Dave Ederer / Stack Metallurgical
Today we are excited about an interview with Mr. Dave Ederer, owner of commercial heat treat Stack Metallurgical in Portland, Oregon.
Dave I am particularly pleased to be able to ask you a few questions today as you have rather a unique insight into the industry. Correct me if I am wrong but I understand that you are a businessman with interests in a number of fields which means you can compare heat treating to other industries and also makes you a bit of a rarity. So my first question is could you share with us your business background and how you got involved in commercial heat treating?
“Thanks Gord. First of all a compliment—I really appreciate what you do for our industry. Your role provides a great deal of information that keep many of us a bit more coordinated about what we do. You describe me properly as a businessman, as opposed to an operator. By background I spent 10 years at Price Waterhouse focusing on merger and acquisition activities from 1965 to 1974. Over the years since I have been involved with over 30 purchases of companies spanning aircraft parts manufacturing, paperboard packaging manufacturing, building demolition and installation equipment for industrial kilns amongst others. My first purchase was in 1974. The company was Commercial Heat Treaters started in 1946 in Seattle. The owners were clients at PW, and when they decided to sell I decided to be the buyer. I was familiar with the business side but not the technical side.”
I have heard Stack Metallurgical described as the best run commercial in North America, a statement which might make you feel uncomfortable but I had to throw it out. What can you tell us about Stack? Size, processes, type of equipment etc.? Why has the company been so successful?
“The author of that statement was my good friend John Hubbard from Bodycote. I believe it is an exaggeration but sure love hearing it from him, a guy I have a GREAT deal of respect for. Having visited Solar and meeting Bill Jones I can assure you that we don’t consider ourselves to be the best, Bill has a great team and the resulting great company. The name Stack is well known in the Northwest industrial community. From Alaska to Spokane and from Seattle to Portland. Originally it was a Steel Service business. One of the best in the US. It was a business that was founded on providing additional services to the customer base. As a result one additional service was heat treating. We competed against them until 1981. At that time the opportunity arose to purchase the heat treating division which I did. We have been open in Portland since January 1, 1984. We have a 72,000 square foot facility and approximately 60 employees. We run 7 days a week and 24 hours a day. We offer a full complement of services but specialize in vacuum work along with the traditional atmosphere and aluminum work. Our vacuum equipment includes Ipsen, SECO and now our recently purchased Solar furnace. Surface has been our atmosphere equipment supplier. Our SECO furnace is an oil quench vacuum with a 10,000 pound capacity and an 86 inch vertical dimension. We have been told by SECO that this is the biggest in the world! I believe the success we have had is directly related to the skills of both our management teams over the years and the experienced operating crews we have had. There is a very clear understanding that our customers are very special and that supplying their needs is solely the reason we exist. I believe the innovation part of what we do has been a result of our willingness to buy really good equipment that others do not have. We have good competitors who we want to be successful so we try to do things they do not do.”
I gather Stack Metallurgical is not your only involvement in the industry. Could you please tell us what other commercial heat treats you are involved in?
“We are the sole supplier located in Spokane, Washington serving the eastern part of the state along with Idaho and Montana. In Seattle we serve the industrial base but oddly enough do not serve Boeing. In Salt Lake and Monterrey Mexico we are partners with Paul Chacon serving the aerospace industry.”
Going back to my first question of heat treating compared to other industries-what is unique about heat treating? For instance many times over the years I have heard heat treating described as basically a service industry with no inventory and no manufacturing. Is this your feeling and along the same lines what other differences do you see?
“This is a different business. It is a daily capacity driven business. Requiring very careful use of your equipment. The “empty hotel room” concept. An empty furnace is lost time forever. I believe that expertise is first, service is second and pricing is third. We are not a commodity. Maintenance as opposed to repairing is a critical decision requiring careful planning. Again one must pay attention to furnace uptime. Finally this is a highly “fixed cost” business. One does really well when at capacity but sure does struggle at low levels of work.”
How would you describe your management style? Micromanager, hands off or somewhere in between?
“Interesting question. You might ask our managers to see if they agree. I am involved on a daily basis with several areas—knowledge—I want information and I want the managers to have information. I like being part of the planning process, the capital decision process, the financing process and visiting customers. I love to visit the shops. I love seeing our people. It is important to know them. I like encouraging. So for the most part I encourage decision making and encourage using me as a sounding board.”
Last year Stack made a very major investment in the form of an enormous vacuum oil quench furnace, one of the largest in North America. What prompted you to make such a large investment and has it been a success?
“I believe this is the largest one in the world—so says SECO, the manufacturer. We are very pleased with the additional capacity. With this furnace we can be a part of our customers sale’s team as much as we are a part of their manufacturing team. This furnace allows them to bid on work that they previously could not bid on. We are looking forward to the upcoming maintenance cycle on the big wind turbine gears.”
Challenges are a fact of life in the business world. Out of all the challenges you face on a day to basis which is the one that causes you the most concern?
“Challenges vary from time to time and cycle to cycle. The biggest one for me now is the 16 trillion dollar debt and the lack of commitment to address this issue. The uncertainties surrounding this issue will affect every business in the US at some time. It is very difficult to think very far ahead with so little being accomplished at the federal government level. Another is the cost issue of employee medical. This is totally out of control for small businesses that provide good coverage to their employees. I am less concerned than before about global competition. I think the US is manufacturing again on a competitive basis.”
With this question we are veering off of the topic of heat treating to some extent but because we value your opinion as an individual with a great deal of business experience I would like to ask it anyway. Current wisdom has it that the USA for years has been exporting jobs to lower cost areas of business and that this will continue which quite obviously means less captive and commercial heat treating in the USA. My own personal opinion is that this is not entirely true but I would like to ask you what do you think? Is North American manufacturing abandoning the continent or is this a misconception?
“I answered question 7 before looking at 8. Think I covered that. I agree with you—our innovation abilities along with the increasing needs of 2.5 billion people coming into the international middle class (China and India) will tax the world’s manufacturing capability.”
Stack pretty much covers all the bases when it comes to processes offered, vacuum, vacuum carburizing, batch IQ, Induction, gas and Ion Nitriding and a few others. Which do you see growing the most and which excites you the most?
“Clearly vacuum. We have 11 pieces now and are still short. I think our customers’ products will demand increasing quality levels and therefore vacuum will expand the fastest.”
The debate about outsourcing (manufacturers sending all their heat treating requirements to commercials as opposed to doing it in house) has raged for years. MTI claims the share of heat treating at commercial shops is currently around 10% and rising, others say that they have not seen much change in the ratio of heat treating in house as compared to commercial. What is your feeling on this? More or less outsourcing?
“We have not seen much change in the northwest. Perhaps a customer or two each year walking through the decision. Typically when a customer’s equipment is in need of significant repair they make another “make/buy” decision. We find that the more complicated the parts are the less likely a customer is to wanting to be in the heat treating business.”
In my opinion many manufacturers attach little value to heat treating. A necessary but unwanted part of the manufacturing process that adds costs and distorts parts with the all suppliers being equal. Is it your feeling that many or most companies only consider the cost of heat treating or do many actually believe that all things are not equal amongst commercial shops and that you get what you pay for?
“We think it is real important to invest in customer relationships and equipment ONLY when a customer understands what we can do to add value to what they are doing. We do not invest in “commodity” mentality potential customers. We feel that other companies are better suited to use up their capacity on those customers.”
As we both know commercial heat treating in North America (and around the world for that matter) consists mainly of relatively small family owned businesses with just a handful of large players such as Bodycote, Bluewater, Paulo, Aalberts and a few others. Is this good or bad for the industry? Do you see the large chains getting larger through acquisitions or do you think this has largely run it’s course? Actually I will take this question one step further and ask you if you have ever actively considered growing Stack through acquisitions?
“We are a result of an acquisition strategy from the beginning. We have been very careful but our Seattle company is the result of the following—Commercial Heat Treaters, Stack Heat treating, Puget Sound Heat Treating, Scanco Heat Treating and Ram-Heat. So we have been active. I believe that our industry will continue to find a balance between the very very large and the rest of us. Our customer relationships are so personal that there will continue to be an important place for our size business.”
So what does the future hold for Stack? Any interesting changes coming up that you can share with us?
“Nothing planned. We are entrepreneurial so we prepare for and anticipate the unexpected. We want to be ready to be first to consider an opportunity, not fast followers, but fast leaders.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Dan McCurdy / Bodycote
Dan you and I have known each other for probably 25 years going back to the early days of Marathon Monitors but I am sure readers would be interested in knowing how you got involved in the heat treating industry to begin with. Care to enlighten us?
“When I was a senior in high school (circa 1972) I participated in the local a Cincinnati ASM chapter recruiting event in conjunction with the University of Cincinnati in which I was introduced to metallurgy. At that point all I knew was that I wanted to be an engineer but I didn’t know what type. I must have checked a box on a form at that event because from that point on, I was heading to the Department of Materials Science and Engineering at UC and I never looked back. UC had a great co-op program which allowed me to go to work at a local gear company (now known as Xtek Inc.) in which I was brought up through the lab and into the operations of their large captive heat treatment department. The combination of the 5-year scholastic schedule with the working every other quarter in a real-world environment was perfect and I found myself quite ready to enter the workforce as a heat treatment metallurgist when it was all over with. A couple of years after graduation I moved into the Commercial heat treatment business with Cincinnati Steel Treating, which gave me a completely different look at the same industry. Looking back, I would say I was very lucky to have these opportunities because it is very difficult to find people these days that’ve experienced anything like it.”
You’ve been with Bodycote now for almost 14 years. What changes have you seen in the company?
“When I joined in 1998, my deal with John Hubbard, who had recently sold his company (Hinderliter Heat Treating) to Bodycote, was to stay 1-2 years and work on special projects for him. Little did I know that John was the future CEO of Bodycote or that I was headed down this incredible path! In those days, Bodycote was a UK-centric company with relatively new investments in Germany, France, and Sweden, plus a brand new seven-plant footprint in North America. It was already the world’s largest commercial heat treater but had almost no reputation to precede it. People were wondering what was going on, how sustainable it all was, and where it was headed.
The first really big change I experienced was the acquisition of Lindberg Heat Treating. From a global perspective, Lindberg was not that big and did not represent a major challenge for Bodycote PLC. But in North America, Lindberg was much larger than Bodycote’s existing footprint and we were somewhat swamped with integration issues for a couple of years. That whole experience was a valuable lesson for me.
The most recent change was the announcement of John Hubbard’s retirement and the appointment of Stephen Harris as our new CEO. This change took place right as the full scope of the 2008-2009 downturn had become evident to all of us. As Stephen walked in the door, the need for serious cuts and restructuring was already growing rapidly, and that’s the direction he had to go. Up until that point Bodycote had been a ‘heat treaters managing other heat treaters” company, but under Stephen (who is an engineer, by the way) this culture gave way to one based more on global strategies, focused local planning and overall fiscal discipline. We are now organized in two global market sectors: “Aerospace, Defense, and Energy” (ADE, which includes HIP) and “Automotive and General Industrial” (AGI). This alignment works very well and can be most easily understood if one envisions all the things that often go wrong when an automotive heat treater chases after aerospace work or vice versa.”
As you said a couple of years back Bodycote split their plants in North America into different divisions, your current title is “President, Automotive and General Industrial Heat Treating, Bodycote North America and Asia” which is a mouthful. With this division what plants are you responsible for around the world?
“The Great Lakes region is still the center of the Automotive and General Industrial customer base in North America, and that’s where most of my Division’s plants are. Moving west to east, they are Eden Prairie MN, New Berlin WI, Sturtevant WI, Melrose Park IL, Indianapolis IN, Ft. Wayne IN, Canton Ronda MI, Canton Haggerty MI, Livonia MI, Columbus OH, Kitchener ON, Newmarket ON, Rochester NY, York PA, and Roselle NJ. I also have responsibility for plants in Silao Mexico, Ranjangaon India, and Wuxi, Ningbo, and Jinan in China.
North American plants in the ADE Division that I do not have responsibility for are concentrated on the East and West Coasts (mostly aerospace and defense) and in the Southwest (mostly energy). My colleague Tracy Glende is responsible for those locations. Another colleague, Jody Turin, is responsible for the HIP (Hot Isostatic Pressing) plants in North America and all over the world.”
Bodycote is the largest commercial heat treater in the world with sales of almost $1 Billion USD/year and the only truly global commercial heat treater. Being the largest has both advantages and disadvantages, an obvious advantage being that you have resources unavailable to many of your competitors but on the other side of the coin a common complaint is that the company has become too large. Specifically it has been said that Bodycote has become so large that it reacts slowly to market changes and that it runs on paperwork. What would you say to these points?
“I wish I had a dollar for every time I heard that Bodycote has all of these purchasing advantages over the independents! Yes, we are able to buy a few things like nitrogen cheaper than many of our competitors via global arrangements. But we also regularly find out that the independent heat treater right next door to us is still getting nitrogen 10% cheaper than we are because he is using a local vendor who was able to piggyback him on another big account close by. The suppliers in the heat treatment industry know the truth, which is that Bodycote pays what everyone pays for most goods and services, and sometimes we even pay more because of our own specifications.
What Bodycote has, which most independents struggle with, is cash to fund growth, all of which comes from operating our business in a disciplined way using our administrative economies of scale that ensure that sales actually convert to profit and cash. With most of our plants, there is constant demand for capital equipment spending which must be refereed by the executive team. We simply choose those projects which we believe will provide the best returns for our shareholders in the medium-to-long term. The process of choosing which projects to execute is not as simple as anyone would like, but the devil is always in the details of these projects and that’s where we have to focus to be sure we’ve got it right. This is the piece that gives us the reputation of being slow to react at times I think.
For example, when approached by a customer to add a furnace in return for doing their heat treating, many independents would jump at the chance. They would find, buy, and rebuild a used furnace and get things rolling, all perhaps in the space of just a few weeks sometimes. The industry is full of examples of heat treatment companies that have grown into very solid businesses by this method. But the industry also has a large number of sick, dying, or dead companies for exactly the same reason. The only difference was often simply the presence of an entrepreneur in the business who somehow instinctively knew which opportunities to grab and which to avoid. With Bodycote being a public company with 180 plants in 28 countries, we obviously cannot rely on instincts of individuals; we instead rely on formal investment evaluation methods to make sure we take advantage of the best opportunities while avoiding those with too much risk. Having said that, when a solid opportunity presents itself we do move things along pretty quickly I think.”
The recent acquisition of the heat treatment plants owned by Metal Improvement Company in the US, one of the largest commercial heat treaters in the country certainly sparked a lot of attention and caught many people off guard. The acquisition has some people scratching their heads as to why Bodycote felt it important to make such a large acquisition at what appears to be a premium price. What are your thoughts?
“If you looked at a map of North America and saw where Bodycote’s plants were in comparison to Metal Improvement’s plants, you would immediately agree that they were located almost exactly where we were not and vice versa. We actually rarely competed with them anywhere. Metal Improvement made the decision to focus on things other than heat treating, and we were able to agree with them a price for the nine (9) heat treatment plants which was not far at all from what historical deals in our industry would indicate. We are happy to have the new plants and are currently integrating them into our management, sales, and logistics strategies which will allow us to reach more US customers than ever before. At this point I can tell you that the acquisition went very smoothly, the plants are so far running well under Bodycote, and the former Metal Improvement employees are for the most part very happy to be a part of our organization. We have definitely learned from the past in terms of smooth integration of acquisitions.”
When speaking to individuals who have a great deal of experience in the industry (and you certainly fit the bill) one of my favorite questions is; “where do you see the industry going in the future?” Things change slowly in this industry, a perfect example of which is Batch IQ furnaces. While there have been some small changes in the design at the end of the day it is pretty much as it was introduced 50 or 60 years ago. So my question would be do you see any radical changes in technology or the way metal parts are processed?
“When we bought our first LPC/gas quench furnace in North America 6 years ago I commented that we had probably bought our last conventional batch IQ furnace. That was maybe 25 batch IQ furnaces ago so my crystal ball is obviously fuzzy. In our industry, we could almost define “revolutionary” as something that takes less than 10 to 20 years to become commonplace. That’s not a shot at the industry – it’s the reality of the industry.
Trends that I see happening at present:
- There continues to be increasing demand for lower distortion heat treatment processes. This trend is decades old and it’s not showing any sign of letting up. Heat treaters who work with customers productively on distortion issues will continue to win market share.
- Continued growth in nitriding, especially FNC-type processes, which are turning up in applications that require simple wear resistance and/or corrosion resistance. The trend away from both hard and decorative chrome plating is driving part of this, but customers have also gotten smarter about using shallower-case processes where they fit with their products.
- There is continued, albeit slow, growth on the commercial side in LPC and gas quenching. This trend has moved slowly because of a lack of commercial process availability which has in turn been caused by very high capital costs. The captives, meanwhile, continue moving forward with LPC on their own. Commercials are going to have to catch up somehow at some point because 30 years from now (note I’m being more conservative this time!) there will be few batch IQ furnaces left.
- Distribution of manufacturing production to emerging markets will continue, commensurate with the projected demand in those markets.
- Competition for new talent will continue to be a challenge for everyone associated with the heat treating business, especially in the mature markets. In the emerging markets, retaining the talented people will continue to be a challenge because there are so many opportunities breaking out all around them. In the 1980’s the heat treatment industry could not spell ‘HR’, but these days Human Resources has become one of the more important administrative departments in Bodycote.”
In such a tight knit industry there are always rumors floating around and one persistent one over the years has been that the company would divest itself of it’s North American operations primarily due to the fact that margins are lower in NA than many other parts of the world. The acquisition of Metal Improvement Company certainly put those rumors to rest but looking at the overall picture what geographic areas do you see as of the most interest to Bodycote in the future?
“Bodycote has NEVER seriously considered divesting itself of its heat treatment plants in North America (just the opposite in fact) and I have never understood the origin of that rumor. One of the very attractive characteristics of Bodycote to investors is its diversification in a portfolio of plants in different geographic markets and all the various market sectors that require heat treatment. These people no longer see us as a UK heat treatment company, or a European heat treatment company, but a globally diversified metal processing company that is able to adjust to, and take advantage of, changing conditions around the world.
Average margins in the North American market these days are quite comparable to those seen anywhere else in Bodycote. That said, there is constant movement in which parts of the North American market are gaining ground and parts which are losing and adjustments constantly have to be made, just as would occur in any business. Occasionally we have to close a plant because the market to support it just isn’t there anymore. This is a very unfortunate but all too-common aspect of global manufacturing industries. At the same time, however, we usually have a nice handful of projects which will lead to new plants in the future in other markets.
As far as where Bodycote is looking for growth in the future, I would say that the emerging markets continue to be of great interest but North America clearly has a long way to go in manufacturing growth and we plan to be part of it.”
While this question is not specific to heat treating it certainly is very connected to it. We all read that manufacturing is fleeing high cost areas of doing business such as North America and Europe and if this is true it will obviously have a tremendous impact on heat treating in these regions. Do you share the general pessimism about that forecast?
“Politicians like to summarize all this in a few sound bites to make companies sound like scoundrels for opening manufacturing facilities in emerging markets, but the truth of the matter is much more complex. My view is that the companies rarely have a choice if they want to survive in the global marketplace.
For a start, it should be obvious that most companies have to go where their customer are. For Bodycote, this meant opening heat treatment shops in China, India, Mexico, the Czech Republic, and so on, simply because our customers were opening plants in those locations and were demanding that we come. Prior to that, our customers opened plants because their customers opened plants and demanded that they come, and so on. This is how a supplier base comes to be in an emerging economy.
The second fact is that some of what used to be made in North America and Europe for export to emerging markets has finally moved to where it can be manufactured and consumed in the same geography, which was inevitable and logical. The typical scenario we see has some production staying in North America or Europe and some moving to the emerging markets. This has been good for the commercial heat treatment industry in all markets, by the way, because lower volumes out of any one manufacturing plant make the idea of captive heat treatment that much less attractive.
The piece that gets everyone upset is when it appears that a company has moved production to an emerging market in order to take advantage of lower labor costs with the intent to export the goods back to the original home market. Having spent years now working on various projects in the emerging markets, I can testify that this does not happen nearly as often as people think it does. It almost never happens with small or medium volumes of machined and heat treated components; the economics simply do not work. There may be savings in labor costs, but energy almost always costs much more in emerging economies and then the goods have to be shipped overseas anyway. We have seen some larger volume projects successfully move, but not across oceans; usually just across a border, with work moving from the US to Mexico or Germany to the Czech Republic being prime examples.
Incidentally, I can state categorically that as of right now it is generally NOT cheaper to do heat treatment in any of the emerging markets despite lower labor costs. Just the opposite, in fact, because the required energy, manufacturing, service, and logistics infrastructures that heat treatment requires are simply not up to par (yet).
There have been a few anecdotes floating around projects that went to emerging markets, only to return a year later because of quality issues. This is certainly not a trend. There is no question in my mind that all of the emerging economies can or soon will be able to compete on quality with any European or North American company. The only open question is how long it will take some of these economies to begin to generate the sort of culture of creativity, innovation, and marketing savvy required to ensure long-term, self-sustaining success. Quite a while, I think, in some cases. Let’s just say that I’m not too worried about my grandchildren’s prospects for gainful employment if they choose to work in US manufacturing. Bodycote has a similar view about Europe; there are simply too many good things going on there to think that it could all move away to other geographies within anything short of a lifetime. And new things are being born in Europe all the time.”
The North American heat treating market has been estimated at $20 Billion/USD per year with commercial heat treating representing 10% of this total (both of these numbers by the way I have never been able to verify). The general consensus at least amongst commercial heat treaters has been that this % has been rising over the years and will continue to rise but again I have never been able to determine whether this is actually the case or more wishful thinking on the part of the commercials. Do you have a good feel for this?
“The data are indeed hard to come by because the required classifications on the captive side simply don’t exist. We do know the sizes of the various commercial heat treatment markets around the globe, but we generally do not know the size of the captive markets with the certainty we would like. The 10% number for the North American market has been floating around for many years, and I believe it is obsolete. I think it’s more like 15% and heading for 20% these days. Around the world it can be clearly seen that the more mature an economy is, the higher its commercial heat treatment share will be. Europe is at least 20% now and it continues to climb. On the other end of the scale, China is far less than 10%, despite the fact that there are several hundred commercial heat treatment shops in Shanghai alone.”
While Bodycote is certainly the largest commercial heat treater in the world you do have a few fairly substantial competitors around the world. Out of your competitors which one most impresses you the most as being a well run, responsive company with good technical and human resources?
“The brightest stars in our industry have tended to be those companies which have managed to couple equipment or process innovation with success in the heat treatment service business. The companies that immediately come to mind in this vein are ALD, Applied Process, Vac Aero, Solar Atmospheres, and Nitrex. However, all of these tend to be focused in their specific niche areas and in my opinion have not enjoyed the kind of large-scale success that can only come from leveraging smart people and money in the broader range of possibilities.
In terms of the US market, we certainly recognize Bluewater Thermal, Paulo Products, Specialty Heat Treating and Specialty Steel Treating (and obviously many others) as worthy multi-plant competitors. And there is no shortage of single-plant independent operators out there who do very well indeed in whatever local markets they are covering, very often giving us major heartburn in the process.”
After all these years are you glad that heat treating became your vocation or should you and I both have entered the computer field?
“Gord, I have landed in a spot that allows me to leverage my entire working experience on a daily basis, so it’s difficult for me to complain about anything at all. However my work is not nearly as glamorous as yours these days, since “theMonty.com” has become a heat treating industry juggernaut in its own right with no doubt the associated riches that ensue. When are you taking this thing public?”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Damian Bratcher / SSI
I am always fascinated by the life lead by Mr. Damian Bratcher “Director International Operations” for Cincinatti, Ohio controls company SSI. I say fascinated because Damian makes 16 international trips a year generally for a couple of weeks at a time on behalf of the company and as such has a very unique perspective on the differences in heat treating around the world. Damian will be at the upcoming ASM show in Cincinatti and will be presenting a paper Monday morning the 16th of September at the ASM Gear Exhibition. If you want to meet Damian in person he will be at booth 1501 at the show and maybe, just maybe, he will buy you a drink or a steak dinner. The photos below are a small sampling of some he had taken during his travels.
Damian I have often been accused of spending my life travelling around the world seeing different heat treat facilities but compared to you as Director International Operations for furnace controls company SSI I am rather a stay at home fellow. On average how much time do you spend away from home and how many countries do you see in any given year?
“Typical travel is around 16 international trips per year plus several trips in the USA. It is about 40% of the time which is less than most sales and service personnel spend on the road. The bigger impact is being gone on those 16 to 20 weekends per year. It can be very difficult to make it to your child’s soccer game or piano recital. You also get to spend many major holidays on the road. As for countries visited, we have operations in Europe (UK), China and Mexico. India, Brazil, Korea, Japan and Taiwan are other regions with large heat treatment markets. Every few years, you go to Australia, South Africa, Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia, etc.”
How many countries have you visited over the years.
“Great question as it is one I had not considered. I had to look at a map and count. I came up with 39 and soon to be 40. Canada is a state, right?”
Having seen heat treating operations on 5 continents do you see much of a difference? For instance do you see a higher standard in some countries or has heat treating become pretty much the same around the world?
“Actually, I have seen heat treatment facilities on six (6) continents and maybe one day there will be a shop in Antarctica so I can make it seven (7). As for standards, the top end of the market is similar all around the world. In developing countries, there will be a very low end to the market where you still see open cyanide baths, charcoal/pack carburizing, no safety equipment and techniques that look to be from the Middle Ages and where you wonder…..why am I here? In some countries, for example China and India, there are two markets that are served – domestic and foreign. The heat treatment for domestic work will be at a lower standard compared to what you will see in Korea, Japan, Germany or the USA. The biggest differences you see around the world are maintenance practices, documentation requirements, atmosphere creation and control philosophy. Maintenance and documentation are more standardized in G20 nations. The client will ultimately dictate how advanced these are at any given shop. If a heat treatment facility is doing aerospace or high-end automotive work, the shop will typically be more pristine and organized than one making nails or general purpose hand tools. When it comes to atmosphere generation, you will see operations with only pure methanol in one part of the world where in others it is all based upon natural gas. In one specific area, it is based upon solid rocket fuel. As for control philosophy, in one area, CO2 is the basis for control in lieu of dew point or carbon potential. There is a split between atmosphere control and associated programming performed in the PLC versus discrete instruments. You see recipe versus segment based programming. The control philosophy boils down to the three major regions of the past 40 years – Germany, Japan or American. All produce excellent results as long as you have your parts at a known atmosphere and temperature for the proper time. To answer your question directly, the more advanced the country, the general standard will be higher and more consistent for heat treatment.”
Along the same lines as the question above is there is a conception/misconception that heat treating in some of the developing countries is not up to par with Europe or North America-your thoughts?
“Companies such as SKF, Schaeffler, Timken, Bodycote, American Axle, Dana, Ford, Eaton and numerous others operate all over the world with the same standards. A multi-national recently opened an aerospace facility in China. They produce parts to the same standard as their other facilities around the globe. You can be up to par anywhere in the world. At one time, Korea was a developing country with a reputation for poor product – consider Hyundai and Kia in the late 80’s and early 90’s or Gold Star appliances. This emerging market of the 80’s has evolved into one of the most sophisticated markets in the world – think Samsung smart phones and LCD screens. Hyundai decided years ago to put long warranties on its U.S. cars to reassure buyers concerned about their company’s then-iffy quality and reliability. The company warranties the powertrain — mainly, engine and transmission — for 10 years or 100,000 miles, whichever comes first. Would you make this offer if your heat treatment process wasn’t well documented, repeatable and to the highest standards at the price they were selling a car? They were able to make the offer because they knew the quality and consistency of their part production and heat treatment processes. They had the results from the domestic market that told them they could make the offer and not have excessive claims. Per the 2013 JD Power IQS, Hyundai and Kia were in the same rating range as Chrysler, Buick, Cadillac, Audi, Mercedes-Benz, Jaguar, Honda, Toyota and Acura. Hyundai, Kia and Mercedes-Benz were tied for 10th place (33 nameplates total) and better than the industry average. As an FYI, the Top 5 were Porsche, GMC, Lexus, Infiniti and Chevrolet. The misconceptions about the non-Eurocentric markets comes from the shops that are serving the local market. Do they have shops that are well below 1rst world standards? Yes. Do they have shops that can compete with their counterparts in the North American and Europe? Yes.”
I know from experience that some countries are easier to do business in than others. What is your personal experience as far as shipping, customs, getting paid and duties? What is your favorite country to do business in and which is your least favorite?
“There are countries where the oxygen sensor must be called an ‘oxygen test tube’ as the translation to the native language better reflects the product. Using the wrong word can triple the duty paid. There are others where a misspelling or lack of pertinent information for a custom agent will result in a major delay or rejection of the shipment. In general, Brazil seems to have the strictest requirements and highest duties. In the CIS (old Soviet-bloc) region, you need GOST certification. Without it, the one-off requirements are more strict and cumbersome than Brazil. Keep in mind, the USA has some goofy rules. We actually had a shipment from a foreign supplier to us rejected by the US government. Every country has its own unique quirks. As for getting paid, there are countries where it is 100% in advance prior to shipment. This requirement applies to everyone in these countries – even multi-nationals. Overall, payment has not been an issue for us. We have been very fortunate.
To do business or to visit? I truly wish there was more business in South Africa and Australia. The engineers in these countries actually read the manuals and have an incredible store of knowledge. It is refreshing when you get questions that are hard to answer because they have tried all published solutions. In general, the places that are low on the list are ones with poor infrastructure – 80 kilometers in 10 hours – or unsafe water or food.”
In your opinion which country has the most advanced heat treating facilities and which the least?
“Advanced heat treating? You can buy a new fixed volume generator with a carburetor – fixed ratio and flows. I don’t recall ever owning a car with a carburetor……when will fuel injection be standard in the industry? Look at the flow meters in a heat treatment facility – then go to another part of the plant and look at the flow meters. Look at the ERP and job tracking systems in part production and then the same in the heat treatment shop. For the most part, heat treatment is a technology generation behind everyone else. There is plenty of opportunity to advance heat treatment. Heat treatment is a dichotomy unto itself. To answer your question, I am a homer at heart. USA! USA! If it is not the USA, it would be Germany. As mentioned, the high-end is the same everywhere. Companies like Phoenix Heat Treat are pushing the envelope of technology (especially in the heat treat industry). Just like in any business sector, the most advanced will be where the money dictates that they have to be advanced or the end product has to be extremely well documented (aerospace). There is a shop in the UK that runs parts for F1 racing teams that is impressive. Ferrari in Italy was the most meticulous shop I have seen. It was hard to see the furnaces through all the plants (supposedly there to maintain humidity levels in the factory) . Making parts for the TATA Nano is not the same as making parts for TATA’s Jaguar division. Is there one country that is the best? I say no.”
When it comes to business the whole world is fixated on China and India as the growth areas of the future. My personal feeling is that yes these areas are growing but I am not convinced that the two countries should be the focus of so much attention. I don’t know whether you agree with me or not but do you see other countries as being well worthwhile to be spending time in?
“Yes. There are many worth time. You are asking two questions really. One is where is the growth or capital equipment spending coming from in the next 10 years and the other is where will we obtain the best return on time invested (focus one’s attention). >From what I hear, there will be substantial growth in South East Asia – from Thailand to Vietnam and inclusive of Malaysia and Indonesia. If Africa ever stabilizes, you will see massive growth and investment in many regions of the continent. Brazil and India will continue to be growing markets. There is enough government hindrance to prevent meteoric growth like we have seen in China over the past 10 years but there will be substantial growth in these two BRICs. As for time invested and where I intend to focus my attention, I am more than happy to share that privately with you.”
Enough of the business questions. What is your favorite country in the world to visit? Where have you not visited and where would you like to go next either personal or for business?
“There are many great places to visit in the USA. Chicago and New York are great towns for a weekend. The National Parks in the USA have some of the greatest vistas and diverse wildlife anywhere in the world. However, your question gives the impression that you want a non-USA answer. Italy, South Africa, Australia, Argentina, Germany, the South of France, New Zealand, Hawaii, the Islands of the Caribbean, Banff (Canada)…..there are so many great places depending upon what you want to do. Some of my fondest visits were to Brussels and Innsbruck. There is no clear cut “favorite”. As for where I want to go – the Galapagos Islands, Barrow Alaska during the winter and summer solstices, to spend a day or two in Antarctica, to dance on the main square in Havana, to take a river cruise down the Danube or the Amazon and to spend a week hiking in Siberia, Patagonia or Alaska. There are several places in Africa that I would like to see but, I will pass for now. There are dive trips to Bonaire, the Red Sea and Thailand in my future. But, the ultimate where you would like to go – The Maldives.”
Several times you and I have exchanged stories about travelling around the world. I have very memorable memories of India-most very good, all very interesting and Moscow I have memories of (we will leave it at that). But what is your most memorable experience travelling?
“I will keep it clean and sanitary. There are some things best left to the imagination. The sea of humanity at the Kolkata train station where the porter carried my luggage on his head as we stepped around the many sleeping bodies (it was early afternoon and frigging hot!). When I asked, I was told they slept in shifts. It was difficult to walk/step around everyone. At the time, it was the most densely populated place on our planet. The wolf running across the road in remote Russia . Being woken by a massive earthquake during a typhoon while in Asia. All in all, I have been very fortunate – nothing too dramatic. One of my favorites was sitting next to Little Richard on a flight and not talking to him. He finally asked me, “Don’t you want my autograph”. I politely declined. But, the most memorable is an easy one. I performed at the Sydney Opera House. I was traveling with a friend and we ended up singing New York, New York during the play Barmaids. We received a standing ovation and frozen chickens as our payment for performance which we gave to our taxi driver as his tip. The look he gave us was priceless. It will be hard to top a standing ovation at the Sydney Opera House and tipping your taxi driver with frozen chickens.”
What is the largest most impressive captive and commercial heat treats you have seen?
“We have talked about these in the past. Hyundai in Korea has multiple heat treat facilities at their main factory. While each is not the largest, combined it has to be in the top five. Dymos in South Korea with their 10 generators, five (or was it seven) multi-row pushers, 10 to 15 batch furnaces, rotary furnace, etc. is another large one. There was a factory in Russia where the heat treat was broken into four sections where they had 14 pit nitriders in one shop, 10 generators in another with all the associated furnaces and two medium sized shops. The tractor factory in Romania was large. While all large and impressive, they are small compared to the one shop at KAMAZ in Russia. They had 30+ Holcroft pushers, 3 different Lindberg batch lines, an Ipsen batch line, an Aichelin pusher, 10-20 more batch furnaces from various companies, 3 plasma and 5 pit nitriders plus 8 to 10 additional pit carburizing furnaces. It was impossible to take a picture. You could not see the entire shop from one locaton.
On the commercial side, ETSA in Mexico and KingKwang in China are probably the two biggest I have seen. You have had the good fortune to see some large ones in Germany. Our European Operation handles these accounts for SSI. They do a fantastic job and it enables us to focus on “where do we want to go next?”. Do we establish a subsidiary in India? Do we focus on all the key emerging markets (BRICs)? Do we channel efforts into existing market such as Germany to gain market share? Or, do we go after a new market with some potential like Pakistan or Indonesia? Who knows, we may find a large captive or commercial shop that will make The Monty’s Top Ten list.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Clif Coleman / Mid-South Metallurgical
Today we have an interview with a fellow who brings a very interesting and relatively unique perspective to the heat treating industry, Clif Coleman, owner of Mid-South Metallurgical in Murfreesboro, TN.
Clif I mentioned how you have a rather unique perspective on the heat treating industry and this is because you entered the industry much later than most of us seem to. Could you please tell us how you ended up as the owner of Mid-South?
“I spent the first 25 years of my career in the corporate world in a variety of industries – moving from engineering/manufacturing to operations and general management. In 2006 I left a great corporate job with a multi-national company, moved from Texas back home to Middle Tennessee to buy a business and “strike out on my own” – so to speak. I looked at wide variety of businesses keeping three basic criteria in mind – the business had to have a stable track record, it had to cash flow to pay the bills and service the debt, and it had to have significant growth potential. I looked at businesses in every imaginable niche and industry. I “kicked the tires” on probably 40 or 50 businesses, took a “deep dive” look at probably ten, and did Letters of Intent and due diligence on 3 or 4. After all of that, which by the way was one of the most interesting experiences of my professional life, I found that Mid-South fit my criteria – although I had no experience or knowledge of the commercial heat treating industry.”
What was your impression of the company the first time you walked into the plant?
“The business was typical of many of the “small businesses” I had looked at in my quest to find the right one – a family owned “mom and pop” operation. Candidly, having never been in a commercial heat treating operation I didn’t know much about what I was looking at. It was clear that the equipment was old and tired with a lot of opportunity to improve efficiency on the shop floor. The business was well known and respected in the local market and had grown by reputation and “word of mouth”. But, there had never been any serious sales and marketing effort. Evaluating the financials, the business was sound, but stagnant. So it looked like an opportunity.”
Please tell us what equipment Mid-South had when you entered the picture and what the company now has?
“In 2007 Mid-South had three Ipsen T4 internal quench furnaces, two small vacuum furnaces, an ion nitride furnace, a salt bath line, a drop bottom furnace, , a couple of induction heat treating machines, a hodgepodge of small temper furnaces, and a “WWII vintage” furnace used for stress relieving. All of the equipment had very antiquated controls and a few pieces of equipment were not even functional.
Due to a number of factors (high operating costs, poor utilization, and low contribution to top line revenue), the salt bath line, the induction machines and the drop bottom furnace were removed. This cleared floor space to make way for larger and more efficient equipment. Of course all of this took place over a period of a few years. This process has been a bit like “flying the airplane and rebuilding it in the air”. You have to keep running the business, serving your customers, paying the bills, plus reorganize and build the company at the same time. The logistics and planning of these steps is always challenging – somewhat like working a puzzle. And I made mistakes along the way. In fact some of my team jokes that we should “install all equipment on casters” so we can easily move it when “Clif has his next brainstorm.
Today we have three vacuum furnaces and the “original” ion nitride furnace. We have four batch IQ’s with companion tempers, washers, and charge cars, and an assortment of temper furnaces and shot blasting/cleaning equipment. And a couple of years ago we installed a black oxide coating line. Only three pieces of the “original equipment” survived the transformation process. Today Mid-South bears little resemblance to the Mid-South of 2007.”
At this point I have to congratulate you on 10 years in business which is truly a milestone. Has the path to date been pretty much what you thought? Are you further ahead at this point than you expected? Behind?
“Thanks Gord. It’s been an interesting “adventure” with some unexpected twists and turns. Shortly after buying the business in 2007, the “great recession” hit everyone. Like other industries, the heat treating industry took a pretty sharp dive. Fortunately Mid-South weathered the storm. In fact while the heat treating industry was down by 35-40% by some accounts, Mid-South remained “flat”. While not the growth track I was looking for, under the circumstances I counted it as a “win”.
Further ‘ahead or behind’ than expected – that’s a good question. My “achievement motivation factor” has always been off the charts. I have always relished the opportunity to “go, grow, build, and create” – whether it’s a personal or professional endeavor. So when I bought Mid-South my imagination went into “overdrive” creating in my mind’s eye the “Mid-South of the future”. So it’s safe to say with that perspective I am way behind where I would like to be. But realistically, we are probably about where one would expect given the nature of the business, the economy we’ve trudged through, and the resources I could bring to bear on the growth of Mid-South. Pleased with our progress to date – yes. Satisfied – probably never.”
Although you were not a heat treater when you acquired Mid South you have obviously been successful at it-so where did your knowledge come from? Can you point to let’s say ASM and say they taught you everything you know? Did you hire a great plant manager and let him make the decisions? Common sense? Or a combination of a number of sources?
“When I stepped into Mid-South, I realized I knew enough to be dangerous. So I sought out information, education, and help from anywhere and everywhere. I’ve been fortunate to meet a number of people in the industry who have been very helpful. I’ve found the folks in the industry to be very supportive and helpful to a newcomer.
Our Plant Manager, Steve Jefsen, has been key to our success and my “education”. He was at Mid-South when I entered the picture in 2007. Steve, an industry veteran with over 40 years of experience, has been an incredible teacher.
I’d say one of the important things for someone entering a new industry or field is to be willing to ask a lot of questions – even the simplest ones that demonstrate just how little you know. Put your pride and ego aside and ask the questions. It’s a lot cheaper to “look dumb” than it is to try to bluff you way through and do something that “is dumb”.
And in my career I have found it very interesting when entering a new industry or new role to often ask the question “why do you do that” or “why do you do it that way”. Then keep pressing for more information – ask “why” three or four more times. Often times the answer I get is “well, I really don’t know why we do it like that – that’s the way they showed me how to do it when I got here” – or “wow, nobody ever asked that question”. It goes to show that sometimes we do things out of habit – not because they are necessarily right or best. Oftentimes it turns out to be a learning experience for me as well as the person to whom I asked the question.”
Is running a commercial heat treat any different than running any other business?
“The essential elements of running any business, regardless of industry or sector, are the same – take care of your customers, take care of your employees, control your expenses, and manage proactively. So, no I don’t think running a commercial heat treating business is fundamentally different than running any other business.
That said, having worked in other industries (much of that being manufacturing), I have a perspective that gives me some understanding and insight into the challenges our customers face. I have been “in their shoes” so to speak. The heat treating step is usually near the end of their “supply chain”. So by the time we (commercial heat treaters) get involved our customers are usually under pressure – behind, late, or at least “under the gun”. So the key is to make sure we “get it right” (quality) and “get it done fast” (turnaround time). No real rocket science here – it just goes back to taking care of your customer.”
This question ties into the one above to some extent; are there any challenges you have found so far that are unique to our industry?
“Every business and industry has unique challenges. In my view, the unique challenge in the commercial heat treating business is in managing risk to people, plant, and equipment. The risk of fire and explosion is inherent to the nature of the process. The shop floor environment is more dangerous than average – so attention to worker safety is critically important. Also this risk of fire and explosion creates a much greater exposure to plant and equipment and the possibility of business interruption. So a very vigilant approach to safety and fire prevention and protection is critical.”
Recently you purchased what I believe is your first major new piece of equipment, an AFC-Holcroft batch IQ furnace. Has this ruined you for forever buying used again-kind of like flying first class and never wanting to return to economy?
“You are correct, we just purchased and installed a new AFC-Holcroft batch IQ, two new tempers, and endo generator. After years of buying and refurbishing, buying new equipment was a refreshing change. Buying “new” clearly has advantages, but it also comes with a premium price. So moving forward, we will continue to evaluate what makes the most sense for the particular set of circumstances – and that will involve considering a lot of factors.”
What is your focus going to be going forward in terms of technology? More batch IQ’s and vacuums or are you looking at different options?
“I think that will depend on what we see happening in the markets we serve. As we see opportunities develop, we’ll respond accordingly.”
What is your relationship with you competitors like or do you have one? I guess what I am asking is do you find commercial heat treaters willing to trade information and help out another heat treater?
“I have found commercial heat treaters very willing to help one another. Understandably, competitors in the same geographic markets are a bit more guarded in sharing information. But we have developed a few relationships with commercial heat treaters outside of our local market that have been very valuable.”
Can you share anything about future plans for Mid-South?
“We have spent the last ten years building and strengthening our organization, infrastructure, and capacity. So I’d say we are poised for growth. They say an overnight success take about 20 years, so we are now ten years into the journey. We’ll see where the next ten years takes us.”
Where do you see the industry going in 5 years and 20 years?
“I think the manufacturing sector that the thermal processing industry serves holds potential. But I think it will be important to pay close attention to new pockets of opportunity and technology. And be prepared to act on those opportunities. This will be a time to “prepare to be prepared”.
Thanks for the time Clif and we will do this again in 10 years to see how your opinions have changed.
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Chris Hall / Accurate Steel Treating
Today we are very pleased to have this interview with Mr. Chris Hall, General Manager of commercial heat treater Accurate Steel Treating in Southgate, California.
First off Chris I am always curious as to how individuals get involved in the heat-treating industry-what is your background?
“Heat treating was certainly not something I planned for growing up. Initially, out of school I needed a job and somehow found a company called Pacific Steel Treating in North Hollywood, CA. That was in 1979. With no formal training (in anything) I started as a receiving clerk of all things and just kept working hard and saying yes to the next thing I was asked to do, the result being I received a very well-rounded education in the heat-treating business. Eventually I went back to school for metallurgical training and throughout my career I have taken, various quality, sales, management and accounting courses.”
I am very familiar with Accurate Steel but I am sure many of our readers know little about the company. Could you please give us the background of the company, when it was started, ownership structure, size etc.?
“AST was started in 1962 as a small commercial shop. In 1989 Ron Loynds acquired the company and along with Mike Bastian grew it into the preeminent commercial tool & die shop on the west coast</em><em>. Accurate Ion Technology was formed in 1998 initially as a joint venture with Lindberg Heat Treating. When Bodycote acquired Lindberg in 2000 Ron decided to dissolve the partnership and carried on with 100% ownership. </em><em>I came to AST in March 2015 after working for Bodycote for 25 years to help the company with the transition to Aerospace heat treating, a completely different animal than commercial tool & die. Additionally, Mike Bastian was ready to retire so I stepped into his position as GM.”
Would you describe Accurate as a “one stop shop” for heat treating or are you specialized in certain processes?
“For years AST specialized in the tool & die market and developed a very strong reputation for quality and reliable delivery in the Southern California region. So much so, that when I was a competitor we were rarely successful at acquiring any of their accounts. Eventually we quit trying. Five years ago, management decided to enter into the Aerospace market to be better diversified and to capitalize on the many opportunities in this sector. Today, I prefer to say we are a full-service heat treater to industry. We offer vacuum & atmosphere heat treating, gas carburizing, Ion & gas nitriding, stress relieving, aging, Met -lab facilities, straightening and all the normal support processes. I’ve had the opportunity to visit and work at many heat treating plants over the years and what I’ve learned is there really isn’t a lot that separates one plant from another other than the people. Despite all the marketing efforts to the contrary it boils down to having the right mix of people to be truly successful in this business…and maybe a little luck. We believe that our competitive advantage is our deep understanding of our customer base and their heat-treating needs combined with our uniquely qualified and experienced management team.”
In terms of sales in your market where does Accurate stack up? Big player? Small player?
“According to MTI we are about middle of the pack for our region.”
As you mentioned you came from the largest commercial heat treater in the world to a company which while reasonably large is still a fraction of the size of your previous employer. What do you see as the advantages of a small company as opposed to a very large one?
“Let me just say that I don’t miss the layers upon layers of bureaucracy Inherent with large corporations. I was lucky in that I had the good fortune to work with number of very talented individuals during that time and I’m grateful for all that I learned from them. I suppose the single largest advantage from my perspective is the speed in which you can get things done in a privately held company. I only need to consult with 1 or 2 people on major decision’s or projects. What used to take weeks or months to get accomplished can now be done in a matter of hours or days. We use a few key criteria to evaluate new projects- value to the customer, ROI, and risk. I believe this environment favors the customer.”
Does anything ever change in the heat treat industry? I have a good friend who has been involved in heat treating for almost 50 years and his feeling is that nothing is new. Nitriding, carburizing, annealing-you name it they are they have all be around for a long time now. What is your feeling?
“I think many of these processes will remain, however, with more efficient or advanced delivery methods. Automated process gas control for surface treatments such as nitriding and carburizing are good examples. Predictive diagnostics with vacuum furnaces is interesting and could potentially be very beneficial. I’m a big fan of Vacuum – LPC technology and have been researching it for some time now and I’m convinced it’s superior to conventional carburizing for many applications. The problem is that unlike the automotive sector, Aerospace companies and thus manufactures have been slow to embrace the technology to the degree necessary to justify investment. Also, anytime an operator doesn’t have to stand in front of a big box with flames coming out of it it’s a good thing. Heat treaters must also do a better job at adopting and integrating lean manufacturing principles into their operations. Many in this industry are quick to say that these principles don’t apply to us because we don’t make anything, which is not true in my experience. For sure some don’t correlate one for one, but the foundation underlying lean methods applies to any business.”
A very common theme in the industry is the lack of young people that are getting involved. Is this something which you have found over the years and if so what is the solution?
“Much about heat treating is not sexy or desirable especially to millennials. Let’s see, sit in front of a computer at a company that has its own coffee bar and in house dry cleaning or work in a hot dirty plant with equipment that can blow up. We need to make our plants safer and more desirable, provide apprentice training programs, and increase the wage scale to something akin to a journeyman electrician or plumber. I believe this is more or less the model in Europe.”
Are there any challenges which are unique to your area, namely California?
“I suppose I’m expected to answer yes to this question as it’s in vouge to complain about how difficult business in CA is, but quite honestly, in my experience, I have not encountered any huge business problems simply because it’s California. Expenses are generally higher for anything here, but for me that’s a fair trade-off for the many advantages to being here.”
I have always been fascinated by Plasma (Ion) Nitriding which you of course offer but I have never claimed to be an expert on the process and I would expect that this is shared by many especially the end customer. Do you feel this is a process which is going to grow or have you reached a limit as to the number of good applications?
“Until I joined Accurate I had limited exposure to Ion nitriding and have since learned that for some material types and processing techniques Ion may well be superior to gas nitride. A good example would be Ion Nitriding Crankshafts due to the superior surface finish achieved over gas nitriding. This is very desirable to the high-end manufactures in the race car industry. However, as with Vacuum LPC, the Aerospace community has been slow to embraced the technology making it difficult to readily identify areas for growth. Additionally, the equipment is fussy and expensive and there are limited support suppliers in this space. So, it’s a real nitch thing that you have to work at to be successful.”
Are there any industry suppliers you would like to praise or for that matter any that you would like to trash?
“McLaughlin Services, Super Systems, Protech Thermal, and Aerospace Testing and Pyrometry are all considered to be key suppliers for us. They have all been very supportive to Accurate and we value our relationships with them.”
What does the immediate future hold for Accurate? Any interesting plans you can share with us? For that matter where do you see Accurate being in 10 years? 20 Years?
“We are very excited about our future. In just two years we have invested over to $2.0M in growth related activities. Except for a couple new trucks, this has all been for new or upgraded equipment needed to fuel growth. We have seen double digit sales growth YoY and expect to double sales in the next 5 years. We have added processes to our Nadcap accreditation each year and been approved by Honeywell, Parker Aerospace, and GE Aviation. We are expecting to make a big announcement by year end that will likely be a game changer for us.”
How about the commercial heat treating in the US? Do you see any reason to believe that it will consolidate more or remain as it is now? How about additive manufacturing? Do you see it as a game changer for commercial heat treaters?
“I think consolidation will and should continue. There are too many heat treaters that are good at heat treating, but not great business people and this ultimately drags down the entire industry. I don’t have enough knowledge about AM to make a meaningful prediction other than to say that vacuum processing will almost certainly figure in prominently.”
Chris, I thank you for your time today and wish you the best in the future. Gord
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Buster Crossley Texas Heat Treating
Buster Crossley, Texas Heat Treating. Like everything else about Texas the commercial heat treating industry in Texas differs from pretty well every other area of the world which is why I am very pleased to have had the chance to talk to Mr. “Buster Crossly” President of commercial heat treater Texas Heat Treating based in Round Rock, Texas.
Buster my impression is that you are a “true” heat treater, born and bred into a family owned business where you started at a very young age-true or false?
“Not sure what qualifies as young, but I have been in the Heat Treating business since 1981. My dad started this business in 1977 & we worked together until his retirement in 2001. So I guess it is true that I did start at a young age and thanks to the leadership and wisdom of my dad, I have learned from the best and have not looked back.”
So what can you tell us about Texas Treating? Types of furnaces, size, capabilities etc.?
“We are primarily a Batch operation along with Pit Hardening & Carburizing capabilities up to 14’ Vertical, Nitriding up to 22,000 Lb Load Sizes, Vacuum, Induction, and a full service lab. In addition to doing Mechanical Testing and CVN, we do MPI, LPI, & Ultrasonic testing too. We run 9 Tractor Trailers daily across the State & Southwest. We may not be the largest Heat Treating Facility in the Southwest, but we are the largest Atmosphere processing facility in the Southwest & still growing. We cover over 70,000 Sq. Feet in Round Rock & 55,000 Sq. Feet in Ft. Worth. Between the two plants, we will have 15 – Surface 36×72, 4 – Surface 30×48’s, 1- 36×48 Dedicated Normalizer, 7 Pit Furnaces, 2 of which are 14’FT Vertical, 5 Vacuum Furnaces with two of those being 6,000 LB Capacity, Induction, 3 Pit Nitriders, with two of those being 22,000 LB Capacity, & Flame Hardening. We do some Cryogenics as well. Our Ft Worth facility will emulate what we do here in Round Rock with the possibility of offering some new processes. Ft Worth will have a full service Lab as well and should be completed within the next month or so. We thrive on continuous education and training at all levels. We feel like that investing in our employees is a win-win for the employee, our customer, and Texas Heat Treating.”
Regular readers of “The Monty” will know that I have visited your brand new “greenfield” site in Dallas a couple of times over the past year. As I mentioned previously this will include a number of brand new batch IQ furnaces, pit furnaces, gas nitriding and vacuum units. Having been in this business for almost 35 years I certainly recognize that this was a very major investment on your part-several million dollars without a doubt. What prompted you to make such a large investment in a new location just a couple of hundred miles from Round Rock where you have always been located?
“There were several factors that prompted our move into Dallas/Ft Worth area. First, we needed to grow, and in order to grow in Round Rock, we needed a larger gas supply than what was currently provided. The Cost of getting that gas into our location and the time it was going to take was prohibitive. 2.) Dallas/Ft Worth is a different market and provides an opportunity to diversify a little into other markets other than Natural Gas & Oil. We looked at other parts of the state, but felt like this area provided a better opportunity and fit with our long term plans for Texas Heat Treating. We fill like with the addition of Ft. Worth, it will give us the growth potential to meet the growing demands of our customers and continue to give them the service they not only demand, but deserve.”
Gas nitriding. What it is it now Buster-5 years since you entered into an agreement with Nitrex to offer gas nitriding in Texas? How has that worked out for you? Have you been able to keep the nitriders bulging with new work?
“This has been a good Niche business for us. We are adding our 3rd Nitrider, another 22,000 Lb. Capacity furnace. This one will be located in Ft Worth and should be coming online within the next few weeks. We continue to grow that business and look for new opportunities for future growth. We have been successful in flipping some Ion Customers after seeing the results we can obtain with the Nitreg technology, so we fill like the potential is unlimited.”
In Texas it would appear that the vast bulk of heat treating captive and commercial is related to the oil and gas industries with a little aerospace, automotive and heavy equipment thrown into the mix. While the oil and gas industries are booming these days this is one of the most “boom or bust” industries I have ever seen. How do you handle the ups and downs? It must create some real headaches for you when it comes to cash flow, employment levels and furnace utilization. I have to add that I always laugh about the “rig” count in Texas.
“I can’t imagine another area in the world where a gas station attendant or bar tender can tell you the current rig count. You nailed it, as it is a “Boom or Bust” industry. It can and will crash in an instant. I have been thru a number of these and we learn a little more each time we go thru a bust. Every Boom and or Bust brings on its own set of problems, and it seems like each one is a little different. It appears to me the cycles have gotten a little shorter than they use to be, so that is a good thing. We are no different than anyone else in their approach to a downturn. We try to keep our skilled employees, and do what it takes to make it thru. We know there is light at the end of the tunnel, so we take it one day at a time.”
Does it ever worry you this dependence upon the energy industry?
“I think we are much like a Shop sitting in the middle of Detroit wishing they could diversify into something other than Automotive. Does it worry me? Absolutely, but after 30 plus years of dealing with it, you learn to accept it. Some years ago, we were QS-9000 Registered in hopes of diversifying and developing some automotive work, but I believe we were ahead of our time. We are taking a second look at that now for the current Automotive & Aerospace Specs.”
I mentioned right up front that business is Texas is different than a lot of other areas of the world. For instance (and I love this) Texans believe in doing business on a handshake and pride themselves that this is much better than a lawyer written contract-personal experience tells me that this is true. Another issue which sets Texas apart is how many commercial heat treaters in Texas are blood related even though they are competitors. Does this raise any special problems?
“It is true that we prefer to do business on a handshake, but it is also true that is changing. Because of the Boom-Bust business, we lose a lot of seasoned professionals to other industries. The new management that is being brought in has a lot more diverse backgrounds and is used to doing business in a more formal manner. To answer the 2nd part of your question, all I can tell you is that even when I think I know all the family connections, I find out someone else has a Dominy Connection somewhere in their bloodlines……….And no, I have not heard of any killings among them. Gord, In Texas, you are either an In-Law or an Outlaw!”
Continuing with the same question while Bodycote has a very strong presence in the state all other heat treaters are family owned businesses. As a family owned business yourself do you see an advantage in size or does this pose its own problems?
“All shops have the things they do well & the things they don’t do as well as the next shop. I believe it boils down to your vision for your organization, people, business plan and execution. Texas has some very well run shops with some very knowledgeable people running them, so the competition is tough. So I really don’t think it is a size issue, but rather where your strengths lie.”
Of all the potential problems with running a heat treating operation which problem or potential problem has the most capacity to keep you up at night? Or is heat treating such a rosy business that you sleep like a baby every night?
“Obviously OSHA & Environmental has to be up there. It seems like each year brings new laws and regulations that you have to comply with. It is almost a full time job keeping up with just that aspect of the business. HR issues are another area that is difficult to keep up with and making sure your organization is complying with all the new laws and regulations. It appears that agencies such as the NLRB has a heavy hand in deciding issues that affect the way we have to run our businesses.”
With your investments in relatively new technologies such as Nitrex you have proven that you have no problems expanding beyond what you have always done. If you had to pick another technology that you feel would strongly compliment what you are now doing what would it be?
“I’m always looking for new technologies and or processes to compliment what we do. Funny you should ask that question as we are working on a project now. Maybe later down the road, we can re-visit this question.”
There are some very large manufacturers in Texas supplying the oil and gas industries that send out enormous amounts of heat treating which in many cases in relatively basic simple heat treating such as quench and temper or stress relieving. Do you see any sign that these large companies are considering or would consider bringing it in house?
“Vertical Integration” We are seeing some organizations move in that direction while others choose not to, staying with their core competencies. I’ve always felt like my larger customers were also my potential biggest competitor……….Large organizations don’t always look at cost the way we do & most feel like they can do it much cheaper in house than we as an industry can do it for. However, with that said, this last Boom pushed some to put in their own facilities simply for thru put. Things happened so fast here in the Southwest, that everyone including the large manufactures got caught with their pants down. I’m not sure anyone ever got ahead of the curve until recently. With the Natural Gas Glut and Oil starting to slide, I believe there is going to be too much capacity out there for a while. Prices for Natural Gas and Oil should stay down for the foreseeable future, slowing the drilling & manufacturing down at that same time. They are already stacking rigs, so the next step will be to cannibalize them instead of buying new replacement parts. It is just a process that it goes thru and depending on the Supply vs. Demand will dictate how long this part of the cycle will last.”
Where do you see the heat treating industry in Texas going? Remaining the same with a number of family owned businesses or some consolidation?
“I think that is anyone’s guess……….People sell for different reasons, so while there may be some consolidations, I believe there will always be a number of family or privately owned businesses. Texas is no different than any other state where family roots run deep & keeping those businesses in the family is important.”
Probably the toughest question of all is where is the industry going? I have asked this question literally hundreds of times over the years and I have never found a great deal of consensus. The general feeling appears to be that as long as there is metal there will be heat treating but this is rather simplistic. If I were to ask you what technologies would be most employed in 25 years and whether the current captive/commercial heat treating mix were to stay the same what would you respond?
“I do realize that since you and I are almost exactly the same age at 54 neither one of us might not care that much 25 years from now but I am always curious about where the industry is going. Gord, I’ve been in this business since 1981, and have seen it go full circle in several areas. I have seen businesses that thought bringing their Heat Treat in house was the way to go, only to find out it was a lot more involved than they expected and ended up shutting down their captive business and selling the equipment on the secondary market. I have seen business where it worked out for them by bringing their Heat Treat in house, but that typically is done for other reasons than cost or quality. It was not that long ago those captives used to bring their Heat Treating in house because of Quality or perceived quality issues. However, I believe that has all changed in recent years where most shops have brought their quality levels to all-time highs. It is hard to say what technologies will be most employed in 25 Years, however, it is typically those niche business that are most profitable. That too appears to go in cycles so we shall see. I do believe that if you are not re-investing in your business, employees & continue to make improvements, you will not be around for the long haul.”
How was your year as President of MTI?
“When looking back over my 2012 presidency I would first have to say that being President of the Metal Treating Institute has been an honor and distinct privilege. The Association has a history and legacy of strong impactful leaders and I was humbled to be a part of this elite group. Starting off in Williamsburg, Virginia, my plan was to continue to increase our MTI membership, promote our YES classes throughout the country, continue to create and strengthen our partnership with associate members, listen to our members and board concerning the future of MTI, but most importantly have fun in the process. I have to admit Gord, I was a little nervous, launching my Presidential leadership role at the 2012 MTI boarding meeting in Miami, FL. The MTI board and Executive Board consist of seasoned and new individuals that have the heart and passion for this organization, and standing up and addressing them made me a little weak in the knees. However, I love to coach and I looked at this like a baseball coach. Position the right players on the field according to their strength to win the game; and that we did. The board and I continued to work thru our strategic plan for the 2012 year and worked together to strive for results and excellence. The honeymoon ended in Miami and the real work began. Weekly, we had countless conference calls with either the Executive Board and or Committees to plan for our events and discuss the issues of the MTI at hand. Everyone took an active part in resolving tough issues that are not always easy to approach, but we stayed on task and focused to the goals of the MTI. There were many behind the scenes calls with Tom Morrison and the Executive Board to ensure the success for the year. It was an effort made by all and I was very fortunate to have a balance team leading the different committees and executing a successful 2012. As I have traveled throughout the United States and Canada visiting the different regions, Frances and I greatly appreciated the outpouring of hospitality, the willingness of other heat treaters to open their business for plant tours, arrange for exciting venues of entertainment and making us feel so welcome. We were so every thankful to all; MTI is like our second family. The year ended with huge success and record breaking 1st; increased memberships & attendance at both the Regional and National levels, increase in YES graduates, stronger financial standing, new technology that will bring added value to the MTI Association and its members, thus equaling a stronger marketing position. Hence, I owe the success to the Board, and Tom Morrison and Associates for the overall success the MTI has experienced this past year. It has been an exciting and fun year. Overall, the year flew by fast as all the past presidents said it would. No doubt we have accomplished a lot, but the MTI has raised the bar and we still have a lot to accomplish. Being President was a true honor and I am very lucky to have been given this opportunity. It will be a time in my life that I will treasure and look back with great pride. I do wish it could have been extended one more year…..I finally got the hang of public speaking! Buster I thank you for your time and hope our paths continue to cross in the future”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Bill St. Thomas / Aichelin
Bill I am always curious-how did you get started in the heat treating industry?
“Gord, I guess it was in by blood. My grandfather and father were both tool and die makers. My father worked at Ford for 37 years. One of my uncles owns a cutting tool shop now based in CA and is still working today. Another was a refractory contractor and I spent my summers and holidays during college relining furnaces in most of the foundries, forge and commercial shops in the Midwest. After I graduated I was offered an engineering job with Ford, but chose to join Lindberg Furnace in 1976 as a regional salesman.”
What furnace/oven builders have you worked with over the last 40 years?
“I have worked for several and always as a direct employee and based in the Detroit area. I started with Lindberg Furnace and enjoyed selling just about every type of thermal processing equipment available, which included: atmosphere, vacuum, and Induction.
I also spent many years selling large scale Alum HT systems for Despatch, MOCO Thermal and CEC. I sold vacuum furnace systems for Ipsen, ECM, and Seco Warwick. Currently with Aichelin and back in the Atmosphere market, I am looking forward to working with the AFC/ Holcroft team. ”
Your experience selling furnaces and ovens now spans over 40 years-what has changed as far as selling and marketing the equipment or is it pretty much the same as it’s always been?
“I would say it has changed quite a lot in both. Years ago marketing was primarily done by mailing or delivering brochures directly to customers or advertising in magazines and exhibiting at trade shows. Now days you can send a photo, brochure, drawing, or video to thousands of potential customers via the internet.
For selling it has become more of a team effort than in the past. Years ago a field salesman would be in front of a customer far more that today. For one territories are much larger and customers don’t have the time to meet without an active project.
Projects today are much more involved that just selling a furnace. Most customers now what to purchase a “system” which typically includes the equipment upstream and downstream from the basic furnace.
Sample testing, process validation, material handling, automation, data retrieval, facility layout and turnkey installation are now key parts of getting orders and requires a team of people not just one person.
However honesty, trust and individual relationships still remain as the key factors in getting orders and that will never change. “
This is going to be a rather leading question but I am trying to make a point here. Because new furnaces are a big ticket item which can easily run into the millions of dollars buyers tend to think that this means large profit margins. What are your thoughts? I said leading question because I run across this scenario on a regular basis.
“As I mention, most of today’s furnace projects take on a systems or manufacturing cell identity rather than a single piece or line of equipment. We also know that customers no longer have the large staff of people to assemble these cells, so the furnace companies often have this task.
If a furnace maker just wants to mark up every item they want to provide with a fixed rate, they will seldom get the order. I think the furnace makers that have great working relationships with their vendors who provide the companion equipment can make some decent profits. Understanding the scope of supply and the customer’s process and vision is key. I often find these high valued sub-contractors and suppliers are often great sources for future projects too…”
A fellow who spent his entire life in selling new furnaces before he recently retired always use to say that there is nothing new in the industry everything is just a variation on something which has already been done. Would you agree or disagree?
“I would disagree. There are so many new materials and processes in the heat treating market. I have been in most Aerospace, Automotive, and Commercial HT plants in the USA and I am often surprised how components are being made today. New processes such as hot stamping of automotive structures, the use of Aluminum in cars and trucks, and the renewal of gas-nitriding and FNC processing are just a few. “
In your opinion what furnace design has been most successful? Some examples might be batch IQ furnaces, mesh belt or batch vacuum furnaces. I realize that it does very much depend upon the process and product but setting that aside what style in your opinion has proven to have the longest longevity combined with lowest operating costs and high uptime?
“Without a doubt BIQ’s have been the most successful. With the ability to build both large and small chamber sizes with a variety of quench medias, they are the most versatile and flexible in the HT world. Secondly, I would say the single chamber 2-bar vacuum furnace also has a great range of process capability. Thirdly, the Alum Drop Bottom has been key for the Aerospace and Aluminum markets with ability to process thin Aerospace parts or forgings and castings for the Automotive with water or PAG quenching. “
Now this question is more fun than the one above but is closely related. What is the worst most unreliable design you have ever seen? If you don’t want to single out a particular company that is fine, I am more curious about the actual design than the builder.
“Easy…. The commercial size (36x48x36) vacuum oil quench for carburizing. Just about everyone struggles with the material handling issues and inner door sealing properly. Another short coming is that the load capacity is about 50% less that of what an atmosphere furnace can provide, and the overall cost of the equipment is double or more. The overall footprint and maintenance costs are factors too. I remember one furnace that was built, rebuilt on site, re-purchased and finally cut up… “
To date furnace builders are reasonably regional probably because of the high shipping costs and lack of local support. For instance (and there are obvious exceptions) many of the North American builders especially the smaller ones tend to only market in North America. The same holds true for many Asian builders and European builders. Do you see this changing?
“Yes. Having recently worked for several European based companies I can say that the cost of shipping is minor in the overall scheme of providing equipment from overseas. Of course I am not talking about a “stand alone” batch oven or furnace. One of the factors is the dollar ratio of course, but furnace design and construction is key as well. Building to our codes and standards is no longer a problem. Most off-shore furnace makers have USA based service teams, spare parts centers or manufacturing capabilities too. Keep in mind that in recent years we have had a great deal of Asian and European firms bring their business to North America and prefer their existing vendors from home too.”
For many years you were an Aichelin fellow, with their acquisition of AFC-Holcroft you are now an AFC-Holcroft fellow. Do you forsee more mergers/acquisitions within the industry in the near future? Certainly there are lots of rumors these days but nothing definite yet.
“I do. The Aichelin / AFC merging is a great example where two competitors now join forces to cover the entire world. The Aichelin Group brings several new products to AFC /Holcroft who gains the history and experience of a company that has been around since 1868…and AFC / Holcroft provides the Aichelin Group with market leadership in the USA. I see Alum HT as a very active market and I wouldn’t be surprised with a merger somewhere… “
So what do you like these days? Out of all the furnaces built by Aichelin, AFC-Holcroft and all the others what do you really like to promote and sell?
“I really don’t have a favorite. What I have is a deep rooted passion for this profession, and a great deal of experience in selling heat treating equipment. I have a very long list of great contacts and friendships that I look forward to sharing with the AFC/ Holcroft team. “
So what does the future hold for Bill St. Thomas-any strong desire to retire and play golf or are you in this another 40 years?
“As you well know this this job is fun, when you can travel and see how things are made. I plan to work as long it remains fun and I can pass along my knowledge to others. As far as golf goes I have been lucky to have four aces and still what another, but would be happier if my Lions would win the Super Bowl…”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Bill Jones / Solar Manufacturing / Solar Atmospheres
Vacuum Heat Treating/Mr. Bill Jones. Today (November 20, 2012) we have an interview with one of the best known names in the vacuum heat treating industry, Mr. Bill Jones, CEO of both Solar Atmospheres (commercial heat treating) and Solar Manufacturing (new vacuum furnaces). In our opinion Bill is one of the most experienced individuals in the vacuum heat treating industry that we have met and also (with all due respect to Bill) an individual with more longevity in the industry than just about anybody else. Read on for some very interesting history about where the industry has come from, where it is going and what changes have been the most significant.
Bill your’s is one of the most recognizable names in heat treating in North America and I would venture to say even outside of North America but I have to confess I don’t know how you actually got started in the industry. Would it be possible for you to tell us how you were introduced to the heat treating industry and how you have progressed through it?
“Thank you for the complement, Gord. I was introduced to the technical world through my father who worked for the Philadelphia Electric Company. On graduation from Penn State with a degree in Electrical Technology, I went to work for a small company building first order process electronic instrumentation for the DuPont experimental station in Wilmington, Del. These instruments among others were photometric, including a two color optical pyrometer and an electrolytic dew point analyzer. This introduced me to the industrial furnace industry. In 1963, I was approached by the fledgling Abar Corp. and joined the company as the 8th employee. A few years later, three of us bought out the original owner and ran the company for several years, but because of our poor business experience we were forced to sell to King 5th Wheel in 1967. I was the only one of the original owners to survive and remained with the company for 17 years, serving as President for the last 5 years. Then in 1979 with a change in King 5th management, I left and formed Vacuum Furnace Systems, VFS along with several others from Abar. My wife and I started the company with $40k in savings, a $40k mortgage on our house, and a $250k government backed SBA loan. Our first sale was to Metal Treating Inc., Cincinnati, Ohio with Jim Williams as President. In 1983 with my son, Roger we formed Solar Atmospheres, Inc. in a corner of our original VFS plant. We purchased a used F J Stokes vacuum furnace out of a junk yard, and later a very used Ipsen Model 924 from a used equipment dealer in Detroit. We completely modified these early furnaces to VFS designs, and this started us off in the commercial heat treating business.”
The names Solar Atmospheres and Solar Manufacturing are well known but I would certainly appreciate a brief idea about the size of the companies and their capabilities.
“Today Solar Atmospheres is our primary business with 3 plants in Souderton, PA., 1 plant in Hermitage, PA and 1 plant site in Fontana, Calif. The combined sales this year will be $41 million. Solar Manufacturing will be $16 million. We also own a transformer company, MSI which builds, among other things, power supplies for vacuum furnaces with sales of approximately $4 million. Employment at all operations is approximately 225. Solar Atmospheres is primarily a broad base vacuum heat treating and brazing processor with 55 vacuum furnaces running 24 / 7. Solar Mfg. builds approximately 20 new vacuum furnaces per year.”
You have seen vacuum heat treating progress and grow over the years (indeed you can take pride in the fact that many of the changes are due to your ideas)-in your opinion what development or innovation in the vacuum world has had the most significance?
“The round hot zone with internal gas quench nozzles and recirculation gas system, the VRT power supply, a modern leak free vacuum chamber with high vacuum pumping system, and modern electronic Honeywell instrumentation all introduced by Abar approximately 1970 and on, are all innovations in the vacuum world that have had great significance. VFS introduced the round graphite heating elements and graphite insulated hot zone and further developed the hot zone, the gas quench system, VSD for the quench blower, PLC logic controller, and computer controlled instrumentation. Solar Mfg. and others have continued these developments and more, such as over pressure gas quenching technology allowing the processing of alloy grades like 4140 and O grade tool steel, and the perfection of vacuum carburizing, and the introduction of vacuum gas nitriding.”
We now see 20 bar quenching (and higher), vacuum carburizing, vacuum nitriding; what is the next logical step in the evolution of vacuum furnaces?
“The vacuum furnace market has been growing approximately twice as fast as other furnace markets since 1990 or so. This is because the vacuum furnace is environmentally friendly, increasingly more efficient, operator-friendly, and most important, adaptable to increasingly broader market applications. The vacuum furnace has to be engineered to perform these functions as presented, such as the annealing of large Ti heavy 80,000 lb workloads in high vacuum, and inert gas cooling in a 38 hour cycle or so. Prior retort furnaces take more than a full week. We see processing of what we call raw materials as the path forward, such as nano grade powders, and high temperature processing of special ceramic and graphite materials. These all require furnace design modification, and the application of controlled hydrogen gas and other partial pressure gas additions to perform those processes prior reserved for atmosphere; in other words, the shifting of the heat treating market from atmosphere to vacuum.”
You mentioned you started VFS many years ago and then subsequently sold the company. In retrospect was this a good business decision?
“This was a painful experience for the Jones Family and thus a bad decision to sell VFS, as we lost 5 years in the furnace market place. The major reason to start Solar Mfg. was to buy the type and quality furnace that was not available from competition. The advantage of Solar Atmospheres and Solar Mfg. is the close relationship to understand technical applications and furnace issues, and interchange facts and ideas on a daily basis between companies.”
I know from personal experience that profit margins for heat treating equipment of all forms has been falling over the years and yet there are just as many or more builders of new vacuum furnaces than ever before. Do you feel there are too many vacuum furnace builders in the market? Along the same lines are there some competitors that you have more respect for than others?
“No, competition is good for the industry and helps to keep us all humble and sharp. Our number one competitor is Ipsen, and my guess is they eye Solar Mfg. closely at least here in the USA. Ipsen has a deep and convoluted history, but none the less is a survivor and will prevail. So will Solar Mfg.”
Another vacuum furnace builder came out with an interesting product line several years back which has proven to be quite successful. The basic concept is a very competitively priced vacuum furnace, fairly standard which is available with a very quick delivery time. Does Solar Manufacturing have any plans to offer a similar product?
“You refer of course to the Ipsen Titan. No, we do not intend to offer a “Titan” concept. Our view is that the furnace business will not accept a cookie cutter type concept long term, as all furnaces need to adapt to location, application, instrumentation, and other specific furnace requirements by customers. Rapid delivery and price is always an advantage. However, a vacuum furnace is not a commodity but rather an expensive piece of capital equipment with an expected reliable trouble free life of 30 years. What sense does quick delivery and low price make when compared to longevity and performance if compromise of specifications and components is ignored?”
What drives you? With all due respect I would imagine that with two successful companies that money is not an issue for you but I know that you put in a lot of hours. Why at this stage or your life are you working as hard as you ever have?
“I am an entrepreneur driven by technology and the challenge having come up the hard way; I know no other way of life. People ask me about my hobbies. I always point them to the plant where I have my “sand box”. I must admit though with current tax plans and the idea of spreading the wealth now coming out of Washington, it gives one pause to think. I have worked harder in the past and time flies at expense to family. I encourage my engineers and management not to make the same mistakes I have in this regard and am trying to shift to a lower gear.”
Lets move from Solar Manufacturing to Solar Atmospheres your commercial heat treating company. I have visited your Souderton, PA, Telford, PA and Fontana, CA locations and all are extremely impressive in particular the large vacuum carbottom furnaces. I know each must represent a multi million dollar investment and a great deal of engineering time. How did you decide to make such a large investment in what is a fairly unusual design of vacuum furnace? Now I have to ask you this also-when you started down the road of the first one did you have any fears that the design might not work or that it would not turn out to be a good investment?
“The first car bottom design came about as a need to process six large Ti coils where we could only process two in our large 12’ front loading furnaces here at Souderton, PA. Our customer insisted we have a plant in Pittsburgh, PA to run the coils or they would buy their own furnaces. Bob Hill, my son, Roger, and I decided very quickly we needed the Hermitage, PA plant and I made the decision to build the car bottom furnace literally on the spot prior to quotes, designs, building, or money. We assembled a team of engineers from within Solar, VFS, and our most important other vendors, to design and build the first car bottom. I acted as Chief Engineer along with Roger Jones, Bob Hill, and my son-in-law, Bruce Craven. We made all final decisions based on our experience processing two coils. The furnace was built and installed in Hermitage. After initial shake down, TC survey, and vacuum checks we loaded six heavy coils into the furnace and made the first heat treat run without a hitch. The car bottom was a complete success and we have built 10 since. VFS made the actual first build. At that time VFS was owned by Ipsen. Ipsen Germany feared the furnace to have many technical problems and asked me to allow them out of any responsibility. I agreed in exchange for all design and patent rights. Done. No, I knew we had a sound design from the ground up and never looked back.”
With the 3 commercial plants in the US do you have any plans down the road to add other locations either in North America or outside of North America?
“Yes, we do, and probably in the South Eastern USA. However, we really need to see how things work out in Washington and to our economy. We can’t build a plant if bank money is not available or if industry is in free fall. My personal view is a flat 2013 and hopefully improvement in 2014.”
This question is not specific to Solar but is rather a general question about commercial heat treating. Your customers represent some of the largest companies in North America, many of them in the aerospace industry. Do you see any signs that that they plan on sending more heat treating to commercial shops in the future, about the same amount or bringing more heat treating in house?
“In general, no. There are some exceptions but these may turn out to be short term until they can buy and install their own furnaces. This is usually a “win / win” for Solar, but not always.”
The largest commercial heat treater in the world “Bodycote” has so far this year made two large acquistions in North America. Commercial heat treating is tremendously fragmented with many relatively small players. Do you feel that one player dominating the market to such an extent is a good or bad thing?
“We see no impact to Solar for a number of reasons. Most of Bodycote is standard heat treat operations for auto, off road, production and the like. Solar is specialized in vacuum technology and niche applications nimble and fast on our feet with decisions based here in the USA and not in the UK.”
Nadcap is a universal standard in the world of aerospace heat treating and I see no signs that this will ever change. However I have heard many times that commercial heat treaters are held to a higher standard than the actual “primes” who don’t follow the rules as closely. As a Nadcap accredited commercial heat treater would you care to comment on this?
“This is a touchy subject, Gord. However, we kind of share the view that the commercial shop has to dance harder and truer than a prime. But we have never been invited into their shops to witness their audits. That would be great fun.”
So what does the future hold for Mr. Bill Jones, Solar Atmospheres and Solar Manufacturing?
“Of course my work days must near an end. I don’t want this to happen but I am secure in my future as you have noted. We have been working on succession plans of course. As most of our customers and suppliers know I have a strong working family in place to the third generation and I have assembled a strong engineering and management team. A good example is our California Plant, up and running, growing, standing on their own feet without Bill Jones or anyone else making day to day management decisions. Many knowledgeable people have commented to me and in fact congratulated me on building such a fine, deep team around and under me throughout our companies.”
On a final note I know many of the people at Solar and have a tremendous respect for many of them. Is there any you would like to single out for special praise?
“I have already mentioned Roger Jones, Bob Hill, and Bruce Craven. Of special note is Don Jordon, Chief Metallurgist; Derek Denis, President of California; and Chuck Miller, his Chief Engineer; Dan Landis, Solar Chief Maintenance Engineer; Ed Engelhard, Head of Solar Quality; Trevor Jones, Solar Process Development Engineer; Jamie Jones, Solar Plant Manager; Ken Bauhof, Vice President Special Processes; and Ginny Osterman, PhD. At Solar Manufacturing, I would like to mention Jim Nagy, President; Pete Reh Vice, President of Sales; Bob Wilson, Chief Engineer; Bob Daley, Chief Electrical Engineer; and Rick Jones, International Sales Manager. At MSI, I would like to recognize Mike Afflerbach, President and Chief Electrical Engineer, and there are many, many more!”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Bill Gornicki
Bill lets start off where we normally start off with an idea about how you got into the industry and what your work history has been.
“My formal career started in Technical Publications where I wrote manuals and did training for SPS Technologies, Automated Systems Division where we manufactured automated material handling systems. After 5 years there, I wrote manuals with Unisys for their Government and Special Systems Group where I focused on the FAA Alert Radar Terminal Systems program called ARTS II-A and also for US Post Office Small Parcel and Bundle Sorting equipment (it was more interesting than it sounds). Soon thereafter I wound up in the vacuum furnace industry, again writing manuals. Over nearly 17 years I held progressively higher positions from Project Manager, Marketing Services Manager, Product Manager and Midwest Region Sales Manager.”
Currently you are with ALD Vacuum Systems but I am rather embarrassed to say I am not sure what your title is. Could you tell us what your title is and what ALD Vacuum Systems has to offer? Also I am sure readers would like to know what is the relationship with ALD in Hanau, Germany and their parent company AMG.
“Currently, I’m Vice President Sales & Marketing for ALD Vacuum Systems, Inc. We’re a wholly owned subsidiary of ALD Vacuum Technologies, GmbH. As a full component of ALD, our focus is to provide expansion of our heat treat related technologies to the NAFTA region. For many years we’ve promoted the ModulTherm® and DualTherm®, arguably what we’re best known for. In recent years our SyncroTherm® has been the technology offering a quantum leap in vacuum furnace capability with deployment primarily into captive heat treaters. Now, with the introduction of NitroTherm®, we round-out our offerings to provide the most sought after surface treatment capabilities with Low Pressure Carburizing (LPC), Low Pressure Carbo-Nitriding (LPCn), Vacuum Purged Gas Nitriding (VPGN) and Active Screen Plasma Nitriding(ASPN). These processes coupled with our world leading capabilities in High Pressure Gas Quenching keep us in the technological lead.”
I would imagine that most North Americans think vacuum carburizing when they think of ALD but you have pointed out many times that this is shifting as you add new products. What can you say about this?
“Having set our sights to LPC/HPGQ for so long and being affiliated with three (3) contract heat treating operations (ALD Thermal Treatment) has ensured that our equipment offerings are robust and industry capable as well as our process expertise is second to none. It has also come with the “good problem” of being thought of in one dimension… LPC. Now, after all these years Nitriding has once again emerged as a legitimate consideration for some components. Our retort style vacuum tempering furnace is the perfect platform from which to begin in offering Vacuum Purged Gas Nitriding. It’s been an option for many years and only now we’re setting focus on it.”
You mention vacuum nitriding-why vacuum nitriding? From what I can see very few vacuum nitriders are sold in any given year so why get into this market?
“There are a couple of key reasons for Vacuum Purged Gas Nitriding in lieu of conventional gas Nitriding. First and for most, the heat treat facility is not flooded with ammonia. I’ve been in some heat treats where the ammonia smell is so pervasive it burns the hairs out of your nose. Nobody today wants to work in an environment like that. That’s not the case with VPGN. Also, the vacuum pump assures by virtue of vacuum level a known oxygen content prior to start. It’s interesting to me how so many heat treaters in Europe have general purpose muffle style furnaces like these. Nearly every HT shop in Europe has at least a couple of these types of furnaces. This is not the same in North America however and we aim to bring these to the NAFTA market. Interestingly, we acquired the patent for ASPN a couple of years ago. After process validation and product development, we’re able to bring to the global market an interesting twist to plasma Nitriding. We can plasma nitride not only workloads of varying part size and geometry, we can plasma nitride non-metallic surfaces as a result of the very low process temperature. For metals type people, that’s something to wrap your brain around.”
Some of the products ALD offers in Europe and other parts of the world are not offered or at least pushed in North America. Single chamber vacuum furnaces comes to mind-why is this?
“Having participated in this market, I watch it fairly closely. Frankly we’ll let the other furnace makers battle that one out. They’re clubbing each other over the heads for on average 3 points of margin on a $0.5mil order. This market is just too crowded. I feel too that this market isn’t really shopping capabilities anymore (although there are occasional exceptions). The focus has been directed toward price and we’re going to stay focused on technology.”
Many furnace builders around the world are largely regional, in other words they tend to stick to just the North American market, the European market or the Asian market as examples. Do you feel ALD had done a good job in becoming a global supplier?
“In a word, “yes”. However it’s not without its pain. “Globalizing” design, capabilities and offerings is fraught with challenges. Some cultural or traditional in nature, some technical, not the least of which is local codes and controls. ALD is globally focused on providing reliable, proven and industry leading technology. This can be challenging and yes, generally speaking we’re doing a good job but can always find ways to improve.”
I am going to ask you Bill if you can tell us what the annual sales of ALD in North America are but I will give you an out if this is information you would rather not share. I know you have a very good feel for the size of all of the North American furnace builders-where would you guess ALD ranks in annual sales?
“Top 10%? Middle of the pack? A niche player? I’m going to hold back a bit on this question because we hold these figures as company confidential. We are of course a publically traded company… Let’s just say we’re a niche player and we’re successful at it.”
How many ALD systems or customers do you have in North America? What about worldwide?
“We’re now well in excess of 150 vacuum carburizing chambers in North America. Worldwide, I’ll say it’s many hundreds more.”
You started your career with single chamber vacuum furnaces, and have moved on to modular vacuum carburizing systems, Syncrotherms and Vacuum nitriders-what is the next progression?
“Our Hanau, Germany based R&D team has a few tricks up their sleeve. This is an extremely talented group. Rolling out new offerings must be timed to coincide with demand and company capacity. We’re not resourced unlimited.”
The single part processing systems such as the SyncroTherm fascinate me but I have spent my entire career thinking large volume processing. Is this the future? Do you honestly believe that in the future most parts will be processed individually?
“Over the past 25 years or so, the use of vacuum furnaces has naturally matured. In 1990 when I started in this business, it was still a challenge to maintain front door vacuum seal integrity. Now, we make and break vacuum seals automatically every 8 minutes 24/7 without manual intervention. It’s no longer a question if vacuum processing works. We’re now into how to make it work within an acceptable manufacturing chain. I assert that 80% of what is put into vacuum furnaces on a global basis is “small” in nature. Of course that’s a relative term so let’s say the size of your hand as an example. Collecting a cache of these parts for heat treat in large batch creates bottlenecks in factory production flow and ultimately provides parts with greater variation. In other words, costs money. Small batch or one-piece-flow processing offers a factory flow that is far more conducive with the creation of the part which is typically one or several pieces at a time and quality can often be held to a tighter standard. Yes, as these systems improve and gain flexibility, we’ll see more captive heat treaters move in this direction.”
What does the future hold for Bill Gornicki?
“I like what I’m doing. I like the group I’m with. I like the friends I’ve made in the industry over the years. I think I’ll stick around for a while longer.”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033
Bill Gasbarre / Gasbarre Products
To get started Bill I would appreciate hearing how you got started in business and what your background is.
“My father had been in the Powder Metallurgy Parts-Making business until the age of 47, at which time he started Gasbarre Products. He recognized a need for a press designed for ease-of-use and with the maintenance person in mind. He started that company in 1973, just a couple of months prior to my graduating high school. I went to work with him that summer, went to the local Penn State campus, studied business while working for the company. I have worked in the family business for 40 years now.”
My understanding is that Gasbarre Products was not originally a furnace builder but rather more involved with presses for the sintering industry. When and why did you get involved in building new furnaces?
“That is correct, we were, and still are, very involved in the powder metallurgy industry, and we became good friends with Ron Brennen, who founded Sinterite in 1978. Both companies were selling to the same customer base, so we were always aware when customers needed furnaces to complement their press needs and growth. Ron approached us about buying the company when he wanted to sell, we did due diligence, and agreed it was a smart move to acquire the business. Sinterite, being only 30 miles away from our press facilities, could be managed locally. It has proven to be one of our most important and successful decisions in our company’s history.”
What are the capabilities of the company as a whole and what do you offer?
“Gasbarre Products consists of our Press Group, Furnace Group, and Tooling Group. We have 10 divisions and subsidiaries, offering powder compaction presses (mechanical, hydraulic, high speed, and isostatic) and furnaces (continuous furnaces for brazing, annealing, sintering, steam treating, tempering; tip-up furnaces, vacuum furnaces, IQ furnaces, box tempers, car bottoms, virtually any design needed for heat treating of any sort). Precision tool and die parts are also an important part of our business.”
So you have ended up with a press group and a furnace group? Which is larger and which do you find more interesting?
“Our press group consists of four press companies: Gasbarre Mechanical Press; Gasbarre Hydraulic Press; PTX-Pentronix; and Simac, Ltd (isostatic press manufacturer). The furnace group consists of Sinterite, C.I. Hayes, and J.L. Becker Co. The tooling group is made up of Major Gauge & Tool and McKee Carbide Tool Company. Finally, Gasbarre Technologies services our local business market with equipment and fabrications to the natural gas and other industries in the Pennsylvania area. The furnace group is presently the largest, at $30 million; press group at $17 million; tooling group at $6 million. Although I am responsible for the entire corporate sales and marketing, I have been assigned the daily activities of J.L. Becker sales & marketing, where we are changing the face and implementing new strategies. We will have a whole new presence in the heat treating industry, and I find this challenge to be the most rewarding throughout my 40 year career.”
Would you care to share with us the size of the entire company and in particular the furnace group?
“Answered in #4”
At first glance it would appear to me that the furnace group has largely grown through acquisitions. Sinterite in 1989, C.I. Hayes in 2003 and J.L. Becker in 2011. Is this a strategy that you had planned all along or did you seize the opportunities as they became available?
“All but Sinterite were planned strategies. Even though we didn’t go after the acquisition of each individual company, when the opportunities became available, and we made sure to revert to our strategic planning of what makes sense that will fit in with our strategic goals. The acquisition of C.I Hayes made sense, because it gave us the capabilities of Vacuum Furnaces and High Temperature Processing to 3000oF, providing us entirely new industries to serve. Then with the J.L. Becker opportunity, we took advantage of the capabilities of offering Tip-up Furnaces with quench tanks and manipulators, box furnaces, Batch IQ, Car Bottom furnaces, etc. This also opened up new markets and further enhanced our furnace offerings. Also, we provide entire process lines which helps the customer with full support, so they can lean on us for entire turnkey operations (and they do).”
Have all of these acquisitions proven to be good business decisions? Is there any that you regret?
“I am happy to say that all acquisitions have proved to be good business decisions. Some, obviously, have been more challenging than others, but all-in-all, each and every one has been a good fit, we have added some excellent technical personnel which only enhances our internal interaction which helps the customer achieve success with each piece of equipment offered, providing support and service. Our aggression and excellent top level management has been successful for Gasbarre Products, our employees, and our customers.”
When I think of Gasbarre I think sintering furnaces although I know this is not a completely correct assumption as CI Hayes is better known for vacuum furnaces in particular vacuum oil quench furnaces. Do you see a time in the future that you will be branching out into other types of furnace such as Batch IQ units?
“There really aren’t a lot of furnace types that we don’t offer now. If we get a lot of requests for equipment we don’t offer presently, we will consider supplying it if it is a fit with our core competency. We will do what makes good business sense at the time.”
If we go back to your acquisition of Sinterite in 1989 we see that you have been providing furnaces for quite some number of years. Have you found that profit margins have increased or shrunk over the years? Out of curiosity I also have to ask; which is more profitable for you? Presses or furnaces?
“Interesting question! Profit margins are managed minute-to-minute, not just hour-to-hour, or day-to-day. We are literally focused on profitability as part of our daily practice, with each decision we make. Profits only shrink or grow based on good management decisions, and of course on the economy and level of business. It’s also a direct result of overhead. If overhead is managed, then profit margins are realized.”
You issued a press release not that long ago about an order your had received for a mesh belt annealing furnace from the Pacific Rim which prompts me to ask if exports are a large part of your business?
“International sales and service is about 20% of our business.”
As your export side of the business has been growing do you see this as a key to future growth? This prompts the question about what if exports do not continue to grow? Could Gasbarre grow and survive based on the industrial base in North America?
“Our export business has remained at anywhere from 15 to 30% of our business. We manage these sales very closely, we need this business, but we don’t rely solely on it. The North American manufacturing base is strong and there are always opportunities for sales. How a company manages those sales determines their success and survival, not on the International markets.”
With the exception of some of the European furnace builders I have seen little sign of “foreign” furnace builders entering the North American market or at least successfully entering it. In your opinion will this change in the future? Are we in North America going to be flooded with furnaces from lost cost areas such as India or China?
“I don’t think that will be a major factor. I have heard our competitors and association members worry about overseas competition coming in and taking away business. It doesn’t matter if they are from another country, we just need to be cognizant of competition overall, no matter where they are from.”
Are you a “glass half full” or a “glass half empty” type of guy? What I mean by this is are you optimistic about the heat treating industry?
“My glass runs over! Negative thinking has never been part of my being. I am extremely optimistic and enthusiastic about the heat treating industry! There are great people in this industry, and I am looking forward to meeting new friends and colleagues. I’ve been doing this for 40 years now; I have heard older people say things like “it’s not the same as it was 20 years ago” and “it’s just no fun doing this anymore”. I enjoy and relish every minute of what we do!”
And what does the future hold for you? I know you are a very hard working fellow who truly seems to enjoy what he is doing. Do you plant to continue to grow the company or are you going to be sailing the world in a few years and leaving this industry behind you?
“I am a very intense business person, and stay focused on daily activities. My future is with our company and all the sales challenges and successes that are out there. I don’t like to sail, so I’ll never leave this industry!”
CALL NOW FOR THE LATEST USED EQUIPMENT OFFERINGS
905.271.0033