Jean Francois Cloutier

CEO of Nitrex


Jean Francois I and many others in the industry have been very curious about your acquisition of vacuum furnace builder G-M Enterprises a couple of months back, how it came about and what these means going forward. However, before we get into that perhaps I could ask you a couple of general questions.

First off what is your background and how did you end up in the position you are now in?

“Let me begin by thanking you Gord for the opportunity to talk about Nitrex with your readers. I graduated from Law school at the University of Montreal and hold a Master’s in Business Administration (MBA) from the University of Ottawa in Canada. I have over 20 years experience in the industrial market, in managerial positions of multinational manufacturing companies. I have lived in various countries so the global aspect of the Nitrex business was and still is of interest to me.

I joined Nitrex as CEO at a transformational time in the company’s history, where our founder Michel Korwin had retired from the day–to–day activities of managing the business but was willing to keep contributing and working together with me on the business strategy. These are truly exciting times at Nitrex and its affiliated companies. Our shareholders and board members, notably our majority shareholder Novacap, a leading private equity firm in Canada, are very supportive of our growth strategy, which led to acquiring G-M Enterprises earlier this year.”

Nitrex is a very well-known name in the global heat treatment industry, however having said that perhaps you could tell us something about the company, the history and what you have to offer?

“Monty readers know Nitrex for gas nitriding in the heat-treating industry. Nitrex is a leader in that field, but we are more than that. Nitrex was born by being innovative in gas nitriding control, which allowed the firm to reach unequaled repeatable quality, supported by over 4000 formulas or recipes and over 18,000 laboratory tests results. This library of knowledge is constantly evolving, which allows us to provide the highest quality while significantly reducing the development time for our customers.

However, what really makes the difference is our people. With the deep knowledge I just referred to, our experts in heat treating, metallurgy and controls are able to go way beyond selling a product: they provide technical expertise to our customers, solving complex problems. That is one of the reasons our customers see us as a solutions provider. The acquisition of various companies that operate today as United Process Controls (UPC) and now G-M Enterprises has enhanced our portfolio and expertise, reinforcing the strategy of being a solutions provider.

Our science and technology will shape the future of heat treating. And this is where I come in: charting a path for the future of Nitrex and setting sights on global expansion.”

What is the relationship between Nitrex and UPC (United Process Controls)?

“The relationship between Nitrex and UPC is highly recognized in the heat treat community. Presently, NTS (the abbreviation for Nitrex Turnkey Systems), and UPC (controls and aftermarket) are standalone divisions of the same company.

That said, both divisions along with our worldwide network of commercial heat-treating centers (referred to as HTS) are an excellent strategic fit – serving the same industries and embracing a vertically integrated business platform. They share a common mission to provide customers with state-of-the-art, sustainable heat-treating processes that exceed industry regulations and quality standards, as well as to increase process and equipment efficiency.

UPC was formed through the acquisition of 5 companies (Atmosphere Engineering, Furnace Control, Marathon Monitors, Process-Electronic, and Waukee Engineering). Over the course of several years, UPC become one of the largest specialized controls company with a competitive advantage both in scale and product offerings.”

January 9th 2020 it was announced that Nitrex had purchased vacuum furnace builder G-M Enterprises of California. First question-when did you enter discussions with Mr. Suresh Jhawar the former President of G-M Enterprises?

“The addition of G-M Enterprises marks a major milestone for Nitrex, on its path to diversifying its NTS division’s portfolio. Discussions with Mr. Jhawar started in the fall of 2019, which went relatively smoothly, and the deal was signed beginning of January this year. The entrepreneurial mindset and culture combined with the strong customer focus within the company are consistent with the Nitrex values.

The acquisition represents a great fit with Nitrex, as both share the same goal of providing sustainable technologies that improve customer workflow and efficiency while maximizing the life span and quality of engineered parts and components.”

What can you tell us about G-M, the products, the size and the market segments they service?

“For the past 30 years, G-M has earned the reputation as a leading supplier of vacuum heat-treating systems in the USA. The potential applications for G-M vacuum furnaces are endless and systems are currently in use by customers in the aerospace, defense, power generation, energy, MIM sintering, additive manufacturing, and commercial heat-treating industries. The addition of G-M Enterprises to the Nitrex family represents a great complement for us and will provide G-M the opportunity to grow internationally through the Nitrex global sales network.”

Now this is the question I have been dying to ask-why? Nitrex offers nitriding solutions, UPC offers furnace controls, what is the fit here?

“As I mentioned previously, the companies are a good strategic fit and our complementary portfolios of trusted brands set us apart from other industry peers. The vertical integration allows both to leverage industry-leading equipment, capabilities and know-how. Through this dynamic and symbiotic partnership, UPC’s focus reinforces Nitrex’s turnkey systems platform with leading edge control technologies; and in return, as new control technologies are developed by UPC, these are incorporated and tested at Nitrex’s commercial service centers, which helps to reinforce UPC’s reputation. As a result, we add value to our customers operations by solving their process problems, which allows our customers to succeed in the markets they serve.”

Have you made any changes at the company? Either management, product mix or marketing plans?

“When I joined Nitrex, my first priority was to understand the business and the organization. Then, we decided to bring on a management team of experienced leaders in both large OEM and small/medium corporations who share the same entrepreneur mindset and servant leadership values. Their experiences are great assets supporting our growth strategy to become a global leader in heat treating solutions. The new structure in place allows the management team to work as a united entity and at the same time promote the particularities of each division.

I am also very pleased that Mr. Michel Korwin, founder of Nitrex, and Mr. Chris Morawski are still active in the company as advisers on strategic topics. Their experience, combined with some new comers to Nitrex, offers a well balanced management team. As an example, just to name a few, Mr. Olivier Caurette, an ex-executive from Bombardier, joined us as the UPC President; Eric Jossart is now UPC Vice President Global Sales; Pat Torok, Head of Product Management; Jason Orosz, President Heat-Treating Services; Michel Frison, Vice-President Global Sales, NTS Michael Winter, Vice President of Engineering and R&D; Paul Oleszkiewicz, Chief Strategist & Chief Technology Officer and Mr. Iwo Korwin, the NTS division President.

In diversifying, we have also developed a compatible product mix that works for our consolidated global sales network, which now distributes and supports all product lines.”

Jean Francois are you able to share with us the future direction of G-M Enterprises?

“G–M has an outstanding growth opportunity, and with the integration of our assets and workforce, the company is poised to enhance its products and services and its capacity to serve international markets and customers, particularly in Europe and Asia. We’re also scaling up G-M’s ability to deliver even more value to the additive manufacturing industry. Planned investments in R&D and the application of AI technology will enable us to develop new innovative solutions that support intelligent workloads and improve process efficiency and application performance.”

One final question-what can we expect to see from Nitrex, G-M Enterprises and Novacap in the future?

“Right now, we are completing the integration of G-M including all assets, employees and systems to the organization structure, while teaming G-M engineers and sales people with Nitrex counterparts to get them onboard, train and leverage expertise and talent. At the same time, we are actively pursuing other acquisitions that fit nicely into our strategic growth plans and which will broaden our capabilities and strengthen our competitive advantage.”


Dr. Klaus Löser 

ALD, Senior Vice President Heat Treatment


We are very pleased to be able to offer you this interview with Dr. Klaus Löser, Senior Vice President, Heat Treatment, ALD. Dr.  Löser talks about the company, future plans and changes within the industry.

Klaus, I really appreciate your time. We have known each other for many years, so having the opportunity to interview you is something I have been looking forward to. To begin, let’s start with your background. What is your doctorate in and how did you end up in the heat treating industry?

“Hi Gord, nice talking to you. I completed my university education at the Technical University of Darmstadt in Germany. After studying general mechanical engineering, I completed my doctorate at the Institute of Materials Science in Darmstadt. There I studied long-term component properties under high temperature stress, especially components for use in stationary gas and steam turbines, but also for applications in aviation. Already at that time I was concerned with the influence of heat treatment on the properties of components, especially nickel-based alloys. So it was obvious to apply the knowledge and findings gained in this field in my professional life.”

What is your role in the company?

“I gained my first professional experience as a development and process engineer in the industrial furnace division at Degussa AG, one of the predecessors of ALD Vacuum Technologies. After positions in sales in North America and Mexico I became head of research and development. Presently I am a senior vice president, in charge of the heat treatment division of ALD. In addition, I was head of the scientific advisory board of the Research Association for Industrial Furnaces Engineering for many years and actually I am serving as a member of the board of directors of the German heat treating association AWT.”

ALD is a very interesting company. One way it differs from many others in this industry is that you build both Thermal Processing Equipment and you also offer commercial heat treating. Could you give us some details about the company both on the equipment side and the heat treating services side?

“When we developed and introduced low-pressure carburizing and high-pressure gas quenching for high-volume applications in automotive industry in the 1990s, many customers were uncertain in dealing with this technology. The transition from atmosphere heat treatment with oil quench to vacuum technology with gas quench was a paradigm shift for them. This gave rise to the idea of giving these customers the opportunity to participate in the advantages of this technology in the form of a service, a real win-win situation for our customers and us. On the one hand they benefit from the longstanding heat treatment know-how of ALD and can therefore use the advantages of the new heat treatment technology. On the other hand they don´t have to pay the financial and technical hurdles that have to be overcome with the introduction of a new technology in their own plant. At the same time, our plant engineering and construction division also benefit from the service companies in that production experience and ideas for optimization flow back directly to our process and plant development.”

Klaus recently you made some changes in the structure of the company in North America, could you share with us what form this took?

“As part of a strategic realignment of our worldwide activities, we decided last year to combine our previously separate heat treatment and metallurgy activities and locations for the North American market at the East Windsor site in Connecticut. From there ALD Vacuum Technologies North America is responsible for over 100 installations of mission critical equipment in advanced heat treatment technologies, superalloy materials companies and special technologies in partnership with top OEM’s in aerospace and automotive. Since the merger of these companies in 2019 ALD North America has continued to expand their capabilities in customer support services and technical sales. They have increased the number of field service engineers and just recently our new sales & application engineer Andrew Chan joined our team to support our heat treat activities.”

Your heat treatment business, ALD TT (Thermal Treatment) is very unique in that it is so focused. What I mean by that is, most commercial heat treaters offer numerous different processes. However, that is not the case with ALD Thermal Treatment. Could you please elaborate why?

“This historically results from the idea to offer our customers a brand-new technology where a lot of process knowledge is available in ALD. Case-hardening is also a process that is mainly used in large series, so the automotive and supplier industry was one of our first customers. Our speciality is certainly the improvement of distortion control with tailored gas quenching processes. Meanwhile our service plants have expanded their range of processes, so besides case hardening and neutral hardening, we also offer brazing and nitriding technologies in our two North American facilities. We are continuously looking into complementary offerings in the future, such as low-pressure carburizing or neutral hardening combined with oil quenching.”

Recently you issued a press release about a new ALD TT location in China. Will this be similar to your facilities in Germany, the US, and Mexico?

“The short answer is: yes. The size will be similar to our facility in Germany, service offerings will be similar to our existing plants and be adjusted flexibly to local market demands.”

Are there any upcoming changes at ALD TT that you can tell us about?

“ALD TT Port Huron has already started the transition process from a contract heat treater for one pilot customer to a multi customer service provider. This process is ongoing and will continue for the foreseeable timeframe.”

I had the opportunity to visit your headquarters in Germany a few years back. However since that time I understand you have embarked on a major expansion of the building. I would be interested in knowing what changes have been made.

“Since our move to a new location in 2016, the company has grown rapidly and we have built into a new warehouse. Further, just a few weeks ago, a new building was inaugurated where we are concentrating our customer service, spare parts activities, and all R&D departments including automation and Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) applications. Besides offices, the new building includes a new technical center which will host leading edge heat treatment and metallurgy furnaces, from lab-scale until production size including a SyncroTherm-system and new ModulTherm-line. This will allow us to further intensify our future R&D activities and perform basic trials and investigations for and with our customers.”

Which future trends and market demands do you identify with current projects and orders?

“Currently we still see a trend towards further flexibility in heat treatment plants, mainly with regard to the quenching processes, e.g. hybrid systems offering gas and oil quench. In times of increasing uncertainties in the heat treatment market regarding future production figures, the trend is towards modular and flexible systems, such as our ModulTherm plant, whose throughput can be adapted to current production requirements in a timely manner.

Sustainable and ecological heat treatment is very much in vogue. The increasing share of renewable energy in the energy mix means that the proportion of electrically heated furnaces is rising. In the age of digitalization, all systems must be equipped for IIoT today, at least with the necessary interfaces, so that they can communicate with the preceding and subsequent processing machines, among others.

So-called small batch production in systems such as SyncroTherm are increasing in demand where small batch sizes of components can be produced flexibly, and where there are particularly high demands on component quality, in particular regarding distortion control. In all cases our customers demand that the furnace manufacturer also supplies the corresponding automation.

One major focus of our R&D activities is low pressure carbonitriding (LPCN) where we focus on the high contents of control on retained austenite which will lead to higher pitting fatigue, if we trust recent publications from universities.

In addition, we have some process- and equipment- innovations in our pocket, which will be released in 2020 and 2021. So this is something we look forward to!”

With all due respect Klaus, you and I have both been in this industry for many years and have seen a lot of changes, especially when it comes to how business is conducted. How has e-mobility changed how ALD operates/functions?

“For the past 25 years, ALD has developed heat treatment technologies for serial production in automotive applications. This industry is the main contributor to ALD’s turnover in the heat treatment sector, especially for case hardening of transmission components. First of all electrically driven vehicles use single or two-stage transmissions with significantly fewer toothed components, reducing the necessary amount of heat treatment capacity. But on the other hand, we also see this as a great opportunity for our technology. Higher demands are placed on the new transmission components, especially higher strength, but also higher precision in gear dimensions in order to avoid noise and vibration. Here we see ourselves very well positioned with vacuum technology and gas quenching, especially with regard to minimizing distortion. If we put the current Corona crisis to the side for a moment, then we see for the short-/mid-term future even more need for carburizing if we think about hybrid drivetrains, where even more gears are needed per gearbox.

Last but not least in the future, there will be even greater demand for flexible, modular plant systems that can be integrated into production. The ever-increasing demands for environmentally friendly and low-emission heat treatment make up the rest.”

The Corona– virus has turned the world on its head, how has this changed how ALD does business?

“Absolutely. The Corona crisis and the enforced measures mean that we have to make massive changes to our working methods. Many of us are working from home and conferences are held via web-ex. Unfortunately, we are forced to restrict our travel activities which of course limits us as a company with a particularly high export share. Nevertheless, we try to continue to look after our customers well within the scope of our possibilities.”

Now this is an unfair question but where do you see ALD and the heat treatment industry in general being 1 year from now?

“Currently facing a situation where we don´t know what will happen tomorrow, it is hard to forecast the business in a year from now. As an optimist, I predict it as follows: The Corona crisis has subsided worldwide to a level that is medically manageable and a vaccine has been developed. The economy, including the heat treat industry, is in the process of recovering from the low and is benefiting from catch-up effects from the year. The economy has learned its lessons from the crisis and is developing more crisis-proof supply chains. Some forms of work that were necessarily introduced during the crisis, such as homeoffice and web–conferencing, will find their way into our normal working lives because they have proven their worth. Finally, I hope to meet you at a heat treatment event somewhere in the world, which can then take place regularly again.

Until then, I wish you and your family and all our customers in North America all the best and every success in overcoming the Corona crisis. “Stay well!“

Klaus, I appreciate your time. Sincerely, Gord

First up, Pat, I appreciate you taking the time to speak with us. I always like to start with some background information. Last time we spoke, you told us about the foundation you earned while learning the trade and going back to graduate school. You started at Ipsen in the mid-90s, and then transitioned into commercial heat treating and brazing as a business owner for 15 years, and then returned to Ipsen in 2015...

Going from a position where you were buying furnaces to one where you are selling furnaces must have made for a very interesting experience. Did it change your perception of industry suppliers and the challenges they face?

“Having experience in both sides of the business has been very helpful Gord. I find myself using both perspectives throughout the day.

Furnace builders are experts in designing, building, and servicing the equipment. Heat treaters, whether captive or commercial, are experts at operating the furnaces. I have heard others explain the difference as “one designs and builds the race car, the other is the race car driver.”

I have enjoyed both sides of the business, and each has its own unique set of challenges.”

What have some of those life and career changes taught you as you developed into your present role as CEO of quite possibly the largest furnace builder in North America?

“One thing I’ve learned is that someone in this industry – like most industries – needs to take responsibility for their own career. A company should certainly provide advancement opportunities for their employees, but it is up to each of us to decide what we want to do and then put in the work and sacrifice necessary to achieve our goals. If we don’t know what we want to do in our careers how should the companies we work for be expected to know?

I am fortunate to have worked at great companies along the way that held up their end of the bargain and I feel the heat-treating industry has no shortage of opportunities for people willing to put in the hard work.”

Please tell us about Ipsen as a global supplier and where Ipsen USA fits in. What are the main markets for your furnaces?

“Ipsen is one of the few truly global manufacturers of vacuum and atmosphere heat treating furnaces. We have manufacturing facilities in the U.S., Germany, India, China and Japan.

Ipsen USA is the largest of the Ipsen Group in terms of sales, and the largest market we serve is aerospace & defense – whether directly, or indirectly through commercial heat treaters.”

Let’s focus on your products now. Why is so much of your business based on aftermarket parts and services?

“Ipsen USA has an installed base of about 2,500 units, and globally the installed base is over 10,000. That alone represents a very large aftermarket opportunity, but in addition we often provide aftermarket parts and services for equipment built by other suppliers. Our aftermarket products and services have grown to almost 50% of Ipsen USA’s annual revenue.”

All of the industries you serve involve critical components, but none more so than aerospace & defense with their Nadcap requirements. How do you address the standards necessary for the aerospace industry?

“We work to stay ahead of the requirements coming down the pike by listening to customers, attending periodic technical meetings such as AMEC, and participating in industry associations such as MTI.”

I have seen a number of Ipsen press releases and news items talking about your increased field presence in the US recently. My first thought is that this is very commendable, and my second thought is that Ipsen is bucking the trend as many companies are going the opposite direction-reducing field presence as a way to control costs. What is the driver behind this? Has it been successful?

“Our Field Service Engineers have a high ‘paid service utilization rate’, which is to say they are busy generating significant revenue. I have never considered reducing FSE headcount as a cost cutting measure. On the contrary, I want to hire as many experienced Field Service Engineers as I can find.”

Speaking of increasing your field presence, I have to ask you about people. Many in the industry moan and groan about a lack of experience. How do we change that? I am not talking about “pie in the sky” ideas to get more people in heat-treating in 20 years…how do we get more skilled people in the industry in 2022?

“You will have more experienced people in 2022 by first retaining the staff you have then investing aggressively in the development of newcomers. We have developed the Ipsen Academy training program (sessions held in 2019 and 2020) to fast-track new Field Service Engineers who have little or no experience in our industry. The year-long Academy represents a significant investment including two full-time trainers and is already proving itself a success. We have held similar Academy sessions for mechanical, electrical, and software engineers in the past as well.”

What do you see as the next logical step in the evolution of vacuum furnace design? Do you see any requirements that would encourage you to design furnaces with substantially higher quenching pressures? Is there much demand for larger size furnaces? Higher temperatures?

“We will always serve both the “standard” and “special” markets. I think it is most logical to let the customer guide our product development efforts. If a customer has a need that aligns with our technology and capabilities, we will take it on (no matter the size, temperature, performance, etc.) as long as it makes financial sense to do so. Many times these “one of a kind specials” actually end up as multiple repeat orders for us in future years.”

Are there any new products Ipsen will be bringing to the market in the near–to–medium future, which you could tell us about or even hint at?

“As mentioned above, we are continuously driven to innovate by our customers and enjoy working on the challenges they present to us on a daily basis. We look forward to sharing press releases on these exciting and interesting projects with you and your readership when able to do so.”

Pat, I thank you for your time today.

Patrick McKenna Biography: Patrick McKenna is President and CEO of Ipsen USA, a global manufacturer of thermal processing equipment for the aerospace & defense, automotive, energy, and medical industries. Having originally worked at Ipsen USA in the mid-1990’s, Patrick returned to an Executive role in 2015 as Vice President of Sales and subsequently promoted to President and CEO in 2017. Prior to joining the Ipsen Executive Team, McKenna most recently served as Co-Founder and Vice President of Nevada Heat Treating and California Brazing (acquired by Trive Capital Partners in 2018). McKenna served on the Metal Treating Institute Board of Trustees for 10 years, holding various board positions, including President in 2016. McKenna has received several awards from MTI, including the President’s Award (2014) and the Heat Treater of the Year/Master Craftsman award (2011). McKenna holds a bachelor’s degree in mechanical engineering from the University of Illinois at Chicago and a master’s degree in manufacturing engineering from Northwestern University, where he still volunteers in the Northwestern Mentorship Program.

We are very pleased to have an interview with Mr. Jeff McLaughlin, founder and President of McLaughlin Furnace Group of Avilla, Indiana, USA. What makes this interview particularly interesting is that we interviewed Jeff back in 2018, so it is interesting to see what has changed.

Jeff we always like to start off each of our interviews with a bit of background. How did you get started in the heat-treating industry?

“I Graduated Hobart Welding School in 1992. I started at Advanced Thermal Technologies Inc. (ATTI) in 1993 as a maintenance man/welder. Working my way up the ladder, I became a maintenance manager/ purchasing manager.  Dean and Dave VanderKaay, the owners, were two great mentors to me over the course of my career.  They taught me the hands-on operation and maintenance of a heat treat company. ATTI was sold to a company known as MP Steel and eventually became Advantage Thermal Services.

Over the course of my career I met a lot of good people that told me I was way more than a heat treat maintenance guy. Well I guess them guys were right, huh! To name a few of them, Randy Simmons of RMA, and John Hansen of Met-Pro, who you know. I thought to myself, if all these guys, with years of experience, are telling me this, then what do I have to lose? In April of 2007, I formed McLaughlin Services LLC with $10,000 dollars. I primarily grew my company on nights, weekends, vacation days, holidays, etc., -whatever it took.  Moving forward to April 2010, I left ATS to focus on McLaughlin Services LLC full time. My experience as an in-house maintenance manager is reflected today in the core principles of McLaughlin Service, LLC. Timely service when production is down and reliability and ease of maintenance on new equipment are a few examples. All the hard work I’ve put in the heat treat industry sure has paid off!”

McLaughlin Furnace Group. When did you start the company? When did Vesco become part of the group? To sum up please tell us all about the company, background and what products you offer.

“McLaughlin Services was founded in 2007 as a service company. Over the course of the next few years, McLaughlin Services began to rebuild heat treating equipment and continually grow its customer base across the United States. In short time, McLaughlin Services began to build new equipment. In 2017 McLaughlin Services purchased Vacuum Engineering Services Company (Vesco) in East Windsor, Connecticut. Vesco has been around since 1983 servicing the vacuum processing industries including rebuilding vacuum pumps, vacuum furnaces, and hot zones. It has been a great addition to the company, enabling McLaughlin to provide a more complete approach to our customers with abilities ranging from equipment manufacturing to field service. In 2018, with the addition of Vesco, and McLaughlin becoming more of a recognized OEM in the industry, we formed McLaughlin Furnace Group. McLaughlin Furnace Group is able to offer both new and rebuilt atmosphere and vacuum heat treat equipment as well as complete service of heat treat facilities across the world.”

You’ve shared with us that you are involved with vacuum heat treating, that you have a growing installed base of car bottom furnaces, endothermic generators and that you are just finishing installation of a pusher furnace (more on this later)-where do you see future growth at McLaughlin Furnace Group coming from? More of the same or are you planning on adding other products such as nitriders or batch IQ furnaces?

“McLaughlin Furnace Group is planning to continue increasing its field service capabilities, aftermarket parts support, and new equipment offerings. We are continuing to expand all of our product lines including the new major additions of horizontal nitriding furnaces and a complete batch IQ line. McLaughlin Furnace Group will be releasing it’s Tru-Carb batch IQ line to production in the first quarter. The Tru-Carb is very exciting for us as we continue to release more technologically advanced equipment to the heat treat industry. We feel that these releases will continue our expansion into additional markets. Our equipment continues to provide maintenance friendly and robust designs time and time again.”

Can you share with us sales figures for the company?

“With sales of over $15 Million, 2019 was another record-breaking year for McLaughlin Furnace Group. We anticipate another record-breaking year to follow this year with continued industry growth.”

You have seen a lot of growth in your company over the past couple of years. Do you expect to continue to grow at the same rate? Tying into this question we would ask, what do you expect of the North American heat-treating industry in the next 2 years-continued growth? Stagnant or even negative growth?

“We do anticipate continuing to grow at a very fast pace in the coming years. We have quite a few large projects on the horizon and new releases that we anticipate will expand our markets across the industry. I expect the North-American heat treat market to continue to grow across both commercial and captive heat treat shops. The advances in the aerospace industry have substantially grown the North American heat treat industry, and I expect it will continue to grow in the coming years.”

Our understanding is that currently you have almost finished installation of a 2-row pusher furnace in the US. Keeping in mind that this is the first pusher you have ever built, how has this project gone?

“It would be a lie to say that this pusher furnace project with a highly expedited timeline hasn’t tested our team, but we have grown greatly from it into a better company. We have executed the project very efficiently, and have had the opportunity to complete this work for a fantastic automotive manufacturer. We have been able to provide some highly impressive technology to enable this manufacturer the ability to grow and improve their process.”

To date I believe all of your equipment has been installed in the USA-feel free to correct me if I am wrong. Have any plans on expanding outside of the USA?

“As a matter of fact, we actually already have some temper furnaces and a Tru-Mix generator installed in Vietnam. We are currently in the process of building fifteen radiant tube box furnaces and two more Tru-Mix generators for the same customer. As we continue to expand our product lines and markets, we anticipate more international equipment including Tru-Carb batch IQs in the near future.”

You have come a long way in a relatively short period of time and made it look easy. However, success generally comes with challenges, what has been your greatest challenge in growing the business?

“Our greatest challenge as McLaughlin Furnace Group continues to grow is finding the right people for the exponential growth we are experiencing. Growth without the right people magnifies issues. We have made great strides in hiring people to step in and fill big roles, but that doesn’t mean there hasn’t been bumps in the road. As McLaughlin continues to grow and hire experienced industry professionals, we anticipate our company to only become more of a threat to our competitors.”

A good friend in the industry, Mr. Bernie Parry who unfortunately passed away quite recently always used to say that nothing is new in the heat treat industry, meaning that most of the technologies we are using today were developed some time ago. Do you agree or disagree?

“I would have to agree that a lot of OEMs in the industry are using outdated technology, but at McLaughlin Furnace Group we always strive to provide the best, well tested technology to our customers. We are continuing to use new materials in place of standard alloy and refractory on our different product lines that enable customers to reduce maintenance downtime, minimize distortion, and ensure long life of wear items. We also strive to use new electrical technologies for diagnostics, burner firing, communication, and automation. Although technology is not cheap, there are many savings that can be passed down to the end customer through using new technology.”

Since we are speaking about technologies Jeff what do you see in the future? One which always fascinates us at “The Monty” is additive manufacturing-do you personally see this changing heat treatment?

“In the technological era that we are in, state of the art equipment will continue to be developed and become the expected standard in the industry. The expansion of aerospace through space exploration and other ventures across the globe will continue to bring technology to the heat treat industry as well. New processes will continue to be developed to meet the needs throughout the world, and whether it be additive manufacturing, or other technologies, I think we can expect a lot of exciting technology to make its way into our industry in the near future.”

Jeff, we appreciate your time and your very candid answers. Sincerely, Gord

For more information on McLaughlin Furnace Group please see the link below.

https://www.mclaughlinsvc.com/

We are pleased to be able to offer you this interview with both Mr. Scott Bodemann, President and Mr. Paul Cairney, Heat Treat market manager, of Nitrogen Generation Technology company South-Tek Systems of Wilmington, NC, USA.

I always like to start off our interviews with a bit of background, for instance what is your background and how did you get involved with nitrogen generating systems?

Scott: “Thanks Gord and great to chat with you. I have been with South Tek for over 15 years and have enjoyed being a part of the Company’s expansion over the years. We were established in 1997 and our sole focus is on the design and manufacturing of nitrogen (N2) generators. Our USA based engineering/manufacturing headquarters is located in Wilmington, NC. Our systems range in size from the dimensions of a small briefcase (1 LPM) on up to flow rates exceeding 30,000+ SCFH. In addition, nitrogen purities range from 95% on up to 99.999% (10 ppm) and pressures can exceed 6,000 PSI.

We supply nitrogen generators into a multitude of markets; Fire Protection Systems (FPS), Food Packaging, Food Storage, Medical, Automotive, Heat Treating, Laser, Electronics, 3D Printing, University, Military, Corrosion Control (Power Plant and FPS), Laboratory, Food Service, Pharmaceutical, Chemical, R&D, Materials. Customers include those as large as Fortune 100 Companies to small privately-run business, all of which realize significant savings over purchasing nitrogen from gas companies. Our technology allows them to control their costs long into the future.”

The focus of “The Monty” is very narrow, heat treating only so we will frame all of our questions around the field of heat treatment. First off why? Why buy a nitrogen generating system when it is so simple to go out and lease a bulk nitrogen storage tank?

Paul: “There are a multitude of compelling reasons to invest in a nitrogen generation system with STS. 2 main reasons are:

COST-The cost of buying bulk gas and the added expense of delivery, tank rental, hazmat fees etc. are essentially eliminated with your own nitrogen generation system. The average cost of buying liquid bulk is around $1.00 per CCF; and the cost of generating your own with a South Tek Systems generator is around 10 cents per CCF. And, with the gas company, you are paying for nitrogen that you do not fully get to use due to daily/weekly vent off. This vent off can be up to 2% waste daily.

CONTROL-When a company uses liquid bulk nitrogen, they are tied to a gas company and, very often, a long-term contract. With our system, we have fully automated N2 on demand. And, no missed deliveries, escalating costs or contracts to sign. Moreover, liquid bulk costs continue to increase, and the end user has no control over these costs.”

What do you see at South-Tek as the best heat treating applications for your systems?

Paul: “We can apply our N2Gen nitrogen generators to a wide variety of heat treating applications, but some are certainly more suited than others. Probably the best fit for us, and where we focus the most attention would be a continuous flow atmosphere with N2 as an atmosphere component or N2 itself.  These would include N2/H2, N2/CH4, or just N2 for cover gas in N2 tempering, stress relieving, normalizing, annealing, hardening, CAAB (continuous atmosphere aluminum brazing), etc.  Another continuous flow application would be N2/methanol atmospheres for carburizing and neutral hardening.  Chamber purging prior to FNC or nitriding or any other atmosphere process is another popular usage.  We have also supplied systems to feed N2 into vacuum degreasers that require a N2 flow.”

What are the more challenging applications in heat treating?

Paul: “Emergency purging becomes challenging in some plants because of the infrequency of outages in combination with the volume of gas required to have on hand to purge all atmosphere furnaces simultaneously (enough to flow at e-purge rates for as long as it takes to cool the load).  However, we do have alternative technology that does not generate N2 on demand but tops off HPC (High Pressure Cylinders) over a determined amount of time so our customer is ready for the next emergency purge.

Gas quenching in vacuum furnaces is a good application for our systems (we can achieve the high purity required) so long as the quench pressure is not significantly high.”  

How much nitrogen does a company need to use before it makes economic sense to install a nitrogen generating system?

Paul: “Our systems are sized and specified for a wide range of flow capacity and purity.  Because of that, we can make a good economic case for about any capacity situation, especially when the users demand is steady.  With nitrogen generation technology, machine capacity (i.e. flow) and purity are inversely related, so the payback will always be better with lower purity applications since the size of the system is reduced.  Many times, we find a customer does not need the 99.998% purity that they initially believe they do.  A lower, but suitable purity improves the economic payback of the N2 generation process.”

What would a typical payback period for a system be? Even better do you have any case studies you can point to with lots of figures to show investment and payback?

Paul: “Typically, a South-Tek N2GEN system can reduce costs by up to 90% compared to the cost being charged by the gas company. The Return On Investment (ROI) is oftentimes very quick when the equipment is capitalized; however, should the customer finance the equipment, operational spend is reduced providing an immediate ROI.

One great example to share is HONDA USA in Anna, OH. This particular customer reduced their spend on liquid bulk by 70%. Moreover, there was a larger reduction in manpower associated with managing the bulk supply and handling deliveries.”

How many systems do you estimate are installed and in use in North America?

Paul: “We would estimate there are hundreds of nitrogen generators installed for Heat Treat applications in North America. This is not a new technology and as more users realize that there is an alternative to working with gas companies, the popularity of these systems continues to become more widespread.”  

I have to ask this question, if this technology is so great why are there so few systems in use in the heat treat industry?

Paul: “This is a fallacy as many systems are currently installed in the heat treat industry and their popularity continues to increase. We are hearing more and more, “Why pay a premium for a gas that I can generate myself?” However, as with any technology, and with a different way of operating, change takes time.

Additionally, many customers cannot make the transition as quickly as they would like due to being held captive by a 5-7-year gas contract. As customers face this, they oftentimes make it a key strategic planning objective to time their exits accordingly and make the switch as quickly as possible.  

Furthermore, early versions of nitrogen generation technology utilized membrane technology which is not nearly as robust as South-Tek’s current Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA) technology. PSA systems require less demand from the air compressors and are significantly more energy efficient. This leads to much better reliability and significantly reduced operating costs.”

In reviewing these questions I see that every single one refers to nitrogen, but I have been missing an obvious question-what about other gases? Heat treaters use lots of different gases, have you ever looked at producing other gases? Could your technology be used for other types of gas generation?

Scott: “Nitrogen makes up 79% of the air we breath, meaning that it is the most abundant gas in our atmosphere. Therefore, it is the most cost effective to generate on site. Other gases simply are not as cost effective to generate (or feasible to generate) on site in the volumes that are needed for Heat Treating applications.”

How is business for you these days and could you share with us about future plans for South-Tek?

Scott: “Business is very good. South-Tek continues to grow year over year, and our company is moving onward and upward every day. We have recently transitioned operations only a few miles from our previous facility into a custom designed, newly upfitted 66,000 sq. ft building. This comes at the right time as we were close to full capacity and were outgrowing our previous production space. We have also added over 20 new employees in the last 12 months.

This exciting move is part of a strategic investment to boost production and overall operational excellence. Furthermore, this facility will allow for easier access to major highways. South-Tek continues to be the nation’s leader in nitrogen generation systems and as part of our expansion, we are committed to developing the highest quality technology for Heat-Treating applications.”  

I appreciate the time today Scott and Paul, thank you. Gord

Mr. Paul Cairney and Mr. Scott Bodemann

Stephen, in preparation for this interview I went through my notes and re-read the interview we did a few years back (this can still be found at https://themonty.com/interviews/stephen-harris-bodycote/). One of our favorite questions when doing an interview is to ask how each individual got involved in heat treating. With your permission I will refer back to that original interview for our answer:

“I was trained as an electrical engineer but along the way I acquired a business degree from the University of Chicago. While my job history is varied it would be best described as a general industrial background. This would include long working stints in the Chicago area and Buffalo, in several cases running the North American operations of UK companies. I was approached by Bodycote in 2008 to replace the outgoing CEO, Mr. John Hubbard with whom I have since had a long and enjoyable working relationship. I became CEO of Bodycote in January 2009 mainly because I found it such an interesting company.”

When you started in 2009 the Bodycote share price was 122 pence; November 27th 2019 the share price stood at 887 pence. Now, granted 2009 was the depth of the worst recession since the 1930s but this still represents a tremendous appreciation. To what do you attribute this?

“We have done a lot to improve the business. Our margins run at about 19% these days as an average across the business, whereas back in 2008, before the great recession, they peaked at around 13%. The improved performance is predominantly due to better productivity. Today we have about 5,700 employees with sales of £728 million compared with over 7,500 employees and sales of £551 million back then.”

“A key focus has been improving operations. We have always had great heat treaters in the business but we have made great strides in injecting operational skills. The facilities are better laid out and far safer than they used to be. We measure our customer service levels at each of the plants. Customer service is, of course, a key attribute in our industry. If customer service falls at a facility, profits soon follow.”

“In addition to hiring great people, a lot of capital investment has been required to enhance the plants. In many instances we decided replacement was a better option. Since 2009 we have closed 70 facilities and opened or acquired 52. We now have 189 facilities around the world having acquired two more this year in Scandinavia and Slovakia.”

“I think it is also fair to say that our growth in the less developed countries of Eastern Europe, Mexico, and China has also helped performance. It is very easy to lose money in unfamiliar territories and it is definitely high risk, but if you get it right the rewards are respectable.”

How does the Bodycote model differ from other commercial heat treaters?

“We call our commercial heat treatment business “Classical Heat Treatment” to distinguish it from Specialist Technologies which we can talk about later. In the Classical Heat Treatment business, we tend to approach the market somewhat differently to most commercial heat treaters. We are a large company and have a very sound financial basis. We also carry around $750 million in insurance. This means that very large companies, including many of the world’s largest OEMs and Tier 1 suppliers, are quite happy to do business with us knowing that we can stand behind our commitments. We often hear about small commercial heat treaters that venture into doing business under onerous trading terms which they are happy to sign. The problem is that when they have a quality escape, the OEM ends up owning the heat treater, which is not what anybody wanted.”

“Apart from our bias towards large customers I would say the biggest difference between us and most commercial heat treaters is our focus. We do not attempt to do business with wildly different customers from an individual plant. Our plants are segregated between those serving the aerospace industry and those serving automotive. We have learnt that these two different types of customers require a different focus. Furthermore, we segregate high volume plants from lower volume/high flexibility plants. We also operate on a local cluster basis with all the plants in a cluster working together. In this way we can limit the number of technologies in any one plant but are still able to provide all the technologies that a customer may need in any area. It is a dangerous temptation to keep adding technologies to a single plant. The extra complexity drives up costs and lowers customer service. It is not about heat treatment knowledge, it’s about production complexity. Keeping things simple is by far the best approach. Of course, it’s our size and number of facilities that allows us to achieve these economies of scale.”

While most of our questions focus mainly on heat treating we should also talk about your Hot Isostatic Pressing division. Perhaps you could share a few thoughts about the “HIP” side of things such as whether this is a growing field and whether it overlaps with heat treating.

“Our HIP business sits in our Specialist Technologies division, which I referred to earlier. The other businesses in the division are Surface Technology (plasma, HVOF and thermochemical coatings), S3P (Specialty Stainless Steel Processes) and Powdermet® (contract manufacturing of products from powder using HIP and 3D printing technologies). We also have two other specialist technologies which are heat treatment types of processes. These are Low Pressure Carburising and Corr-I-Dur® (these last two operate within the Classical Heat Treatment facilities). In the Specialist Technologies division, each technology has its own dedicated facilities which are quite separate from the heat treatment business. They also have their own management and sales forces. So, as you can see, we do not believe there is any real overlap between HIP and heat treatment.”

“We are aware of a number of heat treaters going into the HIP business. History suggests that this is a very risky move. It is an expensive business to get into and the maintenance costs are astronomic, which is not something the suppliers tend to advertise. Replacement of a molybdenum furnace will cost you well over $1 million for a large HIP and, unfortunately, unlike vacuum furnaces they fail quite regularly. Bodycote has acquired quite a number of HIP vessels over the years from companies both small and large that have attempted to enter the HIP industry and failed quite spectacularly. Most of the new entrants are going in at the small end, targeting additive manufacturing. I think this is sensible as the risks are lower and that market is growing at a reasonable rate.” 

When we spoke all those years ago one of the main topics concerned two acquisitions you had recently made, Metal Improvement and Carolina Commercial. The Carolina Commercial acquisition raised a few eyebrows at the time due to the relatively high sale price. In retrospect was this a good decision?

“A good question. I would say the results of that acquisition were mixed. The Metal Improvement acquisition was much better. The fact that Carolina Commercial had been held by a Private Equity firm for a number of years was clearly a problem. Many PE firms do not have a great knowledge of running businesses themselves and they tend to underinvest. This was the case with Carolina Commercial. Of course, it didn’t help that shortly after acquisition there was a fire that destroyed one of the facilities. Given the opportunity again I would have still tried to acquire Carolina Commercial, but we would have approached it differently, paying less and going into turnaround mode straight away.”

My understanding is that Bodycote is considering all heat treating technologies currently available and amongst the criteria for new equipment is the degree to which it is environmentally friendly. Would you care to comment on this? Perhaps comparing vacuum carburizing systems to batch IQ furnaces?

“Well, Gord, I wouldn’t quite state it like that.  We avoid some technologies. We do not like salt both for environmental reasons and because of poor production flexibility.  We avoid continuous processes such as mesh belts and pushers, once again due to limited flexibility and poor carbon footprint. When times are tough these types of technology tend to lose money. Obviously continuous processes with salt quenching are highly unattractive to us!”

“We do like vacuum carburizing. This is primarily because of the better results you get for specific applications.  Unfortunately, there is not a great deal of demand for vacuum carburizing today outside of the automotive OEMs and the equipment cost is very high.”

Nobody in the heat treating industry will argue with me when I say that Bodycote is the only truly global commercial heat treater. That being said, which geographic areas of the world do you see as offering the largest growth potential to your company?

“We spoke earlier about the lower developed countries in Eastern Europe, Mexico and China which clearly offer good growth, albeit at high risk. I still see the largest growth potential as being the United States. Aside from the natural growth rate of the US economy itself, the amount of work available that today is being done quite inefficiently by many manufacturers in their captives is very large.”

A good friend of ours and a very respected individual in the heat treating industry, Mr. Dan McCurdy, recently retired as President, Bodycote Automotive and General Industrial Heat Treatment, North America and Asia. There has been a lot of discussionabout who is replacing Dan (and we confess we have fueled some of this speculation). Could you please explain to us how you are filling this position? 

“We will miss Dan tremendously. He has been a key member of the team for many years. Replacing Dan was always going to be very difficult. So we didn’t really replace him. Instead, we reorganised the company. Dan’s North American Automotive and General Industrial (AGI) business now reports to Tom Gibbons. Tom also runs the North American Aerospace, Defense and Energy (ADE) business. Tom has five Vice Presidents of Operations reporting to him that run the sub-divisions of:  Automotive, General Industrial, East, Central and West.”

“The European ADE business now reports to the two European Classical Heat Treatment Presidents, one for Northern and Eastern Europe and one for Western and Southern Europe. These are run by Paul Clough and Eric Denisse respectively. Paul is also responsible for Asia.”

“We then have the Specialist Technologies division run by Thomas Oury.”

“The accounting and other central functions, such as HR, are then taken care of outside of the divisions in shared service centers. In the US this is in Dallas.”

This question ties in with the previous one: how much autonomy does each general manager have? For instance, if the GM of plant XYZ wants a new furnace how long a process would it take to put this in motion?

“Our operating philosophy is to not try to centralize or tell the GM’s how to run their businesses from headquarters. We give them guidance as to our corporate strategy and general direction, our expectations for customer service, safety, and financial returns. There are specialists that can help them with specific issues if they need it. It a tough job but the rewards can be high. It is a job that carries a great deal of satisfaction if performed well. There is a great deal of recognition. If a plant does well it is down to the GM. In large part, how the GMs succeed is up to them, but we do have a number of rules that have to be followed. Foremost of these is that they cannot buy businesses or properties. This is done by our M&A team, which includes Mario Ciampini who many of your readers know well.”

“Investing in a furnace comes under our capital investment rules. We require a specific rate of return that depends on the risk. A GM can submit a request as long as it justifies the required return. The first thing we do is then look for unused or underutilised furnaces already in our network. With over one thousand primary furnaces and many more temperers in operation, and more in storage, we can sometimes fill the need straight away. The majority of the time taken in getting a capital item approved is taken up with the GM and the divisional team doing their homework. We do not buy equipment on a whim. Once a case has been developed and submitted it can take a few weeks to get approved if it fits with the strategic vision for the Group. If it doesn’t it can take a very long time. Requests for large mesh belts with salt quench somehow never seem to get answered!”

Bodycote is of course headquartered in the UK but there have been some rumors suggesting that the company might move the headquarters to another country in Europe. Is this something you can comment on?

“Bodycote is a UK registered company and is listed on the London Stock Exchange. The registered office remains in Macclesfield, UK.  A new management office has been opened just outside of Geneva where a number of senior managers are based, though we have regional headquarters in Dusseldorf, Germany; St Priest, France; Prague, Czech Republic and Dallas, Texas.”

When we spoke a few years back you estimated that captive heat treating represented 80% of the total market and commercial heat treating the remainder. Is this still the case? Part II of this question would be: is the company still interested in taking over the heat treating requirements of some of these captives? If my memory is correct I believe I saw a press release from Bodycote a little while ago mentioning that you had signed a long-term contract with Rolls-Royce which would indicate that the answer is ‘yes’.

“This is a statistic that is almost impossible to measure accurately. While we have seen a general slow trend for companies to outsource their heat treatment this is offset by very high growth in countries such as China and India, where the high-quality heat treatment is overwhelmingly done in-house. My guess is that if you could measure it accurately you would find that there is now more done in-house than there was ten years ago due to this effect.”

“Bodycote is always looking actively to take over captives. We are often approached to do this, however we are not interested in high volume operations where the only motivation is for the customer to swap their balance sheet for ours. In fact, it is quite rare for us to take over a captive. When we do buy a captive we more often than not scrap the equipment and invest in more flexible, fit for purpose equipment. At the end of the day, we are an aggregator and we need equipment that allows us to do this. In many instances we do not take work that is already being done in-house. Instead, we will be working with the OEMs, such as Rolls-Royce, and will take the products before they have ever been treated in-house.”

Stephen, what can we expect to see from Bodycote over the course of the next year? Are there any exciting new developments you could share with us?

“Gord, we expect to see several very exciting new things happening in the next twelve months in both our Classical Heat Treatment business and our Specialist Technologies. Unfortunately, there aren’t any that I am allowed to share with you at this time.”

Thanks for taking the time to talk with me. Stephen as always I appreciate your time and candid, open answers. Gord

We are very pleased to be speaking with Mr. Andreas, Fritz of cleaning system specalists HEMO GmbH in Ötisheim, Germany.

Right off the bat Andreas I have a question for you about the name of your company. I had always thought it was EMO however I see that the company name is now HEMO GmbH-which is correct?

“HEMO is the correct name of the company. The two companies Hoesel GmbH, manufacturer of fine cleaning machines, and EMO Oberflaechentechnik GmbH manufacturer of large cleaning systems merged in 2017 and changed the name to HEMO. Nevertheless EMO is still our brand name in the heat treatment industry and the machines we sell there are still called VAIOCS (Vacuum Assisted Inorganic Organic Cleaning System).”

I am always curious about how people get involved in our industry-could you share with us your background and that of the company?

“The company was established in 1979 building open-top atmospheric degreasing system using chlorinated hydrocarbons as solvent which was state of the art at that time. Due to changes in environmental and health legislation we invented and patented the first cleaning machine which was working under vacuum in 1995. This new technology had a huge impact and finally all competitors were our licensees.

In 1996 HEMO delivered the first vacuum cleaning machine using hydrocarbon far above its flash point for perfect cleaning and drying results to a commercial heat treatment shop. Their customer was BOSCH and their quality control returned the whole batch stating it was not in the furnace because the parts were not black after tempering. Only reason was that the parts were cleaned after oil quenching and the oil didn’t crack on the parts anymore after tempering process. Finally, for a certain time, BOSCH stated in its specification sheet that all parts must be EMO-cleaned which was our boost into the heat treatment industry.

In 1999 I joined the company as a temporary help after school. I did whatever was necessary in any department, was fascinated by the size and technology of the machines and finally agreed to do an apprenticeship. After that I did a 6-year distance study in order not to loose the daily business and also spend 3 years at a machine manufacturing company near Nuremberg.

Since 2012 I am Managing Director and pretty much involved into the heat treatment industry. To be honest, customers in this industry are different than in others. The direct, honest way of talking – negative and positive – is and was very helpful for me to guide me especially in my first years. It is like a big family and I really like to meet these people whenever and whereever possible.”

Please share with us a little information about your company; Size? Products? Locations? Industries you are involved with?

“HEMO GmbH currently has roughly 140 emloyees and a turnover of 35 Mio. Euro being generated at two manufacturing locations in the south of Germany. We are shareholder of the the companies LPW Reinigungssysteme building water-based cleaning systems and BERTOMA which is a job-cleaning company.  Additional foreign joint-ventures are Mecanolav-Ridel in France, NGCT Cleansys in India and the latest one Washtech in Queretaro, Mexico which all offer sales, service and manufacturing capacity for HEMO products but also build their own kind of cleaning systems.

Finally we have a licence manufacturing and service partner in China being done by Shanghai Advanced Metallurgical Technology Corporation. In any of these locations our custom-tailored solvent-based or hybrid cleaning machines are build or used. Roughly 25% of our turnover is generated in heat treatment industry (hardening and brazing) followed by coating, automotive and aerospace industry.”

Is your equipment typically a standard design or more custom machines?

“Our equipment is always custom-tailored. For sure we adapt furnace batch sizes from well-known manufacturers into our „standard“ but even small differences in batch dimensions cause differences in filling volumes, tank sizes, piping diameters and many more details. We are used to that and the customer is mainly interested in the layout of the whole furnace line. And by the fact that roughly half of the supplied machines substitute old existing spray washers we must be able to implement a much more sophisticated machine into the existing floor space. This is our strength and makes us competitive enough to be a well-known partner in this industry.”

In the heat treating industry how important is part cleanliness-let me rephrase that slightly. Nobody will argue that in an aerospace application as an example parts have to be clean, however if you are heat treating fasteners in a furnace with oil quenching is cleanliness really that important?

“Basically there is more than one reason why cleanliness is important. A good cleaning system cleans the parts after oil quenching and doesn’t take all the oil together with water into the tempering furnace. That saves money in maintenance and guarantees stable processes and quality. The perfect cleaning before the hardening process ensures cleanliness till the end. Otherwise white spots would stay on the parts and could cause soft spot faults.

Not new but pretty much upcoming are cleanliness specifications which show max. particle sizes (automotive parts), min. surface tension (before brazing) or final carbon residues (medical applications). We could not be happier about this development but unfortunately customers do not understand that sometimes the relation between costs and benefit fail.”

Tying in with the question above, by process where do you sell most of your systems in the heat treatement industry? As an example do you have a lot of systems in plants operating batch IQ (sealed quench furnaces), or is it more to firms doing nitriding or vacuum heat treatment?

“The cleaning machine process must always match to the hardening process hence we sell our machines for any process. In the beginning most cleaning machines were sold for batch IQ because cleaning off oil with water was a mess and customers wanted to have a stable quality. We substituted hundreds of washers in existing lines with our hydrocarbon systems in the last more than 20 years. Years ago optical issues in gas and plasma nitriding process came up and customers requested perfect pre-cleaning. Our hybrid cleaning systems which are using hydrocarbon and water in the same system made it possible to offer spot-free pre-cleaning without the necessity to continously maintain and exchange the cleaning bath.

By the fact that especially commercial heat treaters offer a wide range of processes, our machines are also able to cover the cleanliness demands of all these processes because investing in a cleaning system unfortunately still is an investment with very low financial return.  It is only valueable in case the customer can offer better quality and can use it 24/7.”

Could you tell us what different types of cleaning systems are available on the market?

“I think most systems are still water-based spraying type systems with circulation air drying. More and more they are substituted by flood washing machines with vacuum drying unit. These flood washing machines can be water-based, solvent-based or a combination of both. These machines can be loaded from the top by crane or from the front by loading carriage. In addition these machines are available as continuous throughput systems.”

In a past life I sold vapour degreasers which in my opinion were and still are one of the best cleaning systems in the world. However because of health concerns related to the solvents being used they have largely fallen out of favour. Out of curiousity are there many of these systems still in the industry?

“Yes there are many of the old open top vapour degreasers on the market which cause cancer and harm the environment. Most run only by using a special permit because the operating company believes that there is no proper substitution on the market.  But depending on the execution and the used cleaning agent these machines are not harmful to humans or the environment and we also build them for e.g. aircraft applications. They are just cheaper than the flood washing machines and in some cases the cleanliness is good enough. Important to know is that we heard next year the EPA will release a list containing these halogenated hydrocarbons with the effect of proscriping them soon. Your readers operation a machine like this should be aware of that.”

Ok solvent vs; aqueous cleaning systems, what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?

“There is a very old chemical rule being called “like dissolves like“.  Anorganics like water-based emulsion or coolant, fingerprints or salts cannot be cleaned off by hydrocarbon. You will always see white spots on the parts which could be soft spots as well. Organics like quenching oil can be cleaned with water but the water will be polluted and must be exchanged quite often to have a stable quality. That’s the reason why organic solvents like hydrocarbons should be used. The residues are solved much better and the by boiling point the oil can be distillated and the hydrocarbon never has to be changed.”

Did you ever wash a pan with fried oil and afterwards a wine glass in the same bath in your bassin? How clean was the glass?

“If we respect the rules of nature things are getting done much easier.”

This might be a rather provocative question but I am going to ask it anyway. From personal observation it appears to me that Europeans are far more obssed about cleaning than North Americans, perhaps more than they should be. You do business all over the world, what are your thoughts?

“Cleanliness is of high importance because everybody wants to reach his destination by car, train or plane without interruption. Everybody wants to have clean medical implants which will not cause pain before the surgery is even healed. There are so many reasons why we should appreciate the positive effect the cleaning industry has but of course people sometimes feel that it is too much. And this obsession is real but it is mainly caused by the automotive industry not by nationality. The automotive industry all over the world tries its best to prevent any problem that can occur. Hence if a problem occur when a metallic particle with 200µm is in the fuel injection system, next time they ask for max. 100µm size.

We are working in the fine and ultra-fine cleaning business as well and when you see that the demands on a mechanical design can never be reached in reality it is really hard to understand for us why nobody stops this situation. The gap between the desirable and reality is widening and to reach the required specifications the whole manufacturing of a car must be done in a clean room.  To be honest, we know how to handle it and others don’t hence we have a profit from this obsession. Nevertheless we try to give our feedback in order to stop the widening of this gap because these things cause costs and finally all of us have to bear them when we buy the final product.”

How do you handle sales outside of Europe? For instance do you have offices in Asia or North America?

“In China and India we have sales and service offices as well as license manufacturing for hydrocarbons cleaning machines. In some other Asian countries we have sales agents who are mainly selling furnaces or coating machines but also know about the importance of cleaning and see our products as additional equipment.

In North America we have a Joint Venture with sales, service and license manufacturing in Queretaro, Mexico. They are taking care of our machines in Mexico, USA and Canada. Outside Mexico we mainly work together with the furnace manufacturers by projects and we exhibit at the usual trade shows. For the US market we are open to discuss in case readers would like to work with us.”

What do you see in the future for your systems as it relates to the heat treating industry? Do you see a shift to more additive manufacturing which would insinuate smaller cleaning systems or do you see the opposite, meaning larger systems?

“In LPC we see that very small batch sizes are coming up which is interesting for us and we already developed machines for that. Additive manufacturing is very good for us because these parts are like sintered parts and you need vacuum to get them cleaned. We have a lot of experience with those parts. Similar thing is the substitution of the cast racks to CFC racks. They are very light and you can have much more parts in the same batch but cleaning without vacuum is impossible. We made a lot of trials for a customer who is now using our hydrocarbon system.

Last year we developed the first solvent vacuum cleaning machine for roller hearth furnaces because the customer wanted to quench in oil and not in salt. Every 7,5 minutes he now cleans and dries a batch in conjunction with his furnace. My company is very innovative and we love to spend time on developments with our customers. Doing the same every day is just boring.”

I appreciate the time Andreas, Thank you, Gord

We are excited to be able to offer you this interview with an individual we have a very high opinion of Mr. Thomas Dopler, CEO of furnace manufacturer Aichelin GesmbH based in Moedling, Austria.  

Thomas I am always curious about how people end up in the heat treatment industry. Could you share with us how you got started in the industry and ended up where you are now? 

 I did my first heat treatment at the age of 15 at high school (higher technical school with optional classes in metallurgy), followed by my studies in material science where heat treatment was one of the major subjects, especially steel and aluminium. These two materials have been guiding me through my entire professional life from the aerospace and automotive industry where I was working in R&D and Sales to my current position at Aichelin, which I joined 11 years ago. Heat treatment of steel and aluminium is our reason to be.  

Please share with us some details about Aichelin-what you have to offer, the size of the company, the number of locations and perhaps even a brief history of the company. 

AICHELIN Group is a leading provider of heat treatment solutions, such as industrial furnaces, induction hardening plants and industrial gas burners systems. The company’s roots date back to 1868. The long-established brand AICHELIN, as well as EMA Indutec, SAFED, BOSIO, AFC-Holcroft and Noxmat, make up the group and together employ more than 1,100 people. AICHELIN Group ranges among the world’s top 3 heat treatment companies. AICHELIN’s subsidiaries in Europe are located in Austria, France, Germany, Slovenia, and Switzerland; the worldwide presence of the company includes subsidiaries and branch offices in China, India, Russia, and the US, as well as a sales network in 22 more countries. The site in Mödling is the technological center for new equipment in Europe, with a focus on continuous heat treatment plants. Our scope of supply ranges from pusher, ring and roller hearth furnaces to belt and sealed quench furnace lines. AICHELIN GesmbH has been doing business in Mödling since 1960 and the Group’s headquarters is also located here. A great deal of our business is After Sales and we are constantly working on new developments such as our latest products heatXpress and #jakob. 

 Historically what type of furnace has Aichelin made the most of? Pusher? Cast Link? Sealed Quench etc.? 

Since we offer such a great variety of furnace types, this question is difficult to answer for the entire history of Aichelin. However, there is certain continuity with gas carburizing. Aichelin started the production of furnaces for powder carburizing according to licenses of the American Gas Furnace Corp. back in 1900. When the contacts to the USA were interrupted during World War 1, these furnace lines were further developed with Aichelin’s own know-how. Together with Robert Bosch (the founder of Bosch group, in person!) and his leading engineers, Aichelin had started tests even before the War in order to improve carburizing in gas. Back then, barrel-shaped retort furnaces were used, which was one of the most-requested Aichelin products of that time. Despite the limited control devices of that period, the test results were astonishingly good. Aichelin is therefore definitely a pioneer regarding gas carburizing. 

Typically who are your customers? Commercial or captive heat treaters? Auto parts makers or aerospace suppliers? 

The AICHELIN Group focusses on atmospheric heat treatment, for both continuous and batch furnace lines. We consider ourselves as one of the globally leading companies in this industry, with more than 150 years of history in Europe, more than 100 years of history in the US and more than 30 years of history on the Chinese market.  Therefore, we serve all kinds of customers, from the major OEMs of the different industries and the leading captive heat treatment shops of the leading tier 1s to commercial heat treatment shops. This also confirms our focus on the automotive market and its suppliers with all their applications, whereas the aerospace market is less our target. At the same time we are also serving customers in the bearing, fasteners and electric machinery industry.

As CEO of the Moedling division do you have much involvement with the other divisions such as China or North America? 

AICHELIN Group’s strength is the global position in the heat treatment market, with more than 1100 employees world-wide. For this reason, a very tight cooperation and close contacts with my colleagues in China & the US are part of our common success. We can help each other with know-how, resources and technical advice as well as with service support. 

Are you seeing or do you expect to see much competition in Europe from either North American or Asian furnace builders? 

No. There is a degree of customization of furnace lines for the individual needs on the 3 continents (Europe, the Americas & Asia). Therefore, the only cases when we see some mixture of overseas furnace builders with the locals is in case our customers go overseas and want a precise copy of what they have in their home country (with adaptations to local standards and equipment)

A common perception amongst buyers of new furnaces is that because they are high dollar items this must translate into high margins for the furnace manufacturer. How would you respond to this statement? 

New furnace business will never make you rich in the automotive business! The market power of “us” (the furnace builders) is far too small against the OEMs. We must therefore focus on continuous improvement of the furnace quality and technology and assist our customers throughout the long life of our furnaces with After Sales Services. This way we remain competitive over the years.  

 I understand that Aichelin has a new product which you are quite proud of “heatXpress”-could you please tell us why you are so proud of this particular system? 

The reason we are so proud of the new product, heatXpress, is easily explained: The step chain furnace has 10 major advantages compared to existing PHS (Press hardening Steel) heat treatment solutions.For example, the durability of the step chain transport system is more than 4 years in contrast to traditional systems using rollers, which must be replaced much more frequently.  Another example is the transport accuracy at every stage since there is no build-up of AlSi on the chains in the furnace.  A final example would be the tailored property options combined with the very short cycle times, which create an important advantage for companies who are looking for cost-effective PHS manufacturing. With our new product, heatXpress, AICHELIN has the right and best product for all PHS requirements now and in the future.        

 What is your number one concern these days? Finding people? Tough competition? A slowing economy? 

Over the last 20 years, our industry has gone through several major ups and downs. Our experience thus tells us that we need to stay flexible regarding the size of our individual furnace companies as such changes can occur within short notice.   On the long run, the most important concern are our employees! We must find them, train them, keep them and challenge them over the years. Only if we manage to have the best experts on the market (for mechanical and electrical design, processes, furnace installation, …), we may set ourselves apart in the dynamic market with respect to our competitors.

I am fascinated by additive manufacturing (or 3D printing) and I have now seen a couple of examples of small systems which incorporate a sintering furnace. Have you had any involvement in this technology? 

Additive Manufacturing is one of the technologies that will shape the future. Heat treatment is an essential part of this technology to reduce stresses and distortion for 3D-printed parts and to obtain the desired part properties. In my own opinion we will see this technology entering the heat treatment market on a bigger scale in the near future (2021 to 2025). We are already working on this technology, in cooperation with 3D-printing prototype manufacturers as well as with 3D printer manufacturers and already have parts running through our furnaces.

Since we’re talking about a changing world and changing technologies let’s look at electric cars. The predictions are that within a decade or two we will all be driving electric cars which by their very nature require substantially less components which means substantially less heat treating. Does this enter your long term thinking about the size of the heat treatment industry?

The heat treatment market has always been very dynamic. The trend towards electric cars (purely electric as well as hybrid) means a big change for us, as some of our customers are strongly in the gear box industry. We face these changes by doing what we have always done: We focus on providing our customers with just the right technology for their needs. An example: One of our big overseas customers supplies parts for the new TESLA models.

Lets keep talking about the future of the industry. Do you personally think that the product mix Aichelin now offers will remain fairly constant in the foreseeable future or do you see it changing?

We see a slight shift in our product and service mix. As we have a high number of existing installations in the market, our customers tend to use them as long as possible. The oldest Aichelin installations working in the market are more than 70 years old! It is our job to keep these installations as up-to-date as possible, from the switch cabinet with the latest safety technology up to the use of most recent energy-efficient combustion systems. Of course, industry 4.0 will play an important role in the future.

Thomas out of all the types of thermal processing systems which you can offer what is your favorite style? Personally I have always liked the versatility of batch IQ (sealed quench) furnaces and have never been overwhelmed by pit furnaces but that is my opinion-what are your thoughts?

Our goal is to provide world class heat treatment for our customers which reproduces exactly the quality our customers require. For this reason, my heart is with continuous heat treatment furnaces with a good degree of automation, as I believe they are the best way to ensure stable quality for many industries with a decreasing number of skilled personnel.

Last but not least is there any interesting developments at Aichelin which you can share with us?

The most exciting recent development is our digital maintenance assistant #jakob. Named after Jakob Aichelin, who founded our company 151 years ago, this tool will make maintenance so much easier, providing all the information the furnace operators or maintenance staff will ever need at a glance, whilst carrying out monitoring functions and predicting maintenance and parts needs. #jakob is AICHELIN’s answer to Industry 4.0 and IoT.  

Steve Thompson & Jim Oakes, Super Systems Inc. Interview

We are excited to have this interview with Mr. Steve Thompson, President of controls company Super Systems Inc., in Cincinnati, Ohio and Mr. Jim Oakes, Vice President Business Development and future President of Metal Treating Institute (MTI).

Steve you got into this business for the same reason as I in that both of our fathers were in the industry. Could you please share with us your background and that of SSI? By the way I am sure many of our readers would like to hear how your Dad, Bill is doing these days-he was certainly a pioneer in this industry and many will remember him quite fondly.

Thank you for this opportunity. I started my career just after high school working at Marathon Monitors(MMI) while earning my associate degree in electronics. Soon after, I completed my bachelor’s in electronic engineering technology. My father sold MMI around the time I graduated and I found a job as a sales engineer in the Midwest selling to various industries including heat-treating. After seven years, I had the opportunity to join my father at Super Systems which was founded in 1995. At that time we sold only the Gold Probe. As time passed, we introduced many other technologies such as dew pointanalyzers, gas analyzers, process controllers, software, and flow technology. Almost all of our products are the result of customers requesting more heat-treat-specific solutions and the introduction of new technology. What I have enjoyed most are the relationships that I have developed with my co-workers and customers. Advice once given to me as a young man by my father was to surround myself with people that are smarter than I am and listen to them.

My dad is doing great. He is now 81 years young and enjoying playing golf and tennis in Jupiter, Florida. He stops up a few times a year and now has the title of CIO (Chief Interference Officer). All kidding aside, he is my advisor on all matters and I am grateful for that. Often it is hard for father and son to work together in business but in our case it has always been a pleasure.

How about you Jim-how did you come to find yourself in this industry?

Well, I was first introduced to the heat treating industry by none other than Bill Thompson. Bill invited me to Cincinnati after I graduated from high school and worked as an intern with Marathon Monitors. I am quite certain that I did not even know what heat treating was for some time but I had an opportunity to work with software and electronics that allowed me to apply what I was learning in school to the real world. I was able to work with some great people – some of whom I still work with today, and others whoI still cross paths with in the industry. Following graduation from college I used my skills outside the heat treating industry but when Steve was ready for me in 2005, I was eager to join SSI and it’s been a great ride. The technology, the people, the industry, have been a great ground for growth, learning and fun for me personally and professionally.

Before we move on Jim perhaps you could tell us more about your role at MTI and what the organization stands for.

MTI is the acronym for the Metal Treating Institute.  Since 1933 MTI has provided an outlet for businesses that focus on heat treating.   Today MTI represents the largest network of commercial heattreaters in the world and under the MTI Board of Directors and all the members,  MTI strives to fulfill its mission of enhancing the image and value of the heat treating industry.  MTI provides many services to its members such as leadership development, technical training for member employees, sales forecasting focused on the heat treating industry, annual meetings with great programming for professional development and networking, a technical standards committee giving heat treaters a voice in the specification review and design process, and a membership committee that is focused on specific topics that are important to the members.  MTI’s bylaws were changed in early 1995 to include Associate Members.  Associate Members are companies that supply equipment or services to the heat treat industry and share many of the same benefits as members of MTI that commercial heat treatersget.  I have served on a number of committees over the years with MTI and joined the MTI Board of Trustees in 2011.  In 2015 I joined the executive committee as the Treasurer and served for 3 years.  Most recently I was nominated for President-Elect which leads me to the MTI President role this fall.  It is quite an honor and I am very excited about the opportunity.  I follow in the footsteps of some incredible people and I don’t take that lightly.

Lets talk about SSi, please tell us about company, the size, the industries you focus on and some of your products.

Our global headquarters is in Cincinnati, OH and we have offices in Birmingham, England; Shanghai, China; New Delhi, India; and Queretaro, Mexico. Our combined offices give us a footprint to address heat treaters’ needs around the world.

Our specialty is providing technology for the thermal processing industry. We do this with a mixture of products and services covering a wide variety of applications. We have a great group of R&D engineers that help enhance and deliver products to the industry. Our engineers cover electrical, mechanical, software, and metallurgy, giving us a vast knowledge base for coming up with products that benefit theheat treating industry.

We mentioned our roots earlier with the oxygen/carbon probe, and of course we still manufacture and ship that product around the globe today. In addition, we have other tools that the industry benefits from like gas analyzers (for carburizing, endo gas, nitriding, FNC,etc), electronic flow meters, data logging devices, controllers, and software.

In addition to our products, we also have some of the best field service engineers in the industry. Our field team provides onsite services commissioning controls and software to give captive and commercial heat treaters the latest in technology for their equipment.

Care to give us an idea about your annual sales? Even a hint?

I am proud to say we are privately owned and don’t disclose our financials. We have approximately 100 employees and I think most can estimate what that equates to in annual sales.

Correct me if I am wrong but I have always considered that the company was built on oxygen (carbon probes) with everything stemming from this-would that be a fair statement? Taking it one step further do you feel that probes will continue to be the #1 way of monitoring and controlling furnace atmospheres?

You are correct. We founded the company on the Gold Probe and probes still represent a significant part of our revenue. We are very proud of the product and continue to see growth each year domesticallyalong with our international markets expanding. The oxygen probe is an in–situ device that is fast in response with very little maintenance required. For that reason along with being cost–effective, it will continue to be the number one choice for controlling atmosphere furnaces.

This question is a continuation of the question above. First came the oxygen probe, next came three gas analyzers (I realize that 3 gas is not a new technology but it is now useable as opposed to the first versions), next came probe plus 3 gas-where do you go from here?

If you look back prior to the use of oxygen probes you will find that CO2 gas analysis has been used for decades as the standard. As you know, gas analysis is an extractive reading and requires regular maintenance for calibration, filtering, and maintaining sample lines. Probes were introduced in the 1970s, and although not as reliable back then as they are today, they were much more cost–effective and reliable than CO2 gas analysis. Over the last twenty years CO2, along with CO and CH4, have provided more accurate analysis of carbon with much more reliable technology. Today the optimum carbon control utilizes the Gold Probe along with a permanent three-gas analyzer. In this case you benefit from direct reading of the probe but the precision of the CO, CO2 and CH4 measurement. This is what we refer to as “probe plus IR.” In the future I expect to see combinations of the probe with three gas and the addition of online process simulation utilizing the software tools available. Although this technology is available today and used by some it has not been adopted by many as of yet.

Over the years you have developed a number of innovative new products-out of them all which new product are you most proud of? To put it another way is there one where you can say it was a brilliant idea and succeeded beyond all of your expectations?

This is a great question. I have to admit the products I love the most are the ones that are the simplest to use: the Gold Probe, DP2000 dew pointer, and PGA portable three-gas analyzer. These three products are used everywhere in the world. Each one has an immediate payback and requires very little training to use. We do have many other much more technical products that frankly are more impressive but when I walk into a heat treat and need to solve a problem it is usually one of those three that provides the solution. Another product that is a workhorse and continues to deliver great value to customers is our data acquisition product, SuperDATA. The amount of data being collected on a daily basis by captive and commercial heat treaters is pretty incredible. One heat treat facility alone can have a million data points captured in one day and if I think about all the heat treat shops running SuperDATAday in and day out, it’s truly impressive. I cannot point to any one product as “brilliant” but I do look at all of them as tools utilized by all heat treaters providing value and giving them the ability to deliver quality parts efficiently.

Jim recently SSi has been making some very impressive investments-what can you tell us about them?

Gord, we are always looking for opportunities to invest conservatively which allows us to grow and effectively deliver new products and services to the industry. Infrastructure is needed to make that happen and for us that means people and space. Our facility has expanded in Cincinnati to accommodate a leaner manufacturing space , which was timely for the manufacturing of our electronic flow meters. During this expansion, we also focused on enhancing our laboratory to support ourISO/IEC17025 accreditation with environmentally-controlled production areas. We also have the equipment to perform nitriding and FNC process development along with lab equipment for metallugicalevaluation of test parts. In Mexico, we moved into a new facility, which has also provided us a laboratory environment, provided more space for our employees, and storage for our products, allowing us to more efficiently meet customer demand. Most recently, we finished renovating our main office to accommodate a friendlier modern workspace with a state of the art conference and training center. This really gives us great space to present our technology to customers and it gets put to good use during our quarterly training where customers and business partners come to Cincinnati to take a deeper dive into learning our products.

Steve you have done a tremendous job of building up the company over the years-when you look back what are you most proud of? I have to ask you this also-did you ever expect the company would be as large as it is today?

I am most proud of the people I work with. I have surrounded myself with very smart and professional individuals. The company is a result of a great team internally complimented by excellent representatives and partners around the world. We have never reorganized or changed our direction.The foundation for our success is getting everyone on the same page when it comes to taking care of the customer and staying current with technology. I love the technical competency of our team at SSI and the excitement triggered when we put a plan in place to enhance or develop products. The company is larger than what I thought it would be back in 1995. Having said that I believe we will double the size in the next 10 to 15 years based on the solutions and global market we have available today.

Jim or Steve what is your number one worry about running the company?

Gord, the thing that keeps me up the most at night is taking care of the customer and making sure we are providing a good experience for our employees. The ideal experience for the employee is providing the best benefits possible, challenging them in their day-to-day operations to keep things interesting,and keeping them safe. Customer service is the backbone of what we do at Super Systems and we instill that in all areas of our business. With so many products and so many customers in the market it is quite an effort to make sure that you’re constantly listening to the all the concerns, needs, and issuesand are able to address them efficiently. I feel we have a great team to make this happen, but it is always a concern. Staying current with technology and competition is not far behind that. Again, having a team in place that pushes us to make sure that we are current and make sure that we take care of the customer makes this less worrisome.

Steve and Jim many times over the years I have done interviews with furnace builders and I always like to ask them what type of furnaces they see as experiencing the most growth in the future. With all due respect to the furnace builders I sometime feel it is not fair to ask a vacuum guy as an example if he thinks there will be more growth in atmosphere furnaces rather than vacuum furnaces and visa/versa. You deal with all types of furnaces-what type or style of furnace do you expect to grow the most in the next few years?

I believe we will continue to see both atmosphere and vacuum grow along with FNC and Nitriding. Today more than ever, there is a demand to meet industry specifications, keep equipment up to date, and most of all keep it safe. As a result, we will continue to see opportunities to update and replaceoutdated and older equipment with today’s current technology. The technology aspect is a significant driver for our growth. Looking at today’s marketplace, automation is a goal for many based on the labormarket. Other technology benefits include harnessing the data from sensors and controls for better decision making. I do believe the vacuum market will have a higher growth rate than atmosphere partly because there is a large amount of atmosphere capacity in the global market today, there are manufacturing processes and materials that lend themselves to vacuum heat treatment, and vacuum has a potentially cleaner footprint. Although the nitriding and FNC market is smaller than traditional atmosphere, we are seeing these applications growing at the fastest pace which we think is driven from the lower distortion rates during heat treating, increase in wear and corrosion resistance, and in some cases aesthetics of the finished part.

Our previous question mentioned furnace builders. Do you work with most of the OEM’s or do you find they like to offer their own control systems?

We do work with many OEMs. We are fortunate to have such a wide variety of products so even when an OEM has their own system, they may incorporate some of our products in the overall control solution. Good examples of this would be probes, gas analyzers, flow meters and discrete controllers. What makes our control packages unique is our ability to create a standard solution providing unique benefits to the users. We build this directly into our controls and when an OEM does incorporate our controls, these features are built in.

Times have been good, as a matter of fact extremely good in the heat treating industry for the past few years. Do you expect the rest of 2019 and 2020 to be as good? Better? Worse?

This is the most asked question. If you asked me in 2017 what 2018 would look like I would have been wrong. If you asked me in 2018 what 2019 would look like I would have been wrong. Do you sense the trend? I think we are due for a pullback. I hope I am wrong.

What does the future hold for you personally and for the company? Any plans you can share with us?

I often think about the growth over the last 24 years. I think about the company when we only had a handful of products and a small staff. Today we have multiple offices with many products, which are allcomplimented by software and end-to-end systems. The desire of heat treaters and manufacturers is tostay current with technology combined with a global market; I believe we will double the size of the company in the next ten to fifteen years. To get there, we will continue to do what I believe we do best, listening to customers and using technology to develop products and solutions that help our customers stay competitive and deliver quality parts efficiently.

I very much appreciate the time. Thanks, Gord

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here

Mr. Slawomir Wozniak, President CEO of SECO/WARWICK Interview

We are very pleased to be able to offer you this interview with Mr. Slawomir Wozniak who very recently became President & CEO of furnace creator SECO/WARWICK. First off Slawomir I would like to congratulate you on your recent promotion to President & CEO of SECO/WARWICK-it’s a very impressive achievement at a relatively young age.

Thank you. It is a great honour to assume leadership of the Company, which I have been associated with since the beginning of my professional career.

We met a few weeks ago at the Thermprocess exhibition in Dusseldorf, Germany and at the time we announced your promotion and provided some background about your career. However some people might have missed this-could you please give us a brief outline of your work career?

For 25 years, I’ve been connected with the SECO/WARWICK Group, observing the organisation’s culture in various parts of the world, gaining rich sectoral, industrial, and corporate experience.

My career at SECO/WARWICK started with an apprenticeship as an electrician. After graduating from the Institute of Electrical Engineering at the University of Zielona Góra, I became a Service Engineer. Throughout the years I assumed different positions – Deputy Manager of CAB, of Managing Director of SECO/WARWICK Retech China, Chief Operating Officer of the SECO/WARWICK Group to name a few.

Tell us a few things about SECO/WARWICK-size of the company, products offered etc., markets served and how the company is organized.

SECO/WARWICK is a global technological leader in innovative heat processing solutions. Provides standard or customized state-of-the-art heat processing equipment and technologies to leading companies in the following industries: automotive, aerospace, electronics, tooling, medical, recycling, energy including nuclear, wind, oil, gas, and solar and production of steel, titanium and aluminum. Expertise includes end-to-end solutions in 5 categories: vacuum heat treatment, atmosphere and aluminum thermal processing, controlled atmosphere brazing of aluminum heat exchangers and vacuum metallurgy. SECO/WARWICK Group has 9 operating companies located on three continents with customers in nearly 70 countries.

You mentioned that you have five groups which focus on different heat treat technologies. It is possible that this is unprecedented in the furnace building industry and leads to the question; is this a good thing or does it mean that you can’t give the attention to some areas that you would like? In other words are you spreading yourself too “thin” by being able to offer all of these different types of equipment?

SECO/WARWICK Group expertise includes end-to-end solutions in 5 categories, where each is managed by a separate team of well-trained and specialized experts. 60% of SECO/WARWICK employees are engineers who are developing technologies and products according to clients needs and industries requirements. The fact that SECO/WARWICK has different business groups gives company and its client a wider capabilities, offer and a unique competitive edge, hard to gain from a narrow-speciality-company.

Thanks to this, SECO/WARWICK is a leader on the market of heat treatment of metals, an innovator who, together with numerous research institutes, defines new award-winning solutions, offering equipment along with modern technology tailored to the needs, possibilities and requirements of individual clients and the industry. Efficient logistics, delivery, assembly and commissioning of equipment, service in every corner of the world, technical and technological trainings, an international team of experts and specialists all result from the need for continuous development. It is inscribed in DNA from the very beginning of the company existence and present at every moment and every thought.

Out of the different furnace groups which is the largest in terms of sales?

In 2018, the largest increase in sales was recorded by the American company, Retech LLC, which generated PLN 143 million in revenues, which means an increase in sales by as much as 62%. It is worth mentioning that SECO/VACUUM Technologies LLC, which has been in operation for only two years, has achieved a significant increase in sales, operating and offering solutions for heat treatment of metals in controlled atmosphere and vacuum in the US market. Its annual revenue is PLN 36m. Higher business traffic is being observed in automotive market, which for SECO/WARWICK Group translated into higher interest in Controlled Atmosphere Brazing (CAB) Line, which has become the preferred joining technology for battery cooling plates within the hybrid electric vehicles (HEV) and electric vehicles (EV) market. The automotive market, which currently is both very vibrant and demanding, provides the product demand for 30% of SECO/WARWICK customers.

I am sure you have quite a few ideas about what changes you would like to make to the company. What can you share with us?

As I have already indicated during our meeting at Thermprocess, Seco/Warwick went through various transformations and business developments over last 2 years and taking that into consideration and looking on current business conditions I do not see at the moment a need for further organizational changes. Instead I would like the company to concentrate on further development of internal operational processes and overall quality which should benefit with higher satisfaction of our customers. I would like to also see ourselves more active in the aftermarket segment especially in US and Asian markets therefore there might be a need for some further tuning of our business units in that locations.

Slawomir I am going to try and pin you down on this question-out of all the technologies SECO can offer which do you think has the brightest future? Vacuum hardening, nitriding, rotary retort are a few that come to mind.

The new future of our product portfolio I can see in our two new products launched at the Thermprocess. Both solutions (Super IQ and UCM 4D Quench) destroy rules, revolutionize the industry and suit the most demanding industries. These inventions will solve every day heat treat problems. The Super IQ (integral or sealed quench furnace), which is one of the two new products, offers all of the benefits of low pressure carburizing and vacuum hardening with none of the added costs. The system combines clean processing with the exceptional performance of oil quenching in the industry’s most innovative integral quench furnace design in decades. With a Super IQ, users get super clean parts while still getting the benefit of a simple atmosphere oil quench.

The second one, the UCM® 4D Quench® enables customers with gas quenchable materials to replace oil quenching with an environmentally friendly, cost effective technology. It provides a solution that eliminates the need for press quenching systems and the problems associated with their operation. What problems?  First of all, no more finishing treatment to remove the oxidized layer. Secondly, it provides parts with higher surface quality and savings due to eliminating the need for heat treatment fixtures and material logistics. Last but not least, eliminates oil and oil vapor contamination, ensuring personnel safety and environmental impact in addition to eliminating washers and chemicals.

At SECO/WARWICK we approach each project individually – a client often looks for a solution that requires cooperation between different segments we are aware of it, that’s why having 5 business segments creates huge advantage for us.

The last question prompts this one; recently SECO/WARWICK has been heavily promoting your rotary retort equipment as an alternative to mesh belt lines. Many including myself feel that rotary retorts are an old technology. What are you doing differently that leads you to believe that rotary furnaces have a great future ahead of them?

There are various benefits we can find using rotary retort furnace instead of mesh belt type solution. Lower operating cost through energy savings and lower maintenance cost, installation & footprint advantages thanks of smaller footprint and no-pit requirements and metallurgical benefits achieved through improved temperature uniformity profile and even load distribution just to name a few.

We’ve spoken a little about technologies and which you believe are growing-what about geography? In other words in what area of the world do you see the most growth for SECO/WARWICK?

The largest increase in sales was recorded by the American company Retech LLC, which generated PLN 143 million in revenues, which means an increase in sales by as much as 62%. SECO/VACUUM Technologies LLC, operating only two years ago, has achieved a significant increase in sales, operating and offering solutions for heat treatment of metals in controlled atmospheres and vacuum in the US market. Its annual revenue is PLN 36m.

Therefore, it is not surprising that, geographically, the US market had the largest share in the sales of the SECO/WARWICK Group and accounted for 38% of the Group’s total sales. At the same time, sales in this market increased by 29% in 2018 – compared to 2017. The European Union market, where the Company has its registered office, accounted for 32% of the Group’s sales in 2018.

As President & CEO you have an enormous amount of responsibility which I would image at times can be quite stressful. If you had to pick one thing which keeps you awake at night what would it be?

You are right that being responsible for an organization can be sometimes quite stressful. However the regular business challenges do not bother me too much as based on my experience there is always some solution which can be worked out if you are surrounded and supported by a strong team of fully committed and enthusiastic experts as I am. The most difficult challenges I see are those related mainly with the global geo-political risks which are completely out of your control and can unexpectedly and significantly hit your business. We are served almost every day with an economic and political information which one day can be taken as an opportunity but another day can be converted to the threat.

I am always surprised when visiting exhibitions at the number of furnace builders there actually are. In your opinion are there too many builders out there? Do you think it might lead to some consolidation in the industry?

I look on the competitors as something good in business what keeps you awake and motivate for continuous improvement and development. However if there is too many players and especially newcomers there is always a risk, that customers who attracted by a low price buy the equipment from unknown supplier, have to finally take a painful lesson for their wrong decision.

Heat treatment market is a large enough to accommodate many players and we can see a natural segmentation of the furnace builders where most of them can fit to the right territory, industry sector and technology advancement level. Consolidation can create some benefits to the business only under the condition that all related with it risks are properly addressed and managed, e.g. overlapping portfolios, markets divisions, cultural differences, know how transfer just to name a few. So I believe that like in many other industries there will be some further mergers and acquisitions in our industry but not every case will pay off and sustain.

This question stems from the last one; just yesterday it was announced that Tenova sold their HTC Group to Ningbo Qijing of China. The HTC Group consisted of 4 companies, all based in Europe who manufacture top end furnaces. This is the first time I can think of that a “western” furnace builder has been bought by a Chinese company. Do you see this as a trend?

Since I lived in China for a several years it is not a big surprise to me that finally Chinese company has taken over a “western” furnace builder. There is more industry sectors where it is more and more difficult to see the difference in the technological advancement between Chinese and western companies. We can see in China also very high expenditures on the R&D and investment in the key technologies required for the development of key industry sectors like aerospace, automotive, energy, etc. When we combine it with a huge available capital there should be an easy prediction that we may expect a further interest of Chinese investors in “western” companies including furnace builders.

SECO/WARWICK has always been very innovative when it comes to new technologies-I can’t recall a show where S/W wasn’t introducing a new technology and the last show was no exception. Could you share what you showed me?

We are currently witnessing unprecedented changes taking place in various branches and industries. Technological possibilities open new doors, but also bring new challenges. Augmented reality, algorithms supporting the decision-making process, predictive maintenance systems, repairs, workshops and cooperation in different time zones, AI and IoT usage in production processes are only some of the factors and trends that make up Industry 4.0 and specifically, Heat Treatment 4.0. Growing industry needs result in developing new approaches to process improvements, and SECO/WARWICK understands this very well. Therefore with a new, strong product portfolio, we continue to present solutions that are unique in the manufacturing world. Being in the top five companies in this industry obliges us to do so.

Thermprocess was a huge and exciting event, during which you cannot miss equally large and exciting product announcements. Visitors to the SECO/WARWICK booth were not disappointed. Apart from current flagship products, the company showed new ones: Super IQ® and UCM® 4D Quench mentioned above.

And last but not least, what do you predict for the heat treating industry in the next 10 years?

10 years is a long period and we know that with uncertain, fast changing and technologically developing world it is not easy to predict such a distant future. I think that 5 years timeframe can be more reliable for prediction but still with some reserve. Considering the directions and trends we can expect significant development and application on industrial scale of additive manufacturing. This would bring us a significant demand for sintering and annealing applications. It would also require a higher capacity for the metal powder making equipment.

The further growth of Electrical Vehicles demand should also impact strongly our industry where some pros (new demands for heat transfer management – aluminum battery coolers) and cons (less requirement for general heat treatment) can be foreseen.

We should also expect a further growth of aviation industry (especially in Asia) where new aviation components manufacturers should come up on the market to serve airplane builders.

There should be also more and more global pressure to use more eco-friendly heat treatment equipment. It means that “clean” heat treatment processes mainly based on Vacuum equipment should gradually replace atmosphere furnaces where polluting emissions are usually observed.

CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS

905.271.0033

Click Here