Today we are pleased to be able to offer you this interview with Mr. Ben Grammer of Grammer Vacuum Technologies of Post Falls, Idaho, USA. Ben, I have been rather excited about doing this interview with you as I have known you and your father for many years now, as a matter-of-fact Bob Grammer and I must go back over 20 years now.
Let’s start off talking about the general background of Grammer Vacuum Technologies, when it was founded, where you are located and the territory that you cover.
Yes, Gord, happy to. My dad, Bob Grammer, founded GVT in 1992. We are located near Coeur d’Alene, Idaho (pronounced Core Duh Lane), home to the world’s first and only floating golf green. Our territory is the Greater Northwestern USA, from the Golden Gate Bridge to British Columbia, and from the Pacific Coast to the plains of Colorado.
Because of my background I am very partial to family owned businesses in the heat treat industry. What is your background and what prompted you to take over from your father?
Ben what is your territory like? For instance, a heavy preponderance of captive heat treaters over commercials? Aerospace over automotive? A growing or stagnant heat-treating market?
A lot of aerospace, some medical, some general manufacturing. Lots of knife manufacturers. Not much automotive to speak of. Steady might be a better descriptor than growing, at least overall. We have seen for instance several commercial heat treat shops in Colorado shut down. That said, there is a steady demand for heat treating in the territory. Many aerospace companies have been slow since 2020, but that will turn around.
Over the years I have seen GVT slowly evolve, a process which has been very interesting to watch. However, lets start out with your origins as a manufacturer’s rep firm. Perhaps you could give us some background as to how a rep firm works for those of our readers who are not familiar with independent sales reps.
What companies do you rep for and what products do they have to offer? Feel free to give your “principals” a free plug.
We have developed strong relationships with suppliers who are the best at what they do. In reverse alphabetic order: For high performance, industrial, air and atmosphere, batch and continuous furnaces, we rep the engineering-heavy Williams Industrial Service. When you need control upgrades, analyzers, flow meters or data loggers, turn to the industry-leading Super Systems, Inc. If you need vacuum, then SECO/VACUUM is your choice, providing high pressure gas and oil quench furnaces with all the options. The industry-standard water-cooling system is found at Dry Coolers, Inc. For freezing and tempering in the same unit, see DMP CryoSystems. For cost-competitive alloy baskets, Cooley Wire Products provides standard or custom solutions.
I would like to ask for your opinion on reps in the heat treatment industry. For many years now suppliers to the heat treat industry (at least in North America) have relied upon independent sales reps to handle their sales efforts. It has been suggested by some that with advancements in information technologies and the isolations brought about by COVID that sales reps are in danger of becoming redundant-what is your opinion? To phrase it another way what does a sales rep bring to the table? Will “road warriors” continue to have a place in the industry?
Reps aren’t going away. Workers are hard to find these days, and reps are a knowledgeable sales force with territory-specific contacts. Web meetings are a great tool, but they aren’t the same as a firm handshake and laughter over a shared meal. Plus, reps pay their own benefits and expenses, and you only pay them when there is a sale.
Earlier I mentioned that I have seen GVT evolve over the years, what I am speaking about of course is that GVT has become a significant player in supplying molybdenum to the heat treatment sector. Please tell us how this came about.
What form does this take now? For instance, I know that you have a substantial stock of moly in Idaho-is this the main part of your moly business?
We do have a large, active inventory of mill products and grids. Inventory is a large part of the business, but we also often provide non-inventory items and finished parts. We provide a substantial number of custom and standard fixtures as well.
You mention that your custom fixtures and grids business is growing-where do the designs come from?
We do the design and assembly at our facility in Idaho.
On a final note I understand that your father and founder of the business, Bob Grammer is not as involved these days. How is he doing and what is he occupying his time with these days? I am sure many in the industry are curious as to what he is up to.
Dad keeps busy! And that has not changed as he has handed the business over to me. While he is still involved in the business, he has directed much of his energy to other areas, like starting troops for Trail Life USA (a Christian leadership and outdoor adventure program for boys) throughout the Pacific Northwest. He wears several hats in the organization and loves training the next generation of men. His “leisure” time is spent in Alaska dredging for gold on his claim, teaching shooting sports, or travelling with Mom to visit his 10 (and counting) grandkids.
Did you like this article? Click here to subscribe to The Monty.
View our recent magazines and podcasts by clicking the following link. https://themonty.com/magazine/
Mr. John Dykstra
Chief Service Officer at Ipsen, USA
Furnace builder Ipsen of Rockford, Illinois recently created a brand new position, that of Chief Service Officer (CSO), an executive-level addition to the manufacturer’s U.S. Leadership Team. The man chosen for that position is Mr. John Dykstra, and we are pleased to be speaking with him today. John, before I ask you about your background, our readers and I would very much like to know, what is a Chief Service Officer (CSO) and why did Ipsen decide on adding this position?
What is the CSO Position? The CSO position is an executive-level position inside of Ipsen that is designed to strategically lead the teams inside of Ipsen Customer Service. As the CSO, I am looking at how we can expand our capabilities through strategic personnel additions and implementation of new technology solutions. These include remote support capabilities, a new online customer portal and enhanced data sharing from service visits. My goal is for Ipsen Customer Service to deliver world-class capabilities for precise and timely repairs, supported by an industry–leading parts organization, to ensure that we exceed our customers’ expectations during each and every interaction.
I have to say, I did read the press release that Ipsen issued when you were first hired and hung on to every word. You have had an interesting career, which I would like to know more about, in particular how you became part of the Ipsen team.
First and foremost, I am the type of guy that enjoys changing oil and doing repair work on my vehicles and other things around my house; it is just who I am. Over a decade ago, I was fortunate enough to wind up working in the warranty group at a defense contractor in Wisconsin. Ever since entering the aftermarket world as a service administrator, I have been fortunate enough to be entrusted with increasing levels of responsibility that gave me the ability to lead all facets of OEM aftermarket groups.
I was actually leading an aftermarket group in Washington State in the food sorting industry when I became aware of the opportunity at Ipsen. As I learned more about the position, the people inside of the organization, and the vision for the Ipsen Customer Service Team, I knew it was a challenge that I wanted to take on. This is truly a great company with many people that live and breathe vacuum furnaces, and I am excited to be here and to continue to add value to our already great offering.
Your interests, I have to say, very much caught my attention. As an avid outdoorsman and world traveller, you and I have an enormous amount in common. Do you see travel as being a large part of your new job as CSO?
Early on in my career, I became highly aware of how important it was to make customers the driving force behind anything a company does. In my mind, I call it a customer centric philosophy. In reality, it means I will be frequently visiting our customers, learning more about what they would like to see, and then developing a strategy that supports their long-term ambitions.
On a day-to-day basis what fills your time?
Presently, I have been spending a good amount of time talking with many of the team members inside of Ipsen to learn more about how Ipsen operates. Also, just before the holidays, I was able to fly out and meet with some of our customers and Ipsen personnel in the Northeast region, which was a truly informative experience. Now I am developing a strategy that will focus on evolving an already successful organization into an even better and more capable organization.
Now that you have had three months in the heat treatment industry, what is your first impression? Let me elaborate a bit – your background shows you have had a great deal of experience with aftermarket teams – Is this industry any different from others in which you have been involved?
In a short answer, no. My career has largely had me working with tactical or emergency vehicles or large commercial power generators. If those go down, they must be fixed immediately. Similarly, the requirements of Ipsen’s customers require us to get their furnaces fixed so they can continue to produce the products essential to their company.
My opinion is that one should look at aftermarket from the perspective of people, processes and products. An effective aftermarket team needs the best people, with streamlined processes, who quickly deliver superior products. Regardless of the industry you are in, if you get those three things correct, the organization should be set up for success in the long run.
With all the supply chain issues these days it must be an enormous challenge for Ipsen to keep parts in stock – how are you coping with this issue? Have prices and deliveries increased substantially?
We do maintain a robust inventory of parts to support our customers; however, depending on what is ordered, we have been witnessing extended lead times to get parts into stock. Subsequently, this has caused us to increase inventory on some hard to get parts to help ensure they are on the shelves when needed.
Additionally, we have a strong supply base, and we are able to buy in volume to help keep any price increases to a minimum. Of course, it would always be prudent for customers to ensure they are stocking common wear components at their facilities. We have had great success supporting customers in this aspect by developing and selling critical spare parts kits.
As if supply chain issues weren’t enough of a problem these days, labor shortages are also a real challenge. Since Ipsen maintains a substantial service department, I am assuming that this also requires your constant attention. My question is – are labor shortages something that keep you awake at night?
First and foremost, our service team is truly an amazing bunch of individuals who work diligently to ensure our customers’ needs are met. The level of tenure, expertise and commitment that our team members have at Ipsen is truly impressive.
It would be naive for me to say that a labor shortage does not worry me. However, we are being proactive about hiring and look forward to 2022 as a year our team continues to grow. If any technician reading this is considering a career change, I ask you to call me. 15 minutes is all I ask for. We are hiring!
With new technologies enabling remote diagnostics, like Ipsen’s PdMetrics platform, how will this effect field service engineers? I certainly can’t see a time when they will become obsolete; however, do you see them having to spend less time in the field because more information is available online?
Undoubtedly, we will need to maintain a robust Field Service Engineer (FSE) staff to complete repairs and maintain furnaces in the field. That being said, I feel as time goes on you will see a shift from reactive repairs to proactive maintenance. I can also envision a time where we do have a centralized team of service engineers watching for faults, monitoring run times, and generally being more informed and able to react to customer needs faster.
Are you personally going to be spending a lot of time visiting current customers? What I am asking is whether you see yourself in a role overseeing the service department, or will you be splitting your time between management and hands on visits?
I would say I will be in the field as much as time allows me to do so. As I have alluded to, I am a hands-on kind of guy and like to be in the field learning and understanding how we can service our customers even better than we do now. However, this is also a strategic leadership role, guiding an important part of Ipsen, which does require being in the office regularly. In short, yes, I will frequently be in the field.
And now, for the hardest question of all – what are your fearless predictions for the future when it comes to service? I am sure that, like every other aspect of manufacturing, changes are in store, changes ranging from fairly insignificant to substantial. You are the expert in this field – any thoughts on what we might see in ten years?
The one thing that is certain is furnaces wear over time and will need to be serviced. It was true 100 years ago and it will be true 100 years into the future. However, I think the evolution of how and when things are serviced will evolve. I feel the internet of things will bring in much stronger predictive analytics and repair cycles, leading to more proactive maintenance work and less reactive/emergency fixes. We will see an uptick in remote services and customer support capabilities and we will see a deeper push into technology as the primary go-to for service, support and training.
We are just seeing the beginnings of what I believe are exciting technologies with hands free wearable devices for remote support. There are really neat augmented and merged reality offerings on the market, and it seems more and more predictive and remote support capabilities hit the market daily. This is where I am seeing the market go now and I am excited about the possibilities these products bring. A simple view of the future can be found in this equation: first to know + first to act = excellence. Digital tools will enable earliest possible detection while our Ipsen Customer Service team will ensure quick action.
John I appreciate your thoughts and your time today. Thank you, Gord
Did you like this article? Click here to subscribe to The Monty.
View our recent magazines and podcasts by clicking the following link. https://themonty.com/magazine/
Mr. Brent Davis
President & CEO of Accurate Brazing
Thank you, Gord. I stepped into the role of President of Accurate Brazing at the beginning of 2021 as our founder, Steve Francis retired.
I came to the heat treat industry as a kid. I grew up in it and there is probably not a job within our organization that I haven’t done at some point in my career. Back when I was growing up, my sister and brother-in-law, Terry Profughi, were part of a family business in Cleveland, Ohio – it was called Technical Metal Processing. I would go visit them in the summers and it started with little trips down to the shop. I would go with them to work and push brooms or hang out with the guys in the shop. As I got older and through high school, I would work there in the summers making big bucks – $2.10 an hour! Wow, I was “somebody.” If they needed “somebody” to do this or that, I was that “somebody” – unloading trucks with a pallet jack; loading and unloading the furnaces; running to fetch tools; arbor presses; learning how to do little assemblies; learning to drive a forklift. I worked my way through college there. I would go to school until I ran out of money and then I’d come back and work a semester until I had enough to go back to school.
After college I went to work for K-C Aviation in Dallas, TX. I was working at Love Field on corporate aircraft designing full interiors. But after a couple of years, I got pulled back into the heat treat industry with Hi TecMetal Group. My first job coming back was in Quality. I worked under a great metallurgist and a couple of engineers in the lab, cutting up and doing evaluations – tensile testing and reports – and talking to customers. It was a good learning curve. Tearing up braze joints to figure out what was wrong. Listening and learning to the older guys that knew the business. I was a sponge. It was fun. I worked with Bob Peaslee on a lot of programs. Everybody knows him as the father of nickel brazing. I was lucky to work with him at AWS on a lot of program development and problem solving. And I was running the AWS Brazing 101 seminar for one event. Having that one-on-one mentoring and hands-on tutoring from him was huge. So many in the brazing industry learned their skills on the job, but I was lucky enough to learn straight from the source.
Then I moved into more of the engineering side working with the plant managers doing development – routers, procedures, travelers, documentations, and improving processes and improving braze joints which I had learned from the metallurgist and engineers. And from there I entered management, running the assembly department. And it just evolved from there learning from Terry Profughi how to run a business, interact with customers and strategically think as a businessman. From managing one division to overseeing two divisions. And just before I left, I took over four divisions as Regional Operations Manager.
In the early 2000’s I moved south to Greenville, SC. We had two divisions here and I acted as the Regional Sales Rep. But the economy crashed and the divisions were sold. I took a brief pause from the industry and started a company for some investors. I worked for Ionbond for a couple of years.
Then I made a connection with Steve Francis through an article that ran in The Monty. He was looking for someone to start a planned facility in Florida, but it did not come to be, due to a change in strategy by the customer and I ultimately came over to Accurate Brazing to run the Garlington Road plant in Greenville. And here we are.
Tell us about Accurate Brazing, what technologies you have available, size of the company, number of employees and the history of the company.
Accurate Brazing’s leading technologies include vacuum brazing, heat treating, and HIP’ing.
Accurate Brazing currently has divisions located in Goffstown, NH; Manchester, CT; and Greenville, SC where we have two facilities. A brief history of Accurate Brazing:
- Steve Francis founded Accurate Brazing with his brothers in 1989 in a garage as a side business.
- 2001 Expanded south and began operating new facility in Greenville, SC
- 2005 Acquired by Aalberts Industries
- 2010 Manchester, CT greenfield start up begins operations
- 2016 Added second facility in Greenville, SC to add capacity to support local customer
- 2018/2019 Expanded/renovated Greenville facility to accommodate HIP
- 3Q 2020 Added HIP services
- 2Q 2021 Second HIP unit commissioned
Accurate Brazing is part of the Aalberts group of companies based in the Netherlands which is one of the largest commercial heat treaters in the world. Can you please tell us the organizational structure of Aalberts and where Accurate fits? Perhaps a little about how many facilities Aalberts has in total?
Accurate Brazing is part of the Aalberts surface technologies group in the US, which includes sister companies Applied Process, Ionic Technologies, Roy Metals, Aalberts surface treatment, Ushers, Precision Plating, and newly acquired Premier Thermal.
Our niche within Aalberts, is that we are the leader in brazing and HIP’ing technologies. Aalberts wants to continue to invest in and grow these services and technologies.
Aalberts NV has 134 locations worldwide and is a €3.2 billion publicly traded company.
Accurate is part of the North American group which I am assuming includes Applied Process and fairly recently Premier Thermal both based in the US. Do you work closely with the other US divisions?
We do work closely with our US sister companies. We are always looking for opportunities to cross-sell services, collaborate, and share ideas and information.
Out of curiosity have you had the chance to visit many of the Aalberts locations in Europe?
A few years ago I helped start a facility in Poland with Hauck Heat Treating and Meyer Tool but have not been able to make a return trip.
And lately, due to COVID restrictions we have not been able to interact with our European divisions as much as we would like to, but there is an open invitation both ways for plant visits, like we have had in the past. The last year and a half, most of our collaborations have been locally within our groups and Teams Meetings with our counterparts in Europe.
Brent I am going to ask you a question which you may or may not want to answer. Aalberts really surprised the North American commercial heat treatment industry when they acquired Applied Process and Premier within the past few years-can we expect any more surprises in the form of more acquisitions?
Aalberts is an entrepreneurial company and is always looking for strategic acquisition and growth opportunities within North America.
I regret that to date I have not been able to visit your facility, however I have seen a number of photos and what I see is an immaculate location with quite new equipment. This prompts the question as to what the Accurate philosophy is, is your aim to be always pushing the envelope on new technologies or is it more to be able to say that you are a steady, dependable supplier who will always work with your customers? You could rephrase this question by asking why your company has been successful.
You are welcome to visit us anytime Gord.
I would say we aim for both.
We are technology driven, innovative, and always pushing the envelope for great customer service – this has always been Accurate Brazing’s as well as Aalberts’ philosophy.
Our success has come from being entrepreneurial, customer focused, and technology driven.
One of the main questions I have been itching to ask you is-why HIP’ing? Accurate has made a very substantial investment in hot isostatic pressing over just the past couple of years, an investment which must be in the millions of dollars which tells me you see a very substantial, profitable market. Why invest in HIP’ing as opposed to lets say Plasma Nitriding or Vacuum Carburizing?
Aalberts is a technology driven company and wants to stay at the forefront by investing in new technologies.
Hot Isostatic Pressing was a request from our customer base to add capacity in the region. We saw it as an easy bolt on to the thermal processing capabilities and services we already offered. We brought HIP’ing under one roof with other key services in Greenville, SC. This is something our customers like because they can get multiple processes in one location, it minimizes handling of parts, and can reduce turn times dramatically.
Our plan is to have three HIP presses in Greenville. The first HIP press was delivered in early 2020 just as COVID hit. COVID was not part of the plan, but the second press was already on order. We knew we needed a second press and even in a down economy we proceeded with our plan. Strategically we knew the economy would pick back up and we would be ready when it did. Press #3 for Greenville is coming. It is being built right now in Sweden. While our plan has been delayed some due to COVID and the aerospace slowdown in, we are proceeding, and we see a strong future for HIP’ing and HPHT.
And why HIP’ing as opposed to Plasma Nitriding? We already offer Plasma Nitriding in conjunction with our sister company, Ionic Technologies.
Perhaps I am being very melodramatic, but I have to say that the world is a very challenging place these days, I personally can’t remember a time when so many changes were going on. For manufacturers it is especially challenging because of supply chain disruptions, longer deliveries, difficulties in even obtaining some items vital to production and price increases which seen to be growing by the day. What are you seeing and how are you coping?
This is not unusual. If you’ve been around long enough you have seen these types of challenges. The only thing unusual is having them pile on all at once – whether labor or materials issues or the cyclical dynamics within individual industries or a global pandemic. We are a very diversified company and can ride out times like these knowing there will be a turn around. Aalberts and Accurate Brazing take advantage by investing in our equipment and people during these times.
As if supply chain issues were not enough to keep heat treaters awake at night there is another issue which many in the industry consider even more pressing-finding good people. Is this a concern at Accurate and if so what is the solution?
We have a very stable and mature workforce that we continue to train and retrain based on customer requirements. The need for bringing youth into the organization is a challenge but we are engaging in a lot of the academic arenas on a local, regional, and global level looking to cultivate new people coming in.
We are engaged with AWS and the Brazing & Soldering Manufacturers Committee. The BSMC committee is a tremendous resource for senior management providing them with a wealth of industry resources. It promotes programs that benefit the understanding of brazing & soldering technology and development of the industry. I sit on the C3 sub-committee, which promotes, through Ohio State and the Weld Engineers, welding courses and brazing handbooks for young talent entering the industry.
You probably didn’t know that I am quite jealous of your location in SC. Not only do you have great weather you are also in one of the fastest growing areas for manufacturing in all of North America. Would that be a fair statement and do you expect it to continue?
Yes. I think it is both a fair statement and we expect to see continued growth.
We are not in the rust belt where a lot of our competitors and customers are clustered together, but this is a growing area because of the automotive and aerospace industries. We are starting to see firearms manufacturers moving south as well.
What is lacking is a lot of the machining and casting guys who are still located up north. A lot of what is being done here is assembly.
The southeast is a business-friendly environment and the cost of doing business is very favorable.
Now for a completely unfair and unreasonable question-where as a commercial heat treater are you going? Do you expect commercials will increase their share of the total heat treating market? Are commercials looking at a bright future in the near and long term even with all of the challenges? What heat treatment technologies are going to be in the forefront going forward? My very unfair question would be; can you give us a glimpse into the future? What are your personal thoughts?
My personal thought is that we are always battling companies trying to in-source our services whether it be braze or heat treat, thinking it is commodity, an easy bolt–on process to get lean and bring in–house. Unfortunately, the companies that are large enough to do that don’t understand the real cost of what it takes.
We see the future of the market in Additive Manufacturing, Aerospace, Defense, Automotive, IGT and Oil & Gas.
Accurate Brazing and Aalberts will continue to grow by adding people, equipment, and technologies based on customer requirements locally, regionally, nationally, and globally. Aalberts will continue to invest in customer needs.
Dr. Bora Özkan
Technical Director, Ipsen, Kleve, Germany
Bora, I appreciate the time you are spending with us, I have been fortunate enough to interview several individuals at both Ipsen, Rockford, USA and Kleve, Germany and have always enjoyed the discussions.
Lets start at the very beginning as they say, how did you end up where you are today-Technical Director of Ipsen, one of the largest global furnace suppliers?
I studied mechanical engineering and made my PhD while I was a research assistant at the chair of materials technology in Bochum, Germany. During this time, I was in charge of operating the universities’ vacuum furnace. My research work had a big heat treatment part in open fired furnaces with a polymer quench bath as I needed to find a heat treatment for my composite cast steel parts. I started my industry career in 2010 at one of the biggest furnace builders for the steel industry. I joined Ipsen in 2019 in the continuous furnace department. In January 2020, I was asked if I would like to take responsibility for the design department and the R&D department.
What does your position involve on a day to day basis? I can picture a Technical Director as being an innovator-somebody in a back room coming up with ever more advanced ideas-am I completely off the mark?
A furnace builder is not a research institute. We have much shorter innovation cycles. Furthermore, we have a lot of different disciplines that are all working together to build a reliable and safe machine. There is a lot of complexity in a modern furnace. The biggest challenge is to manage this complexity. It must be easy for us at Ipsen to offer a highly customized machine to our customers with only few efforts for our designers. You cannot do that from a back room.
Ipsen recently made a number of changes about where equipment is manufactured, my understanding is that the USA operation focuses on vacuum systems, while Germany has an emphasis on atmosphere. If that is the case does your position involve mainly atmosphere technology or a combination of both?
For new equipment mainly atmosphere in Germany. But of course, we do work together with our colleagues from USA every day. We should not forget to mention the daily cooperation we have with our colleagues from Ipsen India and Ipsen China. For service and aftermarket, the organization did not change. Therefore, we have several designers from both mechanical and electrical engineering who spend more than 90% of their daily work on vacuum aftermarket and revamping projects. To mention only one example, in April even though we had Covid restrictions, a German customer who ordered a replacement hot-zone for their vacuum furnace, visited us for two days. We developed improvements for their very special process together and at the same time could significantly improve the lifetime of some components with the feedback we got.
Lets talk about one of the hottest topics in the world these days, greenhouse gas emissions and their effect on the environment. In North America this has not been serious consideration, however there are some signs that this is changing. For instance several heat treaters in North America have told me recently that they are considering Nitrogen/Methanol systems as opposed to endothermic generators for the simple reason that there is no combustion in a Nitrogen/Methanol system hence less emissions. In Europe I know this is a topic which has been taken more seriously than North America for quite some time now. My question would be; “are your customers asking that greenhouse gas emissions be considered in the design of a furnace?”
It sounds interesting that nitrogen/methanol systems have no combustion. Methanol is a liquid that needs to be heated up, decomposed and then heated further to the process temperature. For transferring 10 litres/h methanol to a typical carburizing atmosphere you need approx. 18 kW of heating power as it is an endothermic reaction. You can see that effect if you inject the methanol/nitrogen too close to the furnace thermocouple. The difference compared to Endogas is, that the furnace burners provide the energy. So, there is combustion, but it takes place inside the furnace burners. However, “green” methanol is regarded as a main energy carrier of the future as it is easier to store than hydrogen.
Nearly all German customers ask for the efficiency of the burners. There is a subsidy program of the government where an investment into equipment that will save CO2 is rewarded with 500€ for each ton CO2 that you will save annually in the future. So the answer here is an emphatic yes! Customers are all talking about reducing their environmental footprint and Ipsen is ready with solutions.
This question is closely related to the one above and has to do with energy efficiency. Again the differences between North America and Europe are quite extreme due to the very high energy costs in Europe. I know this from experience because every time I visit Europe my hosts gently remind me to turn lights off when I leave a room. Is energy efficiency a prime consideration amongst your customers and what solutions does Ipsen have?
Yes it is. CO2 emissions are a big topic in Europe. The most important answer on what we have is: we do have the right furnace size. There is nothing more inefficient than having an empty furnace on temperature or every time loaded with too few parts. On the other hand, it is inefficient to divide a bigger batch into several batches because your furnace is too small. In bigger installations we have already delivered energy recovery systems to make use of waste gas and the heat of process gas flare. We will launch very interesting new products next year that exactly address these issues.
Lets talk Nitrogen Oxides (Nox values). Many jurisdictions around the world have tight regulations to control this form of air pollution and I would imagine to your customers this is a consideration which must be taken into account when considering new equipment. What does Ipsen have to offer?
The regulations in Germany will be tighter with the new “TA Luft” directive that is expected at the end of 2021. We will see how the NOx limits will be. Heat treatment furnaces with protective or reactive gas atmosphere are indirectly heated. So, the burner fires into a tube and the waste gas is not touching the heat treated part. For this kind of indirect heating, the new regulations seem to restrict NOx values to 1/3rd of the levels that are permitted today. This is a major change and Ipsen will be ready.
Lets switch gears a bit and talk about furnaces and furnace designs. Your customers obviously have many considerations that must think about when buying a new furnace but what is the number one thing they think about? Examples might include throughput or is flexibility more important? Do operating costs mean more than throughput? Perhaps emissions or is that a lower priority than making production? I realize it will generally be a combination of all of these factors and more but what are your customers really concerned about these days?
The heat treatment cost per kg is only half in a continuous pusher type furnace compared to a typical batch atmosphere furnace. A pusher therefore has a much better carbon footprint but is of course not as flexible. A CAPEX and OPEX calculation is essential to guide our customers to the right choice of equipment. The number one thing for the customer is safety. Nobody wants to see an accident, neither the operators nor the designers of the furnace.
Does anything ever change in the heat treat industry? I had a close friend who spent over 50 years of his life designing and selling furnaces and his contention was always the same-except for control changes and some relatively minor design changes carburizing was still carburizing, and through hardening was still through hardening. Cynical perhaps but I have always remembered his comments. Has furnace design changed dramatically in the past 30 or 40 years?
A retired colleague with 40 years of experience in furnace building used to tell the young engineers: “I already forgot more in my life than you have ever learned.” It is important not to forget what the more senior engineers could build. You are right, it is a well-established technology. In our daily life we have a lot of well-established products like bread, steel, and paper. The question is how to produce these essential goods today. In a digital world where the drawings are a 3D-model in a computer and the supply chain is organized digitally and globally. Of course, it needs to have the same or even better quality than in the old days.
To be fair you should mention low pressure carburizing that came later than carburizing in an equilibrium gas atmosphere. In some areas where carburizing in deep holes is necessary, LPC has a lot of advantages. But there are other areas with high throughput or more flexibility where there is a big demand for the classical sealed quench atmosphere furnaces.
We just spoke about where we have been-where are we going? Will sealed quench furnaces remain the most popular design of furnace in the world or do you see us going to single part processing as some have suggested?
CAPEX and OPEX are better when you collect more parts and treat them as a big batch. Therefore, emissions should in the most cases be also lower than in-line heat treatment. The cycle time of many hours in a carburizing furnace does not match the cycle time of some minutes of a machining line. For machine availability it is also difficult to connect too many manufacturing machines in a hard sequence.
Please tell us about your most challenging and most memorable project ever. I am not going to ask about customer specifics but what furnace project is the one which will stick in your memory the longest?
Ever? Then I need o be fair and mention a railway wheels project in my previous job. After two years of development of a heat treatment line, finally there was the day when the first high speed railway wheel was produced. With the computer model I developed to calculate the cooling media flow we were able to achieve the desired material properties in the first attempt. What I learned from that project, is something that most heat treaters know from their own experience: Cooling is more complex than heating.
To round things out I have a very personal question for you-what do you enjoy most about your job? Pushing the envelope as us North Americans would say-in other words doing what others have not done? Seeing a new technology successfully introduced? Modifying existing technology to be more efficient? What gets you really excited about your job?
Furnace building is one of the few jobs where mechanical engineering and materials science have the same importance. Both are really my passion for nearly 20 years. There is a difference between new technologies and inventions on the one hand and innovations on the other hand. Innovations are often to successfully do what others were trying without or with little success or maybe in the wrong application. My job is to create something useful. I have a very good team of engineers. Most of them with many years of experience and still there are meetings where all these experienced guys have learned something new from each other. There is no chance that furnace building will ever get boring.
Bora, I really appreciate the time and your very interesting thoughts. Gord Montgomery
An Interview with Mr. Victor Oreskovich, CEO of Can-Eng Furnaces International, Ltd.
Victor I have been looking forward to asking you some questions about your background, how you became CEO of Can-Eng and what your plans are for the future-I am sure I am not the only one in the industry who has an interest. So I appreciate the time today.
The number one burning question I have for you is how did you become CEO of Can-Eng Furnaces, one of the largest furnace builders in North America? In other words what is your background and how did you end up where you are today?
Gord I was born and raised in Niagara Falls and have always had a great love for the area and the people. After high school I attended McMaster University and graduated with a B.Eng in mechanical engineering then went off the grad school at Western for a master’s in business administration. My first job after university was at General Motors Oshawa as a manufacturing engineer. I was fortunate to have exposure to mergers and acquisitions and financings in my last position as an investment banker which provided me the experience to begin acquiring companies. The first purchase was JTL Integrated Machine Ltd Port Colborne Ontario, followed by Trenergy Inc St. Catharines, Ontario and then CAN-ENG in Niagara Falls. All three are in the Niagara region and I knew each of them growing up. It was just coincidental that these businesses were all located within close proximity to one another.
I have known the senior executives at CAN-ENG for close to 15 years and so when I contacted them to get a sense for what the current shareholders intentions were, they felt that there would be an interest in a sale. I then made contact with the Owners, and we were able to come to an agreement.
It is important to understand that all my life I have admired CAN-ENG and what they have achieved since 1964. They have extraordinarily creative and knowledgeable engineers and a superbly efficient manufacturing strategy. What has thrilled me more is that the staff and capabilities are far better than I could have imagined. With the combined resources of all three enterprises (250 staff and over 270,000 sq ft of manufacturing and office space), we will be able to execute virtually any order of magnitude project without straining resources.
Going forward our intentions are to expand our footprint in North America with appropriate partnerships/ownerships in the USA and Mexico. We believe that a service network as well as manufacturing capacities in certain regions, will allow us to maintain close contact with our customer base and provide them geographic and cost advantages for new installations or refurbishments. In fact, we are in discussions now with several parties to accomplish these objectives.
Tell us about the history of the company. In what year was Can Eng incorporated, what products do you offer and what industries you are involved with?
CAN-ENG was founded by the partnership of Art Neufeld and Wally Bamford in 1964, but the origins of the Company as a manufacturer of Industrial Furnaces can be traced back more than 120 years. Early contracts were secured in the local automotive and steel industries and by 1965 CAN-ENG had an order for five (5) complete Walking Beam Quench and Temper Lines for automotive leaf springs. The founders had a passion for growing the business and expanded to Mexico in 1965 with the creation of SELMEC, then the first manufacturer of comprehensive furnace lines in Mexico. Growth and diversification lead to the founding of commercial heat treating operations including CAN-ENG METAL TREATING in 1968 (Ontario), and Temple y Forja Fortuna de C.V. in Mexico in 1972. In the 1970’S CAN-ENG had its own Alloy (Heat Resistant) Foundry, Air Pollution Controls Division and even a Poly-Urethane manufacturing operation. Throughout the nearly six (6) decades CAN-ENG has been in business, the Company has been known for many thermal processing innovations including high volume energy conservation Porcelain Enameling systems, Fluid Bed Technology, and in 1988 the introduction of the first continuous mesh belt quench and temper lines in North America. Acquisition of HARPER ELECTRIC FURNACE CORPORATION of Buffalo, NY in 1989 brought one of N. America’s oldest industrial furnace companies under common ownership and resulted in synergies in both Engineering and Manufacturing. The Company had the early foresight to recognize the transition from Iron Castings to Aluminum Castings for automotive Power Train applications and in 1993 one of the first high volume aluminum T6 systems was installed at the Ford Motor Company. The introduction of the BHTS – Basketless Heat Treatment System technology for Aluminum Castings in 2005 revolutionized the production of high-volume aluminum automotive castings, slashing energy consumption and overall footprint, while improving mechanical properties at the same time. Post Millennium, the Company saw renewed demand for furnace contracts all over the world with a focus on developing new technologies for the Railway, Aerospace, Forging, Military, Steel and Automotive sectors. The acquisition of CAN-ENG in March 2021 opens a new chapter of manufacturing capabilities and facilities, positioning the business for even greater growth.
How large is the company in terms of number of employees and annual sales? I certainly understand that as a privately held company you might not want to share sales figures-if that is the case perhaps you could give us a hint.
The CAN-ENG team consists of just under 70 people, made up of a dedicated group of skilled and talented Industrial Furnace Professionals. We are proud of our team at CAN-ENG, some of which have over 30 years experience. Sales bookings in our business is cyclical and can vary from year to year based upon project timing, project size and activity in the market. For general purposes Sale Figures for the year range in the $25M to $40M Range (however have been greater than the high range in the past).
Can Eng is a Canadian company but having said that I have seen examples of your furnaces all around the world-as a matter of fact you had a recent announcement about a large order from a customer in Italy. What % of your products are shipped outside of North America and how do you handle sales and support?
CAN-ENG is a truly global provider of Industrial furnaces systems and have supplied equipment to 17 different countries around the world. With that being said, annual installations outside of North America can range between 10% to 40% of our annual projects which varies based on the project sizes.
Customers today demand local support and as such, over the last twenty years CAN-ENG has developed a team of Sales and Engineering professionals to deliver this level of service. CAN-ENG has developed and assembled a team of technical experts that spend considerable time on the road meeting and working with our customers. In addition to this, CAN-ENG has specialized resources embedded in certain geographies to augment this customer support.
Lets talk mesh belt furnaces and I will get started. Roughly 35 years ago as a young, very inexperienced salesman I can remember trying to sell Can Eng air cooled quench oil coolers. At the time I was dealing with Mr. Wally Bamford, owner and Mr. Pete Mackenzie, Chief Engineer. I remember very clearly them telling me the future of processing fasteners lay in mesh belt furnaces, a brand new concept in North America at the time. As it turns out everything Wally and Pete told me about mesh belt furnaces turned out to be absolutely correct. Would you care to share with our readers the history of mesh belt furnaces and how Can Eng was the pioneer in this technology?
In the early 1980’s CAN-ENG recognized there was going to be a great demand for domestically produced High Quality and Critical Automotive Fasteners. It was this foresight that began the development of the CAN-ENG Mesh Heat Treatment System. CAN-ENG evaluated competing technologies that included Shaker Hearth, Rotary Drum and Cast Link Conveyor designs and found them all to be flawed of one reason or another. Understanding these deficiencies, CAN-ENG sought out to develop a new concept that would overcome these deficiencies that yielded improved mechanical properties results, minimized opportunity for part damage and mixing, greater size range of products which can be processed, increased system throughput efficiency and equipment uptime.
As part of these development activities, in 1988 CAN-ENG built the first of four continuous mesh belt carburizing furnaces under a licensing arrangement with KYK of Japan. These systems were of low capacity and as such, the license was subsequently cancelled and CAN-ENG developed the next generation designs which is now the major player in this niche of the industrial furnace market.
Today CAN-ENG routinely engineers 1,000 to 7,500 lb/hr capacity neutral hardening, oil quench lines utilizing the mesh belt technology developed in the 1980’s. Efforts are constantly being made to integrate design improvements for energy consumption reduction, product quality improvement and equipment reliability and uptime features. Recent system developments include:
- CAN-ENG’s Energy Reduction System(ERS™) features that recuperates waste energy from the furnaces burner flue gases and atmosphere discharge.
- Enhanced Temper Furnace Forced Recirculation System for Improved Temperature Uniformity and Accelerated Cool Down Features
- Integration of Automated Rotary Drum Phosphate Removal Washers
- Austemper Salt Quenching Systems with Salt Removal and Reclamation Systems
This question is quite closely related to the one above and related to austemper furnaces. I have seen several examples of your mesh belt furnaces being used for austempering, is this a large product offering for you?
Actually, Continuous Mesh Belt Austempering Systems have been an active product for CAN-ENG since the early 1990’s. Generally, we would build on average One or Two lines every year. Thus far, CAN-ENG has supplied systems ranging from 150 lbs/hr to 3,000 lbs/hr capacity, processing a wide array of parts requiring a tough bainitic microstructure. We have found that after we engage and consult with our customers and share the depth of process know-how and integrated equipment features there is a realization and appreciation by the customer with added value CAN-ENG provides with this niche product.
A topic of a great deal of interest to all furnace builders is the potential transition from Internal Combustion engines in vehicles to electric. The concern of course is that there are far fewer parts in an electric vehicle to be heat treated as opposed to ICE systems. Is this an area of concern for Can Eng and if so what steps are you taking?
Of course, there is a concern however CAN-ENG has been actively addressing this for some time and is well prepared to support our existing and new customers with the technologies that will be coming down the pipeline. This is why, CAN-ENG routinely invests in our Research and Development Center. CAN-ENG’s R&D center is made available to support customers and augment their in-house development capability resulting in a true partnership. Our world class customers have found CAN-ENG’s R&D capabilities of significant value that includes: High temperature processing (direct fired or atmosphere), low temperature aluminum component heat treatment and heat processing development, Quench technologies that include Oil, Polymer, Salt, Spray, Precision Air Quenching (PAQ™), Hybrid Quenching and Integrating Automatic Part Handling. CAN-ENG employs sophisticated R&D Engineering tools that include CFD modeling, Physical Part Testing and Measuring Equipment, Atmosphere Sampling Meters and Time Elapsed Thermal Imaging to name a few.
A hot topic these days is how difficult it is to find and retain good workers. Does Can Eng have solutions to reduce the dependence on human interaction?
As you know, furnace engineering is not an elective available when completing secondary education and of course brings together a wide array of engineering applications. For this reason, CAN-ENG invests considerable time with on-the-job development and mentoring of our staff. We find that our people enjoy what they do and want to grow within the organization. Some of these positions require direct human interaction and some do not. As a global provider of Industrial Furnaces, CAN-ENG values the need to have local support and as such, has developed a key group of Furnace Advisors located in key Geographies around the world. With the growth that we are now experiencing, a number of new engineers have been brought on to commence training and knowledge transition.
We’ve covered two of your product lines, mesh belt furnaces and austempering systems, however I know the company has other product lines-perhaps you could share with us what other innovative products the company has to offer.
CAN-ENG is well know for its Aluminum Heat Treatment Technology which has been an active and growing product group for CAN-ENG since the late 1990’s. In the early days, CAN-ENG’s name was synonymous with Continuous High–Capacity, Roller Hearth Basket Style Cylinder Head and Engine Block T-6 Heat Treatment Systems (Solution Treatment, Water Quench and Artificial Aging).
As part of CAN-ENG’s continued product development, we introduced our Basketless Heat Treatment System (BHTS®) in the 2000’s and realized significant interest as a result of the benefits that include reduced $/pound and capital costs to process, improved product quality associated with individual part handling and reduction equipment floorspace requirements. BHTS® processing was made possible via the integration of robotics within the heat treatment cell. Robotics Integration has become an area of specialty today, after having integrated well over 200 robots into our Heat Treating Systems.
More recently, CAN-ENG is widely recognized with the development of Aluminum Heat Treatment and Heat Processing Systems required by the mobility industry in applications of light weighting components. This includes Thin-Walled Structural Aluminum Casting Heat Treatment Systems that are integrated with Precision Air Quench Technology as well as Aluminum Sheet Hot Forming and Quench systems used for Body in White component manufacturing.
Lightweighting. I have heard the term used by various individuals including yourself but I have to confess I am not entirely sure what it means-would you care to elaborate?
Lightweight is a term used in the mobility market as any manufacturing process change that can be applied to reduce the overall weight of a vehicle. Vehicle weight reduction is something that is continuously sought after as a means or improving fuel consumption or vehicle range. Examples include integrating aluminum castings in place of iron castings or fabricated metal assemblies and integrating carbon fibre over traditional metals or plastic components. Of course, the economics of these manufacturing processes provide the direction on what is economically feasible and what is prohibitive.
One of my favorite questions and the one which is probably the most difficult to answer is what does the future hold for Can Eng and the heat treat industry in general? Since it is rather an unfair question let me make a couple of suggestions. When Can Eng first introduced mesh belt furnace lines they were relatively small-1,000 pounds per hour was typical. We are now at the stage that 6,000 pound/hour lines are not uncommon-how far can you push this? Are we going to see 12,000 pound/hour lines at some point? Another question about the future-salt. It is not uncommon to find companies mandating the elimination of salt for quenching on the basis that it is not environmentally friendly (whether this is the case or not is open for discussion). On the other side of the coin salt is one of the best quenching mediums out there. Do you feel that salt in heat treating applications is going to slowly disappear from the industry?
We see a great future for CAN-ENG in the Heat Treating Industry. As mentioned earlier, with CAN-ENG’s prepositioning for future technology and R & D capabilities we are uniquely prepared to support the current and future needs of the industry. CAN-ENG has identified tremendous opportunities in the EV sector and future mobility market , and are actively pursuing them. In addition to new technologies, CAN-ENG will continue to enhance our existing product value proposition. This may take the form of increased capacity, reduction in cost of ownership or both.
We see salt having a home in the future and would dare say that as engineers push the limits of material engineering properties, the need for salt quenching will become greater! What is important is the continuous development of Austemper system such that we can eliminate wastewater discharge through improved cleaning and diversion systems while also ensuring the systems provided eliminate any risk.
Victor I very much appreciate the chance to speak with you today and look forward to visiting your plant in the near future.
Ben Gasbarre
President, Gasbarre Industrial Furnace Division
We are very pleased to be able to offer you an interview with Mr. Ben Gasbarre, President of one of the larger furnace manufacturers in North America Gasbarre Industrial Furnace Systems.
Ben we have known each other for a number of years, I have to say I have been looking forward to asking you a few in depth questions about your background, the history of Gasbarre and your thoughts about the heat treatment industry and where it is going.
Thank you, Gord. Appreciate the opportunity to speak with you.
Since Gasbarre is a family owned business I certainly don’t have to ask how you got involved in the heat treatment industry but I would like to ask about your earliest memories about working at Gasbarre. What was your first position at the company?
My memories of Gasbarre go back to when I was young, visiting my Dad, and walking around the manufacturing floor. In the summers I worked in shipping and receiving and in customer service roles at our Press Division in DuBois, PA. I didn’t get my first taste of the furnace division until I graduated from college, at which point I started overseeing manufacturing and scheduling at our furnace facility in St. Marys, PA. Over time, I took on more responsibility in purchasing, inventory control, and project management. I learned a lot in my first few years about our manufacturing processes, but most importantly, I learned how the furnaces worked inside and out, and how they were used by our customers. Today, I spend most of my time focused on growing our business through customer relationships, ensuring that we are providing the best customer service and driving technology changes across all furnace lines.
Tell us a bit about the company, specifically as it relates to supplying thermal processing systems. For our readers that are not that familiar with Gasbarre we should briefly mention that Gasbarre also provides other solutions for manufacturing, generally related to the powdered metal industry.
Gasbarre was started in 1973 by my grandfather, George Gasbarre Sr., we started as a compaction press manufacturer for the powdered metal industry, which we still supply today on a larger scale. Since that time we’ve acquired eight different companies, and have started up an additional two. Today we design and manufacture compaction presses for powdered metal, ceramics, and hard metal applications. We design and manufacture precision tooling for compaction presses. We also design industrial automation solutions, and supply contract machining and fabrications for a wide range of industries such as oil & gas, glass, rail car, and mining.
Of course we have the Thermal Processing Systems division, which started with the strategy of diversifying our product line through complimentary products. Our first was the acquisition of Sinterite in 1989 to supply sintering furnaces to the powdered metal industry, then in 2003 we acquired C. I. Hayes, which enabled us to enter the higher temperature market with their atmosphere pusher furnaces and vacuum furnaces. In 2011 we acquired J. L. Becker, which allowed us to enter the broader heat treat market with our line of batch atmosphere equipment. We have made substantial changes both organizationally and in regard to our product technology and services since the acquisitions. In 2018 we rebranded all our product lines under the Gasbarre name you see today. Our focus is not on the name of the equipment, but supplying the proper type of equipment for our customers’ application. Today, thermal processing equipment and related products accounts for about half of our sales. Compaction press and tooling is about 35%, with contract machining and fabrication being about 15%.
What products do you supply to the industry?
I believe we have one of the broadest product offerings in the market. In some cases that can be seen as a “jack of all trades, master of none” situation, but with us that isn’t the case. The way we’ve grown the business has allowed us to maintain technical knowledge and expertise for each of the product lines. Our core products include: continuous mesh belt and pusher furnaces for annealing, brazing, and sintering. Both batch and continuous vacuum furnaces for nearly any process, and can adapt oil and gas quenching, or slow cooling. Batch atmosphere equipment for most heat treat applications including annealing, hardening, nitriding, tempering, etc… We also provide aftermarket parts and service. We have extensive fabrication capabilities for muffles, retorts, fan shrouds, and fixturing. We are also ISO 17025 accredited for control calibrations.
My first impressions of Gasbarre (and these go back quite a while), is that the company is very strong in mesh belt sintering furnaces which is no surprise since Gasbarre was started in the sintering capital of the world, St. Marys, PA. I know you are still very strong in this area but recently I have seen the company expanding into other areas such as nitriding. Why nitriding furnaces and why now?
Yes, as mentioned earlier, we got our start in the powdered metal industry, and still have a large presence in the market today. The sintering furnace product offering equates well to processes such as annealing and brazing, which have helped grow that portion of the business.
Regarding the nitriding, it is no secret that has been a growing process for many years. We saw a hole in the market where most OEMs of that style equipment are based overseas, and there was an opportunity for a domestic provider offering the latest in nitriding and FNC technology. While we have made plenty of equipment for nitriding over the years, Gasbarre wasn’t well known for it. We brought on personnel familiar with selling the process, maintaining the equipment, and who have managed operations and metallurgy based around nitriding and FNC. From there we updated our designs and controls to ensure compliance to AMS standards, have technology for improved cycle times, process control, and repeatability. The horizontal style nitriding units are gaining more traction in the U.S. and we’ve been able to impact the market with our ability to design, manufacture, and service the equipment all from the United States. Again, that is not something most OEMs of these style furnaces can say.
As more and more processes are converted to nitriding and FNC, we look forward to being apart of it, and supporting the domestic industry in its continued growth.
The company has grown over the years through organic growth, but also through acquisitions. CI Hayes and the JL Becker Company are two acquisitions over the years that come to mind. Going forward do you see more acquisitions or are you content with the organic growth you have been seeing?
You can never stop looking for additional opportunities for growth. From my past comments, you can see acquisition is a large part of what we’ve done. At the same time, we know we have a strong product offering, and can continue to advance our products and services to expand our footprint in the market. Currently our focus is organic growth and product/service development, but we are always open and opportunistic if the timing is right and the fit is right for acquisition.
You have one particular product line which has always fascinated me, continuous vacuum furnaces. I say fascinated because it is a very unique concept and one which you don’t see that often. Is this a large portion of your business and do you have any competition?
You are correct, the continuous vacuum furnace is a unique product in the market. The process flow of the equipment fits well into many medium to higher volume manufacturing environments. Our design also takes maintenance into consideration, and allows easy access to the heating chamber and other areas of the equipment. With the heating chamber maintaining vacuum it creates the purest of environments for part quality and repeatability. We’ve had certain captive heat treaters justify a continuous vacuum furnace on part quality alone. We’ve also seen conversion from high temperature atmosphere pusher furnace processing to the continuous vacuum furnace. This allows the same type of part flow through the manufacturing process, while also gaining significant savings in atmosphere and energy consumption using vacuum over atmosphere technology.
Over the years we have seen a lot of activity in this product line with aerospace OEMs, tool manufacturers, and even some commercial heat treaters. Of late more interest has come for the benefits of high temperature sintering as it relates to both powdered metal and additive manufacturing applications. We certainly see it as a differentiator in the market, and a product line that has growth opportunity.
COVID-19. How has this effected your sales volumes, sales strategy and the topic of most concern for all manufacturers these days-your ability to find and retain employees?
We are definitely back to more normal levels (and above in some areas) since COVID hit in early 2020. The fall of 2020 is when we saw things start to come back, and since January business has been strong across the board. Between our work on the digital marketing side, and our ability to service and retain existing customers, we’ve been able to grow our backlog to levels we hadn’t seen since 2018. We have been fortunate on the personnel side in that we were able to increase our manufacturing capacity by almost 50% as things picked back up. We are continuing to recruit to keep up with demand, and have upcoming plans for expansion on the furnace side that will be announced soon.
Lets switch gears slightly and look at the global market. Are sales outside of North America significant for the company? The second part of this question would be global competition. Do you often run across Asian or European competitors when quoting in North America?
Throughout our history we’ve seen our international business account for anywhere from 15%-30% of our business. Obviously with the dynamics of COVID that has been reduced over the last couple years. While we have international representation and service, our focus on the furnace side is North America. It is a large market with plenty of opportunity.
With our diverse product offering we run across all different kinds of competition depending on the product or market. For instance the continuous mesh belt market in Mexico sees competition from Europe, Asia, and the U.S. depending on the company’s ownership. As I mentioned earlier many of the players in the nitriding equipment market are European. Then when we get into the vacuum and more conventional heat treat equipment the competition is mostly domestic.
The competition does vary quite a bit, and again, we see our advantage as being a strong player in each of these areas, and can offer an objective approach to providing a solution to our customers. We don’t go into an opportunity pushing a single product. We can objectively look at what the customer wants to do, and offer batch or continuous style processing, or even weigh atmosphere versus vacuum technologies.
Lets look to the future for our next questions, first up would be the upcoming ASM show in St. Louis, MO this fall- the first North American heat treat show in 2 years. Your company will be exhibiting there, what are you expecting attendance to be like? To phrase it another way do you think the average North American heat treater is over their fear of COVID and ready to “mingle”?
I attended the Metal Treating Institute’s spring meeting in May and I have to say attendance was great, and people were eager to have the personal face-to-face interactions. We recently exhibited at the MPIF (Metal Powder Industry Federation) show, and while attendance was down compared to normal years, the activity level and quality of collaboration at the event was high.
I still think we have a mix going into the ASM show in September. People are ready, the market is ready, but companies are still going to take advantage of cost savings as it relates to travel and other aspects of attending a show. Obviously the new COVID variants are a cause of concern. With that said, we are excited about the show, we believe attendance will be good and we expect to generate opportunity from it.
This question is the most interesting in my opinion but also far and away the hardest to answer; What does the future hold for the heat treatment industry? For instance do you see the possible growth of electric cars dramatically changing the amount and type of heat treating? Are greenhouse gas emission concerns going to change the style of furnaces?
You are right, we’ve paid special attention to some of the market conditions you are referencing. While it seems inevitable the market will change with the electrification of vehicles the real question is when. All of our industry organizations have an eye on this and are supporting companies that will need to adapt. We as a company are working on the next phase in finding the opportunity that will be created from electric vehicles, additive manufacturing, and the expected growth in vacuum heat treating. With that said, we have a lot of optimism in the growth of current markets over the next several years, we are proud and confident in the product offering Gasbarre has created, and we look forward to advancing our products into the future!
Ben I very much appreciate the time and looking forward to seeing you in the near future.
Jim Demarest
VP Sales & Marketing, North American Cronite
Jim you and I have known each other for some time now-it actually dates back many years to when we were both working with furnace builder AFC-Holcroft. However in spite of this long history I don’t believe I have ever asked how you got into this industry. Could you give us some background?
I got my start in the industry from a help wanted ad in the Detroit Free Press. My soon to be Mother-In-Law clipped an ad out of the paper for a Project Manager with Holcroft in Livonia, Michigan. I was living and working in Lansing, my fiancé teaching in Dearborn, and a summer wedding fast approaching. Vera Roggen, Manager of Contracts, was kind enough to hire me and launch my education into capital equipment and heat treatment. I was fortunate that Holcroft had a very experienced team that was willing to share their knowledge. After our acquisition by Atmosphere Furnace Company, I had the pleasure of working for and being mentored by Gordon Willett. On the morning of September 11th, Gordon promoted/transferred/off-loaded me to the sales department to work for Tim McMann. It was just a surreal day for me with this significant career change being followed by a world altering terrorist attack. It’s been quite a ride ever since. The heat treat industry has been very good to myself and my family, and I owe it all to my Mother-In-Law wanting to keep her daughter close to home.
Can you tell us a little bit about North American Cronite’s background and how the company got started? Where are they located, how many people work there, what products you offer? Along the same lines where would Cronite rank in size compared to other alloy suppliers?
North American Cronite (NAC) was founded in Cleveland, Ohio in 1976 as a sales, distribution, and fabricated products manufacturing location for Cronite Castings Limited (CCL) in the UK.
In 1992, AFE Technologies completed its acquisitions of Cronite Castings Limited (1919), Mancelle de Foundry (1935) in France, and Klefisch (1917) in Germany to form a European foundry group. There were several name changes along the way as AFE expanded to add steel casting and plastic injection molding to their portfolio. In 2018, the Cronite Group was spun off as an independent entity.
The Cronite Group continues its global presence with five alloy foundries in (England, France, India, and China), two fabricated products facilities (Germany and USA), a CFC fabrication facility (France), an R&D center (Czech Republic), and sales offices throughout the world.
Cronite is know for our expertise in design, engineering, and alloy development. Our foundry processes include green sand for mass production, chemical sand for items over 2 Tons, lost wax for very accurate parts, and centrifugal for tubes.
The Cronite Group is a midsize company with revenue of 75-100 million Euro and approximately 750 employees. We pour over 3,000 tons of cast alloy products annually.
There are a number of different casting processes, sand cast and investment cast are two that come to mind. To many of us the differences are not clear as to why you would choose one over another. I certainly realize that this could turn into a very long, detailed explanation but if you could give us a brief overview it would be appreciated.
The three primary differences to focus on would be Cost, Accuracy / Surface Finish, and Strength. The lost wax or investment casting process is generally more expensive. It requires more manufacturing steps and energy to produce similar parts. Lost wax is ideal for small parts or parts with complicated details/features which require dimensional accuracy. The surface finish of lost wax parts is fine and uniform. Lost wax is occasionally requested for part contacting surfaces. Green sand is ideal for high volume production. Green sand products also have a finer grain structure due to the slower cooling rate and are generally stronger in applications with mechanical forces applied at elevated temperature.
People sell the process they produce, so I can understand how there may be some confusion in the market. We routinely provide solutions with products using both processes.
Jim I had the privilege of hearing you give a talk at a heat treatment open house at ECM USA a few years back. In that talk you explained how Cronite was offering “hybrid” fixtures for lack of a better term, basically combining a cast fixture with a CFC fixture-why? Let me rephrase that slightly, what are the benefits of combining the two materials and has it proven to be a success?
Just like with lost wax and green sand, CFC and Alloy each have their Pros and Cons. Our addition of CFC/Graphite machining in 1995 to our facility in France allows us to design and produce hybrid solutions combining refractory alloys and carbon materials to achieve the perfect balance of cost, strength, weight, and temperature/process resistance.
At the 2019 ASM Heat Treat Show in Detroit, I believe there were more CFC suppliers than alloy suppliers exhibiting. The same principle holds here where people sell what they produce. Our niche in the NA market has historically been dedicated heat treat fixtures due to our design/engineering expertise. Our CFC/Alloy Hybrid fixtures are simply an extension of this design strength, combining the benefits of each material to maximize load size, life cycle, and process results all while minimizing cost.
Lets talk competition, in particular lets talk China and India. Both have made efforts to penetrate the North American and European markets with low–cost alloy products and both have had some success or perhaps I should say limited success. Do you see this changing?
The alloy foundry business is a very difficult business. It’s particularly difficult when you consider the product mix is thousands of short run part numbers in multiple alloys being used in a destructive process which makes your parts a consumable. It is very challenging to satisfy price, delivery, and life cycle at the same time.
There will always be a place in any market for the low-cost supplier whether they be domestic or international. There are not many corners to cut in our industry, so the low-cost supplier typically utilizes excessive scrap, has poor quality controls, simplified tooling with few cores, and a standardized feeding system. The size of the market willing to purchase from the low-cost supplier will remain roughly the same over time. At present, it’s very difficult for the low-cost international supplier to compete due partially to tariffs but mostly to logistics costs and delivery time in this post-covid economy.
China and India have their own domestic markets which include many North American and European customers. A foundry being located in either of these countries does not necessarily make them a low-cost supplier. We operate foundries in both India and China, and the bulk of our production is for their respective domestic customers. Our Cronite Kartik foundry in India is primarily dedicated to the Petrochem industry so not too applicable to your readers. Our Cronite Castings Wuhan foundry in China started production in 2009 and has excelled at lost wax production of larger parts for the heat treat market. Their success this past decade is the reason we are currently ramping up production of a newly constructed high volume green sand plant. Don’t get hung up on location. It’s a global world now and quality products can be produced anywhere.
The last year has been “trying” which is truly an understatement of monumental proportions. What would you say are your biggest challenges as a company have been over the past year and how are you overcoming them?
Our biggest challenge of 2020 was the simultaneous build/launch of our new green sand foundry in China and the closing of our foundry in Mexico. Travel restrictions and quarantine requirements compounded the challenges involved with these two major tasks. Fortunately, we’ve essentially completed both projects and it’s merely a matter of ramping up production to pre-pandemic levels.
Business has really fluctuated because of the pandemic, how was this past year for you and what do you expect for the remainder of 2021?
Globally the Cronite Group did experience a pandemic downturn, but our North American Cronite business unit did not. I’m not sure why. Maybe we just had the right product and/or customer mix. 2021 has been supercharged since January 4th. I expect it to continue well into 2022.
I can imagine you run across some odd requests in terms of materials, processes or quantities. Are there any really memorable or interesting jobs that you’ve worked on that you can share with us?
I’ve certainly experienced many unique requests in my 24 years in this industry. Having signed so many NDAs over the years, I must be rather general with these two alloy stories.
We were approached by a captive heat treater looking to purchase a batch IQ tray at 6” thick. Aside from being incredibly heavy, expensive, and difficult to cast, this obviously prompted a few questions to understand the why behind the request. The why was the need for flatness precision of the base tray and the 6” thickness request was to provide sufficient machining stock for years of service life. We proposed and delivered a hybrid Alloy/CFC solution which provided the results they were looking to achieve.
We had another captive heat treater request a replacement for an existing pit carburizing fixture. This was during covid lockdown, so I was unable to visit the plant. During our proposal design review, the customer casually mentioned that his existing fixture was well over 40 years old. This set off a red flag for me. What in the world am I missing for a pit carburizing fixture to last 40+ years? They sent us the existing fixture for review and dimension confirmation, and it was a wrought 330 fixture! I was now truly perplexed and worried that I would not be able to provide a solution which matched the longevity of the original fixture. Come to find out this fixture was used for very low volume specialty parts, so the cycle count of the existing fixture was equivalent to maybe 3-years of high–volume operation.
My daughter will make fun of me when she reads these “memorable” stories.
I know you used to travel quite a bit to see customers, do you still travel as much as you used to? Do you think business is going to transition to a lot more online meetings rather than in person?
Aside from the initial 6-8 weeks lockdown period, I traveled and visited customers throughout the pandemic. I find in-plant visits to be very helpful in grasping the full picture before recommending a fixture solution. I have had more Zoom, Teams, Skype, and WebEx meetings than ever, but things are trending back to the old normal rather quickly.
Another thing that’s really changed with the pandemic is the transition to online heat treat shows. Do you think the upcoming show will be held in person or online? Will Cronite be planning on having a booth this year?
I certainly hope we are in-person. St. Louis is my hometown, so I’m looking forward to taking a few extra days to visit family and childhood friends. We will have a booth if the in-person show goes forward. Attendee numbers will probably be down, but it’s still worthwhile in my opinion to maintain relationships with other suppliers to the heat treat industry.
Please look deep into your crystal ball and tell me what you see short term, medium term and long term for the industry. A good starting point would be electric vehicles, a discussion you and I have had several times recently. Personally I believe it will be some time before EV’s become prevalent enough to effect the volume of heat treating required currently but it would appear that you are seeing something different.
My crystal ball is always evolving, and I must admit I failed to appreciate one fact I learned from the Dennis Beauchesne podcast. There are fewer gears in an EV transmission, but the gears are larger. It’s been a few years since I sized an LPC furnace, so I failed to grasp the impact of gear size on furnace chamber requirements. To see the forest through the trees, sometimes you need to be a good listener. Heat treat volumes may not be affected as much by the transition to EVs as I had originally thought. EVs are coming, and our electrical infrastructure will have to grow to meet this demand. Ford has done an exceptional job of marketing the benefits of the F-150 Lightening, and its level of success will be the key indicator in determining the speed of market change.
From a heat treat perspective, I can confidently say that EV transmission production will cement the transition from atmosphere carburizing to LPC for automotive gears. It may also expand the use of other specialty thermal processes which are not currently being utilized for automotive gears. We certainly have exciting times ahead of us.
Where else can you see us going? Boom times ahead for the heat treatment industry?
The continued growth of automation and process/part traceability is enhancing our customers ability to accurately track their heat treatment costs. Cronite has been at the forefront of this development for our automotive customers. Our carburization resistant alloy grades and alloy/CFC hybrids will continue to grow in popularity as customers realize the benefits of a higher initial cost but lower total cost. These technology developments will probably have a larger impact on future alloy volumes than the transition to EV transmissions.
Jim as always I enjoy speaking with you and look forward to many more conversations in the future. Sincerely, Gord Montgomery.
Craig Moller
Chief Engineer at Ipsen
We are very pleased to be able to offer this interview with Mr. Craig Moller, Chief Engineer for furnace manufacturer Ipsen in Rockford, Illinois, USA. Craig brings with him over 40 years of experience in the heat treating industry and has the distinction of being the driving force behind the famous Ipsen “Turbo Treater” vacuum furnace.
With your vast experience in the design of heat treatment furnaces I am sure you must have some fascinating stories about furnace design to share but let’s start at the very beginning. How did you come to be Chief Engineer for Ipsen?
As the years rolled by I worked my way to senior mechanical engineer, where I checked other designers work, visited customers, and involved myself in solving field problems while still doing my own design projects. Some of my designs resulted in multiple patents for Ipsen.
As years passed by, when Ipsen merged with Abar the engineering group was split between the two locations in Bensalem, Pennsylvania, and Cherry Valley, Illinois. Eventually the owners of the company made a big decision to consolidate Abar and Ipsen in Cherry Valley (1997), where I was then made manager of the mechanical engineering department.
Abar Ipsen employees in Cherry Valley, Illinois, after a company merger.
Abar Ipsen 50th anniversary in 1998
As you can imagine, I have seen a lot of changes within Ipsen in my tenure. Most of those changes affected me in a positive way, like opening up the path for my current role as chief engineer. The engineering department was re-organized and I began working within the sales and marketing department and reporting directly to the President of the company. I continue to be involved with the design group mentoring the younger engineers while working on new furnace concepts and product development.
The bottom line of how I came to be Chief Engineer at Ipsen was dedication to the company and its customers.
The Ipsen “TurboTreater” vacuum furnace is a legend in the heat treatment industry-rumor has it that this was your creation. How did this come about and why has it been such a success story?
Yes, the Ipsen TurboTreater® is my “baby”. Prior to the merge of Abar and Ipsen, when the two companies were still competitors, Ipsen only had vacuum furnace designs with rectangular hot zones and internal gas cooling systems, and Abar only had vacuum furnace designs with round hot zones and external gas cooling systems. The Vice President of Sales at Ipsen approached the engineering group and challenged us to design a vacuum furnace with a round hot zone and an internal gas cooling system to capture the advantages of those two designs. The project was given to me to head up in 1984. The prototype TurboTreater® hit the shop floor in 1985 and soon after the initial testing was completed, the furnace was introduced to the market.
The first TurboTreater® brochure, featuring Craig on the cover (left, person pointing).
The success of the TurboTreater® results from its features. There are no actuated parts in the hot zone, the round hot zone has inherent load geometry flexibility, the compact internal cooling system delivers more cooling gas volume flow per horsepower, and the furnace has a user-friendly controls platform. The heating and cooling performance is outstanding. We currently have over 750 TurboTreater® units in the field.
Another very successful product for Ipsen has been the line of “TITAN” vacuum furnaces. My impression is that the “TITAN” line has been successful for a number of reasons, primarily that it is very cost effective, installation can be done in just a few days, lead time is excellent and it is a fairly standard product. Are my impressions correct? How many have now been sold around the world
You are correct. The TITAN® has been a very successful platform product for Ipsen.
Along with the reasons you have stated above, the controls platform is set up for multiple languages, easily selectable, and some of the mechanical design features stemmed from the TurboTreater® design (round hot zone, internal cooling system, etc.).
Ipsen has sold almost 400 TITAN® furnaces since the prototype in 2009.
I am shocked sometimes at the size of some of the furnaces Ipsen has produced over the years-as a matter I was told recently that your company has built at least one brazing furnace with a weight capacity of 50,000 pounds. Is this true or is somebody getting carried away? While we are talking about large capacity furnaces what is the largest vacuum furnace design that you have been involved with?
While I can’t specifically discuss the large brazing furnace due to non-disclosure agreements, I can state that Ipsen has many very large vacuum furnaces in its portfolio with large payload capacities. The largest vacuum chamber we have designed so far has a volume of 10,300 standard cubic feet.
With four decades of experience in the business you must have seen a vast number of changes. What trends have you seen over the course of your working career?
When I started work at Ipsen in 1978, office word processors were starting to be used. Digital 2D drafting tools were available, but only as main frame systems that would take up a whole room. Handheld calculators were just becoming available. Drawing storage was hard copy or microfilm. It took a long time to get drawings or copies of drawings from the blueprint room. Designing a furnace took a very long time relative to what we can do today. I would estimate that today’s technology has cut the design time and information gathering by a factor of at least 10. 3D CAD is a blessing.
Special Projects Engineering Team room where Craig drafted the first prototype TurboTreater® and engineers worked on R&D.
On the furnace side of things, controls have evolved over the years with advancing technology. When I started, controls were all relay logic. Furnace cooling performance has increased drastically from 43 years ago. The vacuum furnaces I first worked on had cutting edge technology with 40 horsepower cooling motors and up to 15 PSIG gas quenching pressure. Today 400 horsepower cooling motors and larger are common. Some dedicated cooling chambers (20 bar) can generate up to 1 megawatt of cooling power. Hot zone materials have also changed. Graphite insulation was just starting to be used in vacuum furnaces when I started. Today we still use mostly graphite insulation in vacuum furnaces but carbon/carbon materials have been added to the design mix.
Most recently, the IoT has taken root in furnace design with many added sensors for checking furnace health. Remote monitoring of the furnace with embedded alerts for system malfunctions is common and the end result is a predictive maintenance system which can save the end users many maintenance, downtime and performance headaches.
This question ties in with the previous one-automation. What I mean by that is that 40 years ago there was little in the way of automated heat treat departments but as automation becomes more reliable and costs come down automated heat treatment departments become more possible. Is this becoming a common request from customers?
Automation of heat treat departments and the equipment within is becoming more common. You see it more on the atmosphere furnace side of the business. Atmosphere furnaces are generally set up as a line with integrated washers, tempers, and load handling equipment. Load tracking and storage are part of the system. There is a breadth of unique automated systems in the field, each one serving a purpose. It’s exciting to see our furnaces as part of those systems.
Speaking of customer requests, what are customers asking you for these days? Higher pressure quenching? Easier maintenance? Lower price? Larger capacity? Probably it is a combination of all of these but if you had to pick one very common request these days what would it be?
I would say requests for very large furnaces (large work zones) has been common in the last five years. It’s not because the end user wants to heat treat more parts in a given load, but rather the end user has a very large part he needs to heat treat. These days, it is common that we have opportunities in which customers come to us with complex project requirements like large work zone sizes with tight temperature uniformity parameters. We like to embrace these technical challenges.
Pick one project that more than any other sticks in your memory. It could be the largest, it could be the most complicated, it could be the most difficult, it could be the one you are most proud about but which one will you think of first when you are old and grey?
Well I am already old and grey, but not too old yet. The one project that sticks in my memory would be the design of the TurboTreater® vacuum furnaces. I was still a fairly green engineer at Ipsen when I was asked to head up the project. I got to work with a professor from the University of Illinois (where I earned my engineering degree) who was contracted by Ipsen to be a consultant on the project. There was a lot to learn for myself and the other designers working on the project about round hot zone design and high horsepower efficient quenching. Four of my patents came from the design of that furnace.
What next in the evolution of vacuum furnaces? In other words where do we go from here?
1) I would like to see the industry strive for harmonization of pressure vessel design globally. When a high pressure quenching vacuum furnace is sold into a country that has a different pressure vessel code (does not accept the ASME Code) it is very difficult to design and manufacture. There are so many unfamiliar regulations and calculations we educate ourselves on. Lots of time and effort are spent with notified bodies. And the furnaces are usually one of a kind designs meaning you have to go through the steps every time there is one to build. Despite these challenges, we have become quite good at handling this complexity, mastering the ability to deliver systems in accordance with Europe, Japan and China standards to name a few.
2) One of my pet peeves on vacuum furnaces is the use of jack panels for plugging in temperature survey thermocouples. Jack panels are convenient, but a source of error for temperature readings. I would like to see jack panels not be used for temperature surveys, but rather have a system by where the survey thermocouples pass through the chamber to the outside world through vacuum fittings. That will produce very reliable data and give a true indication of what the temperature uniformity truly is in a given furnace. These designs exist at Ipsen, but they are much less convenient than jack panels.
3) More furnace sensors. As mentioned in question five, the IoT and connectivity of furnaces for more data gathering and diagnostics is happening right now. I see a further evolution of this utilizing even more sensors and applying the data from those sensors to perform advanced diagnostics.
Did you like this article? Click here to subscribe to The Monty.
View our recent magazines and podcasts by clicking the following link. https://themonty.com/magazine/
Jeff McLaughlin
McLaughlin Furnace Group
Jeff you are part of a very small group in that you are one of only a handful of people we have interviewed 3 times over the years. Because of this we are going to start off where we left off on your last interview-for our readers who would like to know the origins of McLaughlin Furnace Group we would refer you to Jeff McLaughlin, McLaughlin Furnace Group | The Monty
When we last spoke with you, you were having a record breaking year and you told us that 2019 sales were roughly $15 million USD. Has this upward trajectory continued since that time? Perhaps a fairer way to phrase this would be-how did the “COVID” year, 2020 effect you?
“This past year was definitely interesting for McLaughlin. Many heat treaters halted capital equipment during 2020, which definitely presented a slew of hurtles for our teams to overcome, but we were fortunate enough to have a large backlog of work which allowed us to bridge the gap. As other manufacturing facilities around the nation were forced to shut down due to Covid restrictions, the team here at McLaughlin put our noses to the grindstone and delivered a number of new furnaces, including an automated pusher furnace line, the first Tru-Carb batch IQ line, and a large car bottom line. And, I’d never hear the end of it if I didn’t mention the number of service calls McLaughlin made around the country in 2020. Our service team is second to none and we couldn’t be prouder of the essential work they provided to our partners around the globe. And last, but not least, McLaughlin moved our Midwest location into its new manufacturing facility in Avilla, IN at the beginning of the third quarter last year.”
During our last conversation it came up that you were in the middle of your first “pusher” furnace installation. Is that project now concluded and how did it turn out? Being the first pusher you have ever made was it quite a learning experience?
“The pusher furnace was a custom one-of-one furnace for McLaughlin that proved to be quite a learning experience. The furnace is currently installed and turned over to the customer for running their beginning PPAP parts. I believe this project helped our company grow tremendously through experience and further recognition in the industry.”
You had another milestone in 2020 also in that you installed your first multi unit batch IQ installation. What can you share with us about the installation and the challenges associated with it?
“The first multi unit batch IQ line was a big release for McLaughlin in 2020. McLaughlin launched its first Tru-Carb IQ line with great success. Throughout the project, McLaughlin faced a few speedbumps in the road with material delivery as it seems everyone else has in the past year. As with any new product line, some minor design changes were implemented during start-up to deliver the total heat treat solution we wanted. The batch IQ furnaces have performed above our expectations with PPAP loads complete and showcasing quality results. The equipment line will be completely operational in production by May 1. Throughout 2021, we are looking forward to expanding the Tru-Carb line throughout North America.”
Another memorable event for you last year was a new building in Avilla. How about a few details about size and capabilities?
Reviewing your 2020 projects makes me wonder whether you ever sleep. Are there any other memorable events in the past year that come to mind?
Has the market changed at all in your opinion? Obviously COVID had a great effect on everybody but putting that aside in your opinion have there been many changes in the way heat treating furnaces are designed and built? Changes in competition-more or less? New competition?
“In my opinion, the heat treat equipment market has shifted from high volumes of new capital equipment to more equipment rebuilds and service to maintain existing equipment. We have seen an influx in the rebuild and service work requests to maintain equipment that was neglected in the lull of the 2020 market. Commercial and captive heat treaters seem to to be leaning toward investing in their current equipment and holding off on the larger capital expenses for the time being. I do see the market starting to shift back toward capital equipment as customers begin to develop more confidence in the market.
The competition seems to have stayed relatively consistent in the past few years for big players in the equipment industry. It’s apparent within the industry that McLaughlin is becoming recognized as a major player, and just to be clear, we’re not slowing down one bit. AFC and Surface Combustion are in our crosshairs.”
I have always had the impression that you like new opportunities. Pusher furnaces, batch IQ furnaces, carbottoms, endothermic generators-McLaughlin has covered a lot bases in the past few years. So the question is what will your next new opportunity be? Vacuum Carburizing? Vacuum furnaces-what would you like to try next?
“Keep your eyes peeled for our product line of vacuum furnaces in the coming months.”
McLaughlin Furnace Group consists of McLaughlin in Avilla, Indiana and also vacuum furnace specialist VESCO in East Hartford, CT. However it seems that the atmosphere group in Indiana gets all the attention and VESCO is not as well known. Perhaps you could share with us some information about VESCO-what they have to offer, size of the company and how they are doing these days.
And now Jeff for my favorite question of all-what are you forecasting for 2021? Yes I do want to hear about your forecast for your company but more importantly I would like to know about the industry in general. You are out there in front of captive and commercial heat treaters constantly-what are you hearing?
“Since the beginning of 2021, we’ve seen a major increase in request for capital equipment quotes, but the orders have not been piling up, yet. The industry seems to be healing up as a whole and heat treaters seem to be gaining more assurance in the market. Many sectors of heat treat have been picking up quite rapidly according to our customers. Gun manufacturing is one that has been off the charts. Many other sectors are playing “catch-up” after the COVID shutdowns left some manufacturing with large voids. I foresee the capital equipment business climbing back up to its pre-COVID heights by the end of this year.”
Jeff as always I appreciate your time and look forward to catching up with you again in 2022.
Mr. Mark Hemsath
SECO/WARWICK
We are very pleased to be able to offer an interview with an individual we very much respect, Mr. Mark Hemsath, Director of Nitriding & Special Vacuum Furnaces, SECO Vacuum.
Describe your position and history with SECO/VACUUM.
Hi Gord, I am currently the North American lead for two of our signature technologies. SECO/WARWICK Group is well known for Vacuum Furnaces, advanced solutions in high pressure gas quenching, including our single piece flow equipment known as Uni-CaseMaster and our 4D Quench. My products are gas Nitriding and Carburizing via our Super IQ furnace family. These two surface treatments, Nitriding (and FNC) and Carburizing, are probably the largest volume of heat treated parts in the US. Our equipment is unmatched in quality and in our utilization of advanced technologies in our furnace designs.
How did you get into the business?
SECO/WARWICK is pushing a new carburizing technology. Can you explain this a little further?
We actually took a very well proven technology, known as our CaseMaster Evolution, which is a classic vacuum carburizing and oil quench furnace and we re-imagined it. This furnace line is targeted at aerospace, but the design makes it rather expensive. So we wondered, how do we use the benefits of Low Pressure Carburizing and Vacuum heating and marry it to a less expensive and standard oil quench? The result is a fantastic furnace that is both highly productive, modern and has the best of both worlds (vacuum and atmosphere). And the kicker…. We priced it very aggressively!
What is the status of the Super IQ?
We are almost finished building our second unit. We have met all our goals. We are now aggressively offering the furnace for sale. In addition to higher quality, this furnace offers more temperature ranges and flexibility, yet still uses standard oils, washers and standard tempers. It truly will remake the carburizing market.
You mentioned your long history in Nitriding, what attracted you to Nitriding?
First, there was no attraction! I love technology and I especially like processes. Nitriding is actually much more complex than some other heat treatments. Hence, that was my attraction. When I joined SECO/WARWICK in early 2014, I was intrigued by the gas nitriding line, but it was still rather new to the company. SECO/WARWICK actually built furnaces for a decade for another supplier. Around 2009 we began to push our new nitriding controls technology. When I arrived in 2014, I saw a need to better define our high level of experience and tweak our messaging. State-side, we had no real process expert. I decided I needed to be that expert and I spent many hours and days with our world-renown expert Leszek Maldzinski.
I researched any paper I could find (I started out in the industry doing a lot of research for my father, so I always enjoyed discovering new papers and books on subjects). So, basically, I was self taught, with the help of many experts at SECO/WARWICK in Europe and many friends I have made in the subject of gas and ion nitriding, including Dr. Rolinski, while I was at AHT. What you get with SECO/VACUUM and SECO/WARWICK are science-based process experts and incredibly well-designed equipment. Many people make and sell furnaces. We sell capabilities in heat treatment. With SECO/VACUUM you get expertise from people who have done heat treating, like myself and our R&D people.
What do you enjoy most about the heat treatment business?
Gord, I enjoy helping customers. Often our customers know how to make parts for their industry. When they come to us, they may only be outsourcing the heat treatment. You would be shocked how many people rarely even know the specs they need to heat treat to. So our job is to ask the right questions and use our experience to craft a solution. Since we are a pretty full-service manufacturer, we can solve a lot of scenarios. For instance, if you have a tool steel hardening need, we can offer high pressure quench vacuum furnaces and we also have the nitriding furnaces for those parts that demand a precision gas nitrided layer after hardening and tempering, say for H13 tool steel.
For carburizing, we now have a viable solution for those people looking to carburize low alloy grades that require oil quenching and high volume production. With gas quenching, it gets expensive to batch carburize, as smaller loads are often necessary to get good quenching.
For very high production, we have the 4D Quench, gas quench option, which can offer press-quench quality. So we really are the go-to company for any manufacturer looking to bring heat treat in-house or looking to expand in-house heat treating.
How has COVID affected your business?
In the beginning we were like everyone else. It got challenging. I have always worked from home so that was the easy part! It has been quite the adjustment for many others in our company. Some people just do not like working from home, but I think it is now going to be a part of the work landscape. As far as business, we really took off after mid year. We had a number of large and interesting projects finally close this year and we had a really good year. Next year is looking even better for us in North America and we see the activity picking up even more. We are very optimistic! Even in Europe, we see resiliency in the demand. All our hard work in product advancement and in focusing on core technologies is paying off and we think 2021 will be a banner year. I can’t wait to help more customers. Call me.
What challenges has SECO seen in 2020 besides the obvious on-COVID?
As with everyone else, the product mix will change. Much less focus on aerospace, so we are looking at 3D printing, medical, defense, and automotive, as well as general industrial like tool steel hardening, nitriding and FNC processes. Oil and gas is weaker and agriculture seems stagnant. Opportunities exist in general industrial as we see tremendous growth in basic items like distribution centers (conveyors and robots), trucks, marine and RV.
What in your opinion is the single most exciting innovation you have seen in the course of your career? This could be anything from the widespread use of oxygen probes in carburizing applications, the use of acetylene in vacuum carburizing situations or even advances in burner technology.
Well, believe it or not, this advancement is right here at SECO/WARWICK. I think our 4D Quench product is very significant. From a technology standpoint, let’s go back to when I started in the business. My father had various patents in impinging jets in convection improvements and I worked with him in the 1990’s on these advances and patents. Uniform convection has always been important to me and my training is in convective heating and cooling. 4D quenching uses impinging gas jets to quench parts. These tiny, high pressure jets, along with the fourth dimension of spinning the part, is brilliant. We also do not have the boiling gas film boundaries, which adds to liquid quench problems and distortions. So, purely from a technical point of view, this technology is very significant for quenching with controlled and limited distortions. I congratulate our team and Maciej Korecki on this technically superior concept and product.
Mark how about some predictions for next year? You’ve told us you expect 2021 to be a very good year for SECO but what about the industry in general? More competition from Asian furnace builders? Consolidation or acquisitions amongst the furnace builders? A rebound in aerospace heat treating? Where do you think.
Gord, we have seen some tremendous structural changes due primarily to COVID. This has meant a number of things.
1) Recreation, in a distanced manner, has become more important. This has led to the marine industry and RV industry exploding doing incredible sales. You know I love boating and it is crazy here in Florida. Boats are flying off the lots and it is hard to get engine parts. In RV’s, a friend went shopping and one large dealer said they are selling 30-50 RV’s a day!
2) On the converse, people are flying for travel and business much less. I do not see a significant return in volume until middle to late 2022. This will hurt common aerospace. I just saw that the 737 MAX is approved again and that means all those jets sitting in fields will come back into the market (a soft market). Military will stay strong, as will private jets.
3) Space is very active again, not seen in decades. Space X is leading here and Aerojet Rocketdyne is being bought by Lockheed.
4) People are moving from cities and working from home. We are seeing urban office areas being emptied. No one wants to live or work in a densely populated area and they have learned to work from home and many like it. In Florida, where I live, it means an explosion of home sales, etc. as we see massive new residents, this means tremendous construction on roads and infrastructure. Other states like Tennessee, Georgia, the Carolinas, and Texas are also benefitting from this migration.
5) People have abandoned retail shopping in droves and transitioned much faster to Amazon and other online shopping. This has put a huge burden on delivery services to keep up, and Amazon keeps building distribution centers. One last trend is we have virtually stopped the growth and change to Uber travel. In 2019 people were buying less cars and living in dense urban centers. Now, people need their own cars as they are leaving these places and Uber has hit a wall. This should bode well for Automotive in 2021. Of course, electric and hybrid vehicles are a huge part of that growth and this will even accelerate more in 2021 and 2022.
In all, this represents more structural changes than we have ever seen in one year, by far! Throw in guns being bought everywhere, and we have a good year coming for heat treating, heat treat furnaces and regional changes in these markets. It is really exciting for someone like me, who likes to study manufacturing trends. I will not even get into how much cash has been and is being pumped (and will be) into our markets by Government spending and the Federal Reserve Bank.