Peter Schobesberger / Aichelin

We are very pleased to be able to offer you this interview with Mr. Peter Schobesberger, CEO of one of the largest furnace builders in the world Aichelin. We were able to speak with Peter at the company’s 150th anniversary which took place in Stuttgart, Germany this past week.  Peter going by memory it is about 3 years since our last interview which can be found at http://themonty.wpengine.com/peter-schobesberger/ In that interview you gave us the background of Aichelin so I see no need to go over that again. Instead let’s look at what has changed since then.

This moment celebrates the 150th anniversary of Aichelin, a very impressive moment for the company- it must make you and your team very proud to be part of it.  What would you like to say about this celebration?

“We are very happy to celebrate this anniversary with a lot of close business partners today in Stuttgart. Aichelin Group is in excellent condition and we are looking forward to the future. This is also a day where we are grateful to all the people from the heat treat community which have helped us in all the decades. For us it is also a mission to continue with all our passion to serve this market in the future in order to be on top for many more decades.”

While there have been a number of changes at Aichelin over the past few years it would appear that the acquisition of US based AFC-Holcroft is the most significant-how did this come about? (at this point I should mention that WG Montgomery Ltd., “The Monty” is a longstanding AFC-Holcroft rep covering Canada and Upstate, NY.)

“For sure, this acquisition was one of the big steps in Aichelin’s history. There were attempts from Aichelin to get a substantial presence in North America since the 1980`s however up until 2016 our success was limited to European based companies, which were familiar with the Aichelin furnace philosophy. This unfortunately though was limited to only a minority of the US heat treatment clients. So it was obvious that Aichelin should team up with a US based partner to gain more influence. We had this plan in our minds for a long time, but in 2016 the timing with AFC Holcroft was perfect. Like in a marriage: Both have to say “Yes” at the same time, which we did.”

Let’s focus on the AFC-Holcroft acquisition, has it been a success and what have the benefits been? Along the same lines have there been any negatives to the acquisition?

“It was truly a success. Now we have an overview about the entire world market development (except Japan) for our relevant customer sectors such as the car and truck industries, bearing and fastener industries as well as commercial heat treaters. Thus we can always offer from the Aichelin Group the optimized concept from the closest location. We are much closer to our customers in after sales services as well. We have already received a great deal of very good feedback about this.”

What have the two companies learned from each other? Has each remained independent?

“The engineering and production processes at AFC Holcroft and at Aichelin showed some differences and both had pros and cons. Already in the first year we have shared a great deal of this information and so have initiated an improved process on both sides. There is still utmost independency in business decisions but as in every family there needs to be some rules.”

 AFC-Holcroft brought you an instant commanding presence in North America, are there any other geographic regions of similar interest to you?

“We are very happy to have a balanced, strong position in Europe, North America and China. Aichelin Group is always concentrating on major fabrication spots for machine production, where heat treatment is required. For us it is necessary to follow closely the development in all areas. For the short term our focus is on the regions where we are already present.”

We have dwelled on the AFC-Holcroft acquisition, what other interesting changes have there been over the past few years?

“Aichelin sees itself always as a technology leader. As an example we saw an increased demand for hot formed press plates for cars. Therefore we entered into this field and have successfully made several installations of our new HeatXpress technology in Germany, USA and China. We expect in this sector further growth and see our system as a true alternative to overcome the shortcomings of the roller hearth furnace concept.”

Let’s switch gears now, Aichelin has vast experience in most types of heat treat furnaces, the only type of furnace where Aichelin is not a dominant player is in vacuum furnaces. This brings up the obvious question, is this something you are considering? Perhaps through another acquisition?

“This is a question I am frequently asked. There are numerous suppliers of vacuum furnaces which more or less satisfy the market. For us it was not a priority to cover this field. We will only enter this market  if we can offer to our clients some added value, which goes beyond todays available technology.”

Batch processing or continuous? Each has its advantages and disadvantages- do you see one becoming more dominant in the future?

“Batch or continuous is not an either or it is a both. The advantage of continuous is better uniformity of part properties and higher efficiency. The advantage of batch is a lower starting cost and higher flexibility. I see some tendencies in the US to batch but in the rest of the world clearly continuous is preferred when the quantities are sufficient.”

I would venture to say that these are the good times in the worldwide heat treating industry and on a personal level I am quite optimistic about the future-what are your feelings? Do you see any potential issues in the future which cause your sleepless nights?

“You are right. Our industry has gone through good times and we are still on a high level. For 2019 I see some clouds on the horizon. My concerns are linked to political developments on a global scale. It seems that globalisation has put us in a reverse gear. Political leaders of large countries promote populistic protectionism. This creates insecurities and thus slows down investments.”

This question to some extent is tied in with the previous one and it has to do with additive manufacturing. Do you believe that this new type of manufacturing process will dramatically change how parts are heat treated?

“A lot of new shaped parts can be realised with additive manufacturing. We are still at the beginning to experiment with various metal powder compositions. For prototypes it is already a viable option. So far heat treatment of 3 D printed parts concentrate on stress relieving or to increase density on the expensive HIP process. For mass production it is way too early to make a judgement whether or not there will be a break through.”

Depending upon who you ask electric cars are the way of the future with gas powered vehicles disappearing either quickly or slowly. As we all know electric cars require far less heat treated transmission components than gas or diesel vehicles. Is this something which enters into your thoughts when predicting the growth of the heat treating industry?

“Yes, this is part of our strategic planning for mid term. We are carefully watching what is going on in this field. However, I think that the current debate over diesel emissions is overheated and it would be good to see some more reasonable evaluations. I am convinced that a modern industrial society will also require sophisticated heat treatment in future.”

Peter Schobesberger, Gord Montgomery

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Pete Batche/CQI-9.  

Today we’re talking with Mr. Pete Batche who is Senior Quality Engineer/Heat Treat Specialist with Akebono Brake Corporation and also an individual who had a great deal to do with CQI-9 heat treating specifications.

Pete you and I have been running across each other for a number of years now but beyond your current position with Akebono Brake Corp. and previous to that with the Robert Bosch Company I know nothing about your background and how you came to the heat treating industry. Can you please give us a brief background of your history in the heat treating industry? 

“1990 I began my career within the fastener industry beginning with the Cold Heading Co. of Warren, MI followed by Ring Screw Works of Sterling Heights, MI.  Ring Screw Works was later acquired by Textron Fastening Systems. I was fortunate to be exposed to many positions within the fastener industry including Furnace Operator, Waste Water Treatment, Metallurgical Laboratory Supervisor, and In-process Inspection (Heading, Thread Rolling & Heat Treatment) Quality Manager & Global Heat Treat Specialist.”
 

CQI-9. The phrase can in some cases set fear into the hearts of many a captive and commercial heat treater. First off could you tell us how and when the spec originated? 

“In 2003 there was a cooperative effort within the automotive industry primarily driven by the OEMs to establish a common heat treat system assessment with universal acceptance. Coincidentally several costly heat treat related quality concerns had occurred around this time frame, thus resulting in increased focus of the heat treat community. The Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG) was selected as the source to aid in directing these initiatives.”

If I was asked to explain in 50 words or less what CQI-9 is exactly my response would probably be; “CQI-9 is a worldwide automotive heat treating specification designed a number of years ago to insure (through self audits) that every heat treater of auto parts is working to the same quality standards”. So Pete how far off the mark am I? 

 “Your interpretation is correct. Same goals, objectives and hopefully the reduced frequency of second party on site assessments utilizing different heat treat assessments that were common place at one time and adding much confusion and a vast multitude of many different customer requirements that made it very difficult to comply with, from a quality prospective.”

I gather you had a great deal to do with the specification and how it is written and for that matter still have a great deal to do with it. How did you come to be involved with this process and how many individuals are actually part of the decision making process? 

” I’ve very fortunate to have been included with the development of CQI-9 from the beginning. I received an invitation from the Detroit Michigan area OEMs to participate. As you have mentioned, I remain a member on the technical committee at this time.  In excess of 19 individuals comprise the technical committee with much guidance by our chair person.  As subsequent revisions and or changes are made to CQI-9, all related documents are submitted to the steering committee within (AIAG) for review and consensus approval. Overall it’s a very complex process with involvement from many individuals.”

I have always been curious-is this a paid position or voluntary? Along the same lines how much time do you generally dedicate to this and how do you fit it in around your “real” job? 

“The committees consist of volunteers within the automotive industry and remain as unpaid voluntary positions. As far as the time dedicated, that’s a difficult question. It truly depends on the workload of “the real job” between committee meetings and the ability to “take on” assignments that are handed out. As new revisions to CQI-9 are scheduled for release, the members of the technical committee will have their hands full. However, as the recently released 3rd Edition has been rolled out I expect very infrequent meetings to discuss potential changes, errors and or maintenance requests (see pg 99 of CQI-9) of the assessment.” 

6) Now here is a real loaded question for you, has this been a overwhelming success in that it has substantially reduced quality issues or do you feel that you still have a long way to go? 

“Unfortunately, I cannot support this question with data and or quality measurable that most would want to see. I can only speak on personal experiences and interaction with other professionals in the automotive heat treat community. Yes, I honestly believe CQI-9 has made a positive impact on product quality,  reduced variation and last but not least large customer quality impact issues in the form of yard holds and recall type conditions to name a few.”

I don’t want to beat the CQI-9 subject to death as I have other questions for you but I have to ask what do you see in the future for the specification? For instance do you see a point in time where every supplier is voluntarily adhering to the principals behind the specs and it will become redundant? Or do you see the specifications becoming more and more thorough? 

“My perception is upon the initial release of the 1st Edition of CQI-9 there was some resistance within the industry. For example “Oh great, CQI-9 the new flavor of the month” what’s next? For the most part I see a disciplined approach taking place within the automotive heat treat community.  As more products and services are sourced to all corners of the globe, familiarity of and compliance to CQI-9 can be nonexistent for several reasons. Either a new supplier to the automotive market and or customer specific requirements are not cascaded down to sub-tiers. At this point in time, I don’t see any major changes to CQI-9 in the near future. A sigh of relief for many I suppose!”

Moving on from CQI-9 I would like to ask you about Akebono Brake Corp. Other than the fact that it is a Japanese company supplying auto parts I know nothing about the company, what could you share with us and needless to say what is of most interest to myself and our readers is how much heat treating you do in house and what type of processes you currently run? 

“Akebono Brake Corporation manufactures a wide range of brake friction material and foundation brake assemblies, including disc brake callipers and drum brakes to the OEM and aftermarket. Current in house processing capabilities include: solution, artificial aging & ferritic nitrocarburizing.”

You are in a truly unique situation in that you have been responsible for captive heat treating at at least 2 companies but you have also spent years looking closely at commercial heat treaters, and probably know commercial heat treating as well or better than anybody in the industry. This might perhaps be a rather simplistic question but beyond the obvious what differences do you see between captive and commercial heat treaters? For instance do you find that captives are more or less likely to invest in new processes as opposed to commercials? Do you find a different mentality between the two? As an example do you find that most commercials consider themselves “genuine” heat treaters compared to captives considering themselves parts makers first and heat treaters a distant second? 

“Monetary capital investment in equipment between captive and commercial sources is like walking a tight rope in my opinion. Most are watching the economy / market place with hopeful optimism to ensure procuring new equipment and or investing in new processes is a sound business decision for long term. As we well know, increased furnace and equipment orders as well as improved sales have indicated a strong upswing for not only the furnace manufactures but also for captive and commercial sources as well. As I have a vast supply base of commercial and captive teat treat sources, let’s just say I have the utmost respect and enjoy working with them all equally!”

In what situations would you consider outsourcing your heat treat requirements and in which cases would you have a close look and say “the only option is heat treating in house”? 

“Maintaining all processes in-house as well as ultimate control over quality is key. Last but not least, cost has a huge impact on the final decision.”

Do you see more heat treating being done in commercials in the future or do you feel the current ratio (roughly 90% in house and 10% commercial in North America) remaining pretty constant? 

“For the foreseeable future I do not anticipate the estimated ratios you have mentioned would change much.”

I have been accused of travelling quite a bit but beside yourself I look like a “stay at home” type. With all the heat treats you have seen in countries around the world do you feel that heat treating is becoming pretty standard in all areas or are there still vast differences between countries in terms of quality and equipment? 

“In my travels I do run across philosophical differences in the approach of quality systems and equipment maintenance in various regions. However, as I am a firm believer of CQI-9, if followed with a disciplined approach (as many have chosen to embrace in today’s day and age) I see some of the differential gaps beginning to close.”

What heat treating technologies do you see with the brightest future? At the end of the day heat treating really has not changed much over the past 100 years, batch IQ’s as an example are still as popular as when they were first introduced over 50 years ago. So do you see anything on the horizon that you feel might revolutionize or at least substantially change the way heat treating is currently done? 

“As you have mentioned in many previous articles for publication various vacuum technologies have appeared to take center stage lately. In addition, I believe there is a much stronger demand for ferritic nitrocarburizing as well. No revolutionizing changes I can speak of. At the end of the day I see a lot of investment in process control for not only new equipment but used equipment as well, specific to furnace monitoring systems  with all the “bells and whistles”. The days of paper chart recorders are slowly escaping us.”

None of us can predict the future but what do you think the future has in store for Pete Batche? Can you see yourself being involved in specifications such as CQI-9 20 years from now or do you see yourself remaining heavily involved in the captive heat treating field? Of course option #3 might be sailing around the world for all I know. 

“Being a small piece of the puzzle when it comes to CQI-9, I have truly been honored to work with such a talented and great group of heat treat professionals. The knowledge and camaraderie I have enjoyed over the last 9 years has been personally and professionally rewarding.  I would like to support the “mission” long term. For the foreseeable future I plan on continuing my involvement and development activities of the commercial and captive heat treat facilities. Or the alternative option would be, if I had it my way, I would be restoring classic British motorcycles full time in my barn.” 

On a more personal note I always look forward to running into you at various trade shows around the world although every time I do it takes a couple of hours out of my life since we seem to be able to chat about heat treating for at least this long. I do want to say though that I truly hope our paths will continue to cross.  Thank you, Gord

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Pawel Wyrzykowski / Seco Warwick

I have to say Pawel that I have been looking forward to asking you a few questions about Seco Warwick and the heat treating world. To start off I have to say I have never been entirely clear about the structure of Seco Warwick. As an example you have a number of different locations around the world-are these all divisions of Seco Warwick?

“After  a  transformation  period  we have been  able to finally create a clear corporate structure of the Seco/Warwick Group as of  the beginning  of 2013. So, right now we have a small industrial management holding company (S/W SA) which, on the one hand is listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange, and on the other – holds all remaining shareholdings in our regional operational companies, such as S/W Eurpoe (Poland), S/W Corporation (USA), Retech (USA), SWR (China) and SWA (India). Apart from this we have 2 sales & service regional companies SWS (Germany) and SW Russia. S/W Holding employes 5 Vice Presidents globally responsible for our 5 technology lines  (business segments) and some functional managers, who are globally responsible for purchasing, HR, finance and a few other functions. Apart from this we developed a legal and management framework which sets up the rules and relations of single companies with our global  business segments and defines the principles of joint projects. ”   

I have always been curious-where did the name Seco Warwick come from and when was the company started?

“Seco Warwick was originally the name only of the SW Corporation in the US, who had acted as our previous parent company. Then, in 2006 the so called reverse take over took place, where the Polish subsidiary took over its US parent company, which in effect became a subsidiary. Until 2012 some management functions were spread over 2  or 3 group companies. We decided to change it and right now we are proud to have not only a very transparent corporate structure, but also a structure which supports our strategy and the know-how transfer.”     

How did you end up as the CEO of Seco Warwick?

“Until  the end of 2011 I had been working for 13 years for a German industrial company. Firstly and I had the honor to lead the East-European business for 10 years and then the last 3 years I spent on the corporate level in Germany being in charge for all international activities. When I wanted to return to Poland, Seco/Warwick was  searching  for somebody of my profile, not necessarily  with furnace experience. From the moment we met, it was a short way to agree on my assignment. I respect this opportunity very much, as there are really not too  many truly global industrial companies  with their HQ in Poland.”  

When I think of Seco Warwick I think of vacuum furnaces first, aluminum furnaces second and everything else further down the list. Is this a fair assessment? Would you care to share with us a breakdown of the various types of furnaces you build in terms of a % of total sales? For instance are vacuum furnaces 50% of your overall business?

“Yes, apart of Vacuum and Aluminum, we have 3 further business segments which are: Atmosphere, Melting (Retech) and CAB (Controlled Atmosphere Brazing).“

What are annual sales for the company or group?

“For 2012 we ended up with  sales of 120 Million EUR, which represents a 34% growth over 2011.  The year 2012 was clearly the most successful year in our history, but we intend to keep growing in sales.“

I would venture to say that Seco has probably sold more single chamber vacuum carburizing furnaces than any other builder out there-sound reasonable? Continuing with vacuum carburizing I know a number of years back you designed a large multi-chamber vacuum carburizing system but I don’t recall ever seeing one in operation. Is this still one of your product offerings?

“SECO/WARWICK has been working on the low pressure carburizing systems for almost two decades. This is one of the success stories of close cooperation between the scientists and the industry. Together with our partner from Technical University in Lodz we have developed and patented a very unique carburizing technology, called a FineCarb. It is based on the special carburizing gases mixture, and jointly with a number of smaller solutions it enables our customers to run the process very efficiently and without the formation of soot and tar. Part of the package is a simulation software, that makes it very easy to build the process recipes. Because of the technical advantages, nowadays, practically all high pressure quench furnaces sold to the commercial heat treaters are equipped with this feature. Encouraged by the success we have reached with single chamber HPQ furnaces, we have developed new double and multi – chamber systems. The first unit build, the one that you are referring to, is working for the global heat treatment service provider. The experience gained with this unit has helped us in winning orders for other multi-chamber installations.“

Any plans on getting into the nitriding business?

“We’ve  been in this business for a few years. More and more of our customers are looking to source the equipment and the technology from one  company . This is why, a little over three years ago, we  launched a nitriding technology called ZeroFlow. What is unique in our method, is the high efficiency  combined with   a very low consumption of ammonia.”

Sales wise what is your largest geographic area and do you see this changing in the future?

“Currently it is still the US and Europe. But we are very happy seeing our development in Asia. SW Allied is already the biggest furnace producer in India.  The year 2012 was the first full year of operation of our  new factory in China and we are proud about our achievements there.  We hope also to increase our activities  in some other interesting markets in the future, like Brazil, Russia and Germany.”

With all due respect to yourself and other new furnace builders my opinion is that basic furnace design has changed very little in the past 50 years. Granted the controls have changed dramatically but beyond that the design is largely the same. Do you see this changing any time in the near future? Does Seco have any radical new ideas which you can mention?

“Generally I agree with your observation. However keeping in mind the purpose which each furnace should serve, Seco/Warwick constantly improves  the  design of our equipment. The biggest changes, that we can see, are in the quenching systems. This has always been a strong feature of our furnaces. We have come out with the new class of HPQ furnace, whose quenching rate is close to the one, reached in medium cooling oil. Our customers also  operate in very competitive markets, especially in USA and Europe. We have realized that and we are offering the systems that can work in fully automated mode. New, three chamber furnace, displayed at last Thermprocess, armed with PreNit technology can reduce the cycle time, by halve, when compared with traditional carburizing technology. We are all becoming more and more environmentally conscious. SECO/WARWICK is investing in the new technologies that reduce, or virtually eliminate the emission of greenhouse gases.   Another interesting design concept is our EXPANITE project which has created very good market feedback already.“

Do you have any plans for acquisitions within the furnace manufacturing industry that you can share with us?

“End of December we announced our  aquisition which was a service company in Germany, which has been renamed for Seco/Warwick Service GmbH. We are confident that this move, in combination with our innovative product range, will fill in a gap in our offer for our German speaking customers. Now we concentrate fully on making our new corporate structure work, so we can transfer easily some of our significant local strengths to the global dimension. This task we regard as our biggest potential.  In 2012 we could see our first success on this field, after having transferred our Vacuum know how from Europe to the US, or after having established a 16 employees Retech division in Poland. Both moves brought as some more satisfied custoersa significant growth of sales in 2012 already. In April we took over the controlling  interest  of S/W Allied in Mumbai , India. Now we  have started the process of a full integration of SWA into our global structures.”

Pawel earlier this year you introduced a new product for heat treating of stainless steels, if memory serves me correctly this would be in competition with other processes currently being offered . Has this been a success for you?

” Yes, at the end of last year we  came to an agreement with Expanite A/S from  Denmark. This is a great team who has developed and patented processes for the surface hardening of stainless steel to achieve superior surface and material properties. A few days ago we launched a show room with dedicated equipment to run an Expanite and Superexpanite processes. When you consider the advantages of applying this technology: surface hardness up to eight times that of the normal base alloy, enhanced fatigue and load bearing properties, corrosion resistance (up to 400 hours in salt spray chamber), we are expecting a  breakthrough successes.”

What are you forecasting for sales in 2013? Better? Worse? About the same?

“As a stock listed company we are not allowed to publish any official forecast. End of 2012 we published our strategy. The financial dimension of this strategy  would be reaching 1 Billion PLN of sales in 2016 (ca.235M EUR).”

The new furnace business is a crowded arena these days with an estimated 183 companies around the world. The past couple of years have been good ones for the industry but in the event of a slowdown do you expect to see a number of your competitors disappear? While we’re talking about competitors do you feel that most are good, respected companies?

“Yes, I am sure there are some very respected competitors of ours out there, on the market. My take is however that we should expect some consolidation in the midterm.  I am sure that some smaller, local furnace makers will always find their niche, but the trend should definitely speed up and  go towards bigger, R&D oriented companies. The new material applications in our key customer industries, such as aerospace, new energy or automotive will further require new heat treatment solutions, which can be generally reached only by the technology leaders in the furnace production. I think this growing R&D burden can be carried mainly by bigger players, who can afford it from the financial perspective, but also from the point of view of the efficient management.  The consolidation trend against smaller furnace makers will further be emphasized by growing environmental standards and some customer expectations in this respect, which again can be better met by bigger furnace companies with broad international base of experience.”   

I thank you for your time Pawel and thank you for your insightful, candid answers.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Patrick McKenna Interview / Ipsen 

We are very pleased to offer this interview with Mr. Patrick McKenna, President and CEO of Ipsen USA.

Pat, I have lots of questions for you about Ipsen, where the company has come from and where it is going however before we go there could you share your background with us? How you got into the business and how you ended up as President of Ipsen USA?

“Thank you for the opportunity, Gord. I started in the industry in the early 90s, as an Engineering Intern at A. Finkl & Sons in Chicago. They are a specialty steel producer and now part of the Schmolz + Bickenbach Group. With in-house melting, forging, heat treating, and machining, it was a great place to learn. The plant operated 24/7 and I remember feeling honored when I was given keys to the office. With a starting wage of $10/hour and unlimited overtime, I was eager to put in as many hours as possible learning my trade.

After earning a degree in Mechanical Engineering, I continued for a time as Project Engineer at Finkl, but ultimately decided to move on. My next stop was Ipsen. I was hired into the Engineering department, but eventually transitioned into Product Management and Sales.

Later, I moved to the West Coast where, together with Rich Penrose, we started Nevada Heat Treating and California Brazing. Rich and I were business partners until January 2015, when I decided to return to Ipsen in the role of Vice President – Sales. The 15 years spent operating a commercial heat treating and brazing facility have proved invaluable during my three years back at Ipsen.

In August 2017 the previous President and CEO of Ipsen USA, Geoffrey Somary, was promoted to COO of Ipsen Group. I was given the opportunity to become President at that time.”

Everybody in the heat-treating industry knows Ipsen but few know the background of the company-could you share that with us?

“Harold Ipsen, a Mechanical Engineer from Brown University, started Ipsen in Rockford, Illinois in 1948. His first ‘heat treat project’ was repairing a kiln for his wife, a pottery hobbyist. Harold later began designing and building furnaces for the steel industry, eventually leading to some of the first batch integral quench furnaces. Sadly, Harold perished in a plane crash in the 1960s (he was at the controls) along with other senior members of his Executive Team. Shortly after, the Ipsen family decided to sell the company.”

 If it is OK with you I would like to focus my questions today on the North American market and interview Geoffrey Somary about Ipsen globally at a future date. How big is Ipsen North America both in terms of physical size, number of employees and total sales?

” Ipsen USA is comprised of (3) manufacturing facilities:

  1. Cherry Valley, IL
  2. Souderton, PA
  3. Pecatonica, IL (Ipsen Ceramics)

There are 250 direct employees between these three facilities, generating approximately $100 million in annual sales.  Almost half of those sales are in aftermarket, which includes parts, upgrades, pyrometry & calibration, maintenance, and other types of services.”

Could you describe your sales efforts for us? As an example do you sell through independent reps? Direct sales? A combination of both?

“We utilize a combination of direct and indirect (independent) Sales Representatives. We refer to both as Regional Sales Owners. We also have overlapping sales coverage with Regional Sales Engineers and Regional Service Managers, all of whom are direct employees. Lastly, we have subject matter experts who travel to support our sales efforts.

Ipsen feels strongly that spending time with customers and maintaining close relationships with them is extremely important, and in my position I am also able to spend a significant amount of time traveling to support our customers and their projects too.”

When I think of Ipsen in North America I think mainly vacuum furnaces but is this correct?

“You may be surprised to learn that, many years ago, Ipsen was 100% atmosphere. In the 1980s, Ipsen merged with ABAR Corporation – a leader in vacuum furnaces – and production in North America began shifting to mostly vacuum. Today, atmosphere and vacuum are balanced globally while in North America we are about 80% vacuum and 20% atmosphere.”

Are vacuum carburizing systems a large part of your “repertoire”? I know you have built systems over the years but vacuum carburizing is not the first thing I think of when I think of Ipsen.

“Yes, we have built many vacuum carburizing furnaces over the years. It’s an increasingly important part of our overall North American product portfolio.”

Over the years Ipsen has bounced in and out of the atmosphere market at least as far as Canada, the US and Mexico goes. What is your current thinking?

“The Ipsen atmosphere furnace installed base in North America is very large and continues to be a target growth area for us.  The market has been very receptive to our recent product offerings. I’m pleased to report we currently have a large number of North American atmosphere furnace orders in our bookings backlog, including a roller hearth normalizing line and a rotary hearth furnace.”

How many furnaces per year does Rockford build in total of all types?

“We manufacture between 60 and 80 new furnaces per year in Rockford, and 6 to 8 furnaces each year (VFS brand) in Souderton. About three-fourths of these are shipped to North American customers.”

 The Titan line of vacuum furnaces was launched a number of years ago as a very standard, price competitive product-has this been a success and how many have you sold over the years?

“Yes Gord, this platform product line has been very successful. To date, we have built almost 300 TITAN vacuum furnaces (both vertical and horizontal).”

 Pat, are these the good times, bad times or in between times for furnace builders in North America? When do you think this is going to change?

“The last three years have all been record bookings years for us, Gord. However, there seems to be a bit of a pause recently, with less urgency in the marketplace. Quotation activity is as strong as ever, which is a positive sign, but there has been some hesitancy in order placement.”

 I’m going to annoy a few vacuum furnaces builders with this question, however it is a question which I am asked from time to time so I believe it to be very pertinent. How much difference is there between different brands of vacuum furnaces? An impartial, cynical observer could say that all vacuum furnaces consist of a pressure vessel, a pumping system from one of only a handful of suppliers, a standard control system (again from a very short list), a few heating elements and a common design. Which would lead them to ask how much actual difference is there between various builders?

“A fair question, Gord. Yes, the systems needed for traditional vacuum furnaces are the same (e.g., chamber, controls, pumping system, hot zone). However, I think there are many details in the design of each system that really impact performance (e.g., heating, control, uniformity, quench rate, ultimate vacuum, partial pressure effectiveness).

One simple example is that there is a very wide cooling rate performance difference between the different brands of high pressure gas quenching vacuum furnaces.   Although quench pressure matters, more important is the mass flow rate of the gas hitting the workload, as well as the rate in which your heat exchanger can extract the heat from the quench gas. We often do side-by-side comparisons with other brands and have consistently proven the superior performance of the Ipsen design.

There are also more subtle differences we incorporate in our designs that increase reliability, improve ease of maintenance, allow for easier compliance with aerospace specifications, etc.

When buying a furnace it’s more than just buying a piece of equipment – you’re really entering into a long term relationship with a heat treatment solutions provider. It’s consultative selling, strong technical support, process expertise, a responsive parts and service infrastructure … it’s the totality of the organization behind the furnace.”

 The last question leads into this one-in your opinion are there too many furnace builders in North America?

“It may surprise you, Gord, but I really don’t think about that question at all. We have competitors that we respect and the market will determine how many furnace builders there should be.”

If you were asked what is the fastest growing heat treat technology on the market today what would you suggest?

“Heat treating technology evolves slowly. At the present time, I’m not seeing a disruptive technology that will significantly shift the equipment business from traditional vacuum and atmosphere furnaces.

With regard to traditional equipment, we see customers demanding increased connectivity, more sophisticated monitoring and process control, and real-time predictive maintenance capability such as Ipsen’s PdMetrics.”

Is there anything realty exciting coming up at Ipsen which you can share with us? Or how about a really tantalizing “teaser” about what might be coming up?

“There’s a lot in the works. For one, Ipsen is continuing to put a lot of focus on supporting customers with aftermarket services. You will see our service team grow in size and capability, and be even more accessible to customers across North America. We look for 2018 to be a big year for Ipsen in regards to expansion of our service team, which will put us in even closer proximity of our customer base. We also continue to improve our ability to service all furnace brands.

As far as projects, Ipsen is fortunate to be able to partner with customers that are the leaders in their industries. We can’t share specifics in many of these situations, but one recent example is a vertical, high pressure quench vacuum furnace with a 1,000 horsepower quench system. We also are currently manufacturing the largest horizontal vacuum furnace we have ever built.  To the best of my knowledge, it is the largest vacuum brazing furnace in the world.  This single chamber vacuum furnace utilizes eight 35” diffusion pump systems!

It’s exciting to see Ipsen at the forefront of these market opportunities and I look forward to sharing more about our unique projects with you and your readers in the near future.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Pat Toruk / United Process Controls

Pat one of the things I like the most about the heat treating industry is the fact that it is so close knit. For instance at one point in time I worked with you in the old Marathon days, subsequently I worked for you in the TriadX days and now we are actually competitors. However having said that like most of my competitors I always enjoy running into you at various heat treating events around the world.

“Gord I agree. It is a close nit industry – to the point of being incestuous! I have always enjoyed spending time with you, reps, customers, and other manufacturers in our small family at various heat treat events. What is so gratifying to me is the fact that we all work together (even as competitors) to further the industry.”

So could you give us some background-how you got started in this industry and what positions you have held over the years?

“Gord I got my start in this industry in 1984 when I was hired as a contract programmer to work on the first industry specific data acquisition / management package which ultimately became known as Process Master. The company was Cincinnati Steel Treating. The guy that hired me was none other than Dan McCurdy (Bodycote). Within a year or so of my hiring this division was sold to a company built by Bill Thompson (SSI) named Marathon Monitors Inc. MMI was busy selling oxygen probes for heat treat applications. This was a perfect fit. The CST division had sophisticated instrumentation and software for heat treat, and MMI had the probe business and the channel to sell it. Dan and Bill were terrific mentors to me over those years where I held positions as software engineer, systems engineering manager, product manager, and finally VP. of customer services. I left the company after 14 years to form TriadX with T.J. Wright (Wirco) and Dick Wagner where I developed the Furnace Doctor – a portable infrared gas analyzer that was designed specifically for heat treat processes. Ultimately this business was absorbed by Waukee/Furnace Control.

I took a job with Furnace Control Corp/Waukee where I was VP of Technology and worked for another industry “founding father”, Andy Melville. FCC assumed the manufacturing and support of the Furnace Doctor. I left FCC/Waukee after 5 years and took a position as Director of NA Systems Business for West Instruments, a Danaher division. Ultimately I was called home. I was approached by Paul Oleszkiewicz of Nitrex to fill the commercial leadership position in North America for the recently acquired Marathon Monitors, Furnace Control, Waukee Engineering and Process Electronic. Gord it’s been quite a ride and I can’t be happier. The quality of the people at UPC and the amazing technical depth of the staff are unsurpassed.”

Could you provide a summary of United Process Controls, ownership, size and what you have to offer to the industry?

“United Process Controls (UPC) is a group of diverse technical experts focused on solving customer problems in the areas of materials science, thermal processing, combustion optimization and automation. This is accomplished through our Process Electronic, Marathon Monitors, Waukee Engineering, and Furnace Control brands. We have manufacturing operations in Cincinnati, Milwaukee, Bejing, Montreal, Poland and Germany. We also have engineering support and field service groups in Cincinnati, Milwaukee, Montreal, Germany, France, Poland, Beijing, Shanghai and Mexico. This along with an extensive network of manufacturers Reps, Distributors and OEM’s gives us a truly global presence. All of our products are compliant to current industry specifications such as NADCAP, AMS 27xx, and CQI 9.

UPC offers the industry customized solutions from standard modules. We have standard packaged systems for most heat treating applications ranging from a simple re-instrumentation to complete heat treat automation. We also offer complete heat treat management/data acquisition software, and sophisticated process modeling software. We employ a highly qualified field engineering and service staff to support our customers.

As the world’s largest manufacturer of heat treat oxygen sensors, we are able to accommodate through our Marathon Monitors, Process Electronic, and Furnace Control lines even the most difficult furnace atmosphere application. Our Waukee line is the industry standard in flow measurement & control, gas blending, generator control, and nitrogen-methanol systems.

Our core strength is the knowledge and experience of our people. We have metallurgists , chemists, mechanical, electrical and software engineers on our team . This, along with input from our customers leads to directed innovation for product development. The result is creative products that meet and exceed needs of our customers.”

I am going back a bit in time but it doesn’t seem that long ago that Waukee Flow meters, Marathon and FCC fell under the UPC banner. Conventional wisdom at the time had it that this was a rather odd fit buying a number of companies with pretty much the same product offering and putting them under one banner. In retrospect was this a good business decision?

“Yes it might have seemed a bit odd to the users of heat treat oxygen sensors in North America, but all of the companies have unique product offerings. FCC for example has the Furnace Doctor and Furnace Doctor DPT. FCC also has oxygen probes and technology specific to H2/H2O ratio, and two phase carbon measurement used in annealing operations. MMI has control instrumentation and Oxygen sensors for both heat treat and combustion applications. Waukee of course has flow monitoring/control and gas blending products. Process Electronic offer sophisticated process modeling solutions and technology fitted to their instrumentation as well as Heat Treat management software. These facts in combination with outstanding channel that includes our NA rep. network made it a very wise and well sussed out strategy.”

As Vice President Sales & Marketing for UPC what fills your time? A lot of office time, proposals or traveling with your reps?

“Typically not much office time- meetings early in the week but the lion’s share of my time is spent acting as a resource to reps and customers in the field. Lots of travel!”

I believe that UPC sells either entirely or mainly through manufacturers reps. What do you see as the advantages of reps (or lack thereof) as opposed to direct sales people.

“Reps are critical to our success. I can’t imagine covering as much ground with direct sales people. More importantly, the relationship that the rep has with most of his or her customer’s is invaluable. My concern is I don’t see enough younger talent choosing this way of life.”

When you came out with the Furnace Doctor many years ago it was truly a revolutionary product-a portable 3 gas analyzer. What prompted this idea?

“Gord the value of having 3 gas analysis available in heat treat is incontrovertible. I wanted to create a product that was affordable, operator friendly, and would help our customers by providing readings in meaningful units that included some calculated values such as %C. I had been involved in trouble shooting furnace atmosphere problems for years and saw it as an opportunity to create a product that would help both engineering staff, and operations people.”

While furnaces have not changed a great deal over the years the controls certainly have. If you looked back over the years what would you say was the most significant change?

“Significant advances have been made in both microprocessor and user interfaces, spec compliant electronic recording and excellent communication capability. Significant improvements peripheral board level components that offer both better resolution, and noise immunity for analog signals such as thermocouples. This coupled with higher speed, denser component layout, and environmental tolerances all translate in to higher reliability and ease of use for operators. Who would have thought that we would see vivid color touch screens on a carburizing furnace!”

Have controls made operators dumber? In other words have new controls made it so that furnace operators need no skill or knowledge of heat treating to perform their jobs?

“I think the converse is true! New controls are so much better at informing the operator of status and problems related to their process. If anything it makes it easier for an operator to do his job. Skilled operators are so important in our industry. They have all of this new information from modern controls but need to know what to do with it!”

So what are the next logical steps in furnace controls? Is there anything out there that really excites you?

“Gord. I am really excited about evolving sensor technology that allows us to do a more complete job of measuring both traditional furnace atmosphere’s and non-equilibrium oxygen free atmosphere’s. This new technology will take us into vacuum processes, atmospheres designed to eliminate IGO issues, and compound layer processes such as FNC. This along with more sophisticated tools for modeling and controlling these processes are just a short time away.”

And what does UPC have planned for the future? Anything really exciting that we can expect from the company?

“Gord one of the most exciting things that we have going on at this time is the ability to model and control the carbo-nitriding process. Our customers have been running this process in the dark for many years- heat the parts at 16~~, turn the ammonia on at 3% – 5% of the total flow and hope for the best. Oh, and by the way your carbon controller will be reporting a false carbon potential! We are also working on more sophisticated process modeling and the integration of this into our instrumentation, improved sensor technology, and enhancements to I/R technology to make it more affordable, and more customer friendly.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Mr. Zhu / Fengdong Furnaces

We are very pleased today to be interviewing in person Mr. Zhu Wenming, Chairman of Fengdong Group based in Yancheng City, China.

Zhu I am very interested in how people get to where they are now. How did you end up in the position you are now in?

“I am originally from Yancheng and my background is electrical engineering. When I was 22 years old I was directed by the government to work for a furnace company by the name of Fengdong although I knew nothing about heat treating. I was trained in Japan for one year before returning to Fengdong which was 27 years ago now. I began with furnace manufacturing, designing, sales, then full management of Fengdong group.”

I know Fengdong by reputation but I know little else about the company. Could you please give myself and our readers an idea about the history of the company?

“Fengdong was officially registered in 1989, when it was partly state owned with Japanese company Oriental Engineering as a partner. It started in operation in 1990. 

The first 10 years (1990-2000), it was a traditional Chinese state owned company in a poor economy with average sales of 10 million RMB (approximately USD 1 million) per year.

The second 10 years (2000-2010), it was transformed to a private company with the employees buying shares. During this period, average sales were 100 million RMB (approximately USD 12 million) per year. Since year of 2000, we took every opportunity to promote sales domestic and overseas and enhance the technical cooperation internationally. During this period, we had very fast growth in the company.

In 2010, we became public and Fengdong remains the only publicly traded company in China for heat treatment. Since we became public, we further grow our company and acquire other business. Our combined annual sales will be approximately USD 250 million in short time. Profit is expected to be USD 50 million.”

What products does the company offer?

“With the acquisition of Powermax Shanghai we now have 12 commercial heat treating locations, 11 in China and 1 in Korea with 5 manufacturing locations including Powermax.  We are very proud of the fact that we can offer all types of heat treating equipment, atmosphere, non-atmosphere, induction and vacuum. Our commercial heat treating plants also offer all available types of heat treating processes.”

Several times over the years I have been told that Fengdong is the largest furnace builder in the world-do you believe this to be true?

“Equipment sales are approximately $100 million USD per year which puts us amongst the one of the top furnace builders in the world and certainly we hope to be the largest in China. Commercial heat treatment sales were about $30 million in 2017.”

Do you prefer the commercial heat treating side of the business or furnace manufacturing?

(Editors Note; There appeared to be a difference of opinion amongst management on this question.)

“There is no doubt that we will stay in the equipment manufacturing business, but we want to invest much more on high end heat treatment services in the future.”

What is your biggest concern running this business?

“We have set ourselves a very ambitious goal and this it to reach annual sales of $1 billion USD. My main concern is where will all this future growth come from? In addition, where do we find the good people necessary to achieve this goal?”

What drives you? Why do you work as hard as you do?

“Our goal is to grow the business and make sure that all our employees feel that they are part of the business, that they are contributing and that they are sharing in the success of the company. This is a large task which takes a lot of hard work. On average, everybody on our management team works 70 hours a week.”

Recently you acquired PowerMax Shanghai. Why was this company of interest and how will it fit in with your future plans?

“PowerMax was of a great deal of interest to us because of their experience with salt quenching and the ADI process. I regard this not as an acquisition but rather a collaboration. We hope and expect that with this collaboration Fengdong will become the leading company in the world for salt quenching. The Powermax name and location will remain.  Fengdong has had great success over the years working with Japanese and European furnace builders and we believe that by working with Powermax with their US ties that it will again be a success. We have worked with Andy for over 20 years now. We have a very high opinion of Andy and regard him as a major asset to Fengdong.”  

The company has come a long, long way in a relatively short period of time-how did this happen?

“There are several reasons but a large one is our close collaboration with foreign companies, to   share technology. We also very seriously consider the customers needs.”

Does it pose a problem for you doing commercial heat treating and also building furnaces? In North America and Europe, a furnace builder would not be able to offer both as potential customers would see them as a competitor.

“This has not been a problem, we believe that commercial heat treating gives us valuable experience for our furnace building business. As a result, even though we are in same business, cooperation is still always possible.”

Where do you sell most of your products?

“85% of our products are sold and installed in China with 15% exported.”

I’m sure that there are a lot of furnace builders and heat treaters around the world that would like to know the answer to this question. Do you have plans to aggressively start selling in Europe and the Americas?

“We have looked at and considered opportunities in many areas around the world including acquisitions and will continue to do so. Geographically all areas are of interest to us.”

Several furnace manufacturers feel that the future of heat will be single part processing. In other words continuous furnaces that process the parts one at a time. Obviously this is not suited for large volume, small parts such as fasteners but more for parts such as transmission gears. Do you personally feel that this will be the way of the future?

“We learned that message from the market place and we do not disagree it is a good idea. However, we are more concerned with heat treatment quality and cost control. Certainly, we do things to meet a customer’s specific need.”

What else would you like to tell us today?

“I have a dream and that dream is for Fengdong to become a world renown company, a company that is an industry leader and where all of our employees feel that they are participating in the growth.

Hello the world- Fengdong have a dream about heat treating!”

Mr. Zhu I thank you for your time today. Gord Montgomery

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Marty Keylon / Keylon Thermal Consulting

Out in California Marty is a long time heat treater who has seen both sides of the fence-one side being commercial heat treating and the other side being a manufacturers rep selling heat treating products. We had a chance to pose a few questions to Marty and this is the result. August 25/2015 

First off Marty could you share some background with us, the obvious things being how you got into the business and what your experiences have been over the years.

“Long story short, In 1975 I started as a 17 yr old sand blaster for Orange Empire heat treating because it paid $1.65 an hour which was $0.30 more than working at the Shell Gas Station! I also worked as a truck driver, inspector, furnace operator and got into maintenance. Found something I was pretty good at so I stayed there for 15 years. At one time I had 6 maintenance guys under me and 2 plants as a maintenance supervisor.  I moved into the plant superintendent position and eventually plant manager, general manager and was the senior general manager running 2 Bodycote plants. I have been through many changes staying with the same company for 30 years. We were bought and sold many times. In this list I either moved to another facility or it was bought and sold. I started at Orange Empire HT, National HT, Downey HT, HinderTec, Hinderliter and finally Bodycote,  I retired in 2004.  I had a Ebay business my wife was running when I was working and after I retired I went at t full time for a while. It was very profitable for the first few years until the market got saturated with companies selling the same product for little margin and over charging for shipping as the profit center! I have over 7,000 positive feedbacks! After living in Orange County for 47 years we picked up and moved into the high sierras. That was a culture shock for sure! It was fun and exciting but I got restless so I started working at North American Cronite as a senior sales manager traveling 3 weeks out of every month. I started Keylon Thermal Consulting in 2006 after working with a lot of customers in the industry and seeing a need for additional talent and aftermarket support.”

As a manufacturers rep what lines do you rep for?

“SAFE Cronite, South-Tek Systems, JL Becker, Conrad Kacsik, CeraMaterials, Phoenix TM. These vendors I sell through or for Alcon, Qual-Fab, Geo-Corp, Cambridge Wire Products, I.P.S. Stanwood, Super Systems, Roto-Jet of America. I also buy and sell new and used equipment. I have partnered with Champion Furnace Company “Rick Apodaca” installing furnaces. We work closely together. I also sell him Moly and other insulation for his Vacuum Hot Zone rebuilds.” 

On a personal level I am very curious about what you have learned now that you are a rep selling to commercial heat treaters as opposed to being the buyer. Do you have more sympathy for the buyers or more sympathy for the sellers?

“I have a lot more sympathy for the sellers. Doing sales is 99% rejection! I have over 200 customers I try to either see or call at least once every 3 – 6 months Some a lot more depending on what’s going on with the projects I have working with them. You have to find that fine line between missing a sale and being a pest! I travel 11 western states on my dime, eating alone and living in hotels away from your family is tough. I have traveled hundreds of miles to show up to a customer and they either forgot about our appointment and don’t have time for you or are not in that day after making appointments weeks prior to my visit. I know from being on the buyers’ side that things do happen, But I never treated my vendors that way. Working for Bodycote I had my preferred area Rep and vendors and always gave them a shot at any of my needs. BUT I would give the other guy’s a chance to quote just to make sure I was still getting a competitive price. Sometimes I would pay a little more because of the quality and relationships I had with the rep or company.”

Hear is a loaded question-which job is more lucrative and less stressful? Working for a large company with a guaranteed salary or working for yourself which is never entirely stable?

“I loved working for Bodycote! BUT when things changed that were not working for me I had to go. It was a very difficult decision but with a supportive wife “she’s a nurse” making good money it was the best thing for my entire family. We up and moved over 500 miles away within 4 months! I will say having a steady income was great, But now I do OK and work when I want too, travel only when needed and find the stress level is self imposed. I wouldn’t trade it for the world! I have never looked back and wanted that life again.”

You have been at this a long time, over the course of your career what changes have you seen in commercial heat treating in general and in California in particular.

“Companies have been losing the depth of talented people. Seems like us older guys are leaving the industry and not much new talent is being cultivated to replace the void? General Managers are being replaced by Senior G.M.’s running multiple facilities. Quality requirement for surveys are becoming unrealistic and sometimes un-achievable by what is required by some of the primes. To meet the requirements furnace loads are much smaller and lighter in larger furnaces that have a lot of load area that is now not being utilized. This has caused prices to go up and profits to stay the same or less!”

Is the California market a growing market or a shrinking one and what industries drive heat treating?

“From my perspective I can only judge it on what people are purchasing and what I see as parts on the floor. As I walk through the different shops I see parts I ran 30 years ago. I ask how’s business doing? Some are telling me it’s been great! Others, not so good. With the introduction of alternate power sources with electric cars, wind and solar electric generation there is some new cutting edge processes and the ones that have changed with the technology seems to be doing well. As with anything else I judge it on what being purchased and it looks pretty good to me.”

The debate has raged for years about whether commercial heat treating is taking a larger slice of the pie with captive heat treating gradually shrinking to the benefit of the commercials. What is your opinion?

“I think as the NADCAP / Boeing requirements are getting more stringent the captives are getting out of the heat treating side. This keeps me busy on the consulting side of my business helping customers keep up with these changing requirements. If it’s any indicator I have sold more equipment OUT of captive shops than in.”

You have met a lot of people in the industry, if I were to ask you who you really respect what names would pop into your head?

“First and foremost would be John Hubbard! I worked for John for over 25 years and have been friends for much longer. He gave me chances to excel and the support I needed to do so. He’s always been straight and fair with me. He did say though he always gave me enough rope to hang myself!  Back in the day it was much easier to ask for forgiveness than it was for permission! Rich Penrose is another one. Great boss and good friend. He also has been very instrumental in my success in supporting me in those Bodycote days. Bill Jones @ Solar. I don’t need to say much about him you already know! Good friend and mentor.”

Many would have you believe that there are substantial changes going on in the industry and we will not recognize it in just a few short years. On the other side of the coin one of the most knowledgeable people I have ever known, Mr. Bernie Parry formerly of AFC-Holcroft always use to say there is nothing new in the industry-what are your thoughts?

“The industry is always changing. You either go with it or get out! There is new cutting edge technology out there and you either embrace it or stand by and watch others profit from it. There is no status quo anymore. There are faster quenching vacuum furnaces, Vacuum carburizing been around for years but now it been used a lot more for gears in the wind power industry. Everything is computerized and paperless! I rep Phoenix TM. There is now cutting edge survey software and hot box technology that saves you time and a lot of money using it. Computers have taken the guess work out and the extra time sitting down at a desk figuring out correction factors after the survey is done. You know as its being run in real time if it going to pass or not.”

What does the future hold for you? Can you see yourself doing this 10 or 20 years from now?

“At 58 I love what I’m doing now. I’m a hand’s on kind of guy still in pretty good shape and expect to keep going at it for at least another 10 years. I tried retirement once and it was not what I expected. Susan and I are pretty busy with kids, grandkids and the Corvette club. I’m sure there is a day when it’s time to pass the torch? Maybe a son in law or grandkid? I don’t have anyone ready to step up to the plate. But you never know..”

Keylon Thermal Consulting, 5125 Debron Court, Pollock Pines, California, 95726-9500, [email protected], 530 788-8566 Phone, 530 644-2601 Fax.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Martin Beaton / Bohler-Uddeholm Corporation

Martin in my opinion you have worked with some of the most respected companies in the world when it comes to captive and commercial heat treating. Could you share with us your work history?

“Hello Gord, I am pleased to answer these questions. Indeed, I have worked with really great companies in my career, with each one offering a different perspective on heat treatment operations. As you know, you and I first met in 1992 when I joined FAG Bearings in Stratford ON, part of Schaeffler Group, as chief metallurgist and captive heat treatment manager with 50 employees. I then entered the commercial heat treatment market in 1995 as division manager for Uddeholm Limited, a 50 person facility in Newmarket, ON. This was my first taste as an entrepreneur and looking back on it I know that it set the foundation for my love of heat treatment and technical services that really has followed me everywhere in my career. In 1999, Bodycote plc acquired the commercial heat treatment business from Uddeholm Limited and my exposure to the much-broader heat treatment world really began. We all know what Bodycote was up to in those days and certainly there were no shortages of growth and learning opportunities. At the time of my departure from Bodycote in 2009, I was serving in the capacity of group director with over 20 sites and 500 employees across Canada and the USA.

In 2010, I joined SNC-Lavalin, Canada’s largest engineering and construction firm, headquartered in Montreal, essentially as a consultant and bird-dog for acquisitions in their operations and maintenance space, focused on general industrial, transportation and energy segments. I relied strongly on the education afforded me during my Bodycote days as we established a very robust acquisition pipeline over the following years. Then in 2014, I was approached by Bohler-Uddeholm Corporation in Chicago to support their corporate development efforts in the value-added/technology segments of their business. It was during this project that Bohler-Uddeholm Limited in Mississauga asked if I would consider a more permanent assignment and we can fast forward to the situation today and my current role as President. So you are right Gord. I have worked with some really great companies, all large, all publicly-traded and all adding unique elements to an education that you don’t find in school.”

Very few people actually choose a career in heat treating so I am always very curious as to how people get into the industry. How did you end up in the heat treating business?

“It is a funny story, actually. I graduated from McMaster University in 1992 with a degree in Materials Engineering. I was all set to take my MBA when FAG Bearings called me for an interview. Well, my graduating class was rather small that year and job prospects were quite poor, so most of my classmates were chasing the same opportunities I was, including two very smart guys that shared the same apartment as me (each went on to earn PhDs and professorships). I was offered the job at FAG Bearings, not because I was the smartest, or because I gave the best interview, but rather because the hiring manager felt I could take a beating and keep on going. Many of us out there in the heat treatment business can attest to the daily challenge of often being the last step in a production chain, already behind schedule and usually more expensive than what customers want to pay. Earning pennies to process parts that are often 100x more valuable, yet carrying the exposure to significant liabilities. But when you do it well, when you get it right, it is a real rush.”

What can you tell us about Bohler-Uddeholm?

“Bohler-Uddeholm operates within the Special Steel Division of voestalpine, a 11.2 billion EURO publicly-traded multi-national with 47,500 employees and headquarters in Linz, Austria. In North America, Bohler-Uddeholm is focused on the sale and distribution of specialty steel for the aircraft, power-gen and oil & gas markets as well as tooling materials for die-casting, injection-molding, stamping and forming businesses. To augment these products, Bohler-Uddeholm (and sister companies) operate about 25 heat treatment facilities, 14 or so coating centers and a wide variety of additional value-added technologies. Of recent interest is our additive manufacturing and laser cladding center in Dusseldorf and our PVD equipment manufacturing and services under our Vacotech and eifeler labels. Our vision is to grow as a steel-based technology company and Bohler-Uddeholm fits into this strategy very well.”

I have to throw this in Martin; I have been fortunate enough to see hundreds of heat treating operations on five continents and your plant in Mississauga I would put in the top 1% in the world. This is based upon cleanliness, equipment capabilities, capacity-you name it and Bohler-Uddeholm is there. Are all your locations at the same level?

“Generally this is the standard, yes. We recently commissioned a brand new heat treatment center in Germany and it is simply world-class. Our coating centers are white-glove clean and offer the most advanced coatings on the market.”

How important is heat treating to the company as a whole? Would it be fair to say that you have to offer this service to sell your products? Or is the heat treating a service which makes money and just happens to help you sell products at the same time?

“Heat treating and all technical services are vital to our business. In keeping with our overall growth strategy as a steel-based technology company, we offer these services not only to enable our customers to focus on their core competency, but really to offer them leading-edge technical solutions around their products and market position. Of course, we do not have to offer these services, but our customers demand them and their customers specify them. Operating on the leading-edge of material performance leaves no choice but to protect our customer’s investments with the matching technical services.”

How much heat treating does Bohler-Uddeholm actually do? Perhaps a better way to phrase it would be do many of your locations have heat treating capabilities?

“All told we operate about 25 heat treatment plants in North America, Europe and Asia with more being added to the mix all the time.”

You have worked at a manufacturer who happens to heat treat, a company that only offers commercial heat treating and now at a steel company who also does commercial heat treating-I have to say that you have a very varied work background. Which would you say is your favorite? A job where heat treating is everything or a position where heat treating is just a portion of your responsibility?

“This is a really tough question because once you are a heat treater; you are always a heat treater. I will answer it this way – what gets me out of bed each day is the access to resources, people and technologies to build a unique value-proposition that the market and customers demand. It is an exciting time with voestalpine and Bohler-Uddeholm as there is a very clear strategy and management will to add value for our customers well beyond that which has historically been provided.”

Are there any types of heat treating processes which you feel the company is lacking?

“Of course, however, it is a moving target isn’t it? As materials and applications change and as we increase our vertical integration within the supply chain, we are continually looking at new heat treatment processes. Our traditional processes of vacuum heat treatment and nitriding remain central to our tool steel business, but we offer many special heat treatments across a broad spectrum of end markets. I will say that my personal interests lie more in quenching technology than in heating technology, but again the landscape is fluid.”

Tying in with the question above are there any technologies that excite you that you feel deserve a second look?

“Surface treatments, coatings, laser cladding are very interesting for our products and markets. Most importantly, the combination of superior material and the services mentioned above are really exciting for us. We are also very involved in additive manufacturing from a raw material, application development and commercial service perspective and the landscape in this technology is really growing.”

On a day to day basis what are your responsibilities? Does the job entail much travelling?

“The best way to answer this question is to quote our mantra, “profitable growth, loyal customers and engaged team members”. My job is to deliver these results for our stakeholders. I am privileged to work with a talented team and supportive parent; so much of my time is focused around execution strategy, new markets and new technologies. There is a lot of travel but very little wasted energy.”

Another of my favorite questions is what do you see in the future for heat treating? I certainly realize that this is a pretty general question but do you see any radical changes ahead?

“I believe that we will see a further acceleration of the divide between the all-purpose, local heat treater and the specialized niche player. Given the shifting markets toward the US southeast and Mexico, there will be more attention paid to technology mobility. I also see that heat treatment as a stand-alone offering will continue to shrink. Customers need a supply chain that can take on more of what they do and we are already seeing many heat treaters offering services well beyond just heat treatment. In my daily business, I usually refer to our offering as “technical services” and our future will be based on 5-6 very broad service technologies beyond just heat treatment.”

Are there any interesting developments coming up at Bohler-Uddeholm that you can share with us?

“We are growing rapidly and strongly focused on delivering solutions to customers and markets. Our plans follow the voestalpine strategy of being a steel-based technology company. Within this framework, it’s not hard to imagine the truly broad array of possibilities ahead. We covered heat treatment, coatings and other services, but the most important thing for us is people. We need a continuing injection of curious, creative and committed talent to help us carry our vision forward. Thank you very much for this opportunity to talk about my career and Bohler-Uddeholm. For sure, I remain a heat treater at heart, but like many before me I am also learning that there is more to life than quench oil.”

Thank you for your time Martin and I hope our paths continue to cross. Gord

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Mario Fabián MÉNDEZ/ Grupo Etsa Mexico

Mario Fabián MÉNDEZ, Grupo Etsa, Mexico With Mexico being one of the fastest growing regions in the world for heat treating we had to interview Mr. Mario Fabián Mendez operations manager of Grupo ETSA the largest commercial heat treater in Mexico. February 23, 2017

Mario I believe you ended up in the heat treating industry for the same reason that many of us did namely that heat treating runs in your family. Can you please give us the background?

“When my father founded ETSA in 1979, he was a former Plant Manger of a large German commercial heat treating shop in Mexico City; eager to cover a market opportunity for maintenance of captive furnaces meanwhile also starting commercial heat treat services with salt bath & shaker furnaces. The commercial division ended up to be much more active and finally covered the whole scope of the company. I started working as an occasional operator Saturdays and Summers since I was a kid; I was also driver and other small duties before starting my engineering studies, during my university studies; I was able to have a broader exposure into quality and maintenance, once I finish my college I began to add value in those areas where my father was not that much interested, such as quality, information technology, human resources and sales. I was easily engaged through my small successes in such uncovered company areas.”

My impression is that your company is the largest commercial heat treater in Mexico-would you consider this a fair statement?

“Yes we are; specially if you consider capacity and number of plants allocated in Mexico”

Maybe you can elaborate on your company, number of employees, sales, processes offered etc.?

“Our company has now 38 years on business, with 254 employees total, we have vacuum, integral quench, continuous & salt bath furnaces for nitriding, carburizing, neutral hardening and some other additional surface technologies; plus we have other value added activities such as assembling, cleaning, packing, measuring and transportation capacities. On the other hand, we are very pleased to announce that recently we had re-launched the maintenance and refurbishing services for heat treatment furnaces due to a very large contract we were awarded to bring, refurbish and reinstall, several furnaces currently in the USA that must be restarted in Mexico.”

What type of heat treating does ETSA concentrate on? I have seen very successful commercial heat treaters who concentrate on large volume small margin heat treating, I have also seen commercials which only go after very high end, high margin heat treating who are also successful-how would you describe ETSA?

“We have plants focused especially on automotive for larger volumes and some other plants focused on smaller markets for the tooling specialties, oil, appliance and aerospace industries; covering both markets but focusing plants to each specific market scale”.

I have to confess that as a Canadian I am rather jealous of the amount of new investment which Mexico is seeing these days-what sort of growth are you seeing in the heat treating industry both commercial and captive?

“For the last 10 years heat treating growth in Mexico has been tremendous, and will continue to be like that due to our worldwide competitiveness increase.”

The common perception is that the number one reason for growth in Mexico is the abundant supply of cheap, unskilled labor which is certainly not a real compliment. What do you have to say in response to this?

“Mexican industrial growth could be divided within three main reasons: labor + agreements + proximity” “As you mentioned, we have cheap labor costs but not always unskillful. In the last two decades Mexico has invested in having stronger polytechnic and technical institutions building young technicians and engineers eager to work on forging, casting, machining and some other “industrial environments” that are no longer interesting for young people in developed countries; so we also have very good technicians and engineers at lower costs. Mexico is one of the countries with more international free trade agreements worldwide. We can import materials cheaper, manufacture and export with less duties than any country in the world. As an example if a US company wish to buy components in Asia or Europe, manufacture in Mexico and Export to Russia; the company could save more than 20% in duties comparing it to US manufacturing. Finally, Mexico has a more easy-going working culture than some other developing countries. For instance if an American company has operations in Mexico, its working force or supplier base can definitely react faster and more effective to problems and new opportunities than its counterpart in India or China due to culture affinity and proximity”.

This question is very closely related to the one above and it has to do with costs. Percentage wise what is your largest cost if it is not labor? What are energy costs like in Mexico?

“Mexican energy costs are 20% higher than US or Canada; and transportation costs 15% higher due to lack of infrastructure and higher highway tolls; so I will consider these two costs must be watch out at all time”

Correct me if I am wrong but my impression of the Mexican heat treating market is that it is mainly in house heat treating with a relatively small % being commercial. Have you ever run across any figures to back this up or do you have a “gut” feel about the relative percentages?

“I will consider that captive is 80% and 20% commercial, nevertheless probably 10 years ago it was 90/10, meaning that commercial heat treating infrastructure is growing at a faster pace due to higher confidence of customers on available commercial heat treating services reliability”

Recently there have been a few `foreign’ commercial heat treaters who have entered the Mexican market including ones from Germany, Japan, Canada and the UK. Do you feel that your very long presence in the market gives you an advantage over these newer competitors?

“Yes, in sports and in business, being local is always an advantage. We understand better the authorities and institutions, the working culture, the risks and the opportunities than a foreign company. The big advantage we acknowledge foreign commercial heat treaters have is that usually they come to attend big multinationals or follow companies they already service in their countries; so in order to continue exploiting our local player comparative advantage we are working very hard to attract and be promptly informed of those international companies willing to be established in Mexico.”

Looking forward what new technologies do you see your company adding?

“We are adding more process and material tracking control into all our plants. As for new equipment, we want to continue our growth and expansion on aluminum heat treating, austempering salt bath quenching, continuous mesh belts and high pressure vacuum furnaces”

Mario you know I have to ask this question even if the whole world is asking the same question. Are you worried about a new administration in the US drastically slowing down the amount of business the US does with Mexico and if so will you be changing anything about the way you do business?

“No, I am not worried about Mr. Trump’s decisions against Mexico, I think his actions had gave our country worldwide exposure and awareness for the sole reason that the world will continue its trend of giving more and more recognition to color people, different religions, women and immigrants as a reality that boost the economy not the opposite. I think he will ultimately is going to do America and the world a service by becoming the vehicle that will finally take down extreme right-wing conservative politics, so that the world politics will continue its change to the left. On the other hand, changing current automotive supply chain inertia would be slow and difficult. Finally, European and Asian companies had reacted on the opposite by recently accelerating its investment pace in our country”

In the short terms let’s say the next year what is going to change at your company care to give us a prediction or even a prediction about the Mexican heat treating for that time period?

“I think as any other mature industry the challenges we must continue to work this year are: One, we need to speed up our internet technologies coverage on process control, material tracking and marketing, to be more and more interconnected to the rest of our systems. Two, energy usage, its impact and our green consciousness must be day to day better and better. And three, we must get used to global competition”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Karen Stanton / Heat Treatment Australia

Karen it is a sign of the times that while you and I have actually done some business together and have exchanged e-mails many times over the years I have yet to meet you in person or even speak with you for that matter. So while I know of your company Heat Treatment Australia I really know almost nothing about your background. How did you happen to get started in the heat treating field?

“Heat Treatment Australia is a family company started by my father in the early 70s.  My brother, Norm Tucker,  and I took over ownership approximately 15 years ago.  We are still very much a family oriented business with other family members and partners working in the business.  Since taking ownership Norm and I have gone from one site in Brisbane to three sites across Australia, including additional sites Sydney and Melbourne.”   

My impression is that Heat Treatment Australia is the largest commercial in the country-is this impression correct and what can you tell us about the company in terms of capabilities and size?

“HTA maintains sites in Brisbane, Sydney & Melbourne with a total staff of approximately 60.  We provides services to all geographical areas within Australia as well as Asia & USA.” 

Most people’s impression of Australia was probably shaped by Crocodile Dundee all those years ago (I am dating myself). I realize that this is only a small part of Australia so my question is how much actual heat treating both captive and commercial is there in the country? Do any estimates exist about the size of the market in terms of sales/year? Combined with this how many commercial heat treaters are there in Australia ?   

“Heat treating is a relatively small, and rather undefined market in Australia.  There are a total of approximately 25 commercial heat treatment shops across the country.  No research or studies have been undertaken that capture the size of the market or the extent of captive shops.  Essentially we fly blind and need to justify all new investment via our own research and market knowledge.”

I know your company is Nadcap accredited and I believe the only commercial in the country that can say this. So Heat Treatment Australia services the aerospace industry but what other industries do you work with? 

“We hold ISO 9001,AS9100 and Nadcap accreditation.  We are the only heat treat business within the Australian market to hold the Nadcap accreditation. As well as aerospace we provide services to the majority of manufacturing based sectors including mining, agriculture, automotive, aviation, general tooling and engineering.” 

Because of the relatively small size of the overall market and your distance from most heat treat suppliers you must face challenges unique to Australia. As an example I have sold several used temper furnaces to companies in Australia and I have always been surprised that it makes sense when the shipping costs are more than the actual pieces of equipment. What challenges do you face that heat treaters in other areas are not likely to experience? Finding good people comes to mind as we have discussed this in the past. 

“We face numerous challenges due to the nature and characteristics of our market.  Heat treatment equipment is difficult to source in Australia and most of our purchases in this area are from either the US or Europe and therefore we face additional freight and import duties.  Skilled staff is another issue, we have limited options for accessing additional skilled staff to support business growth.  Currently are choices are to grow staff from within (in-house training) or to bring staff from overseas.  At last count we have brought in 8 staff from the UK to work in our Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne plants.  Other issues revolve around consumables, in order to have Nadcap compliant consumables (eg. thermocouples) we have to purchase from the US and import.  The issues here are the significant lead time and the additional costs.”

Going back a few months we had an interesting news item about Heat Treatment Australia which included a photo of the owner of Shanghai Heat Treatment Mr. Kent Zuo and yourself in Australia. While it was an interesting little news item it really didn’t tell us too much. Can we spread some rumors about your company entering the Chinese market or Shanghai Heat Treatment entered the Australian market? You know how we like rumors .  

“We have had a number of conversations with Mr Kent Zuo from Shanghai Heat Treatment over the last 6 months.  We are very interested in the exploring the opportunities in the Chinese market, however no commitments have been made to date.  Norm has a visit to China scheduled for August, perhaps this accelerate the discussions! “

One of our favorite questions always is where is the industry going? Over the years I have made a number of predictions including salt processing disappearing (not my finest moment) and going back a few years we were hearing about how vacuum carburizing would account for almost half of the carburizing market (another one that didn’t prove to be correct). With this fine track record on my part and others would you care to take a stab at where you think heat treating is going?

“Our business is definitely heading down the line of clean, highly efficient, low maintenance, high consistency equipment and processes, such as vacuum furnaces and advanced nitriding processes.”  

You have seen a number of heat treats around the world, personally my feeling is that heat treating is heat treating whether it be in Nigeria or Germany but perhaps you have noticed differences that I have not.  

“Generally speaking you are correct about heat treat shops across the world.  However, I think given our geographical location we have been forced to approach the industry from a different aspect.  HTA is highly IT oriented – from our process controls, customer service, equipment, etc.  if you have some time take a look at our website, even our customers are able to access online systems that allow them to track jobs through our plant.  So, I think that we might have a different model to the standard heat treat shop where we look to value adding and customer involvement in the service delivery.” 

Where do you see Heat Treatment Australia in a few years? 

“We will continue on our current line, focusing on our points of differentiation and gaining a greater profile in international markets.” 

Thanks for your time Karen one of these days I hope to meet you in Australia.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here