Brian Reid, Park Thermal

Brian we have known each other for many years but I am embarrassed to admit I don’t know how you came to be in the heat treating industry. Could you give us some background?

“Gord, I think both of us entered the Heat Treating Industry in similar fashion. In the late 1960s, my father, John Reid, started Park Thermal in 1968 at the age of 68. At that time, I was part of the management team at a large hotel in Bermuda and my father indicated he needed help. I joined Park Thermal in 1970 and at that time, we primarily built Salt Baths, manufactured and supplied salts, quenching oils, stop off paint, catalyst and other spare parts for furnaces. We could see at that point in time that we needed to diversify to grow and entered the used/reconditioned and new furnace industries. Over several years, we acquired the A F Holden Company in Milford, Michigan and The Metal Works (Jim Laird) in Michigan. In 1970, Park Thermal was the first company in the world to try and utilize ceramic fiber in a furnace and this was done in a furnace just outside of Buffalo, NY in a Car Bottom furnace which is still in operation today. Ceramic fiber insulation is used in most furnaces today. In the course of 40 years, we have taken Park Thermal into the 21st century evolving into a leading supplier of Thermal Processing Equipment for clients all over the world who rely on Park Thermal for Heat Treating Solutions.

Park Thermal has a long history in the heat treating industry and I understand at some point had an affiliation with Park Chemicals-could you share with us the background of the company?

Relative to our relationship with Park Chemical, you are correct in that at one time, we were one group. Park Thermal based in Georgetown, Ontario and Park Chemical based in Detroit, Michigan. We had a lengthy relationship with Park Chemical and in the early 1990s, Whittaker Corporation purchased Park Thermal and Park Chemical amongst other companies and when the decision was made to concentrate on its core business, they put up the chemical divisions up for sale and I purchased Park Thermal.

When I think of Park Thermal I think of salt, I think of catalyst and I think of used equipment-is this a fair statement?

There is a misconception between Park Thermal and Park Chemical. Park Chemical primarily deals with chemicals while Park Thermal not only supplies similar chemical products but we are also a manufacturer of Industrial Heat Treat Furnaces, Ovens, Metallurgical Test equipment, parts, controls, catalyst, stainless steel foils and other related furnace and oven parts.

What is the breakdown of your business in terms of sales? 30% Salt? 40%

Our sales fluctuate from year to year, but overall salt makes up about 30% of sales, new furnace equipment is 35% and used equipment along with other ancillary items makes up the other 35%.

What is the strongest advantage that Park Thermal has? Along the same lines what has Park’s biggest success story been?

Our advantage can be described in a couple of ways. Firstly, the way we are structured, we are not limited to a set size and type of equipment we supply. By that I mean, we are versatile in that we can accommodate almost any needs our customers have. We are not bound by specific size of equipment only. Our facility is set up to customize to our customer’s requirements. We have the capability to modify an existing piece of equipment to suit the client’s needs.

Secondly, we take great strides to understanding the customer’s process, type of steel utilized, hardness requirements, automotive or aerospace specifications, options for electric, gas or propane, type of instrumentation. All of these items give us a better understanding and selecting the right piece of equipment to give our client the best scenario from which they can be successful in producing consistent results on each and every part.

Thirdly, this is where our “One Stop Supply House” concept comes from. In addition to purchasing a piece of equipment, we understand their application and needs, we can provide the appropriate quenching oil, salt product, catalyst for the generator, basket for proper handling of their products, state of the art instrumentation package to accurately monitor and control their processes all under warranty. In terms of success stories, we have narrowed down to 2 examples; one large and one small. The large project involved the supply and installation of 3 very large Car Bottom Furnaces for processing oil tank cars and each furnace is capable of handling 2 tank cars at a time. The installation was outside and the difficulty was achieving uniformity between the 2 vessels and guarding the top of the car from the inclement weather. These factors presented a unique set of challenges but they were overcome and the furnaces are still in first class condition. The second story is a smaller project. Around Christmas of 2017, there was a shortage of Epipens in North America and our team responded to a manufacturers facility and our task was to increase the output and we were told that by doing so, we had saved many lives due to their dependency on the availability of Epipen supplies.

A common perception exists that because a company is selling a big ticket item such as a new furnace or temper that the margins must therefore be very substantial. What would you say to a buyer who suggested this?

Relative to profitability being substantial on big ticket items, as we all know, the world has become very small and competitive. If we are to stay in business, our pricing for items big or small must be competitive and the product needs to perform perfectly, or we’ll lose market share. We prefer to have four (4) $100,000 orders than one (1) $400,000 order.

Obviously you are a Canadian company but what percentage of your business is in Canada and where else do you do business?

One of our companies is Canadian owned and we also have registration in the US. Additionally, we have warehouses in Detroit, Chicago, Houston, Los Angeles, Minnesota etc. We are a strong supporter of local manufacturing and purchasing and as a result, we actively look to support North American based companies. Our clients span the globe including Canada, USA, Mexico, Tunisia, Germany, India, Poland, Turkey etc.

This question ties in with the one above, has heat treating technology changed much over the years?

Advances in technology has made immense improvements in terms of automotive, aerospace specifications which reflects in the quality of heat treating over the past years.

When you and I run into each other the conversation generally seems to take a turn towards reminiscing about individuals in the industry. Who would you consider the most colorful, memorable person you have met?

Great question but it is difficult to narrow down to just one person. There have been so many people that I have met and associated with. Some colorful, some with extensive knowledge and others that are just good people in general. People such as John Becker, David Pye, Dr. Robert Foreman, Jack Laub, John Hubbard to name a few.

How is business for Park Thermal these days? Do you anticipate that things will be better or better or worse in 2019 and 2020?

Business at Park Thermal is very good. Currently, we are building several very large Car Bottom Furnaces. One of which will bear a payload of 450,000 lbs. In addition, we are building a mesh belt furnace for a client in Mexico, several tempering furnaces, a couple of charge cars, a couple of high heat die furnaces, a gas fired water quench tank, Austemper furnace rebuild, an Integral Quench Furnace, two  salt baths, a Nitriding Salt Bath Furnace System and several ovens for an automotive application with the expectation of many more to come in 2019/2020.

Prediction time. I know this is a question which is almost impossible to answer but I love asking the question anyway-what do you see changing in the industry over the next few years? I will give you an example which I often wonder about; in 5 years will there still be travelling salespeople in the industry or will sales of heat treat equipment largely be done on line?

Relative to travel or doing the lion share of sales via computer is possible but I don’t think you can beat being on site and interacting in person and talking to all the people and getting their input for the project. This will probably prevail for some time. In closing and as an aside, I find it difficult to understand that all of the people in our industry love what they do but what I cannot understand is that if you go to a social function and people ask what you do and when you tell them that you are in the heat treating industry, they don’t understand what that is. We need to do a better job of educating the public about heat treating in a way they understand the important service we provide. When they see that the 70 plus springs in automobiles or other automotive components, the steel caps in our work boots, etc. are heat treated, do they then understand what it means for something to be heat treated. In addition, our salt products are not only used for processing steel components, but eyeglass lenses are tempered in salt, rubber products such as gasketing, wiper blades are processed in molten salt. Oil and gas industry also use salts for processing crude oil to extract specialty chemicals used in the plastics industry etc.

I, certainly, have enjoyed being in the industry for past 50 years mainly because every day a new application pops up. For our customer base to receive the best possible equipment, we recognize that we need good qualified people for all of our departments. That is why we have recently added several engineers with P Eng accreditation, Steve Cropper as our Vice President of Sales and Jay Mistry heads up the company as the new owner and CEO of Park Thermal.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Laurent Pelissier, ECM

Furnace manufacturer ECM based in Grenoble, France is one of the larger furnace builders in the world as you can see in this interview. We had the privilege of meeting and interviewing the CEO of the company, Mr. Laurent Pelissier at his headquarters in Grenoble, France last week.

Laurent I believe you got into this industry for the same reason as many of us do-parents who were also involved in heat treating. Could you tell us about it?

“Yes it is definitely a family business! My father, Mr. Francis PELISSIER, created the foundation of today’s ECM in 1984. After doing an engineering degree I joined him and the ECM adventure 30 years ago, in 1988. I covered many jobs in the company and this gave me a strong understanding of how it works. At the end of 2008 ECM got a new start in its current structure and my wife Marlène joined ECM then as HR director and administrator. My son Arthur, after completing the same engineering degree as me, joined ECM Group in 2017 as Business Development Manager, and he has now moved to a project manager position. Some people in the company I have known their entire professional lives and if you ask around in the workshop you will see that many technicians have spent their entire working career at ECM. We will be celebrating our 10 year “anniversary” March 30th of this year to mark the moment and all employees will be bringing their families for the celebration.”

Can you tell us about ECM-the history of the company, how large the company is in terms of sales, number of employees etc?

“To give you an idea about our vision, the ECM GROUP motto is: “Industry leader in the design, manufacturing & installation of heating treatment industrial furnaces.” Our 2017 turnover was 84 M€ (90% was international). The group employs about 350 people. Shares are mostly held by family, a close friend and management. However in order to help our development we opened about 15% up to institutional and private investors. We have 5 manufacturing sites in France and 1 in China and 8 international subsidiaries: ECM CHINA (Beijing), SEMCO Inc., USA, Texas,  ECM USA (Kenosha WI), ECM INDIA (Bangalore), ECM KAZAKHSTAN (Astana), ECM GREENTECH MIDDLE EAST (ABU DHABI), ECM GMBH (Saarbrücken, Germany) and SEMCO in Singapore.”

When I think of ECM I think of Low Pressure carburizing-is this a true statement and if it isn’t what other types of furnaces does ECM manufacturer?  

“It is true that ECM has been a recognized global industry leader in Low Pressure Carburizing (which is roughly 50% of our production). Now the strength of the group also comes from our ability to adapt our leadership and build competencies in other heat treating areas. So right now we are able to design all kinds of furnaces: vacuum furnaces, special furnaces, crystallisation furnaces for PV industry, melting furnaces, atmosphere pusher furnaces, VPA furnaces, Photovoltaic semiconductor furnaces and Rapid Thermal Processing (RTP) furnaces.”

I have lost track of the number of carburizing cells you have produced over the years but I know it is impressive. Care to tell us the exact number?

“We have 1280 carburizing cells installed around the world”.

Does this make you the largest low pressure carburizing furnace supplier in the world?

“Yes we can say so: with our INFRACARB® patent we are the worldwide leader in this field.”

A number of years ago the prediction was that low pressure carburizing was going to take over the heat treating industry at the expense of atmosphere carburizing. While to some extent this has happened in two specific areas, automotive transmission gears and fuel injection nozzles it does not appear that the technology has been adapted in many other areas. Would you agree or disagree with this statement?

“Regarding LPC, the automotive industry is still the main market but not the only one anymore. We believe that our new ICBP FLEX, ICBP NANO and DUO machines (which are specifically targeted to heat treaters) will accelerate this market diversification as we are seeing some strong interest from many other industries.”

Let’s change gears a little bit-I remember it as a very interesting story about how ECM got started in North America all those years ago. Care to give us all the details?

“Well the interesting story is probably the human side of it. We first started to be interested in the US when we figured there might be some opportunity to export one or 2 furnaces! Then to cut a long story short we (Yvan Trouillot, Dennis Beauchesne & Fred Otto) built commercial heat treater MTV and ECM (both in Wisconsin) at the same time in 1998. The starting point was one specific customer order …and like you North Americans like to say: the rest is history! ECM USA is our most vibrant foreign subsidiary because of its existence and recognition in the heat treating community.”

Do you still have an affiliation with Midwest Thermal:

“Of course! Mostly thanks to our history and also the incredible support the MTV / Otto family has given us throughout the years, we hope they will always remain our partners.”

What are the main geographic areas for ECM when it comes to sales and installations?

“ECM has been able to address all geographic areas, all countries. No region is predominant and we usually find a pretty balanced ratio between the Americas, Europe and Asia. Depending on the local economic climate, some years the North and South American market is the largest and some years the European market is the largest but typically it is 1/3 Asia, 1/3 Europe and 1/3 the Americas.”

Do you notice a difference in attitudes in different markets? For instance does an American or an Asian have different requests or needs which differ from a German or a French customer?

“We could probably talk about this topic for hours! Dealing with complex international projects has taught our teams that yes indeed there are differences and they can be divided into 2 main parts: specifications and regulation differences on one side and cultural differences on the other. Now you see where I am going with this idea: depending on their culture customers do not address specifications and regulations the same way!! We have a very diverse workforce in ECM and this often helps us to at least to reduce some of these cultural challenges.”

There is a lot of talk these days about single piece part flow, meaning that rather than our tried and true model of a batch furnace processing a load of parts furnaces would be handling parts one at a time on a continuous basis. Do you see this as the future of heat treating?

“This can also be debated for a long time! We have definitely seen some market requests for smaller batches and have started developing some products around this need a while ago. Our ICBP NANO product category (now fully marketed) is able to produce parts in an almost completely robotized manner and with extremely low distortion. This system has been designed to work in single piece part flow production scenarios.  We are very proud of this product range which is also getting a strong signal from various markets.”        

The last question leads me to ask this one; on a regular basis I am asked about “lights out” heat treating meaning a completely automated furnace (s) with little or no human interaction. What is your opinion-is this the future, the distant future or not in the future?

“This is a medium term goal. In preparation we have created a robotics business unit to integrate robots into furnace automation systems. We are also working on Factory 4.0. As an organization we have made a lot of investments already in automation to help our customers. First we have a full robotics division which is integrated within the group. This has already helped us design a totally autonomous installation. ECM currently has several installations which are completely automated and in production. Second, we believe that integrating the furnace and the robotics will provide better results for our customers.” 

Out of all the numerous processed available, gas nitriding, plasma nitriding, vacuum heat treating, gas carburizing etc., which do you believe enjoys the brightest future with the most growth?

“I firmly believe that LPC is the future of heat treating which is why we concentrate on this technology. We have created both modular and batch solutions especially with our new DUO system which is able to replace a standard batch IQ furnace.  LPC has demonstrated that it is environmentally friendly with low CO2 emissions, part quality second to none, safer operation and a better working environment for the operators. New car technologies are showing real opportunities: for example in hybrid related products there will be a need for low distortion gears and improved metallurgy which will mean heat treaters will need to invest in new technologies to meet these tougher requirements. We are also enjoying repeat orders for  ICBP systems.”

2018 was a tremendous year for most of us involved in the worldwide heat treating industry-what fearless predictions would you like to make about 2019?

“2018 was an excellent year for ECM and we are expecting that 2019 will be even better. So far our order book is showing excellent promise of major investments in all heat treating markets.”

And last but not least what does the future hold for Laurent Pelissier and ECM? What can you share with us today about where you are going?

“ECM believes in innovation. This is what has led us to where we are now. Right now are working on a number of projects around preventative maintenance, connected machines, or Factory 4.0 just to name a few. As an example ECM consistently invests 10% of our sales into our R & D efforts.  But we are very flexible in our R&D path and what we consider innovative today might become something totally different altogether. In the short term 2019 should see some new LPC type batch furnaces (our DUO product) being installed that will replace the current generation of furnaces. Going forward we see our growth coming from a combination of new products and external acquisitions.”

Laurent Pelissier , CEO, ECM

ECM, Grenoble, France

Fred Ott, Midwest Thermal-Vac, Kenosha, Wisconsin, USA

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Mr. Jan Söderström, Quintus Technologies. We are very pleased today to have an interview with Mr. Jan Söderström, CEO of Quintus Technologies-the world’s largest supplier of equipment for Hot Isostatic Processing.

Over the years I have run across Hot Isostatic Processing many times, but I have to confess I know little about the technology-could you please give us a brief summary about the process and why it is used?

“HIP is mainly used to densify metal castings, containerized powder shapes and ceramic parts. With typical pressures from 1,035 to 2,070 bar (15,000 to 30,000 psi) and temperatures up to 2,000°C (3,630°F). A combination of temperature and pressure for a specific soak time eliminates porosity allowing HIP to achieve 100% of the theoretical density and improve the ductility, fracture toughness and fatigue resistance of critical, high-performance materials. For castings this technology has been extensively used in the aerospace as well as the industrial gas turbine market, but it is also widely used for powder metallurgy and near net shape production in the Oil and Gas industry. The fastest growing new user of HIP technology is metal Additive Manufacturing (AM), 3D-printing.”

Would you consider this a heat treatment process or more of a related process?

“Originally HIP has been one part of several steps in a heat treatment process to create materials with superior properties. However, in the latest development of Quintus HIP systems, very fast cooling rates can be achieved, and multiple heat treatment steps can be included into the HIP cycle. Processes like stress relieving, solutionizing as well as aging and tempering can all be run in one and the same HIP cycle while the high pressure remains. Quintus call this High Pressure Heat Treatment (HPHT). This is possible due to the unique design of Quintus wire wound pressure vessels where very quick cooling rates can be achieved in the HIP under high pressure. So in answer to your question, our modern High Pressure Heat Treatment equipment is definitely a part of the heat treatment World. Traditional phase transition curves might need to be re-written to include pressure as a parameter as this can have a measurable effect on controllability of phase transformations.”

“The major benefits of combining heat treatment processes in the same cycle are of course lead time savings, cost savings as well as improved material properties. In comparison with oil quenching High Pressure Heat Treatment has also proved to be very beneficial to prevent distortions and crack propagation in the final product and tailored cycles can help prevent cracking with the use of pressure.”

What kind of heat treatment cycles can be run in your equipment?

“As mentioned above our modern HIP systems can be used for multiple parts of a heat treatment process. All of our systems have the possibility to run pressure and temperature independently which gives our customers a big flexibility in how to run their cycles. In addition to this the systems can be equipped with quench functionality where we can achieve cooling rates in which is similar to oil quenching. With these capabilities you can do stress relief, HIP, solutionizing, tempering as well as aging in our HIP systems. With that said it is up to our customers to verify what the most economical way of using the HIP system is for their respective products.”  

Who is your typical customer, a manufacturer or a commercial heat treater?

“Historically Quintus has sold HIP systems to a few providers of HIP services in the USA, and Europe as well as Asia but this is now changing. Quintus have seen dramatic increase in interest from commercial heat treaters in the last few years both in USA as well as in Europe. As you reported last year Gord, two new commercial heat treaters entered the HIP market in USA, Paulo and Stack, and Quintus also sold a system to a heat treatment company in Mexico which will be the first HIP service provider there.”

“In addition to this we also see an increase of interest from insourcing HIP technology where companies both OEMs and components manufacturers that have used HIP services for a period of time see the economical, the lead time and the Intellectual Property benefits of insourcing HIP technology besides the possibility to freely chose HIP parameters. It is especially the metal Additive Manufacturing (AM) industry that is coming into a production mode that now start to insource HIP and High Pressure Heat Treatment technology. Additive manufactured components can often benefit form specific HIP and heat treatment parameters that are different from the conventional parameters used for castings. This is due to the quite different microstructures seen in material produced by AM compared to cast material. HPHT enables tailoring of microstructures with the help of pressure and high cooling rates and many papers are now being presented on the benefits. This helps to fuel the demand from OEMs.”

“Finally, there is a category of metal AM companies that take the whole metal AM production chain into considerations that are now moving to insource HIP and HPHT. Having the possibility to control everything from the powder, printing, post processing etc. is a huge benefit for the final part quality. There has been a great deal of focus on powder and printing over the past few years, and now the industry is moving to look at post processing and lean manufacturing.”

How large is the market for HIPing, to phrase it another way how many HIP systems, both yours and competitors, would you estimate to be in operation around the world?

“Today there are around 100 presses operated by service providers (tollers) around the Globe.  The market is currently growing by more than 10% annually. The growth can be divided into two categories, the larger presses for traditional HIP use and the compact and midsized presses offering High Pressure Heat Treatment catering to the Additive Manufacturing industry and high performance investment casting.”

Geographically is HIPing more prevalent in some regions than others?

“The largest market is USA followed by Europe and Asia.”

Feel free to correct me but my impression is that Bodycote is far and away the largest in the world when it comes to HIPing. Having said that I can think of 3 US commercial heat treaters, Lake City, Stack Metallurgical and Paulo who have invested in this technology over the past year. Why this sudden and growing interest by commercial heat treaters?

“You are right in Bodycote being the largest player of HIPing in the USA and Europe but this is not the case for Asia. In Japan MTC is the biggest player and in China you have a multitude of companies offering HIP services. Regarding your question why commercial heat treaters start to invest in HIP now there are several answers to that:

The HIP market is growing dramatically and there is an increasing demand for HIP capacity. The requirements are increasing for the HIP service providers, and customers require much faster turn-around times from despatch to receipt of the part back from the toller. Larger systems dominate the HIP service market, and these require time to fill from various end OEMs, and now Quintus® sees an increased demand of smaller systems that can be run with faster turn around times and tailored heat treatment cycles.

Quintus can today also offer a rigorous preventative Maintenance and Application support program, called Quintus® Care. This program assures a trouble-free operation as well as optimized functionality and usability at a fixed cost. This program can be tailored to fit the specific needs of respective customers.

Finally, I would also like to mention that the Heat Treatment companies entering the HIP service market see this as an investment for the future where they will increase their market share not only for HIP services but also for Heat Treatment services. With the fast-growing market of Additive manufacturing these heat treatment companies will become One-stop-shops that can offer the whole heat treatment package at the same location which will simplify the logistics situation for many customers.”

My first impression when I see your systems is that they are highly engineered, heavy duty and complicated which generally translates into expensive. This a rather convoluted way of asking, what do these installations typically cost?

“As you can understand the price range ($0.5-$20 MUSD) is heavily dependent on the size of the equipment and it is especially the diameter of the system that increase the price level. We like to talk about what value a HIP investment brings to our customers and we always do a rigorous business case study together with our customers to be able to suggest the most economical solution for respective customer. Typical cost of operation is $0.1-$2USD/lbs (0.2-3.8 €/kg) depending on press size and how efficient you can load the components in the press.Typically, customers see a full return on their investment within 2-4 years depending on the size of the equipment”

Lets change gears slightly and look at your company Quintus Technologies. What can you share with us such as the history of the company, total sales, number of employees etc?

“Quintus Technologies has roots going back to the mid-1950s, when ASEA in Sweden was among the first to commercialize the isostatic pressure technology conceived at Battelle Memorial Institute in Columbus, Ohio. The world’s first high-pressure press came into operation in 1953 and was used to manufacture synthetic diamonds and other products. ASEA, later ABB, then continued to market sheet metal forming and isostatic presses throughout the world. Today Quintus has global annual sales of around 150 MUSD and we have 230 employees.”

Do you have much competition?

“Quintus is the largest manufacturer of Hot Isostatic Presses globally, but competition increases on a daily basis. We specifically see increased competition in China where several HIP providers are working on design improvement. With that said I like competition because we need competition to stay alert and continue to develop our technology leadership. Competition also means more players developing the market.”

What differentiates your machinery to that from other suppliers?

“There are a couple of significant differences between our systems and the main part of other HIP systems suppliers and they are:

Pressure vessel design – Quintus uses a high strength steel wire to pre-stress a thin walled forged cylinder. The walls of the cylinder always experience compressive stresses which prevents crack initiation and growth. This manufacturing method was developed in the mid 50’s for Quintus® diamond presses and has proven to be a safe and reliable concept ever since. The use of wire winding also makes it possible to use higher pressures for larger pressure vessel diameters. Quintus are today offering 30,000 PSI (2070 bar) for all standard equipment and can design machinery for high pressure ratings also for larger diameters.

Cooling capacity – As an effect of the thin walled wire wound design the pressure vessel can be cooled very effectively giving the opportunity to cool the load very fast. For the majority of Quintus pressure vessels cooling rates in excess of 400°F/min (200°C/min) up to 4500 C/min can be achieved which gives the possibility to combine HIP and Heat Treatment in the same cycle.

Temperature accuracy – Quintus have optimized its furnaces (Thermal Barriers) as well as the software controlling it and our customers typically experience temperature variations of ±3.6°F (±2°C) during the steady state hold time.”

What is your sales strategy? Do you sell through reps, direct sales people, regional offices? Along the same lines will be seeing you at any of the large Heat Treat shows in 2019 such as Thermprocess, ASM, HK19 or the Moscow heat treat show?

“Quintus has a global presence of its sales force and our front-end has expanded quickly during the last few years. As well as our Head Quarters in Västerås, Sweden, which covers large parts of Europe we also have sales offices in United Kingdom, Germany, USA (Columbus, OH), China and Japan. In addition to this we also have a large agent network that covers the rest of Americas, and Asia-Pacific.

We also see our Quintus Application Centers being an integrated part of our sales force. There, tests are performed to verify the customers’ processes and securing an attractive business case.

You will for sure see Quintus at several trade shows this year and even if we are not exhibiting we will be walking the floor at a multitude of events. For Heat Treatment we will exhibit at MS&T in Portland and Heat Treat 19 in Detroit as well as Thermprocess in Europe. In USA we will also exhibit at AMUG (Chicago), Rapid (Detroit) and Cast Expo (Atlanta). In addition to exhibitions, we are very active at conferences presenting a large number of papers each year in conjunction with industry and university projects.”

On a personal note Jan how did you come to be involved in this industry and in particular with Quintus?

“In 2012 was asked by the former owner, a US based PE company if I wanted to be involved in this opportunity- I got very excited. During my earlier time at ABB I had the opportunity to follow the development of the high pressure business close by and I was always intrigued by the highly specialized and powerful machinery.”

What does the future hold for Quintus and HIPing in general?

“The future for Quintus and HIPing is very exciting from many different aspects. HIPing is starting to get the traction we at Quintus always have worked for. In the aerospace industry HIPing has been used extensively for several decades having realized the benefits and HIP is considered from the start of the design process. Here it is seen as a perfect way to reduce weight and maximize safety since you know that you can rely on your material properties. With the whole metal Additive Manufacturing industry growing extensively this is something they have a direct use for as well. We can now see that more and more industries are applying HIPing more extensively including the automotive and orthopedic sectors. The greatest increase can be seen in the growing demand for High Pressure Heat Treatment capabilities, allowing further design improvements through repeatability and improvement of material properties.”

I very much appreciate your time and in particular your very open and forthright answers-I hope to meet in person in Sweden one of these days.  thank you. Gord

Surjit Bawa/ Metex Heat Treating 

We are pleased to have an interview with Surjit Bawa founder of Metex Heat Treating in Brampton, Ontario, Canada-arguably one of the most successful commercial fastener heat treaters in North America.

How did you get started working in the heat treat industry?

“My background is as a Metallurgist and my first position in the industry was with Budd Heat Treat in Windsor, Ontario, Canada where I started as a furnace operator. While I was a furnace operator I occasionally had to change into a suit and put my metallurgist hat on when a customer visited-I ended up as General Manager.”

Raman – “I decided sometime in high school that I wanted to spend my life working on computers.  That somehow transcended into a degree into Electrical Engineering.  From there, I worked at BlackBerry working on software security & privacy.  When things started going south over there, I decided I needed something fresh and more hands on.  Obviously growing up around Metex, it seemed like a logical choice.  It combined a passion for engineering with the hands on nature I was looking for.”

Tell us about starting Metex.

“I started Metex in Brampton in 1983 partly because I wanted to live in Toronto (editor’s note; Brampton is a suburb of Toronto). The name comes from “Metal Experts” and I started with 1 rotary retort furnace, 1 batch furnace and 1 brazing furnace. From there we expanded to 4 brazing furnaces and got rid of the batch furnace. In 1985 we added our first mesh belt line with a capacity of 1,000 pounds per hour and then a 3,000 pound line and then a 6,000 pound line.”

Please tell us something about Metex, the size of the company, number of employees, processes offered etc.

“Metex now has 4 buildings, mesh belt capacity of 21,000 pounds per hour, 4 batch IQ lines and 10 Induction systems with a new, automated, very large induction system arriving shortly.”

You have been very successful in processing fasteners, so much so that you have little competition in the Canadian market-what has been the secret?

“We are able to offer our customers not only heat treating but heat treating, plating, sorting, packaging and shipping as a boxed product. No longer do our customers have to unload their trucks 6 times between production and final shipping.”

Is there anyone in the heat treating industry that you’ve learned a lot from, and what was the most valuable thing they taught you?

“My first boss Budd Decker of Budd Heat Treating taught me an enormous amount about heat treating, business and how to treat your customers.”

What’s your favorite part of your current job?

“Innovation. Controls and robotics have changed the industry and this is what I most enjoy, coming up with innovative solutions.”

Raman – “With a large part of our business being in Automotive.  It is an amazing feeling to know the products we work on every day are being used in vehicles all over the world.”

Obviously you’ve been quite successful so I don’t mind asking this question, what was the biggest mistake you’ve made when it comes to Metex?

“In 2007 very shortly before the Great Recession I bought a 7,000 pound per hour cast link belt line. Business slowed down so much that we never actually ran it and ended up scrapping it.”

What still motivates you to work as hard as you do?

“I am still having fun and my son Raman is doing a very good job of running the business on a day to day basis.”

Raman –  “With heat treating being somewhat of a niche industry, the knowledge base we have here is tremendous.  I feel it is my duty to nurture and grow it to ensure we can be a company that industries can rely on.”

What does the future hold for Metex and the heat treating industry in general?

“2018 is going to be a good year for us. The NAFTA negotiations (North American Free Trade Agreement between Canada, the US and Mexico) is certainly a concern for us. We will continue to make new investments, businesses that don’t continue to invest will not survive. Robotics and controls become more and more important each day. We are also looking at a very exciting new technology which we are not ready to talk about. Predictions about the demise of heat treating due to plastics replacing metal a number of years ago proved to be false.”

Raman – “The concept of lighter and stronger seems to be paramount today more than ever.  I believe this puts us, heat treaters, at an advantage.  Every new project we work on seems to have some form of this and with the tools of metallurgy we can aid the transition to the new evolution of manufacturing.”

I thank you for your time today Surjit.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Stephen Harris / Bodycote

This past week we were fortunate enough to catch up with Mr. Stephen Harris, CEO of the world’s largest commercial heat treater, UK based Bodycote. Our timing was fortunate in that Stephen was in Atlanta, Georgia with the Bodycote team reviewing their very recent acquisition of Carolina Commercial. Stephen’s responses to our questions were succinct, thought provoking and in some cases not what we expected. In addition I can say that Stephen is a very competent fellow (we would have been surprised if he was not) and remarkably easy to speak with.

Good afternoon Stephen, I have to say that for quite some time I have been looking forward to meeting you. The first question I have to ask you is what is your background and how did you ever come to be involved in the heat treating industry?

“I was trained as an electrical engineer but along the way I acquired a business degree from a university in the Chicago area. While my job history is varied it would be best described as a General Industrial Background. This would include long working stints in the Chicago area and Buffalo, in several cases running the North American operations of UK companies. I was approached by Bodycote in 2008 to replace the outgoing CEO, Mr. John Hubbard with whom I have since had a long and enjoyable working relationship. I became CEO of Bodycote in January 2009 mainly because I found it such an interesting company.”

After what 4 or 5 years in the industry what is your impression of the industry and how does it differ from other industries you have been involved with?

“Fragmentation. The commercial heat treating industry is far more fragmented than virtually any I have seen with numerous players from very large to very small and this has a great deal to do with geography. In a past life I was involved with the equipment renting business which in some ways is similar -many small companies because who is going to drive more than 50 miles to rent a tool? Heat treating is in some ways similar – who wants to send their parts 200 miles to be heat treated? Other differences that come to mind are the age of the industry and the relative smallness of the bureaucracy. We have traced heat treating back to 800 BC which means nothing is new in the industry and yet on the other side of the coin it is not a particularly mature industry in that there remains a lot that can be improved upon and modernized. Another factor that strikes me is that the bureaucracy in the industry is far smaller than in most other industries.”

Under your watch Bodycote has been flourishing with revenues, profits and share prices all higher. To what do you attribute this? To phrase it another way what have you changed at the company since you became CEO?

“When I became CEO of Bodycote it was an extremely difficult time for all heat treaters. We sat down and made conscious decisions about what needed to be done and those decisions turned out to be the right ones for the company. Those decisions included hiring the best people both from in the industry and outside for the right positions, ensuring that we were extremely responsive to customers’ needs, that wherever possible we operated on a 24/7 basis in our plants and that what we were offering the customers was the right fit for both them and Bodycote. As an example we looked closely at which jobs were profitable and which weren’t and made decisions based upon this. While the general direction was set at the top level we have always believed that most decisions need to be made at the local level so our local managers have a great deal of decision making responsibility. This is a huge industry with many opportunities but it is crucial that the processes and services we are offering our customers are the best fit for both them and Bodycote. Choose the customers, choose the work.”

In the past year you have made two major acquisitions in North America, Metal Improvement and Carolina Commercial. To some extent this surprises me as my understanding is that profit margins are lower in North America than other areas such as Europe. Why this focus on the North American market?

“You are incorrect on this Gord. Profit margins in North America are very respectable when compared to the rest of the world and when you consider that it is estimated that the worldwide captive and commercial heat treating industry is worth $35 Billion USD/year and that $20 Billion of this is in the US, North America is and will remain a crucial area for us. Our recent acquisitions demonstrate that we take this seriously and that have the ability to offer heat treating services in every area of North America.”

Can we expect to see any major changes at either Metal Improvement or Carolina Commercial now that they are part of the Bodycote group?

“Both Metal Improvement and Carolina Commercial are profitable, well run companies so we do not plan on any major changes although we are making new investments in these facilities. Obviously the names will change to Bodycote. The Metal Improvement plants were divided up between our Aerospace, Defence and Energy business, run by Mr. Tracy Glende, and our Automotive and General Industrial business (North America/Asia) where Mr. Dan McCurdy is President. Carolina Commercial will be wholly under Dan McCurdy”

With these 2 large acquisitions under your belt would it be fair to say that you see the future growth of Bodycote to be mainly through acquisitions? This is a bit of a loaded question as I know that the company has always focused on taking over captive heat treating operations so to rephrase this question slightly do you believe that growth in the future will be more through acquisitions or by taking over heat treating requirements that are currently done in house by manufacturers?

“Most future growth will be “organic” as opposed to acquisitions. When it comes to captive heat treating our largest opportunity comes when a customer adds a new product or substantially changes a current one which would require a new heat treating process. Typically at this point the customer will very seriously consider outsourcing.”

After your recent acquisition of Carolina Commercial I made the statement that Bodycote is both the only truly international commercial heat treater and the only commercial heat treater with the resources to make such acquisitions. Fair statement in your opinion?

“Fair Statement.”

I have worked with Bodycote for many years now and have a very high opinion of the company, in resources and global reach no other companies in the industry come close in my opinion. However (and there is always a however) I have heard many times over the years that the company is so large that it makes it difficult to compete with smaller more nimble heat treaters. Would you regard this as unwarranted criticism?

“I do not agree with this statement! Bodycote invests $100 million USD in new equipment and technologies every year which is something none of our competitors can say and this is done in a very timely fashion while keeping in mind that as a company we are always looking down the road 20-30 years. As a matter of fact I would say that we are extremely nimble and quick to make decisions especially on relatively small investments under $200,000. We give our plants a great deal of autonomy and when an opportunity presents itself to our local managers we will always consider it.”

The Bodycote name is most closely associated with heat treating but I know that your Hot Isostatic Pressing Division is very successful. Care to give us a bit of background about this portion of the business and how it compares to heat treating in terms of revenue?

“Our “HIP” business is roughly $100 million USD/year and actually consists of two parts; HIP Services which is strengthening castings and HIP Product Fabrication which is a manufacturing process as opposed to a heat treatment process. Our HIP business is the largest in the world.”

I can’t imagine that there is a single heat treating process in the world that Bodycote does not offer. I am not sure whether you care to answer this question but which is the most profitable for the company and which is of most interest to you personally?

“You cannot say that one particular process is more profitable than another as there are a number of different factors that come in to play such as local demand. For instance heat treating of fasteners can be very profitable if there is a very strong demand for fasteners in a given area however as this demand goes up or down it affects our profitability. Some heat treatment plants can be very successful by offering NADCAP accredited heat treating of aerospace parts but this model obviously will not be successful for plant “B” if there is little aerospace work in the area. So again it comes down to having the right process for the customer. We do not set out to pick a particular process, rather we listen to what our customers need and invest based upon this. Vacuum Carburizing, Vacuum, Induction, Batch IQ – driven by the customer needs. Some heat treating companies are very successful by stressing a particular process but at Bodycote we are open to consider any process as long as it is the best fit for the customer.”

This question ties in closely with the previous one; is there any particular type of heat treating that you see growing substantially in the near or medium term?

“None in particular. Again it is crucial that we match the correct process to the customers’ needs which means we are at the mercy of the customer.”

Bouncing back a little I mentioned how it would appear that you are paying particular attention to the North American market which might or might not be a reasonable statement. What other geographic areas do you see as particularly of interest to you?

“Eastern Europe and Asia are two markets that we are paying close attention to. While Eastern Europe is still a small market and has little in the way of commercial heat treating it is growing which represents an opportunity for us. Our large investments in China and India demonstrate how seriously we take these areas. While we have substantial assets in Brazil this is a country where the ups and downs of the economy make it difficult to know what is going to happen.”

You have some really top notch people in the company, some of whom I have known for years and would consider personal friends-are there any that you would like to single out for a mention?

“I am tremendously proud of all of our people but if pushed I would suggest our two “Elder Statesmen”. Mr. Jan Elwart in Germany and Mr. Guy Prunel in France.”

I have asked many very experienced people in the industry what they see in the future for heat treating. I have to say that I have never received any real sort of consensus. I have heard everything from more commercial heat treating and less captive heat treating, to Vacuum Carburizing taking over the industry, to most heat treating following manufacturing out of North America to areas such as India and China (which I personally don’t believe by the way) all the way to heat treating becoming a smaller industry down the road. This long winded question all leads up to this; what do you see in the future?

“We would estimate that 80% of heat treating in the world is captive and we don’t see this number dramatically changing. Your question about manufacturing and heat treating moving to areas such as India and China is a good one and we see it as a good thing. For instance when a foreign manufacturer sets up a facility in Asia it is generally for the local market and usually includes an in-house heat treating department. A large investment in Asia means less investment for plants in the US (and new heat equipment is a large investment) which translates into more outsourcing in North America which is of course a good thing for us.”

And what do you see in the future for Mr. Stephen Harris? Most people that get involved with heat treating tend to stay in the industry for their entire working careers, have you been bitten by the heat treating bug yet?

“It’s been a blast!”

Thank you for your time.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Skip Jones / 2°OFF.LLC

Skip I believe that you are quite unique in that you went from West Coast Manager of Bodycote overseeing a number of plants to a manufacturers rep selling heat treating equipment. How did this come about?

“It is really not much different. As you know today’s Corporate Manager must always be justifying and selling operations ideas, investments and expansion plans. The manufacturer rep is selling the same, just at a different level. Our approach to selling is a bit different, in that we use our 25+ years experience and the manufacturer’s technical expertise to provide solutions for the customer’s material and thermal processing challenges.”

Having been a rep for my entire working life I have to ask you-what do you think of the life of being a rep? Is it the road to riches?

“I have to say I have not seen any lotto sales come our way. The manufacturer rep life is difficult because the capital gestation period for the sales may take as long 12 months to 24 months. It is very important to have a mix of products and consumables to provide sustaining cash flow. As you know to help 2OFF with cash flow our consulting engineering business has provided this base. We have retainer clients where 2 is the client’s metallurgical engineering resource and assisted several companies with business plans and accreditations. Also the affiliation with an International Consulting Group has provided in-roads to new business.”

Continuing in the same vein you saw the heat treating industry from the standpoint of being a buyer and now you are on the other side of the fence selling to heat treaters. Has your viewpoint changed with your transition?

“I do not think my viewpoint has changed… but is enhanced. One frustration I have had as a heat treat-plating equipment buyer; I have found the sales people have not always been process savvy and therefore not providing all the information necessary to meet the processing criteria. With processing knowledge expertise, I assure our customers with the right equipment technology to satisfy their needs and the process.”

Feel free to enlighten our readers about your territory and your product lines.

“The west coast (CA,OR,WA )heat treat dollar value of all metal treated (commercial & captive) is estimated at approximately $1.4 billon. The metal treating market is 55% aerospace; 14% commercial; 10% fastener; 8% tooling; 6% semi-conductor;4% medical; & 3% miscellaneous. It should be noted in aerospace the metal usage has shifted in the last 10 years with aluminum down 6%; steel down 5%; high-strength alloys up 4%; titanium up 6%; and composites up 8%. This market shift has impacted the thermal processing equipment requirements and moved the heat treat process to the metal producers. 2OFF has aligned with key manufacturers to provide atmosphere equipment (batch and continuous), vacuum furnaces, LPC vacuums, aluminum drop bottom furnaces, age ovens, plating equipment, environmental recovery systems, specialty induction systems, instrumentation and analyzers, oil-water separators, air-liquid cooling and used equipment. These product lines provides 2the capability to canvas the west coast markets.”

The California market is very different from most other areas of North America. I would very much appreciate your comments about the market. For instance what are the main heat treating markets? Do commercials hold a large or small percentage of the heat treating market? Do you see mainly vacuum furnaces, continuous, batch IQ’s drop bottoms? Do the furnaces tend to be as large as in other areas?

“Commercial heat treaters have approximately 15% to 20% of the west coast metal treating markets. There are 60 commercial heat treats on the west coast. The top 12 heat treat companies have approximately 65% of the commercial heat treat sales. Aerospace manufacturing mainly is small lot and there are limited automotive- commercial manufacturers. The majority of the automotive business is focus on high performance racing products. The majority of the furnaces on the west coast are batch type. The west coast fastener market predominantly uses shaker tray (atmosphere & vacuum) furnaces, batch IQ furnaces, and vacuum furnaces in their operations. Looking at the 2 frequency of inquiries for furnaces: age furnaces 26%, aluminum drop quench 11%; atmosphere IQ 6%, braze belt 3%, continuous atmosphere quench 1%, hydrogen retort 1%, LPC systems 2%, nitride furnaces 11%, open fire 6%, ovens 14% and vacuums 19%.”

I have to say that California is one of my favorite areas of North America but I know from experience that the state does not appear to be especially business friendly. How would you respond to this? What barriers do you see that are not seen in other areas?

“I can say it was a learning experience for me when I moved to California from North Carolina. Everything is different from labor laws to OSHA to environmental impact regulations. I have had several projects fail due to regulatory obstacles that put non-value added costs resulting in diminishing returns on investment. One of our clients in 2012 had planned to expand into the California market; however after the changes in labor practices from their Midwest operation, more OSHA requirements, AQMD requirements, and the increase taxes, they decided to cancel the relocation plan and moved to Mexico.”

As far as manufacturing and consequently heat treating goes are you optimistic or pessimistic about heat treating in your territory?

“I can only describe my crystal ball as “June Gloom”, and I am not sure when the marine layer will burn off. I am seeing some companies making investments and bringing on new product lines. However, I am seeing more relocating product lines to Midwest, Southeast, Europe, Mexico and Asia. I believe there is a core entrenched business base here in California; the underlying concern is that many of the companies have been purchased by large divested corporations with the key decision makers located out of state or even out of the country.”

Would you care to share with us the main players in your area when it comes to new furnaces, alloy and controls?

“In general the California industries that have made large investments in the last 18 months in new equipment are: aerospace forgings, aerospace fasteners, and commercial heat treating.”

About Skip Jones and his company. “2°OFF.LLC provides the necessary functional and operating expertise to provide your company the resources to navigate through material and thermal processing solutions. Our dedicated professionals use state of the art equipment and product suppliers to provide cost effective and timely results. We furnish the necessary guidance to meet today’s industry’s challenges, while rendering the most pragmatic solutions.
2°OFF.LLC is the west coast resource for ALD-Holcroft Vacuum Furnaces; AFC-Holcroft Atmosphere Furnace, Bogh Aluminum Furnaces, DK Ovens, GH Induction Atmospheres, Super Systems Instrumentation and Analyzers, RK Fabrication Plating Lines, Tanks and Environmental Systems, Universal Smartskim & Machine Coolant Recovery Systems, Qual-Fab High Alloy Fabrication for fixturing and 2OFF,LP consulting.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Rolf Terjung / Graphite Materials

We are pleased today to have an inteview with a very interesting fellow by the name of Rolf Terjung of Graphite Materials in Germany.

For years I have been fascinated by Carbon composite (C/C) fixtures for furnaces because of the fact it’s strength and ability to withstand high temperatures seems to be out of all proportion to it’s size and weight. Can you tell what makes this possible?

“To cut a long story short the strength of carbon fibers is based on the graphitic covalent structure which is highly orientated in fiber direction. The covalent bond is the strongest link between tow atoms we know. As an example picture the diamond which is one of the hardest material by nature due to the covalent bond. The thermal withstand simply relates to further exceptional material properties such as the negative CTE and high thermal conductivity. With raising temperature the fiber length shrinks but the diameter grows. For industrial plate stock the CTE turns out to be almost “zero”. Combined with a high thermal conductivity the material shows almost no thermal stress behavior. Finally the low density of about 1.6 g/cm³ (0.058 lbf/in³) compared to about 8 g/cm³ (0,29 lbf/in³) for HT-metal is responsible for the proportion of size to weight. High temperature strength combined with low density results in stiffness. A C/C fixture weighs about just 20% of the equivalent HT-material fixture carrying the same load.“

Very briefly what is involved in the manufacturing process?

“We start with the engineering which means the technical design and simulation of thermal and mechanical load patterns. The result is fixed in a blue print. On the shop floor plate stock material is cut to size by water-jet-cutting, grinding and milling. Diamond coated tools with special cutting edges come into operation with the milling process. At this point experience and know-how regarding milling parameters makes the difference regarding cost and quality.“

I understand the advantages but what about the disadvantages in particular the cost-how would a typical fixture made of graphite compare to one made of HT material as an example?

“From my point of view we face two disadvantages due to the material characteristic: Oxidation beyond a temperature of 350°C (662 F) in oxygen containing atmosphere and the contact reaction (C/C with Metal) in vacuum or inert gas beyond 1050°C (1922F). To avoid oxidation CC-fixtures basically can only be operated in vacuum or inert gas furnaces. The contact reaction is no longer a problem as the industry as well as we have engineered low cost and long lasting industrial solutions easy to handle. When it comes to cost we can prove by simple calculation that amortization is much less then the life time of a conventional HT-material. We looked into a clients process with a return of investment within 12 months. The winning arguments read as: more load per fixture, shorter process runs (heating/cooling), from manual to automated processing and lower energy use. On top one worker can easily handle the fixture by muscle power. In one word: significant increase of productivity which pays off in profit immediately.”

I am assuming that you can only justify the cost in high end applications such as vacuum carburizing. Is this a fair statement?

“Yes and No. We´ve successfully introduced CC-fixtures in different heat-treatment processes with gas and even oil quenching. Vacuum carburizing is of course one of the processes but also the vacuum brazing. Any heat treatment process beyond 1000°C in vacuum or inert gas has the potential for C/C fixtures. Distortion of the component due to fixture deformation of HT-material produce rejects and waste. One of the unbeatable arguments of CC-fixture is the non-distortion and hence no costs for straightening. Basically the process stability level shoots through the roof. Another brownie-point to be added to the factors already mentioned under item 3)“

This is part statement part question. As a North American I am well aware that we think more short term. In other words we want a profit today not 10 years from now which makes it harder to justify a high initial for fixturing even if it does provide far longer life. Is this an attitude that you run across very often or is it very unique to North America?

“Yes we came across this argument but no longer very often. The “winning arguments” already mentioned in question 3) provide a “profit” from the first time you put C/C fixture into operation. On top the level of process stability achievable makes live much easier considering planning, quality control and delivery time. On one hand we can look back to more than 15 years of successful experience which has spread around in the HT-family in Europe. On the other hand global competition forced the HT industry to examine the cost of the entire production process carefully. As a result among others fixtures have been identified with a significant cost potential. With a view to total cost and facts such as the “carbon food print” CC-fixtures are becoming a must-have.“

What percentage of the market, either in Europe or in other areas, is graphite as opposed to more traditional materials?

“I have no official data to present. But I guess CC has gained about 10% of the potential market. Don´t get me wrong. CC won´t replace traditional HT-material. Both concepts have its qualification in the industry. But the more the power to compete is the driving force the more CC-fixtures come into place. Please notice we have already engineered CC-fixtures to carry a single piece weighing 5000 kg (11023 pound). The HT-family is a traditional industry used to work with durable massive HT-fixtures. There is some doubting we have to overcome with our arguments.“

All of my questions to you have been more focused on fixturing than other furnace components. Where else in the heat treating industry do you see demand for your products?

“Our portfolio covers Graphite, Carbon/Carbon and fiber insulation products. If you look into the vacuum or inert gas furnace from cage to hot zone we provide the insulation (soft felt or rigid board), surface protection (foil or C/C-shield), heating systems (connectors, rods, electrodes, etc.), bars and C/C fixtures. We´re proud of having a skilled engineering and production team which is thrilled by bringing smart ideas into winning products for clients. As an example we developed a fixing system for the board insulation (cage and door) which stays back in the board. Hence the heat loss by the Molly pins (feed through from hot zone to cold wall) totally disappears. It has proven performance for several years even in gas quenching furnaces up to 10 bar. We optimized various heating systems by combining material – engineering and production know-how with the effect of longer life time and higher productivity. We gained our clients trust and based on that we are servicing the HT-industry since 2012 with entire vacuum furnace hot zone upgrades and replacements.“

Is the graphite industry a competitive one or do you see just a couple of suppliers?

“The industry is competitive although there are just a few highly skilled suppliers. As I already mentioned technical know-how and trust is important in that business as carbon based material all looks black. The market became significantly competitive when the solar hype cooled down in 2012 with the consequence of too much stock material globally hanging around. Generally speaking we take it as a challenge: competition gives birth to new ideas and drives innovation.”

So how did you come to end up in this industry? What is your background?

“Good question as it is still a niche industry. My educational background is powder metallurgy and engineering ceramics. The element “C” is a monoatomic ceramic. So I came across carbon and graphite by education. As a “hands-on” man I preferred to work in the industry after my PhD. When we started Graphite Materials in September 2000 as a trading company I always dreamt of my own machine shop which came through in 2008. Since then we established the entire machine shop service on about 3000 sqm with a total staff of 30 people. The customer base covers Europe, USA and Mexico.“

What are your predictions for the heat treating industry in general in a world full of turmoil? Are you optimistic about the future? Reserved or pessimistic?

“I am optimistic due to my personal settings. Heat treatment is a fascinating but complex subject full of possibilities. I have no doubt what so ever turmoil shakes the world this industry stays economically well established and will discover new application areas. We´re ready to be at your side.”

https://about.me/graphitematerials_en

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Rich Ott / Linamar Interview

If there is ever a vote about who is the most experienced, hands on heat treater in the world we know who our vote would be for-Mr. Rich Ott of auto parts supplier Linamar based in Guelph, Ontario, Canada. We are very excited about this interview as Rich is in charge of all the heat treating requirements for a total of 59 plants around the world.

Rich could you share with us your background-how you got into heat treating and where you have worked over the years?

“At the age of 14 I started working at a commercial heat treat plant in Kitchener, Ontario, Canada by the name of Steffler Heat Treat. Steffler became part of Can-Eng, which later became Hinderliter plant which eventually became Bodycote which it still is. For most of those years I was General Manager. In 1998 I joined Linamar Machine.”

Is spite of the fact that we talk on a regular basis I am not entirely sure about your job title at Linamar, what is your title and what does your dad to day job entail?

“My title is Corporate Heat Treat Specalist which I suppose means I am the go to guy at Linamar when it comes to heat treating. While I am based in Guelph and generally spend about 3 ½ days a week here I don’t get involved with the day to day operation of the heat treat department as much as I use to. Heat treat issues from any of our plants around the world takes up part of my time as does design problems and most heat treating equipment purchases-roughly 95% of which I get involved with.”

Linamar is an incredible success story, a company which didn’t exist roughly 40 years ago and is now a multi-billion dollar a year company with plants all over the world. Could you give us a brief idea about how large the company is, number of employees and what your main product lines are?

“Linamar was started by Frank Hazenfratz in 1968 and has grown to $6 Billion/year in sales with 26,000 employees in 59 plants in 17 countries. In addition we have 21 sales offices. Linamar is a publicly traded company and while most people think of us as an auto parts manufacturer this is only part of the story. Our Skyjack division as an example has annual sales of about $1 billion and we are also involved in farm equipment.”

Your plant in Guelph has what I would consider to be the largest batch IQ installation in North America-why? What I mean is why not continuous furnaces? Care to say a few things about the heat treat department?

“Flexibility is why we went with batch IQ furnaces as opposed to pushers and the years have proven that this was the correct decision. Incidentally the cost per pound is not that different between pushers and batch’s. Mesh belt furnaces would have been cheaper per pound but were not suitable for our product mix.”

At a guess how many of your plants around the world do heat treating?

“Out of 59 plants approximately 60% have some form of heat treating in house.”

Which are the most impressive Linamar plants when it comes to heat treating? I know Nuevo Laredo has quite a heat treat department-what others are really impressive?

“Our largest heat treating department is at SEISSENSCHMIDT Group in Germany a forging company which we acquired in 2014. This locations (s) has a number of different styles of furnaces including Ipsen batch IQ furnaces doing carburizing. When it comes to straight carburizing Linamar Gear in Guelph is the largest, followed by our location in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico (formerly part of Visteon) which has 36 vacuum carburizing cells and then the plant in Arden, North Carolina which is in the process of adding another 8 cell vacuum carburizing system.”

Over the years you have played with it all, batch IQ’s, Vacuum Carburizing systems, Induction, Nitriding furnaces-do you have a favorite?

“No. While Induction and batch IQ’s form the largest part of our heat treating different parts require different types of heat treating. By the way worldwide Linamar has approximately 450 induction spindles in operation.”

This is very closely related to the question above, has heat treating changed that much? Will we be seeing the death of batch IQ’s in the near future as an example? Pusher furnaces nearing the end of their life?

“Controls have made the largest change to the industry and furnaces are typically larger than they use to be but controls are what have really changed things and changed them for the better. As an example it is easier to achieve temperature uniformity with the new generation of controllers and besides that they are cheaper than they use to be which means they can be upgraded more often. Yes there are now more considerations about emissions but it is not a major consideration other than increased carbon taxes.”

We all know that the auto industry can be a very tough demanding business, what for you is the hardest part about heat treating auto parts? Fluctuating volumes? Quality? Furnace uptimes? Experienced employees?

“Finding good qualified employees is always a struggle. While we can and have automated some parts of our manufacturing processes it is very difficult to completely automate a heat treat department.”

You have seen far more than most the changes in quality specs over the years. Most heat treaters will agree with various degrees of enthusiasm that tightening specs to ensure a better quality part and more importantly a more consistent part is a good thing. However many heat treaters will also say that some specs are unrealistic and at the end of the day probably don’t significantly improve the quality or lack of. What do you think-have quality specs gone too far, about right or not far enough?

“Quality specifications have become tighter over the years but as I mentioned improved controls make it easier to meet these specs. Sometime the specs need a little “tweaking” based upon practical experience and testing but generally specs are not an issue.”

Is there anybody in the industry that has really impressed you either with knowledge, business savy or hard work?

“I learned a great deal from Wally Bamford of Can Eng. John Hubbard of Bodycote, Surjit Bawa of Metex and Harry Hall also all come to mind. For business savy and people skills without a doubt I would say Mr. Frank Hazenfratz, Chairman of the Board and founder of Linamar.”

This is a very personal question but I have to ask it; you are legendary in the industry for the incredible number of hours you put in each week, 70-80-why? Do you still love your work that much?

“When I started with Linamar 20 years ago the company had a total of about 8-10 Induction hardening systems. The incredible growth of the company meant that we were hard pressed to add enough heat treating capacity which meant I put in a lot of hours. Since then I have slowed down to 60-65 giyrs oer week but really what it comes down to is I like what I am doing.”

Last but not least care to make any predictions about where the automotive heat treat industry will be in 10 years? 3 D printing? Single part processing? Everything moved to Mexico?

“I believe we are seeing a real resurgence of manufacturing in the US and less imports coming from China. There is a lot of talk about electric cars and how it will change heat treating because there are so few drive train parts which need to be heat treated but I personally don’t expect to see any real changes for 10 years.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Peter Sherwin / Eurotherm

Peter you have had a rather interesting work career which includes working on three continents if memory serves me correctly-could you give us a bit of background?

“Thanks Gord, just before we start, quick legal statement, these are my personal comments and not necessarily endorsed by Eurotherm. Ok, with that said, yes, I have been lucky enough to live and work in a variety of places around the world; I started my career in the UK and ran Heat Treat operations for both Captive and Commercial Heat Treaters, I then worked at in India for nearly a couple of years before finally moving to Colorado, US 8 years ago.”

So how did you end up with Eurotherm and what are your job responsibilities?

“I have a colleague to thank for joining Eurotherm – Kevin Robinson (our Heat Treat Business Manager in the UK). Kevin knew I was commuting between India and the US because of work and family. He mentioned a job opportunity for Eurotherm in Heat Treat in the US and I jumped at the chance to be based out of one place. That was nearly 8 years ago. Since then I have had a few roles in Eurotherm; I moved out of the initial Heat Treat role to cover Marketing for the US team and then moved into a Global marketing role for the entire Eurotherm business. Very recently (literally a few weeks ago) I moved into my current role, I am back with a Heat Treat focus and leading business development activities worldwide.”

Does this involve a lot of travelling?

“Yes, I now travel about 50% of the time and split my time between the US, Europe and Asia.”

Please tell us what Eurotherm has to offer to the heat treating market.

“Historically we have provided Power, Furnace Control and Data Acquisition products and focused on providing solutions to address Aerospace and Automotive Heat Treat standards/regulations.”

How do you sell your products into the industry-through reps? Direct Sales People? Distributors?

“We have a mix of all and it really depends on the size of the region. For example, in Europe we have more of a direct sales team in certain key countries because of the manageable country size. In the US we have Territory Managers who work with Partners who are local to our customers – we have well over 100 partners in the US.”

Without even thinking about it I can name at least six companies whose controls can be found in the heat treating industry-do you feel that it has become an overcrowded market?

“Competition fuels innovation and that’s good for the end customer . I think the crowd becomes smaller when you look at the companies that are committed to ongoing innovation – we always strive to invest at least 5% of our revenues back into R&D and this gives us a healthy product roadmap.”

I’m dating myself but I can remember the days of the Barber Colman AC controller designed to control the carbon level in a furnace. If I remember correctly the exact same instrument was sold for over 25 years without any changes. Now of course instruments can become obsolete in just 2 or 3 years which is a bone of contention with many users. How do you respond to criticism that instrumentation changes too quickly?

“Great question Gord! The Heat Treating Industry is pretty conservative as a whole, and demands support for controls that match the life of furnaces (which can be 25 years+). We tend to have some of the longest life products within the Industry and don’t take decisions lightly when products need to go into what we term an obsolescence (or end of life) program. Typically these decisions are forced because of electronic components in the supply chain are no longer available or a requirement to meet the ever increasing environmental regulations on electronic component usage and disposal. A newer trend is the ability to enhance instruments already in the field rather than have the short lifetimes you mentioned – we demonstrated this when we launched the nanodac controller/recorder nearly 5 years ago and continued to roll out new features and functions over a 2 year time period.”

What is your path to a new design of controller or a new product? Do you and your team take an existing product and figure out how to improve it? Or do you have a mandate to come up with new products or systems on a regular basis?

“We are constantly gathering customer feedback on our products and applications in order for us to develop new innovations. We also have input from our Parent group (Schneider Electric) with all the technology developments they bring to the Industrial market. At Eurotherm we have an open idea forum where anyone in the company can create an idea, and this then goes through a variety of stage gates before it’s considered for inclusion in the ultimate product roadmap. This is a very comprehensive process and has created products like the innovative nanodac (1/4DIN recorder/controller), the new E+PLC platform and our newest offer due to launch in May – Eurotherm Online Services (EOS) – this brand new offer provides a digital Compliance/Calibration platform as well as an ECat Calibration tablet app.”

Most people in this industry recognize that it is not a glamor business and consequently it is very hard to find experienced heat treaters. This has lead to a number of companies trying to automate the heat treat process as much as possible so unskilled labor can be used. To what extent does Eurotherm plan around this?

“We continue to develop full automation solutions (not just instruments, but full panels and enterprise solutions) as well as now offering support to operators through what we term ‘Augmented Operator’ solutions. Examples of this include Augmented reality apps for use in Maintenance troubleshooting – this technology is currently in its infancy but soon will be commonplace in industrial sites aiding operators and maintenance technicians troubleshoot problems quickly through leveraging mobile technology solutions.”

Do you see much demand for “wireless” installations? In other words getting away from running conduits?

“We believe in control and data capture at source (as close to the operation as possible) – this provides a better control situation and reduces the potential loss of data. We also have ‘store-and-forward’ technology that can electronically report this information up-to SCADA type solutions either via wires or wireless (a break in Wi-Fi communications will buffer the information at the machine controller/data logger until the communication is restored in order to protect from any data loss). There are also some very interesting applications for wireless thermocouples – this is a topic I will save for our next interview.”

Whats the next logical step in the evolution of furnace instrumentation?

“Similar to the smartphone principle of getting a device to do more than one thing (a smartphone is a phone, camera, personal organizer etc.) newer instruments have multiple uses. For example new control platforms incorporate Programmable Logic Control (PLC), Precision Control, Data Logging and Visualization all in a single device (the E+PLC100 is an example). The ability to also take algorithms designed in the classroom and port into hardware control systems is now much easier than ever before – certainly advanced algorithms will help facilitate better control in Heat Treatment over the next few years.”

What technologies really excite you these days? Anything on the horizon that will truly change the industry?

“I spent quite a bit of time with the Schneider Electric IIoT team last year (IIoT – Industrial Internet of Things). This truly is a fascinating area and this type of technology is set to have a real impact on the Heat Treat Industry over the next 5 years. There is a trend to capture more and more data today but we don’t generally have the time to really analyze this data to give us actionable insights. A term you will start to hear in Heat Treatment in the coming months will be Machine Learning to aid Predictive Maintenance – the outcome of this technology will be to reduce the time and cost of expensive equipment downtime.”

Can you share with us any new products which we can expect to see from Eurotherm?

“Yes, we are launching EOS – Eurotherm Online Services – at the end of May along with the ECat digital calibration app.”

Thanks for your time Peter.

“Many thanks Gord, I appreciate you taking time to ask these important questions. Fueled by technology, the next 5-10 years are going to transform the way we all look at and think about Heat Treat operations – a very exciting time! I look forward to catching up with you at various events around the world.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Peter Schweighofer, Cieffe International AG

Peter your route to the heat-treating industry has not been as direct as many. Could you tell us how you ended up here?

“Absolutely, it is more the result of many accidental factors. I joined Accu Holding AG, the former owner and mother company of Cieffe, as M&A manager and Head of Finance back in April 2014 just before the intended acquisition and financial integration of the whole Cieffe Group started. My first project therefore was to perform a due diligence of the acquisition target including a strategic analysis of the end markets with the corresponding economic potential. This gave me a broad and enhanced understanding of the major industry drivers, the structure of the end markets, the players as well as the cyclicality of order partners from different customers. Unfortunately, Accu got into serious financial troubles and was forced to divest all relevant assets. Supported by the two remaining major shareholders, we decided to buy out Cieffe Group from the assets in liquidation and to launch a radical and far-reaching restructuring program. Consequently, I took over this challenging responsibility to lead this project as CEO of the new holding company Cieffe International AG in Zug (Switzerland).”

Please tell us what you can about Cieffe, the size of the company, markets served, the types of furnaces you offer, anything that you feel comfortable sharing.

“After downsizing the company in non-core segments and focusing on the core business we currently employ slightly over 100 people in Italy and a few selective sales agents in important strategic markets. Although our product portfolio offers a full range of products, from chamber furnaces to nitriding lines, we are currently unable to compete on a global basis in every segment. Therefore, we focus on our existing strong customer basis within Europe and to grow our platform through their global expansion. This approach requires a clear focus on innovations and technological developments to secure the competitive advantage for our customer and/or the OEM. The most recent example is the political development regarding electrical cars. This requires us to find efficient commercial solutions for processing smaller parts and/ or combining different materials at various temperatures.”

I don’t want to dwell on this but there were some issues in 2016 having to do with the ownership of the company. Could you address these issues?

“You are referring to the bankruptcy of the previous owner Accu Holding. Unfortunately, the former CEO Marco Marchetti and majority shareholder had been remanded in custody for misappropriate use of funds and falsification of documents on April 11th, 2016. The subsequent investigation revealed multiple and severely punishable criminal offences. This resulted not only into the liquidation of Accu but also triggered massive financial distress in all other companies involving M. Marchetti as owner or executive. To protect us from regressive actions we had to financially restructure Cieffe, to put the companies into liquidation and to restore trust towards our customers by transferring all operating activities into a new structure. Therefore, we incorporated Cieffe Thermal Systems S.R.L.  as rescue company in October 2016. Since the 1st of April 2017 we are fully operational and independent.”

Are you comfortable that any past problems are just that, past problems?

“The problems of this company were not based on the technology issues, sluggish customer demand or missing human resources but rather a result of disastrous cash flow planning and misallocation of funds. As my professional background perfectly matches the existing problem areas, strengths of the core competences of the new Cieffe are substantially improved. Key is, to focus on the client, restore confidence and not loose track of the market development or innovation cycles.”

What are your impressions of the heat-treating industry so far? Same as other industries you have been involved with just different products or have you seen more fundamental differences?

“It depends from which part of the value chain of the heat treatment industry you are talking about. The automotive and aerospace OEMs have well understood that there will be some dramatic changes within the next 10-15 years and that heat treatment will play a key role in addressing future needs. This behaviour is well known and understood and mirrors a modern approach of mid- to long-term strategic planning.

On the other hand, the heat treatment industry as such is a very fragmented sector, which mainly consists of smaller sized family owned companies. A lot of them are struggling to finance new investments and push the life cycle of there installed asset base to its limit. Many of these lines are 20 years and older and do not fulfil today’s ecological criteria’s or efficiency requirements. Furthermore, they struggle to find a successor as their descendants have only limited interest in running such a business based on these premises.

The products we are selling belong to the capital goods sector and is it basic nature very similar across all industries. Obviously, we have some specific value drivers, which differentiate the heat treatment equipment from other products but still it remains a project business.”

Over the years I have seen many examples of Cieffe’s work including batch IQ furnaces, vacuum furnaces, continuous furnaces even vacuum carburizing units. Would you say that the company has a product it specializes in or do you feel you have the experience to offer most types of thermal processing equipment?

“Thanks to the trust of various customers we have build a significant knowledge in designing, producing and installing big heat treatment lines (chamber-, belt– , roller furnaces, etc.) globally in various fields of application. This not only gives us a competitive advantage but also allows us to rely on a broad database of different challenges and solutions, especially from projects realized in emerging markets. On the other hand, we have lost some ground in vacuum furnaces where we are currently not competitive in economical terms. It is yet to see within the next twelve months where we will set our key targets.”

Recognizing that you are based in Italy what geographic areas do you concentrate on?

“We will focus on our existing customer base within western and eastern Europe but with a global approach. This means that we would design a project for our French customer in Mexico or for our German client in China. Production will be concentrated in Italy as we have a well established and reliable supply chain within 150km. However, the dispersion of our current client basis will require us to increase local physical presence in the southern part of Germany within the coming year. Also attracting new talents and key hires will play a key role in this topic.”

Last year we did a ranking of the largest European furnace builders and Cieffe was very respectable at #6, however since that time the rankings have changed slightly due to acquisitions. The result is that some of the larger players are growing at a very substantial rate-does this pose a problem for your company, namely that your resources are more restricted than those of some of the really large players?

“I am glad we still rank somewhere! The focus of 2016 was to rescue Cieffe Group and the key challenge of 2017 was to re-store and re-launch Cieffe as a manufacturer for heat treatment plants and equipment. Analyzing the performance of our competitors requires to draw a clear line between organic and absolute growth, otherwise we are comparing apples and oranges.  The growth of Aichelin for example, is due to an acquisition in the US and predominantly a strategic move to have a meaningful footprint in this market. This is fine for them but not something we would consider now.  Size in terms of turnover is certainly not the only criteria which makes-up and defines a successful company. Nevertheless, we aim to grow our company sustainable up to manageable level within the next three to five years with the clear aspiration to become a dominant top three player within the European market.”

I just asked you about European furnace builders but what about Asian furnace builders? There are several very large ones but to date they have concentrated mainly on the Asian market. Are you seeing any signs that this is changing?

“Asia is a market on its own and we currently have no interest engaging Cieffe in such a price-war driven geographical area. However, as already stated, we are very keen to support our customers for heat treatment lines and equipment for their Asian subsidiaries. On the other hand, I doubt that European customers would shift their orders to an Asian manufacturer even if they would have a production facility in Europe. This does not mean that we are not following or ignoring strategic moves from Asian furnace builders.”

I am going to ask you to be brutally honest on this question. What do you see as the strong points and weak points of the Cieffe organization? I have a high opinion of the company but I have yet to see any company that was perfect on everything.

“We have lost some trust from our customers due to bad execution pre-dominantly causing delays in production start. Furthermore, during the reorganization process, we have partially lost confidence from our employees regarding the whole restructuring, which resulted in loss of human capital. Some competitors used this situation to distribute falsehoods to our customers and to spread rumors about bankruptcy, failing production, etc., irreverent in a very unprofessional way.

From my point of view the whole picture has changed since the 1st of April 2017 when Cieffe Thermal Systems took over the operational activities and full control. One of the key topics within the next years will be to transfer the know-how from the founders’ generation to the new generation.

The good thing about this is that we have a unique chance to restart this company on a clean basis. We have been very fortunate that two of our strategic customers committed to support us in relaunching Cieffe by placing some sizable orders of larger heat treatment lines. And I certainly do not forget to mention our suppliers, which reach out to us even in times of high uncertainty as well as all employees that remained with us and believed in the future of a restructured Cieffe. 

We started to promote our new concept – Italian passion for technology and Swiss reliability in execution – and have received very positive feedback from our clients.  New hires in Italy helped to increase motivation and restore trust with existing employees. Fortunately, current market conditions are still very favourable and this is further reflected in our very promising order book. However, it is very important to understand that we have prepared the new Cieffe not for 100-meter-sprints but for a marathon. Therefore, we tend to act thoughtful and not like a gunslinger.”

On a personal note what do you see for Peter Schweighofer down the road? Can you see yourself travelling the world promoting the company? More of an administrative role? Can you picture yourself getting old and grey in the industry?

“My motivation is to successfully relaunch this company and to execute on the expansion steps within the coming years. I am fully committed and currently spend a lot of time on-site in an executive operational position. This will not change in the near future.

However, to get this company to the next level we need to change the way we do business, with whom we partner our research and development activities and in which fields of activity we want to be successful in the mid- to long-term. This will be a key strategic task and will automatically shift my centre of gravity towards a broader oriented business development role within the next twelve months. 

Nevertheless, I will always act as first ambassador for Cieffe to our customers, not only to reflect my passion for this company but also to pay respect to all our employees, which have been tremendously supportive also during very unpleasant times.”

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here