become more and more technically advanced and rivaling the capabilities of some of the “western” long established new furnace builders. How much of a threat does this pose for your company? Do you see some of these new builders becoming major players in Europe of North America?
“In the last few years it was also our experience that the growth in China and in India allowed a lot of start ups in the furnace industry. Aichelin itself has taken advantage of these favorable market conditions and has gown tremendously in these areas. Generally we are successful in keeping these new suppliers out of our current customer base. For several reasons I am not really worried about the competition from the East. If you have a close look at the quality provided from Chinese furnace fabricators for instance, there is still a huge difference. The prices in China or India are rising nearly 10% per year, which diminishes the present cost advantage steadily. The transport of a bulky good such as a furnace to a western country adds another 5 to 10% to the investment. Most important however is the lack of good customer support after a furnace is installed. Spare parts, trouble shooting and maintenance support in Asia has not grown as quickly as it should have. We see that many Asian competitors are not nearly as focused on after market service and support as they should be. Without being worried, however, we are always alert to quickly follow the market trends in Asia.”
Of all of your competitors which one do you respect the most?
“I do not want to place names here and deeply respect every honorable creative competitor. Sometimes I see exaggerated performance data given by competitors which leads to an investment decision based on a faulty base, which makes me angry, particularly when I later on see no severe consequences when this data is proven to be incorrect. Aichelin always wants to be identified as a trusted and reliable partner for all in the heat treatment industry. We are fully committed to our mission “Reliability at Work”. I believe more furnace manufacturers should take this approach.”
You always strike me as a very happy, optimistic individual who truly enjoys what he is doing. While none of us can forecast the future do you plan to spend your entire working life involved with heat treating?
“Again you want me to make look into a crystal ball. I have more than a decade ahead of me in my business life. At present I am enjoying my assignment with Aichelin and I don’t see any signs on the horizon, which would lead me to believe I will be looking for another challenge.”
So what interesting developments can you tell us about at Aichelin? Any “juicy” tidbits of information or gossip that you would care to share with us?
“I do not know whether you have already heard about our recent acquisitions in China. Aichelin, China acquired in the spring of 2012 two furnace fabricators in Tangshan, which is located some 200 km from our main production site in Beijing. This allows us to proceed with our growth strategy in China and to expand upon our leading position in the country. Aichelin now has three production facilities in China with approximately 750 employees.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033