Mr. Dan Reardon

Director of Technical Sales, Abbott Furnace Company


Dan I have been looking forward to speaking with you about Abbott Furnace Company, I just regret that it can’t be in person because of COVID, hopefully in the near future. In these very strange times I want to ask you what is probably the most asked question in the world these days-how is business for you?

Our business is doing okay. We our working on our backlog. We are seeing some uncertainty in some sectors while others continue to be strong. The election has contributed to this along with COVID.

What’s your background Dan?

I graduated from Penn State with a degree in Mechanical Engineering Technology. I started working for Rockwell International in the R&D Lab. I was there for 15 years before coming to Abbott. While at Rockwell I continued my Education and obtained a degree in Electrical Engineering Technology.

How did you get involved in the industry and end up at Abbott?

I was ready for a change and since I live in the PM world capital, I decided to get involved in something related to that. Abbott was a growing company with a lot of potential so I joined then in 1993.

What does your typical day entail?

We start everyday with a review of our current projects to make sure we deal with any issues that arise so we can stay on schedule. Since COVID the rest of the day consists of several online meetings with staff and customers. Since our equipment is custom designed we spend considerable time on engineering reviews and discussions.

With your title of Director of Technical Sales I would imagine that at least pre COVID your position involved a lot of travel but I am guessing on that.

You are correct. Pre COVID travel was at least 50% of the time.

When I think of Abbot rightly or wrongly I think of sintering applications, such as mesh belt sintering furnaces. Perhaps this is because you are located in St. Marys, PA the powdered metal capital of the world. Is that impression right or wrong?

This is somewhat correct. Sintering is still a very big part of our business but we were able to build on this to and expand into other markets. Sintering is one of the most complex processes for a furnace design, so it made branching out into other areas much easier. We understand atmosphere control very well which is critical to all processes from heat treating to stainless steel brazing.

Perhaps it would be easiest if you could tell us tell us about Abbott, the history of the company, the products you offer and the size of the company.

Abbott was founded in 1982 as Abbott Control Systems. We built our first furnace in 1986. Since then we have built over 900 furnaces. We purchased Drever in 1986 which allowed us to expand our furnace capabilities.

Over the course of the past year your company has sent us several rather interesting press releases. Going from memory I recall a press release about a new product for Abbott, an Endothermic generator and also a news item about a Roller Hearth Tube annealing installation. Lets start off with the generator-what prompted you to start offering this product line, especially considering that a number of companies in North America also offer generators?

With the acquisition of Drever, we obtained several generator designs. To support our customers, we looked at current generator designs and reviewed with them their likes, dislikes and wish lists. Our engineering team then set out to incorporate as many of the changes as possible. Energy efficiency as well at atmosphere quality and control were two of Abbott’s primary goals. We achieved all of these with the new design.

I also recall the press release about a roller hearth furnace line, can you share some details with us about what this project involved?

Drever had a great reputation for building high quality roller hearth annealing furnaces. Abbott utilized Drever designs and upgraded and modernized them to meet todays process requirements. We were able to make substantial improvements in all areas of the design. This allowed us to meet the customers requirements for a ASTM 2750 accredited furnace with a rapid quench system to meet their stringent metallurgical requirements.

Abbott is offering some new products which include the “Vulcan Delube System”-what is this exactly and where did the name come from?

Vulcan is the Roman god of Metal working/ metallurgy. One of the biggest problems in Powdered Metal is the delubrication of the parts prior to sintering. The Vulcan is a paradigm shift in how this process is performed. We are able to independently control all the variables needed such as time ate temp, atmosphere, and addition of oxidizing component to deal with the lubricant. It works well with light loads or very heavy large parts.

Another new product for your company is the “Nautilus” system for lubricant removal and strengthening the compact for soft magnetic composites. Care to share some details about this system?

The Nautilus furnace was designed to meet the time, temperature and atmosphere requirements necessary to process powder metal parts manufactured for the soft magnetics market. We see this as a growing market with the electrification of vehicles and continuous need for more efficient electric motors.

As I go over these questions one thing which jumps out at me is that Abbott has added several new product lines to your offerings in a fairly short period of time-why? Do you feel that the traditional market for sintering furnaces is becoming saturated or are looking for more solutions for your customers?

We still see growth potential in PM and continue to work to advance this industry as you can see by the development of the Vulcan and Nautilus. We added the roller hearth to compliment our existing base and to allow growth into other markets and it leveraged our Drever IP.

Where are your customers? From past press releases you seem to have a strong presence in Mexico in addition to the US market (and I should add the Canadian market also as I have seen several examples of your products in my home country)-what about outside of North America?

We supply furnaces worldwide including China, Taiwan, South Korea, Germany, and many other EU countries. Our goal is to be able to supply the best equipment available with the lowest cost of ownership to our customers wherever they are located.

This a totally unfair question and one which I shouldn’t be asking but what do you think 2021 is going to be like for Abbott in particular and the furnace industry in general? If it makes it easier I will even go first-I firmly believe that next year will see substantial growth in manufacturing and consequently heat treating-but perhaps I am leading the witness as they say.

I would like to agree with you, but I don’t. I believe there are too many uncertainties for which we don’t know the outcome yet. Getting the pandemic under control would certainly help. We don’t know what is going to happen with a new President taking over. What will happen with the taxes and regulations on business?

Dan I really enjoyed speaking with you and I hope our paths continue to cross for many years. Sincerely, Gord


Mr. Scott Puhalsky

Vice President of Sales for Cleveland Electric Laboratories


Scott, I have been looking forward to talking to you and learning more about Cleveland Electric but first I want to ask how you are doing these days? How has COVID affected you and your family?

“It has certainly been an interesting year for us all. Each of us has handled things differently; I tend to immerse myself in work as a general distraction for outside noise in my life. That is not always easy. My wife and I are learning to work with potential home schooling for our youngest, and our two college kids that may or may not make it through a full semester. We have older parents that are concerned. In general, we are missing life as it was. But with change comes opportunity. For me, that means coming out of this better and stronger. I have enjoyed time with family so much more, from walks and talks to just re-connecting with each other. At work I have also been reminded of the daily value in each of our employees — their presence and input and passion.”

“Cleveland Electric Laboratories was established in Cleveland, Ohio in 1920. At that time, the primary focus was to service and repair electric meters for railroads and local Cleveland industries. Over time, field service became a more prevalent part of our business. At the request of customers, as well as our own requirements for higher quality thermocouples in our service work, CEL began to design and build thermocouples. Eventually the business model shifted exclusively to thermocouples as we began selling to a wide range of industries. What started as a small service and repair business has grown to be the global leader in industrial thermocouples and home to over 100 employees.”

I understand you have two locations, the one in Twinsburg, Ohio and a second, Advanced Technologies Group, in Tempe, Arizona-what is the story behind the Arizona location?

“CEL was looking to expand our physical footprint, create duplicity in manufacturing capability, and complement our existing product offering to our primary customer base, so in 2004 we opened our Advanced Technologies Group in Tempe, Arizona. Realizing that turbine engine manufacturers for both aerospace and power generation perform extensive testing for new designs and are constantly in search of greater efficiencies for existing models, CEL wanted to position itself to support these testing initiatives. Cleveland Electric Labs began fabricating specialty temperature and pressure probes, in addition to performing modification machining of customer components and offering engineering and installation of temperature, pressure and strain gauges on engine components.”

Our focus at “The Monty” as you know is the heat treatment industry, so this question is specifically dedicated to the heat treatment industry. What products do you offer to captive and commercial heat treaters and industry suppliers such as furnace builders?

“Cleveland Electric Labs is proud of its history and relationship in the heat treatment industry. Since our company is rooted in the service industry, we continually focus on how the customer uses our product, and how we can partner with them to meet or exceed expectations that are critical to them. We consider raw materials, accuracy, drift, response time, longevity, lead times and pricing. We work with significant industrial furnace manufacturers to understand form, fit, and function. In short, if it is an industrial thermocouple, then we make it, but our expertise has moved towards high temperature (control or high limit sensors) and critical–to–quality builds.”

How do you sell your products? Direct salespeople? Manufacturers reps? Distributors?

“Our sales strategy is clean and simple – CEL sells direct. All the staff operates as a team and is salary based. The group all has the same goal: to diligently serve our customers, having their best interests in mind. If we can move a customer from a type ‘S’ to type ‘K’ for their application, I do not want our staff to ever think about how a decrease is sales dollars may affect their overall compensation. For that reason, any potential commission structure is removed from consideration. Our group is measured based on the longevity of our relationships, and the ability to retain, foster and grow them.”

At this point I want to mention that the company is celebrating a very impressive anniversary this year, one which only a handful of companies in this industry can match-please tell us about it.

“A century of business is certainly a milestone that we do not take lightly. Under the leadership of Fred Lieske, who became President in 1954, followed by his son Jack Lieske in 1981, then the appointment of Alan Seymour in 2019, the business was built on a foundation of faith, family, and service. Our customers are truly considered partners, and our employees are CEL family. We have extremely high employee retention, which offers us a continuity in knowledge and customer familiarity that is invaluable in today’s uncertain conditions.”

Scott I am going to play Devil’s advocate for a moment and make a rather provocative statement, isn’t a thermocouple a thermocouple? Now before you get annoyed at me let me rephrase this a bit, how much difference can there be between a thermocouple made by Company X as opposed to one made by Company Z-what sets yours apart from others?

“It is fair to question if a difference exists between manufacturers, especially if a thermocouple is classified as MRO and is not considered critical–to–quality. It is important to realize that the ramifications of a “bad” thermocouple can be catastrophic. A customer selects a supplier based on price, quality, and delivery. These buying criteria are unique to everyone, and as a manufacturer of custom products we must balance the significance of each. For CEL, quality takes precedent over all else, as much of our business requires elevated standards. We also have a constant eye toward reduction in “Per Heat Cost”—how we extend the service life of our thermocouple while maximizing performance. This is generally achieved through thoughtful collaboration and by carefully listening to our customers’ needs.”

What is a typical order for you Scott? For instance, are your customers buying a few small items from you at a time or is it more typical that a customer will place an order for their thermocouple requirements for the next year? This question leads to another one, are you mainly dealing with end users, captives and commercials or is more of your business with furnace builders and industry suppliers?

“Cleveland Electric Labs sells thousands of line items to a wide range of industries. We support long-term agreements, blanket orders, and spot buys for customers. Our relationships are not overly selective or targeted, as diversification across industries is something we value, especially in today’s market. CEL targets end users, captive and commercial heat treat, and furnace builders. Our business model supports a direct relationship as much as possible, reducing the risk of misinformation and increasing our ability to give the customer exactly what they want—from performance and certification to packaging, product identification, serialization and more.”

Has the technology behind thermocouples changed much over the years? This of course leads to the next question which is; do you see any changes on the horizon when it comes to measuring temperatures in furnaces? Anything exciting which you can share with us?

“The technology behind thermocouples is nearly 200 years old, with CEL existing for over half of that timespan. The general purpose of simply achieving a temperature reading has elevated to the adherence to strict quality standards, both internally and industry/customer mandated. There is a constant effort to raise temperatures, increase longevity, reduce diameter, and improve accuracy. The industry is trending, as it should, towards value-added relationships. We believe that there are many suppliers that can give a customer what they ask for. We make it our business to give them what they need. We make the effort to understand our customers business as if it is our own.”

I owe you a bit of an apology here Scott, I didn’t ask the most important question of all; what is your background and how did you end up as VP of Sales for Cleveland Electric Laboratories?

“The short answer: family. I grew up with Cleveland Electric Labs. My father, Ron Puhalsky, was with CEL for over forty years. I spent time as a teenager at CEL, learning the product before going to college. I worked as a financial analyst for a short time before I realized that I did not want a desk job, and I was fortunate to have General Electric in Cleveland offer me a position in sales, managing a distribution channel with Grainger. Both companies taught me a lot, but I eventually moved into medical sales. Opportunities for advancement in that field required relocation, and that was not attractive to my young family. I joined the sales team at CEL again in 2007. CEL was good for my father and has been great for my family as well.”

Our final question has to do with the state of the industry. This have been a very upsetting and disappointing year for just about everyone and we all have been forced to change the way we do business. What changes have you made to sell, market, and produce your products?

“This year has been a challenge for both employers and employees alike. All of us have been tasked with navigating constant uncertainty and the toll that takes has been significant. For CEL, 2019 was a record year, and the first quarter of 2020 was even better. The economy was strong and our customers were challenged to keep up with demand. Investments were made in new employees, furnaces, buildings, and the like. No industry was fully prepared for this, but we are doing our best to overcome each challenge as it comes. We are finding new business and working to create diversification without moving too far from our core. We have reduced lead times, increased inventory, and stayed strong. We are optimistic about our business and our industry, as well as our next century of service.”

Scott I very much appreciate the time and I look forward to the time when we can get together in person again, shake hands and do things the way we use to.


Mr. Mrinal Nandi

Hofmann Engineering in Australia


Back in 2018 we ran across a very interesting fellow by the name of Mrinal Nandi who at the time was a metallurgist in India who was looking for a change. Fast forward and today Mrinal is a metallurgist in Australia who is going to tell us a bit about the heat treatment industry in Australia amongst other things.

Mrinal I just gave a very brief summary about your career, perhaps you could tell us how you got into the industry and how you ended up moving from India to Australia.

First of all, I would like to thank TheMonty.com for this opportunity to share my background, work  experience and present my employer, Hofmann Engineering, on this prestigious platform. I completed my engineering degree at one of the oldest Engineering Colleges in Gujarat, India. From there, I obtained a campus placement as Trainee with FAG Bearing India Ltd (Schaeffler Group) for 1 year before a permanent placement in the heat treatment department, where I remained for the next 5 years.

One of my professional passions is the automotive sector and I aspired to work in this fast paced, highly competitive industry. That opportunity came with Mahindra Automotive, one of the most reputable organizations in India that manufactures products for the global automotive market. Before moving to Australia I was working with Auto Auxiliary Giant Bosch India Ltd (Bosch Group) as department head- Heat Treatment for 5 years.  In 2018, I received and offer I simply could not refuse and moved to Australia under an employer sponsorship program as skills and experience are in high demand for my field.

A few years back I spent some time in Australia for a mixture of business and pleasure. One of the companies I had planned on visiting was your current employer Hofman Engineering, however due to the vastness of the country this did not come to pass. Please share with us some information about Hofman, particularly as it relates to heat treating.

Since 1969 Hofmann Engineering has provided specialist engineering services to Australia’s industry leaders. Quality Assurance accreditation by Lloyds (LRQA) complements total quality culture. Hofmann Engineering is committed to continuous quality improvement which touches every aspect of products, services, and customer support. Hofmann Engineering staff and management alike pursue a single goal – a total focus on quality in every aspect of manufacture, customer service and on time delivery. We believe in continuous improvement and always working at being the engineering and technological leader in our industries. Our individual skills and experience are what underlies our reputation as a totally self-contained engineering company with all resources “under one roof”.

How about processes offered? Do you see any limitations on what is available in Australia?

Hofmann Engineering owns four large factories in Australia as well as factories in North and South America. In Perth, the company headquarters, the company has a large heat treatment operation: Our largest is a carburising furnace with working chamber of 1.9m diameter and 4.8m deep from Aichelin. Other carburising and nitro carburising furnaces are 0.9m diameter x 1.8m deep, 0.6m diameter x 0.8m deep and 2 off 0.3m diameter x 0.6m deep in the form of fluid bed furnaces by quality heat treatment.

The Perth facility also made significant investment into induction hardening with a complete ABB robotic induction hardening cell, 1 off EMA tooth by tooth gear hardener, 1 off large capacity Radyne pin hardener and 2 off variable frequency induction hardeners. We also have a large portable induction hardening unit for re- hardening rope drums in situ. Finally in the heat treatment area we have an assortment of quench and temper, cryogenic, salt bath, draw furnace, blackening and shot blast.

In the fabrication area we have extremely large PWHT and stress-relieve furnaces in the form of a top hat 4.6m diameter x 2m high and a box furnace 14m x 14m x 4m high. Our eastern state factories in Bendigo and Newcastle have specialist PWHT for railway bogies on a large scale among other smaller heat treatment capabilities. One limitation I can see is that manufacturing costs relatively high in Australia due to factors like power, labour and geographically long supply chains. Having said that, Hofmann Engineering competes globally with up to 50% of sales for export.

How would you sum up the future of heat treating both captive and commercial in the country? Do you believe it can look forward to a bright future with steady growth or the opposite?

I believe the future of captive and commercial heat treating in Australia is bright. The reasons are that the current government is launching key policies in defence, resources, power, transport and other sectors as part of the post COVID recovery plan that will stimulate local, in-country manufacturing. It is a great time to realise the potential within Australian manufacturing. In fact Hofmann Engineering will invest in heat treatment equipment in the coming years and upgrade exiting processing units with SCADA monitoring and automated controls.

How about differences in heat treatment processes in India and Australia? I have always thought heat treating is heat treating no matter where you go but you have far more firsthand knowledge than I.

Heat treatment scope in India is vast due to the automotive, agriculture and textile industries.  The automotive industry plays a pivotal role in driving the heat treatment market in the country. Various parts and components of an automobile undergo a variety of heat treatment processes, hence, the heat treatment sectors has been fueled by the significant growth in automotive industry.

Secondly, favorable government policies such as Make in India, StartUp India, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), and Goods and Services Tax have attracted significant investments from large overseas multi-nationals adding to the demand for heat treatment.

Australian heat treatment industry is far smaller than India’s and a direct comparison between the two countries is difficult. None the less, you are correct in saying that the principles of heat treatment are the same regardless of country and, from my perspective, the only significant differences are in the size and volume of parts processed. This obviously impacts on the equipment and process choice that companies in the two countries must invest in to be competitive.

Seeing as how it is a fairly small market do these pose problems when it comes to equipment suppliers, spare parts or service?

You are correct; we have very limited resources for equipment supply, spare parts and service, and the fact that Perth is the most isolated city in world we have long supply chains to deal with as well. This has driven Hofmann Engineering to become self-reliant in many respects with the ability to perform servicing and upgrades in-house.

This leads to another question, who in Australia does service and support heat treating?

Most of our essential consumables come from NSW and Victoria. Regarding service we have 1 or 2 specialist companies in Western Australia who provide local spares and services for heat treatment furnaces. 

On a final note do you expect to see any substantial changes going forward?

As mentioned above, if the government can stimulate manufacturing and allow Australia to realise its’ full manufacturing potential then there are substantial opportunities on the horizon. On a lighter note, there is a great sporting rivalry between India and Australia on the cricket field. I do not see much change there as India will remain the most loved, most supported team in the world!

Did you like this article? Click here to subscribe to The Monty.


Mr. Hans-Joachim Wickert

Managing Director of Wickert Maschinenbau


Press Quenching (also known as fixture hardening) has long been known as a technology to reduce distortion in parts and is typically found in captive heat treating departments of gear or bearing manufacturers. Today we speak with Mr. Hans-Joachim Wickert, Managing Director of Wickert Maschinenbau one of the leading providers of Press Quenching systems.

Lets start with some background about you and your company. Perhaps you could share with us the history of Wickert, the size of the company and your part in it?

“Wickert was founded in 1901 by Jakob Wickert, who was my grandfather. Originally he made forging presses for horseshoes. His business was located in the town of Landau which at the time was a garrison town which meant a lot of horses for the military which meant a lot of horseshoes. After the 1st World War, the Wickert company, located in the middle of a large wine-growing area, started making wine presses. This production continued until 1945, when it was gradually converted to industrial presses.

Today, Wickert employs 180 people, 25% of whom work in engineering and R & D. From this pool of qualified engineers the company today draws its innovative strength. From a company that only offered press quenches, Wickert has developed into a manufacturer who also offers complete turnkey systems for all aspects of presses. Today I personally take care of the sale of hardening systems and hardening presses and am the technical manager for the company.”

When I think about Wickert I think of press quenches but I realize that is probably unfair as the press quench is only a small part of what you have to offer. It would probably be more fair to say that you offer complete heat treatment solutions with press quenching being one part of a complete system. What would a typical Wickert Heat Treatment system look like and consist of?

“Yes, that is correct. As already mentioned, Wickert today is more a system manufacturer than a pure press quench manufacturer. Today Wickert supplies complete, fully automated hardening systems, primarily for manufacturing gears. A typical Wickert fixture hardening system starts with fully automated loading, followed by pre-washing machines and manipulators for loading the furnace. After the furnace comes the press quenching for which we provide all the fixturing and dies, followed by cooling, washing and transfer to tempering furnaces. After tempering, Wickert integrates clean blasting systems and post-washing machines. At the end of the production chain there are output stations with appropriate buffer systems.

If required, deep-freezing stations can also be integrated into the production process for the complete conversion of residual austenite. All components of the system are incorporated into the Wickert control system. This would include part tracking, process data, datalogging and complete control of the entire system. Interfaces to the customer’s own computer systems are programmed according to customer specifications. Statistical process control enables the customer to set his individual test levels. Wickert thus supplies turn-key systems for component hardening in gear manufacturing with the corresponding planning and deadline tracking capacities.”

Do you manufacture everything? For instance do you build the automation, furnace and associated equipment or do you partner with other companies?

“In order to be able to offer complete systems, we always purchase additional furnaces, blasting machines etc., or the customer provides them and we integrate them into our system control. At the end of the day Wickert provides the total design and is responsible for co ordinating all mechanical and electrical interfaces, start up and project management. 

All automation including handling and loading of parts are designed and manufactured by Wickert. In addition Wickert designs and builds the washing systems, press quench itself and oil return system. It would be fair to say that a complete system is designed and built by Wickert, with some components coming from outside suppliers.”

At this point lets talk about press quenching in some detail. Press quenching is a very high end process and not something that most heat treaters run across on a daily basis. Why would a manufacturer consider this process and what are the most common applications? As an example are you going to see your equipment in automotive transmission applications or would it be more common to see a Wickert system in a bearing facility?

“Lets look at manufacturers of gearboxes and bearings as an example. Manufacturers of gearboxes know that the service life of a gearbox depends upon the precision of each individual component. In addition the efficiency and associated fuel savings also depend upon the precision of each part. The same holds true for bearings, precision is crucial to reducing friction and also reducing weight while maintaining the same performance. In this age of ever more powerful, lighter and environmentally friendly drives, process-safe precision in particular plays an increasingly important role for each component.

To achieve this precision, the parts are hard machined after hardening. As hard machining is expensive, the aim is to reduce this as much as possible. This is made possible by reducing the distortion of the components during hardening to a minimum. The avoidance of distortion results in a reduction of the hardening depth in addition to the reduction of hard machining. All in all, this is also a contribution to a more climate-friendly production of these components. This is why press quenching is so popular in the bearing and gearbox industries-we are able to reduce distortion which reduces hard machining.

The most common method used in gear manufacturing is the so-called mandrel hardening. With this method, the component is shrunk onto a fixed mandrel and thus maintains its roundness and cylindricity. At the same time, hydraulic hold-down devices such as press quenching act on the component to ensure the axial run-out of the component.”

If distortion is the main reason to use press quenching the next obvious question then is what sort of distortion levels can you achieve?

“While most people think of reducing distortion as the main advantage of press quenching this is not entirely true-metallurgy is also a very large factor. Press quenching can create a homogeneous microstructure property in the part by a targeted flow of the quenching medium to the component. This is of enormous importance, especially in the case of mechanical stress and/or wear resistance.”

What are the largest and smallest parts you have ever processed?

“The largest parts that we have hardened in a press quench so far have a diameter of 1 m (3’) and a weight of up to 75 kg (165 pounds).  The lightest part, on the other hand, weighed only a few 100 grams. When it comes to an entire press hardening system, the largest components measured 1300 x 1400mm (51” X 55”) and had a sheet thickness of up to 150mm (6”)with a component weight of more than 100kg (220 pounds).”

We have spoken about your systems, where they are likely to be found and why a manufacturer would invest in the technology, now lets switch gears slightly and look at the overall market. Would you care to hazard a guess as to how many systems using press quenching are in operation around the world?

“This question is very difficult to answer, as there is a very wide range of applications for press quenching. Therefore, the question cannot be answered in general. But I would guess that there are several thousand systems in operation worldwide, if you include all types and styles of press quench machines.”

Is this a growing market? There are a number of processes available which claim to be able to significantly reduce distortion, bearing that in mind is press quenching growing in popularity?

“The press quenching business is not a growing market, at least not currently. This is not because of press quenching technology, rather a changing market. Largely this is because drive technology is moving away from the internal combustion engine and more and more towards electric drive. Nevertheless, we believe that our systems offer technological advantages over other technologies and that we have the right solutions in the drawer, especially for recording all process parameters in the sense of Industry 4.0.”

Where are the markets for your technology geographically? Being based in Germany I would assume your largest market is in Europe, but beyond that do you do much in Asia or North America? I know that recently we had a press release about a new sales office in the US which caught our attention.

“Yes that’s correct. The European market is the most important market for Wickert next to North America. Especially in America we see a good chance for Wickert to sell more press quench presses and press quenching systems. Therefore we have established a new sales office in Hebron, Kentucky. Our sales manager, Matthew Stachel has been active since January 2020. He is supported by a very experienced service technician who takes care of the after sales service of our machines.”

There are a lot of challenges in the world these days ranging from COVID 19 to growing protectionism to shifting markets. As Managing Director of an international company what do you see as your greatest challenge these days?

“As managing director of a family-owned company, you have to think long term. That is why Wickert is using this period of slower economic development to push ahead with its own technological developments and innovations. By advancing our technology now we will be able to help our customers in the future. In spite of the current political climate I don’t believe that protectionism will hinder us in the future. On the contrary, I think that volatile markets will demand much more flexibility and as a medium-sized enterprise, we can demonstrate this flexibility very well.”

What has 2020 been like for Wickert in terms of sales? Good? Bad? Indiffirent? And what would your prediction for 2021 be?

“In terms of new orders 2020 has been weaker than 2018 and 2019. Having said that Wickert has a very broad base and supplies presses and lines to many different industries. This broad base has so far helped us through the crisis. While it is very difficult to make a forecast for 2021, we are preparing for another weak year.”

Hans-Joachim I appreciate your time today and look forward to a time when we can sit down together and talk in more detail.

“Finally, I would like to thank you, Gord, for giving me the opportunity to report on Wickert Maschinenbau GmbH.”


Mr. Shlok Sundaresh

Engineering Manager-TS USA (HEF Group-North America)


HEF Group, one of the worlds leading providers of Liquid Nitriding and Physical Vapor Deposition Technologies. Today we have An interview with Mr. Shlok Sundaresh, Engineering Manager-TS USA (HEF Group-North America).

Shlok to start off perhaps you could give us some background information about yourself, educational background and work experience in the heat treatment industry?

First and foremost, I would like to thank TheMonty.com for this opportunity to share my background, work experience and about my organization – HEF on this prestigious platform.

I earned my Bachelor’s degree in Metallurgy and Materials Science Engineering in 2012 from one of the oldest engineering colleges in India – College of Engineering Pune. As the Student Treasurer of the Indian Institute of Metals (Pune Chapter) that focused on strengthening the industry-academia relationship, this stint provided an opportunity to get acquainted with the heat treatment industry. I interned in the heat treat department at Bharat Forge Ltd. in 2011 and was fascinated with the potential opportunity in this field! I moved to the United States in 2012 to pursue my Masters in Industrial Engineering with specialization in manufacturing at The Ohio State University. As a Graduate Research Associate, I worked on heat treatment modeling and simulations for industry projects and published several research articles in this field with focus on powder metallurgy and liquid nitriding.  

After graduation, I joined TS USA (Techniques Surfaces USA – HEF Group) in 2014 and have been working here since then. In parallel, I recently completed a one-year executive education program from Stanford – Graduate School of Business focused on leadership and corporate innovation.

TS USA and HEF are companies which I have little personal experience with. Perhaps you could tell us more about the companies, their relationship and what you bring to the heat treatment/surface engineering industries? 

HEF Group, which has been in business for more than 60 years, is headquartered in France and is a leading global provider of surface treatments and coatings for wear, corrosion and friction reduction.  Our two primary surface technology options are Liquid Nitriding and Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD – specifically diamond-like-carbon DLC coatings) – the only supplier that offers both technology options.  In addition, we do offer a whole range of other surface treatments to meet customer specific needs.  HEF is an employee owned company and a majority of our 2,500+ associates are shareholders. 

TS USA (Techniques Surfaces USA) is a subsidiary of HEF Group – jobbing network in the United States offering the above-mentioned services. HEF manufactures its own chemicals and equipment for liquid nitriding and PVD coatings while TS network does the processing activity. To summarize, we are a vertically integrated organization offering value-added surface engineering solutions. 

What has your career progression at TS USA (HEF Group) been? Along the same lines what are the most interesting aspects in your role as a heat treatment engineer?

I joined TS USA (HEF Group) in 2014 as a Process Engineer for its Springfield, Ohio facility offering liquid nitriding treatments and PVD coatings. As our footprint in the US grew, my responsibilities included other facilities offering liquid nitriding treatments across diverse applications. In 2018, I was promoted to the role of Senior Process Engineer leading process development activities for the US organization. During the same period, I was the resident expert for the automotive heat treatment and coatings management system CQI-9 and CQI-12 that are key requirements for heat treat suppliers per IATF 16949. In 2019, I was promoted to the Engineering Manager position responsible for all process engineering activities of the company. Part of my responsibility includes providing technical support to our licensees on the liquid nitriding service side of the business and assisting our customers in North America on application development utilizing our surface treatments.

There are several aspects of my role that I find interesting. To name a few:

  • Visibility and direct impact on application performance with the heat treatment recipe/process developed for our customers.
  • Ability to work on diverse products and market segments where our technology is offered – automotive, industrial machinery, oil & gas, aerospace, medical, firearms, etc.
  • Dealing with what I call a 5P paradigm – Product, Process, Property, Performance and Price!

What are your thoughts on current trends in surface engineering/case hardening technologies? How does HEF Group fit in with these trends? 

Surface engineering and tribology (science of interacting surfaces, study of wear and friction) are still an emerging field globally.  With more innovative and complex systems being designed and manufactured for various demanding applications, along with a stronger drive for continuous efficiency improvements, surface engineering solutions have become crucial for meeting performance standards. This has led to more emphasis on value-oriented solutions vis-à-vis solely cost-oriented ones.  

Traditional case hardening technologies with environmental concerns have now been replaced with advanced, environmentally friendly methods as in case of liquid nitriding solutions offered by HEF.  As a matter of fact, the chemicals/ingredients manufactured and utilized for liquid nitriding processes by HEF are REACH and RoHS compliant. On the other hand, there is growing interest in thin-film deposition methods (PVD/DLC coatings) from a higher hardness, reduced friction and excellent dimensional stability standpoint. With HEF’s DNA in R&D focused on tribology, this has given us the necessary depth and bandwidth to offer technologically innovative, customizable surface engineering solutions to our customers and adapt well with the current market trends. 

Could you explain what advantages you feel your processes have over gas nitriding and other competitive platings?

Nitriding, or nitrocarburizing, can be accomplished using four different media: 1) Liquid; 2) Gas; 3) Plasma; and 4) Fluidized Bed.  All methods are intended to accomplish similar – though not identical results.  However, Liquid (salt-bath) is considered the benchmark for uniformity, consistency, and flexibility. ARCOR® and MELONITE® Liquid Nitriding also provides the best combination of wear and corrosion protection and short processing times (4-5 hours total – compared to 24-hours with gas nitriding).  In addition, Liquid Nitriding is very price competitive with other nitriding options. 

HEF also offers the option of post-nitriding impregnation utilizing various proprietary oils or aqueous polymers to further enhance the corrosion resistance of the nitrided component.  The controlled and customizable surface porosity generated by the ARCOR® Liquid Nitriding process is very effective in retaining the impregnated fluid and increasing the level of corrosion protection.  This impregnation also provides additional surface lubricity which is very beneficial during the break-in operating phase of the component.

In the past, gas and ion/plasma nitriding were the default processes for components with large dimensions (more than 60 inches long) and weights – because Liquid Nitriding furnace sizes were not big enough.  With our new facility in Chattanooga Tennessee, this has changed.  Now customers from a diverse range of segments – O&G, Hydraulic & Pneumatic equipment; miscellaneous industrial machinery – can get their large size parts treated using ARCOR® liquid nitriding – which is the most value-added option for their applications. 

On a side note, HEF’s environmentally friendly liquid nitriding technology along with its enhanced performance has been the go-to process replacing hard chrome platings – which has its environmental challenges with hexavalent chrome. 

Shlok you are a relatively young fellow (and I say this with great respect) what do you see as the opportunities/challenges that a young engineer faces getting into the heat treatment industry? Any words of advice which you can offer? 

Based on my limited experience in the heat treatment industry, there are certainly many interesting aspects to consider as a young engineer. Heat treatment is a core, evergreen field and the entire gamut feels larger than life in industrial environments with massive equipments, furnaces, instrumentation, components, etc.  As a young engineer, one of the main challenges (or rather an opportunity as I see it) is the application of theory to practice. Joining the industry which already has immense practical, application experience can sometimes be overwhelming as a young heat treat engineer. It is thus important to continuously learn on the job, grasp the practicality of heat treatment effectively, gain the required hands-on experience, work together as a team with the more experienced / often underrated shop floor operators and at the same time understand direct impact on applications from customers where such processes are utilized. As a word of advice, I would also recommend having few mentors to look up to and follow in this industry. Their guidance and feedback can be instrumental in shaping one’s career.

In your opinion what are the skills/qualities that a young engineer must possess as he/she gets exposure in our industry? 

The most important quality that a young engineer must possess in my humble opinion is the ability or rather willingness to continuously learn. As we all know – “Knowledge is power”, but true power is to apply what you have learnt and continuously improve! Young engineers need to have an open mind and must pay attention to detail especially in a heat treatment facility. While metallurgy is sometimes abstract to understand unless observed under a microscope, it is important as heat treatment engineers to communicate effectively in simple terms to not just shop floor staff, but also to customers explaining the impact and criticality of the designed processes.

I have spent my entire working life in the heat treatment industry and I find it to be a solid, mature, conservative field where things change relatively slowly. What is your opinion?

I do agree with your assessment of our industry to a great extent – it is certainly solid, mature while conservative with changes taking place relatively slowly. However, with the advancements in technology and recent market trends, many organizations in this industry are in process of constantly adapting to the changing needs of the customer. Stricter government regulations, more stringent quality standards, enhanced performance requirements and complex-integrated systems have resulted in more innovative, technologically advanced and state-of-the-art heat treatment/surface engineering solutions while being cost-efficient at the same time.  Unprecedented times like we are currently in (COVID-19) is one such external factor that has pushed our industry to rapidly change and adapt to a new norm, with most organizations strategically implementing internal changes to strive for a profitable future!

Where do you see yourself in 10 years? 20 years?

As a passionate engineer in the surface engineering service industry, I look forward to continuously learning and utilizing my knowledge and experience, thereby actively contributing to the growth of my organization from a techno-commercial management standpoint. Also, on a more holistic level, I would like to contribute to the development of our heat treatment industry and promote it across universities for the younger generation of engineers to carry the torch forward!


Paul van Doesburg

CEO, Ipsen, Germany


We are very pleased to be able to offer our readers an interview with Mr. Paul van Doesburg, CEO of Ipsen Germany. Paul, I thank you for your time. Let’s start off with your background, how did you become involved in the heat treat industry and end up in the position you are now in?

“Thank you Gord for asking. I grew up in The Netherlands where I earned my Master’s Degree in Mechanical Engineering, majoring in surface treatment. After finalizing another Master’s Degree in Business Administration, I started my career with a shot-blasting and painting equipment manufacturer. This was followed by several positions in plastic surfaces and foils, each time having sales role in those jobs. I came in contact with Ipsen three years ago, and joined the team two years ago. I started as Director of Sales for Ipsen Customer Service, our aftermarket services program, then moved onto the position of Director of Equipment Sales. Last December, I was asked to take over the position of CEO of the Kleve, Germany plant.”

Earlier this year we spoke with two individuals from Ipsen, Mr. Peter Kerbel, VP of Sales and Mr. Pat McKenna, CEO of Ipsen. Both Peter and Patrick are based near Rockford, Illinois, USA, whereas you are based in Germany; so I would like to ask questions more focused on the European market in general and atmosphere furnaces in particular. Please share with us what form Ipsen, Germany, takes. 

“If a company wants to be successful in the market in the long term, it must be proactive to developments and changes. Many of our customers are currently undergoing structural change, and many are suffering particularly badly from the Coronavirus pandemic. We are also recording a reduction in sales. At the same time, the requirements of our customers are changing. We have to continue to adapt as best we can. This strategy will help us to make the company fit for the future despite the circumstances presented by the pandemic.”

“The focus on a single technology area, specialization through our Excellence Centers, promotes faster innovation, performance and quality. Just what our customers expect from us. In addition, we are massively expanding the aftermarket-sales area at all locations because we see increased demand here. That means Ipsen Germany location will exclusively build Atmosphere Batch and Continuous Systems.”

“We offer atmosphere batch-type furnaces together with auxiliary equipment (e.g., endogas generators, washing technology, and low-temperature furnaces), but we also build continuous furnaces like pusher, rotary ring hearth and roller hearth furnaces.”

“Another area we excel in is the automation of complete heat treatment lines. Depending on the furnace type, we offer software solutions like Carb-o-Prof, Conti-Control, and AutoMag. These software packages are all programmed by our own software engineers and are an important part of our product portfolio.”

July 29th, Ipsen issued a press release entitled “Ipsen Group Establishes Excellence Centers” which told us that going forward Ipsen, Germany, would focus on atmosphere furnaces and Ipsen, USA, would concentrate on vacuum equipment. What lead to this decision and what changes will this mean for Kleve?

“Following months of market analysis, the three main drivers are customer demand for expanded technical services, identical metallurgical outcomes worldwide and solutions for processing newly developed materials. These were the main reasons for this step. By creating centers of excellence, we will be able to respond even more closely to the needs of our customers.”

“We also see that the product lines vacuum and atmosphere are becoming more and more different. Whereas software and the range of parts play an essential role in vacuum technology, product logistics and environmental requirements are more important for atmosphere furnace technology.”

“The complexity of our products is getting higher and higher. More sophisticated software with connections, new processes and more complex products to be handled. We need more innovation and at the same time globalization. Globalization in terms of standardization and know-how.”

In Europe and indeed in most of the world Ipsen is extremely well known for both vacuum and atmosphere furnaces. Having said that I would suggest that in North America Ipsen is far better known for vacuum furnaces than atmosphere furnaces. Care to comment?

“We already had quite a high number of success stories in the last couple of years for atmosphere technology in North America, especially in the agriculture, automotive and firearms industries. But, you are right, we want to greatly improve the level of atmosphere awareness in North America.”

“For this reason, Mr. Marcos Garcia is the responsible Sales Manager for the USA. He has been with Ipsen for more than a decade and has extensive experience working in the American market. With his particular expert knowledge in atmosphere and process technology his main focus will be on customer experience and the support of our local sales team to secure the successful growth in the North America market.”

Last year I was fortunate enough to visit your facility for the first time and I was surprised at the size of the plant and the number of furnaces under construction. In a typical year how many furnaces are built in Kleve and what would be a typical product mix? As an example during my visit I saw sealed quench furnaces, a couple of big pushers, vacuums even a few endo generators-is that would you would normally see on your shop floor?

“For an international company like Ipsen, it is important that we offer a product portfolio which allows us to be flexible to market needs. This has not changed. The new structure of the Atmosphere Technology Center of Excellence in Germany and Vacuum Technology Center of Excellence in the USA fosters faster innovation and a laser focus on performance and quality for the whole company. It’s a benefit for our customers.”

As a North American I have seen how the COVID–19 situation has affected various industries. For instance, automotive has certainly suffered but is coming back, aerospace is in for a long, hard road, oil and gas is hurting but the firearms industry is booming. Does this mirror Europe?

“Yes, this largely reflects the situation in Europe. But it is now more important than ever to connect and combine technologies such as advanced data analytics, environmental sustainability, natural resources preservation and the new mobility solutions. These mega trends create future markets. For example, customers from the automotive industry already state requirements in their specifications for power consumption to meet the environmental requirements of tomorrow.”

“We are also registering an enormous demand and growth in customer service. The Ipsen customer service offers an expert advice – 24/7. In addition, we can support our customers with our “Remote Service in Augmented Reality” right now in real-time. Our experts also pass on their knowledge in trainings, which currently take place exclusively in webinar form. All this with the clear objective: to maintain the excellent performance for which Ipsen customers around the world appreciate.”

By the way Paul I have been working under the assumption that most of what you build in destined for Western Europe, with some going to Eastern Europe but is this a fair assumption?

“Central Europe is still our core business. In fact, we deliver about 20% of our units to Eastern Europe. Eastern Europe is an increasingly important and growing market, which we will continue to expand in the future.”

Over the years you must have seen many different types and sizes of furnaces going to many different industries. Which projects were truly memorable for you? Either by virtue of being a different design, a furnace which dwarfed all others in size or just a really interesting heat treating process.

“An impressive international project we worked on in 2019 was a normalizing atmosphere furnace, which was then delivered to North America. The furnace had a gas-tight inert gas roller hearth with forced cooling in its chamber.”

“There were also several orders in the last months: For example, a big and well-known tool manufacturer who ordered in total 12 large fully automated furnaces. Another example was a very big ring hearth furnace.”

Of all the challenges you face these days as CEO of a very large company what is the most challenging for you?

“Although the challenges related to COVID-19 are there for everyone, the bigger challenge and, at the same time, opportunity is to accelerate our company transformation. Success of this will be measured by both the positive spirit of our employees and satisfaction of our customers.”

This is a very unfair, unreasonable question to ask but I am going to ask it anyway. When I interview you again in 5 years how will your answers be different? For instance do you think we will be talking about more nitriding systems, a large % of furnaces for additive manufacturing, larger sealed quench furnaces? To phrase it another way what do you see for the future of both heat treating furnaces in general and Ipsen in particular?

“Our goal is to go deeper into the supply chain of our customers in 5 years by networking our units (IOT), so that units operate at their best without downtime and at the same time reduce production costs. We are currently developing a system, which allows the client to predict when which spare parts will be needed and to ensure the highest possible availability of the furnaces. That’s the future.”

“Yes of course, nitriding could be one of our topics in the next years. I strongly believe that nitriding will have a bright future since you can achieve excellent metallurgical results at relatively low temperatures while partly avoiding distortion at the same time.”

“Also energy-saving systems, for example, the reduction of CO2, will be a big part of discussion in the next years. Our concept for energy consulting in the field of heat treatment is about to be finalized.”

“Technical innovations like this are an important driving force for Ipsen and our success.”


Mr. Robert Roth

President & CEO of RoMan Manufacturing


We are very pleased to be able to offer you this interview with Mr. Robert Roth President & CEO of RoMan Manufacturing, one of the leading suppliers of transformers, power magnetics and power conversion systems for heat treat furnaces. An Interview with Mr. Robert Roth, President & CEO of RoMan Manufacturing June 24, 2020.

Robert first off, I would like to thank you for your time and congratulate you on the 40th anniversary of RoMan Manufacturing, this is a milestone that only a small percentage of companies reach.

“Thank you so much for having a conversation with me. My Dad was one of the co-founders so RoMan Manufacturing is part of my DNA. I love and appreciate any opportunity to talk about the great work that this company gets to take part in. You make a very good point in that 40 years in business is no small feat, especially for a second-generation run family owned business. RoMan is actually a combination of the founders’ last names. Dietrich Roth, my Dad, and Robert Hofman. They provided us as the second generation a phenomenal example of how consensus proves to be a very reliable corporate management style. Their deep-rooted friendship has grown into the Roth and Hofman families being very close knit and I firmly believe that has kept the destructive elements of family business at bay. Our Founders’ behaviors have served as a great model for my generation to work together and be motivated by the next 5 – 10 years not just the next quarter. We believe in the products we build and more importantly the people that build them. We do not take our amazing team of people, or anything else for that matter, for granted, and look forward to celebrating our 50- and 75-year anniversaries!”

I am rather embarrassed to say that I don’t know a great deal about your company or your products so this interview will be a real learning curve for myself as well as our readers. Perhaps you could tell us something about RoMan, the products you offer that are applicable to the heat treatment industry and how you became President & CEO.

“I’ll start off by giving you my history with RoMan. I joined the company in 1987, 7 years after the company was founded. I had the opportunity along with Robert Hofman’s sons Rob & Kurt Hofman to work for and with our Dads. Fast forward to the late 90’s when our Dads, the founding generation, were ready to transition towards retirement and wanted the leadership of the company to reside with the second generation of the families. Since RoMan’s inception in 1980 it has truly been run as a 50/50 partnership. That being said, every business needs a Captain to steer the ship. My Dad was the president at the time and when looking at retirement looked to both Hofman brothers and me to decide who would take over as Captain. In unison Rob & Kurt nominated me and so off we went! The three of us had a decade of working together learning from each other as well as our Dads, and although I was now President, the idea of management by consensus has been a legacy we have continued. Our partnership has been no different than the relationship of our Dads and it has proven time and time again to be a very successful model.”

“RoMan Manufacturing was started in 1980 to be a designer and manufacturer of transformers, power magnetics and power conversion systems. We have been historically focused on the resistance welding industry and as we continue to develop the business we have seen other industrial processes that require high current, low voltage power so we have worked to take our knowledge and history in resistance welding and expanded into the glass melting and industrial heating markets. We have ingeniously designed products that will lead to several advantages for electrically powered heat treat furnace applications.”

Is this a crowded field? To phrase it another way are there many firms which offer transformers specifically for the heat treatment industry?

“I have always found the Industrial Power conversion/Magnetics/Power Supply industry to be fragmented. You typically see a few major suppliers to specific segments of the market. I have not seen many competitors that offer the breadth of industries served that we do. The diversity in backgrounds within our engineering group has provided us with the knowledge base to enter multiple market segments. There are several competitors, per say, in the industrial heating market however no one in North America has the breadth of water-cooled magnetics that RoMan Manufacturing does.”

RoMan has been talking a great deal about your IGBT/MFDC system, which one furnace integrator describes as the largest innovation in power supplies in the past 50 years-please tell us more.

“IGBT Control Technology and a water-cooled inverter style transformer allows us to bring a more compact package that gives a more finite control in power output, improves electrical performance by creating better Power Factor and a significantly more efficient secondary circuit. The technology brings benefit by enhancing performance and greatly improved operating efficiencies. Because energy is a huge input cost for a furnace, anything that can be done to lower that cost can drive tremendous savings over the life of the equipment.”

“Specifically, in its application to industrial heating, yes, it is new technology. It is however a known technology in other industries that has proven to be very robust, very serviceable and, for example, has a 20-year track record of reliable performance in automotive resistance welding. We have the added benefit of being one of the early adapters and integrators in the resistance welding market so to that end we become a great resource in new application to the furnace market.”

You have emphasized the size and weight of your transformers which leads to the obvious conclusion that they are smaller and lighter that your competitors-how are you able to do this?

“I’ll start by trying to paint a picture of what we do. A long time ago I had a dirt bike that had an air-cooled engine. If you’ve ever seen one like that, you will recall the engine, specifically the cylinder and head was large relative to the engine size or displacement. As liquid cooled engines were developed, my newer dirt bikes had a liquid cooled engine. It was the same displacement, but the engine was significantly smaller in physical size. The only thing they took out of the engine were the massive cooling fins, which left just the cylinder with the integral water-cooling jackets, taking up much less space. When my we designed the RoMan water-cooled transformer, the transformer secondary components contain the integrated water-cooling system. With a traditional air-cooled transformer design space must be provided to allow appropriate air flow and the corresponding surface area to dissipate the heat into the surrounding ambient air. With the integrated water cooling the size and bulk created for air flow and heat dissipation is eliminated creating a much smaller package size per kVA. By designing our transformers to be water cooled from the ground up, our transformers will be much smaller than legacy products that may have been originally designed as an air cooled but adapted to be water cooled. Our design intent was to build products that did the same work while taking up a much smaller footprint. Taking that mission a step farther, the output of our IGBT control is 1000 HZ which lets us drastically reduce the amount of the electrical core steel required, making the transformer even smaller than our standard 60Hz RoMan water-cooled transformers. This concept was originally developed for airplanes to reduce the payload required for their power supplies. We have used this technology in resistance welding to allow for a very light pay load on welding robots. It translates well into the furnace market because it provides OEMs and End Users much greater mounting versatility.”

On your website you point out that because of the size and weight of your units they can be closely coupled to the power feed throughs on a furnace. Robert would you care to hazard a guess as to what % of transformers are mounted in this manner?

“Today, practically none, because with the typical air-cooled transformer used by the furnace industry it is not practical. We look to change that! The air-cooled transformer physical size and the need for ample air flow limit how and where they can be mounted. Another issue with most air-cooled power supplies because of their construction must be mounted in an enclosure or cabinet to protect them from contamination and damage which takes up even more space. All RoMan transformers are constructed to be sealed and protected from any outside element. Therefore, they do not need to be installed is a separate enclosure or shroud, and with the water cooling and advancement of IGBT technology we can mount our units right on the furnace where the secondary conductors feed through to the heating elements. This eliminates the need for long water-cooled cable lines as well as eliminates the electrical losses those cable lengths create.”

I am assuming that your customers include both the furnace manufacturers and the end users– what is the relative percentage of each, mainly manufacturers or mainly end users?

“Currently our customer base is pretty evenly divided between furnace manufacturers and end-users. I believe that trend will continue for some time as we provide significant value for both groups of customers. Furnace OEMs are able to promote more efficient products and heat treaters – both commercial and captive – can realize significant energy savings if they retrofit with a RoMan IGBT MFDC power supply system.”

The previous question leads into another one, actually more like two; how long does a unit typically last before it needs to be replaced and do you see many orders from companies replacing an older (but still operating) unit with a new transformer?

“As it relates to the life of our transformers, if they are sized properly and operating within their design parameters, we have seen them last over 50 years. In regard to the controls we marry to our transformers, they have a more finite life span but again, when properly applied & operated you will still see decades of use.”

“We see a mix of older transformers and power supplies that are no longer functioning that need to be replaced or repaired but we also see functioning equipment being updated with newer technology because of the great advantages and return on investment. When applied properly RoMan products provide many years of worry-free operation and that peace of mind is invaluable to a heat treater who needs their furnace fully operational all the time.”

What is the ROI on one of your units?

“Return on investment is fairly customer dependent so I can’t answer that with a firm number. However, I can provide you with some of the ways our customers have calculated their return. If space is an issue and a unit can be installed in spaces where a legacy product could not. This is an opportunity to utilize existing factory space without the cost of building expansion. The return is calculated on the additional capacity and the higher absorption rate on the facility fixed cost. If energy efficiency and power factor penalties are major costs, the return is calculated easily and will be dependent on energy costs in a particular area. By understanding the life span of RoMan units, the conversion costs can be returned within a few short years. Lastly, when a utility limits the amount of power a facility is able to use, RoMan’s more efficient power supplies provide increased production levels, making return based on added production capacity. I have personally talked to users who have used these various calculations depending on their specific situation. I love seeing their reaction when they realize the amazing benefit to using RoMan products to power their furnaces.”

So, have you pushed the envelope on the technology as far as it will go or does RoMan have some exciting changes coming up in the near future?

“RoMan is continuously looking for technology enhancements. These are constant, micro-evolutionary changes as opposed to revolutionary macro changes. Our lab is daily testing new designs and the impact on different applications to continuously improve our products. We also continue to monitor the markets that we serve. Feedback from those markets and our customers is what has led to some of our biggest product developments. We truly see every customer we have as more of a partnership. We attempt to help them in their power delivery needs by providing them with the best solutions possible, and they in turn provide feedback and recommendations that could possibly help make their systems run even better.”

Let’s go from the specifics of your product to a couple of more general questions starting with the business climate. How has your company been affected by COVID-19?

“First and foremost, we have evaluated our entire work environment to ensure the health and safety of our employees. We implemented sound protocols like daily health screenings, contact tracing logs, assessing work centers to have appropriate social distancing, use of PPE, and have made adaptations for sales and administration to work remotely. We are paying close attention to and continually complying to the everchanging employment laws centered around having a safe workplace. More than ever, the Covid-19 pandemic has emphasized the necessity of trust-based relationships with all our constituencies (employees, customers, suppliers, etc.) to the very forefront of our minds. If we want to come out of this successfully, we all have to work together to create that mutual success. Obviously, the short-term economic impact has been an ever-present issue as well, but because of the mutual trust we have with those constituencies, we are very optimistic about the growth we will see coming out of this.”

Care to make a prediction about how business will be in 2021?

“I think by the time we get to the end of 2021 our sales velocity will match what we were seeing pre-Covid. There is no doubt that the brakes have been slammed on industrial capital spending here, it is the same story in Europe, and the continued tension between the United States and China effects our opportunities there. The turmoil in the oil and gas sector also has a great effect on industrial capex spending. I am confident that when there is clarity in the marketplace, confidence will rise, and the purse strings of capex spending will loosen. American businesses are tough and resilient, and I believe we are stronger than this pandemic, and who knows there may very well be opportunities in the future we haven’t yet anticipated.”

Robert I really appreciate your time and I very much look forward to meeting you in person and shaking your hand as soon as things get closer to normal. Thank you, Gord.


Mr. Joern Rohde

ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH


We are pleased today to have an interview with the owner and President of furnace builder ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH of Hanau, Germany. Joern you are like many of us in the industry in that you got started in the heat treat industry because you had family in the industry, could you elaborate a bit for us?

“Hi Gord! The company was founded by my father in 1979. I have grown up with “furnace building” like many others in the industry. As a kid I always worked at the company during the holidays to earn some extra pocket money. So I literally started sweeping the floors of the factory and then I worked in the different technical areas, learning from employees that had a lot of experience, until I started designing the furnaces. After finishing school, I started an apprenticeship as an industrial mechanic and at that time I did the service and maintenance work for our customers. During my studies of mechanical engineering I then started to work in the furnace design department. I graduated with a degree of “Diplom”-engineer and when my father retired in 2009 I became owner and president of the company. I had to handle the first crisis then and it was a tough start, but everything turned out fine in the end. My wife Natasha manages the financial department and the human resources. We have two sons and of course we hope they will later continue the family business in the third generation. Konstantin is only 2 years old, so he is still very young but he loves Lego, which is already a good start. But Vincent, the older one is now 7 years old, and has already started to sweep the floors in the factory a year ago. At the moment he is already practicing a lot to build things with Lego and he is very creative. So let’s see, if we can encourage him to be a furnace builder in the future like Daddy.”

Tell us about ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH, the size of the company, number of employees, annual sales and what products you offer.

“We currently have 27 employees and have around 4.000.000,00 € turnover per year. 2016 we moved to our new factory and this enables us to produce our whole equipment in Hanau near Frankfurt. We do not depend on suppliers, as we can build nearly everything on our own. Besides our skilled workers in the furnace building, service and maintenance, our workforce is formed by electrical engineers, mechanical engineers and process engineers. We are able to develop everything in-house. We manufacture all kinds of atmosphere furnaces and can offer ALL processes, that can be carried out in a retort furnace. What all our furnaces have in common is a gas-tight retort. The equipment mainly consists of standard assembly groups, that can be compiled at will by the customer. We also manufacture especially developed solutions for customers. Besides our furnaces, we have also been manufacturing salt recovery units (SRUs) for over 30 years and this has been a very successful product for us. We sell the SRUs directly to customers, but we also sell them to other furnace manufacturers, who include them in their furnace lines.”

I was lucky enough a few years ago to see a very impressive example of a pit carburizing furnace which you designed and installed at a company in Bochum by the name of REESE. It is without a doubt the largest pit carburizing furnace I have ever seen. Could you tell us a bit about the project including the size of the furnace?

“This furnace was especially designed for Gerhard Reese. The retort diameter is 5,5 m (16.5’)and the depth is 5 m (15’). Due to the design of the loading table, it can handle loads of over 200,000 pounds at temperatures above 1000° C. The furnace is equipped with 24 recuperated gas burners with a heating capacity of over 1900 kW with additional electrical heating for the loading table. Nobody in the industry wanted to design that furnace. Some people even told me, I was crazy when they heard that I was building it. The furnace was delivered in 2011 and is still working successfully.”

Do you have many installations outside of Germany?

“Around 45 % of our installations are outside of Germany. Many German affiliated groups want us to equip their foreign factories with our equipment, as they trust in our quality and service. The percentage of equipment that we deliver worldwide is constantly increasing. The industry of heat treatment furnaces and equipment is small, our reputation good and the number of customers is also constantly increasing. We have increased our workforce in the service department to be able to serve our customers around the world as fast as possible.”

Are most of your products standard or custom designed?

“We design whatever the customer wants. Our nitriding chamber furnaces (vacuum nitriders) and pit furnaces are standard products, designed in a way that when the customer places the order, he can choose between different additional options which can also be customized of course. But we try to fulfil every wish a customer may have, so if he needs a different size than our standard sizes, then we design it. We are very flexible in every way. As we always have a SPS controller, we can use any controller the customer wants and are still able to offer our process engineering. By the way, our furnaces need 30% less energy than similar ones from other German competitors, which means lower operating costs for our customers after the investment.”

I have seen your SRUs (salt recovery units) in operation at a number of locations around the world and it is obviously a pretty standard product for you. How many of these have you sold over the years and can you tell us a bit about how they operate?

“We have sold over 150 salt recovery units to customers worldwide. The operation of the SRUs is very simple. The wash water is introduced into the unit, the water is condensed and with the steam we pre-heat the wash water. What remains inside the unit is molten salt which can be either discharged back into the quench tank by a heated pipe or directed to a collecting tray where it can be saved for future use. All carbonates and impurities are filtered out and remain in the plate system until they are disposed of. What comes out of the system is clean salt which can be reused immediately. The return on investment is around 2 years as the clean salt can be reused and leads to a significant reduction of costs. The investment in a SRU unit does not only save the customer’s money, it also saves the environment.”

Who buys these systems? What I mean is are these units more suited for a continuous operation such as a mesh belt austemper line or do you sell them in batch type situations?

“In Europe manufacturers of continuous furnaces with salt quenching buy the salt recovery units from us and deliver them together with their installations, as a matter of fact North American furnace builders have also done the same thing. Thus the customers directly receive the recycling solution with their installation for salt quenching. I would even dare to say that in Europe there has not been a single recent installation that has not been equipped with one of our SRU’s. But our customers also include a number of heat treatment companies that use our systems on batch furnace installations. Again the only disposal involved is for some dirt and carbonates, all the salt itself is 100% reused.”

By the way many years ago I predicted that due to environmental regulations salt quenching would slowly be phased out-obviously I was completely wrong on that prediction. What do you see-is the use of salt in heat treating increasing, decreasing or staying about the same?

“Salt quenching has been condemned for a long time for being dirty and harmful to the environment. However this is simply not true. As an example companies that have continued to use salt quenching are still very busy. The negative environmental balance is equalized by using our SRU. The advantages of salt quenching are very well known, very efficient heat removal, easy post-cleaning due to water solubility, it is non flammable and offers extremely low distortion of parts-as a matter of fact the only drawback is the quenching pace for very thick components. So, I have to say, I’m sure you have noticed it, I am a fan of quenching salt and that’s not only because I manufacture SRUs. “

In your opinion what is the fastest growing type of heat treating in Europe?

“I would say that gas nitriding is the fastest growing type of heat treatment here in Europe-a clean process with high potential. Developments in the field of nitrocarburizing and low temperature nitriding for steels with a high percentage of chrome will make this process even more interesting for a lot more components. Gas nitriding is much cheaper than ion nitriding and of course a lot more environmentally friendly than salt bath nitriding. Vacuum hardening is in my opinion the second growing part of heat treating, but it´s not our business right now.”

The topic on everybody’s mind these days is COVID-19, how has it effected you and your business?

“I hate this virus! Everybody is afraid of this virus. Customers have postponed projects and everybody with a running nose is on sick leave for two weeks, to make sure nobody gets infected. At our company there haven’t been any big changes: our employees are working and manufacturing furnaces and SRUs. Fortunately until now, nobody at our company has been sick with COVID-19 and therefore it is business as usual-kind of. The largest difference we see is that the phone doesn’t ring as much but we receive more emails as a lot of people are still working from their home office.”

How do you see business in Europe for the remainder of the year and for 2021?

“Everything is going to be ok! We still have enough orders, when the Corona crisis started we were very fortunate to have a large backlog of equipment and that has kept us busy. We have a very big advantage, which also helped us through the financial crisis 10 years ago and that is the fact that we are not focused on one industry-our customers come from many different industries. We have many open projects so we are looking positively into the next year. We recently developed a new furnace type and will be delivering our new fully automatic bell hardening centre (BHC) for overpressure gas carburizing processes in September of this year. This installation allows for oxygen-free gas carburizing similar to low-pressure carburizing with either salt or oil quenching without surface oxidation. The appropriate process has been developed in collaboration with IWT Stiftung Institut für Werkstofftechnik Bremen some years ago and is called Rox-free.”

Where will ROHDE Schutzgasöfen GmbH be in 5 years? For instance can you see yourself setting up facilities in North America or China? Do you think your product mix will be the same? Joern I realize this is trying to predict the future which is not an easy thing to do so let me rephrase the question-where would you like to be in 5 years?

“We are very active in the field of process development. Also if new furnace types are needed, we are the company to work with. This strategy allows us to always focus on customer needs and to be flexible in offering solutions. We will see what the product mix will be, as I think that our customers are the ones who will have the influence on that, telling us what they need. There will always be someone in the market who is offering cheaper equipment, but I hope that there is nobody who is better then us.

My family and I, we love North America. I would love to be able to serve the north American market directly from there and to set-up a subsidiary there. Of course we love Germany as our location for business and proudly offer equipment “Made in Germany”. But if the sales especially for SRUs continue increasing in the north American market, the next step will be a facility in the States. We do already have a collaboration with Honor Equipment, located in Charlotte, a company that stores our spare parts and offers technical service in the US for our installations.

We are currently not planning any investments in Asia. We manufacture high quality products and to ensure a solid installation we need time and money. We need qualified personnel who love their job and this is what we have been establishing during the past 40 years here in Germany. The existing “old” furnace concepts and types are currently being put to test in Europe. This is due to the high energy costs in Europe and therefore new energy-saving furnace designs are needed. We have already been improving our furnaces for a long time regarding energy-savings. And we can promise our customers that our furnaces need 30% less energy and gas than furnaces from German competitors. This means more profit for our customers with the same or even a better heat treatment result. So what we try is to constantly improve processes and products where it’s useful or saves money for our customers or for us.”


Pete Kerbel

Vice President of Sales, Ipsen


Today we are pleased to present to you a first for us at “The Monty” a video interview with Mr. Peter Kerbel, Vice President of Sales at furnace builder Ipsen. In this interview Gord Montgomery of “The Monty” and Pete Kerbel discuss a number of topics including how the COVID 19 virus is changing the way the world does business and what Ipsen brings to the market.

“Pete Kerbel’s primary focus as Vice President of Sales is providing unique insight into customer needs and solutions since joining Ipsen in 2008. Pete has held roles as Midwest Sales Manager, Manager of the Engineered Components Group, and Director of Aftermarket Sales. He has built a technical background that allowed him to develop strong working relationships and see results that ultimately enhance the customer experience.”


Bill Disler

CEO of AFC-Holcroft


Bill I appreciate the opportunity to ask you a few questions about your background, about AFC-Holcroft and its parent company Aichelin and also for your thoughts about where the industry is going. First off how did you come to be in this industry and end up where you are now as CEO of one of the largest furnace builders in North America.

“I was introduced to the heat treat industry while I was still in college, working for a computer company selling networks and doing database development. We sold a job to Holcroft to automate their proposal and estimating department. Following my graduation with a degree in Electrical Engineering I started working for Holcroft in 1988 as an electrical engineer and soon was asked to travel to China to help with some field startup issues. Incidentally, that work included networking temperature and carbon control instruments for one of the very first Marathon Monitors ProcessMaster Supervisory computer systems. Dan McCurdy was the man behind that system at MMI. Later AFC purchased that software from MMI. My six-week assignment in China turned into two years and during that time I was able to learn hands-on what goes into making a furnace system work. I helped build and commission all aspects of batch furnaces, rotary furnaces, automated press quench systems, and many large pusher furnace systems. It was a tremendous opportunity to learn about all facets of heat treat equipment and their processes. It also opened my eyes to culture outside of the United States which has proven invaluable to my career. After that I worked in various positions at Holcroft including performing estimating and proposal work, managing Holcroft’s Advanced Controls Group, a stint as Operations Manager for the Pacific Rim territory which brought me back to China in the early 90s, and eventually Domestic Sales Manager. In 1998 Holcroft was sold out of the Thermo Electron Group to a venture capital company. Suffice it to say the new owners and I did not see eye to eye and I left Holcroft to work in a global sales position for the German company Dürr. We sold industrial automation and high-level cleaning technology. This period in my career was valuable as I look back because it exposed me to both European business and non-heat treat markets. After the venture capital company was done doing damage, Holcroft was sold to Atmosphere Furnace Company. I was asked by Bill Keough to come back to lead the company’s Sales and Engineering activities and eventually assume the position of President and CEO. The merging of AFC and Holcroft, along with the several other furnace companies Mr. Keough had previously purchased, lead to a great era of growth and re-organization in the company with tremendous support from Bill Keough.”

Perhaps you could share with us a history of AFC-Holcroft and how you came to be part of the Aichelin Group of Austria.

“As mentioned previously, AFC-Holcroft was owned by Bill Keough and over the years the company had been in more of an acquisition mode without any real desire to sell. In 2015 discussions started between Aichelin and AFC-Holcroft about options to find synergies together. I believe that both parties quickly learned that we could identify many business synergies, but we also realized that our philosophies and business cultures shared considerable commonality. As discussions continued, I believe that Aichelin’s interest in acquiring our group grew at about the same rate as Bill Keough’s openness to sell. Aichelin is a big player in Europe and China and AFC-Holcroft is a big player in North America. The combination of the Aichelin group of furnace companies and AFC-Holcroft created a powerful global organization with leading positions in Europe, North America, and Asia. The fit just made sense. In July of 2016 we officially became part of the Aichelin Group. In 2016 we celebrated our 100-year anniversary and 2017 was Aichelin’s 150th anniversary. Together we have a tremendous combined history and experience and an unmatched global presence.”

Tell us about AFC-Holcroft, what products you offer and which products really get you excited.

“As you know, we have a very wide range of products. We will continue to be known for our large, custom engineered systems. Our next generation of furnace engineers will continue to be equipped to serve these market needs. That expertise is diminishing within our industry and we are going to great lengths to assure it continues at AFC-Holcroft. Most of our key products are atmosphere furnaces with various quench systems. We have a strong line of modular “standard” products such as our EZ-Gen endothermic gas generator and Universal Batch Quench (UBQ) family. These products have strengthened globally over the past 10 years and have become a bigger percentage of our sales year by year. We have worked hard to have well–thought–out, top performing, easy to maintain equipment at fair prices. High volume processing and online furnace diagnostics have played a big role in the evolution of our modular product families. They are standardized modules, however we remain more flexible than most in our ability and willingness to customize per customer requests. You can expect to see a couple of interesting products added to our modular products group throughout this year. Regarding what products get me most excited, I think that the best answer is the ones that our customers have not seen yet.”

Where does AFC-Holcroft fit into the Aichelin structure?

“AFC-Holcroft fits neatly into the gap that Aichelin had in the North American market. In other parts of the world we share in various ways within those marketplaces. AFC-Holcroft is in a good position to help bring other Aichelin products into the North American market. Within our group we have a strong induction company, EMA, located in Germany and have a strong center of excellence for equipment serving the hot stamping market in Austria. This has been a great benefit to all of us within the Aichelin Group.”

With the background information out of the way lets get into some “meatier” questions starting with one that is on everybody’s mind these days-COVID-19. I know that AFC-Holcroft has taken every precaution possible to safeguard your employees and customers but that is not what I want to ask. What I want to ask is; is this “pandemic” going to change the industry? Do you see that in 12 months this will be a bad memory and everything will be back to normal or do you see this causing some fundamental changes in the industry?

“Although I am still processing the impact and likely changes that the world and specifically our industry will see after this crisis, I am happy to share my current view. I have little doubt that this crisis will impact our industry in many ways. I can highlight some areas that I expect have changed for at least the mid-term. First, for companies like ours – manufacturers of industrial equipment – day to day work will be impacted for many of our workers who have been teleworking. With the new generation of engineers and other office workers desiring more flexibility, I had envisioned more teleworking being required over the next several years. I was not a proponent of it before the crisis, but today my view has changed. With the ease of video conferencing and teleworking technology, our company’s forced transition to this way of working accelerated the inevitable from my perspective. Our Team has been incredibly effective in this mode of operation. Although face to face meetings and working physically together will remain necessary and clearly beneficial in many situations, I no longer see it as mandatory on a daily basis. I suspect we will not be alone in this conclusion. Managed correctly with more technology investment, we can become a better and more flexible Team. Obviously those members of our workforce who physically load and maintain equipment or physically build equipment will not be impacted the same way. The second significant factor that I believe will impact our industry is a trend to localizing manufacturing to minimize risks. That means that for regions like North America, I expect to see the return of manufacturing to this area to accelerate. It may not remain the long-term trend, as many tend to have short memories when it comes to things like this, but initially we already see this happening.”

How bad is it these days for furnace builders? I understand that because of the long delivery times of new furnaces there is always a long lag time between a general economic slow down and when a furnace manufacturer would see the slow down. Now I’m sure you are making projections so lets phrase the question this way- do you see the current situation as bad as 2009, the same or not as bad?

“You are correct that our furnace manufacturing business seems to lead other aspects of economic change by about a year. That means we tend to be affected by slow downs earlier and feel recovery sooner as our customers plan further in advance. Just prior to the crisis we had fortunately seen a nice rise in business including several larger, greenfield projects. In my opinion we were starting to see an increased trend of manufacturing returning to this region. Given the unique nature of what this crisis represents globally compared to anything else we have ever seen, my favorite forecasting crystal ball just got a whole lot foggier. My current feeling, however, is that we will see a much quicker initial recovery in most industry segments. However, some segments like the airline industry will be hurt for years to come and this will be felt hard by many of the suppliers and commercial heat treat folks that support aircraft production. Of course, the oil industry has other problems compounding this mess, but there is only one way to go in that industry as this crisis relaxes and that is up. Our inquiry level remains surprisingly high with many customers continuing their willingness for significant capital investments. Of course, that optimism may be crushed when true cash flow impacts are accessed and PO’s go for final signatures. In the USA, the huge cash infusion into the economy will certainly help, but the next stages of government action will be critical. If we see a program to accelerate much-needed investment in infrastructure like roads and bridges, this will be terrific for us.”

Lets switch gears a bit. AFC-Holcroft and I am sure Aichelin must always be looking at heat treating technologies, which are growing, which are stagnant, and which hold a great deal of potential in the future. So Bill what do you see as growing technologies and which do you see as mature technologies?

“The biggest thing changing fast in this industry remains the technology to gather useful data from our equipment. We have several technologies that are available for our systems and they are getting smarter every year. We are using that data for a few critical purposes. It helps us make our equipment better and more reliable via remote diagnostics tools like our RDX system. It can help customers have more forward planning capability for maintenance to improve uptime with the use of the tools. Most interesting in my opinion, and likely what will become the most welcome tool by our customers, is technology to automatically validate furnace calibration. Not just what a TUS tells you but also other aspects of the furnace setup that are often equally important to process quality. This may be what finally gets our customers’ attention as it seems like as much as people ask for and want maintenance prediction tools, it is hard for them to change their traditional ways and actually use them. Being able to push a button and have the furnace validate if it is operating as it did prior to the last PPAP can really help support many heat treaters needs. All of these technologies and tool sets are also changing the landscape for annual service contracts so that OEMs can help customers better utilize their equipment. The data can now help end users see that the upfront investments needed to gain uptime availability are justified. Although habits are tough to change, we see it happening and it will help everyone be more competitive and profitable with our equipment.”

Do you have any plans on introducing new technologies to the market? Either new to AFC-Holcroft or new to the heat-treating industry in general?

“Other than the IoT items mentioned previously, we have two significant products that our customers will see this year. Both are based on our Modular Product platform and philosophy. This means that they will offer shorter lead times and carry less custom engineering expense than similar products. One of them will complement our UBQ family of products and the other will offer a unique continuous furnace solution that can be installed on a flat floor in a fraction of the time required by any other system built today. This system will also offer some unique ways of managing salt quench options to contain and recover 99+% of the quench salt, hence making it both clean in the plant and green for the environment. As much as salt has had a bad name in the past, it has made a huge comeback. When it comes to distortion control, it is a single phase quenchant, like gas quench systems. This allows it to provide results far better than oil with respect to distortion control and it does not require 300HP motors and huge volumes of nitrogen and water to achieve better and more predictable heat transfer. Combine all of this into a quick install or quick relocate system that fits into shipping containers and I think it will get some attention.”

What keeps you awake at nights these days? I realize there are a lot of things to worry about right now but what is the one thing which you think about the most?

“This single biggest thing that keeps me awake at night is the welfare of our employees. I doubt I am alone, as other company leaders are struggling with the same challenge. I worry about everyone’s safety, both working at the facility or just managing through this crisis at home. This has impacted every employee and their families in so many ways. I worry about the financial impact this situation has created for them and the uncertainty of what is to come. As we bring more and more people back into the facility, how do we manage this with the right attention to safety? It is not just following government guidelines; it is more about what we as a Team are comfortable with. Fortunately we have a great group of people and together we seem to be navigating these tough decisions well. One other thing that might seem odd which is heavily on my mind is our planning for a major facility update which has been in the works for some time. Prior to this I was worried that the planned office space allocation might be too big if we started having more flexibility with teleworking in our workforce. Too much empty space is better than too little space, but it is also not optimum. Two things are likely to happen with this crisis. First, we will delay this project a bit to recover from the financial impact of this year. Second, the new office facility design will be far better equipped for the future than previously planned. This crisis has given me a glimpse into the future and will help us plan better for our next 20 years.”

This question to some extent ties in with the one above. There are a lot of predictions out there that in a short period of time we will all be driving electric cars which would of course mean a lot less heat treating of transmission parts. Many of your installations are heat treating transmission components. Do you see that the possible growth of electric cars will have an adverse effect on the heat treating industry?

“The transition to electric vehicles will certainly change the shape of the heat treatment needs of our automotive markets over time, but I am not losing sleep over it. First, we serve many markets and industries to dilute our dependence on automotive. Most of the smaller vehicle transmission work has already shifted to modular LPC systems and we participated in that transition with ALD-Holcroft long ago. That is a saturated market today. Second, I just do not agree that the timeline for this will be nearly as fast as our politicians would like it to be. The impact will also be felt much differently region to region. In the USA, for instance, I think electric vehicles will continue to struggle to get wide support without significant government subsidies. Not only do most Americans drive longer distances, but smaller autos are not the bread–and–butter products for American auto companies; trucks and larger SUVs are. Those vehicles will continue to favor conventional powertrains. In places with dense downtown traffic an electric solution is more appealing, provided user expectations for heating and cooling in the car are not too high when the outside environment is either extremely hot or cold.

We all hear lots about the auto industry’s transition to electrics. In Europe, much more than the USA, governmental mandates for this transition’s timing have been so extreme that the auto industry is in a tailspin. The political goals just do not seem to align with reality. In a similar way, in my opinion, neither do the environmental benefits touted politically align with the overall environmental gain by shifting to electric, battery operated vehicles. Making batteries is not a clean business and critical materials needed to make next generation batteries are not exactly located in regions without complications. Even if cobalt, lithium, and other elements were widely available in the USA, I can only imagine the environmental pushback against the strip mining and chemical treatments required to extract the elements. It would make drilling for oil and fracking look like environmentally friendly ideas. That does not get any more media attention than the recycling challenges of the same materials which is fraught with problems. From the practical side, the charging infrastructure and tracing back of what fuels were used to make the power feeding the batteries is a whole other story. My point in all of this is that I feel that politics has been pushing electrification of vehicles at a pace faster than technology can practically support.

I read an interesting and objective article in SAE’s magazine a few months ago.  It was about a simple 600-mile round trip test drive in a leading EV.   Even having received free charging overnight at a hotel that was good for 111 of the 600 miles, the energy costs for the trip were $153 and added hours of extra time to the trip.  The drivers felt fortunate that they found each of the planned recharging stops to be available when they arrived.   The equivalent trip in a gas vehicle would have cost less than $60 (with gas at $2.75 USD per gallon) and the time for the round trip would have been far shorter.  The required infrastructure is not even close to being ready in the US as well as most other places around the world.   Even when it is, cultures that typically drive longer distances and value convenience will be slow to adapt.

Most people probably do not relate the current crisis as being anything that could impact the intensity and focus on EVs. I have to say that, as wrong as I might be, I am not so sure that the launch rate of EVs might not be one of the things impacted by this global crisis. The amount of money that the leading auto companies are investing in electrification when it seems likely the market is not ready for them on the same scale is extraordinary. Investments are measured in the 10’s of Billions of dollars for a few percent of the total market. I wonder if, after the massive financial impact to these businesses is finally realized from this crisis and hands go out to governments for help, the political pressure might relax a bit to allow them more time to better synchronize the transition to electric vehicles to other realities. This will be a welcome change to many in our industry that still heat treat many parts for conventional gas or diesel powertrains. If it happens, expect it to be subtle and out of the political limelight.”